Diablo the mafia game!

[seph]

Vote Count

Bender (2) Clov, Dice
Yates (1)  Bender
Clov  (1) Lenlo, Aj


Not Voting 
everyone else

Deadline is in roughly 24 hours!

[Zander?]

Vote Count

 

Bender (2) Clov, Dice

Yates (1)  Bender

Clov  (1) Lenlo

 

 

Not Voting (9/13)

everyone else

 

Deadline is in roughly 24 hours!

 

 

Why are these votes still on us?

 

Are these joke votes and if so why are they still there, cause there's been a fair bit of game content since then to go off of?

 

If they are not please explain why you are voting us.

[Lenlo]

Because you are wrong.  I had no reason to ASK him, because he had already been asked.  Taborline asked him directly what he didn't like.  I said I had thoughts on the matter - which did - and I was going to wait until after he answered, specifically so I DIDN'T spoonfeed him an answer.  

 

He gave the answer of "vibes" and then asked what MY take was.  I told him what I had figured his mindset was.  I never forced him to choose between one; I never said it HAD to be one of them.  I said those were the two scenarios that I could have seen him reaching it as.  

 

So your statement about me grilling him if he didn't choose one is objectively wrong, because he didn't...and I didn't.

His exact quote was "Just a vibe I get". He didnt choose one cause he responded with a question. A question pointing out that both of the answers you gave for him kinda lean towards him being town.

 

No. The point is he didn't even seem to think I could be

 

 

Your right, im sorry, you didnt explicitly say "AJ one of these is what you had to have done", but you also didnt address his vibes post. You gave him options without addressing the answer he gave you. As for you grilling him, it seemed to me like something that you could have done. I dont believe I ever said it is what you did do, but if I did I was wrong.

[Clovdyx]

 

Vote Count

 

Bender (2) Clov, Dice

Yates (1)  Bender

Clov  (1) Lenlo

 

 

Not Voting (9/13)

everyone else

 

Deadline is in roughly 24 hours!

 

 

Why are these votes still on us?

 

Are these joke votes and if so why are they still there, cause there's been a fair bit of game content since then to go off of?

 

If they are not please explain why you are voting us.

 

 

I voted you for being outed scum, five posts in LDO.

 

And on a serious note, it's there for the combined reasoning of not having had a good candidate/having plenty of time left.  

[Lenlo]

Id would also like Clov and Dice to respond to Zander, cause deadline is less than 24 hours away I believe.

 

Also would like someone to weigh in on the no lynch option. I still think its probably a bad one, but not necessarily the worst.

[Lenlo]

Yates, whats your take on this? You dont seem to be doing much?

[Lenlo]

Can uh... someone remind me how to do ISO's? I keep trying to search someones name and it just comes back with their posts for the entire forum rather than just the game.

 

Im curious how much of Yates posts have been gameplay and how much as been jokes/gifs cause I dont remember much from him and that seems weird.

[Clovdyx]

 

Because you are wrong.  I had no reason to ASK him, because he had already been asked.  Taborline asked him directly what he didn't like.  I said I had thoughts on the matter - which did - and I was going to wait until after he answered, specifically so I DIDN'T spoonfeed him an answer.  

 

He gave the answer of "vibes" and then asked what MY take was.  I told him what I had figured his mindset was.  I never forced him to choose between one; I never said it HAD to be one of them.  I said those were the two scenarios that I could have seen him reaching it as.  

 

So your statement about me grilling him if he didn't choose one is objectively wrong, because he didn't...and I didn't.

His exact quote was "Just a vibe I get". He didnt choose one cause he responded with a question. A question pointing out that both of the answers you gave for him kinda lean towards him being town.

 

No. The point is he didn't even seem to think I could be

 

 

Your right, im sorry, you didnt explicitly say "AJ one of these is what you had to have done", but you also didnt address his vibes post. You gave him options without addressing the answer he gave you. As for you grilling him, it seemed to me like something that you could have done. I dont believe I ever said it is what you did do, but if I did I was wrong.

 

 

Of course I didn't address his vibes post.

 

 

 

What is it about Clov that you don't like most of anyone?

Just a vibe I get

 

 

when I drive by six people and five I hit

 

 

There's literally nothing to be gained there.  Either he's telling the truth, in which case he can't form an actual case, or he's lying...in which case he's not going to form an actual case.  At most I say, "I don't believe you" and we get nowhere.  

 

Your statement that I didn't address his answer is also wrong.

 

 

 

 

Don't both of those scenarios assume I am town?

 

 

(note: I just pasted this, and it says Tab instead of AJ in the editor window.  I'm almost positive it will display correctly when posted, but if it's screwed up, it's a site error)

 

No. The point is he didn't even seem to think I could be

 

 

 

Don't both of those scenarios assume I am town?

 

I would certainly say the first does.  I don't see any reason you couldn't do the latter as mafia.

 

 

Unless you want to claim incompetence, I suppose.  

 

 

 

 

 

[Clovdyx]

Id would also like Clov and Dice to respond to Zander, cause deadline is less than 24 hours away I believe.

 

Also would like someone to weigh in on the no lynch option. I still think its probably a bad one, but not necessarily the worst.

 

We're not no lynching this game.  Period.  Via mechanics/set up, it is literally the worst option.

[Zander?]

Id would also like Clov and Dice to respond to Zander, cause deadline is less than 24 hours away I believe.

 

Also would like someone to weigh in on the no lynch option. I still think its probably a bad one, but not necessarily the worst.

 

 

I can only speak for myself but No Lynch is always a bad option imo.  Any confirmed flip provides at least some new information towards game solve.  There's not a lot of time left but there's still some left to get a few half decent reads at least.

[Zander?]

 

 

Vote Count

 

Bender (2) Clov, Dice

Yates (1)  Bender

Clov  (1) Lenlo

 

 

Not Voting (9/13)

everyone else

 

Deadline is in roughly 24 hours!

 

 

Why are these votes still on us?

 

Are these joke votes and if so why are they still there, cause there's been a fair bit of game content since then to go off of?

 

If they are not please explain why you are voting us.

 

 

I voted you for being outed scum, five posts in LDO.

 

And on a serious note, it's there for the combined reasoning of not having had a good candidate/having plenty of time left.  

 

 

I don't hate this response but I'm also not encouraged by it either.  So any alignment reads either way atp Clov? 

[Lenlo]

You addressed his question about why both of those seemed to lean him town, you didnt say anything about his vibes reasoning. What you could have done is, I dunno, ask what vibes? What posts made you feel this way? Dont ask him if hes lying or not cause that gets you no where, ask him to expand upon it so we get more info or he slips up. Both are better options than just ignoring it.

[Zander?]

 

Id would also like Clov and Dice to respond to Zander, cause deadline is less than 24 hours away I believe.

 

Also would like someone to weigh in on the no lynch option. I still think its probably a bad one, but not necessarily the worst.

 

We're not no lynching this game.  Period.  Via mechanics/set up, it is literally the worst option.

 

 

 

 

Id would also like Clov and Dice to respond to Zander, cause deadline is less than 24 hours away I believe.

 

Also would like someone to weigh in on the no lynch option. I still think its probably a bad one, but not necessarily the worst.

 

 

I can only speak for myself but No Lynch is always a bad option imo.  Any confirmed flip provides at least some new information towards game solve.  There's not a lot of time left but there's still some left to get a few half decent reads at least.

 

 

 

Ninja'd!!!  lololololololol

[Clovdyx]

You addressed his question about why both of those seemed to lean him town, you didnt say anything about his vibes reasoning. What you could have done is, I dunno, ask what vibes? What posts made you feel this way? Dont ask him if hes lying or not cause that gets you no where, ask him to expand upon it so we get more info or he slips up. Both are better options than just ignoring it.

 

....You're actually right about this.  I could have done that.  Instead, I made the assumption that if he had ANY sort of justification beyond "it's a vibe", he would have given that to begin with.

[Zander?]

Can uh... someone remind me how to do ISO's? I keep trying to search someones name and it just comes back with their posts for the entire forum rather than just the game.

 

Im curious how much of Yates posts have been gameplay and how much as been jokes/gifs cause I dont remember much from him and that seems weird.

 

Click the Red Magnify Button in the upper right corner.

[Lenlo]

 

You addressed his question about why both of those seemed to lean him town, you didnt say anything about his vibes reasoning. What you could have done is, I dunno, ask what vibes? What posts made you feel this way? Dont ask him if hes lying or not cause that gets you no where, ask him to expand upon it so we get more info or he slips up. Both are better options than just ignoring it.

 

....You're actually right about this.  I could have done that.  Instead, I made the assumption that if he had ANY sort of justification beyond "it's a vibe", he would have given that to begin with.

 

He doesnt have to justify his vote. ATM I am harping on you cause you have content, your someone thats around and someone I can talk to/get reactions from. I intend to talk to AJ later about some of his stuff to, cause he is by no means cleared. I simply like what he has done so far.

[Clovdyx]

I don't hate this response but I'm also not encouraged by it either.  So any alignment reads either way atp Clov? 

 

 

Beyond what I said about your hydra and Dice earlier, not really.  I have a very minor - and stupid - reason to be suspicious of AJ that I'm just not going to address today (if my suspicions are wrong, it's going to screw us over; if I'm right, I'm not getting him lynched over it anyways).  

 

Mixed feelings about Lenlo.  I think you're right that he's working towards solving, and that's obviously a good thing, but I feel almost every point he's making is refuted by just examining the thread and using basic logic that I have a hard time considering it genuine.

[Lenlo]

I would love it if there was more to go on Clov. ATM I am taking what I have on hand and trying to hit you with it to see what happens. I dont feel like what you did around there was great, but I am glad I have gotten the chance to talk with you about it.

[Zander?]

 

 

You addressed his question about why both of those seemed to lean him town, you didnt say anything about his vibes reasoning. What you could have done is, I dunno, ask what vibes? What posts made you feel this way? Dont ask him if hes lying or not cause that gets you no where, ask him to expand upon it so we get more info or he slips up. Both are better options than just ignoring it.

 

....You're actually right about this.  I could have done that.  Instead, I made the assumption that if he had ANY sort of justification beyond "it's a vibe", he would have given that to begin with.

 

He doesnt have to justify his vote. ATM I am harping on you cause you have content, your someone thats around and someone I can talk to/get reactions from. I intend to talk to AJ later about some of his stuff to, cause he is by no means cleared. I simply like what he has done so far.

 

 

 

Why? Unless its an obv joke vote, I feel its never a good idea to not try justify it.

[Lenlo]

Its not a good idea not to justify it, your right. But he doesnt have to. There have been plenty of players here, like Wombat, whos thing it is is to just drop a vote on someone and say "Scum".

 

Thats why you push people to explain things like hard town/scum reads and votes.

 

Having fun figuring out this ISO thing.

[Zander?]

 

I don't hate this response but I'm also not encouraged by it either.  So any alignment reads either way atp Clov? 

 

 

Beyond what I said about your hydra and Dice earlier, not really.  I have a very minor - and stupid - reason to be suspicious of AJ that I'm just not going to address today (if my suspicions are wrong, it's going to screw us over; if I'm right, I'm not getting him lynched over it anyways).  

 

Mixed feelings about Lenlo.  I think you're right that he's working towards solving, and that's obviously a good thing, but I feel almost every point he's making is refuted by just examining the thread and using basic logic that I have a hard time considering it genuine.

 

 

 

Fair enough brother.  Depending on how things play out later I'd like to hear your reason to be suspicious of him.  The only reason I'm not pressing for it is the first bolded part.

 

It's the 2nd bolded part that's really making me wonder.  If you have a suspicion of someone and its confirmed correct why wouldn't you want him lynched over it?

 

If the answer to the 2nd bold outs it, I'll not be too worried if you don't respond to it atp.

[Clovdyx]

No, nobody is OBLIGATED to give an explanation, but he had been asked about it and DID offer up a reason - just a vibe.  I'm saying that I assumed if there was more to it than that, he would have said so.  If he could have backed it up with reasoning for the vibes, he likely would have included it when he replied to Tab.

[Shad_]

Taking a swig of liquid tylenol to kill this headache and then I will catch up and out three scum or possibly fall asleep.

[Lenlo]

I think hes saying he wants AJ lynched for it if hes right, hes just not confident he would be able to get him lynched today cause he needs a consensus.

[Zander?]

Its not a good idea not to justify it, your right. But he doesnt have to. There have been plenty of players here, like Wombat, whos thing it is is to just drop a vote on someone and say "Scum".

 

Thats why you push people to explain things like hard town/scum reads and votes.

 

Having fun figuring out this ISO thing.

 

 

 

Can uh... someone remind me how to do ISO's? I keep trying to search someones name and it just comes back with their posts for the entire forum rather than just the game.

 

Im curious how much of Yates posts have been gameplay and how much as been jokes/gifs cause I dont remember much from him and that seems weird.

 

Click the Red Magnify Button in the upper right corner.

 

 

After clicking that:

 

fill in the players name in Author slot.

 

click by posts

 

click ascending order.

 

and the should be gg.