[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[csarmi]

No testing Seph. We don't even know how many mafia are left (probably two, but not sure). We also might vote faster.

Even better, we could just lynch the mafia. Someone care to claim wolf?

[csarmi]

What I mean is:

 

Let's say there are 5 townies and 2 wolves left. That means we need to lynch wolves. Can do it right there... or obviously you can lynch me, but that's just postponing the decision - and wolves have good kills (by killing Dice/Seph they don't change the lynch pool).

[csarmi]

In any case you should make up your mind on whether you suspect me, in fact, you should have doen that already.

 

You don't need to worry btw. I'm town.

[seph]

Csarmi we are testing your claim before lylo. Don't wanna lose cause you were mafia.... I don't think you are but I would kick myself.

 

 

Last time I my gut was telling me darthe and I went aj...

Going with my gut here.

[csarmi]

You guys are the only thing that's doesn't make sense...

Wombo is my only other suspect and you guys protect each other .. so yes I am a bit confused

The wolf team is probably Seph & Yates. No one will see that coming.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

FWIW I'll put my vote there. Don't have a better option right now.

 

[v]Dice[/v]

 

good vote

 

i guess

 

To me that just shows Eldrick is more derp town.

Chances on this being wolf-Lee with wolf-Eldrick? Sounds low innit?

 

I could go either way on that. Lee knows Eldrick is a derpy wolf too, but Eldrick doesn't seem to be under any pressure. It does remind me of lee reading me town... eldrick plays scum badly, so why town read him unless he's town.

[seph]

I don't, i think you are town.

But there is always a chance.

[csarmi]

Csarmi we are testing your claim before lylo. Don't wanna lose cause you were mafia.... I don't think you are but I would kick myself.

 

Last time I my gut was telling me darthe and I went aj...

Going with my gut here.

No we don't. Too late for that. I have offered it day 3. It could have made sense yesterday (day 4) to delay the decision on Heart/Masons. We can't afford that any more - sorry.

[csarmi]

I don't, i think you are town.

But there is always a chance.

There is no need for you to tinfoil on me. Put your mind at rest.

[csarmi]

@Seph - I don't know how I can help you handle endgames. Trust your gut. Believe your reads. Don't overthing, but read the game again if possible.

 

If you think you're getting into circles, maybe step away for a while.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

I don't, i think you are town.

But there is always a chance.

There is no need for you to tinfoil on me. Put your mind at rest.

 

brev, u r tilting me with your soothing words. stahp it.

 

but seriously, can't see you posting this much as scum. seems out of reach.

[Talya]

I really have no idea who can be the last wolf/s

 

If you look at the list of roles and believe Womby then I think 4 wolves is very low. Considering we don't seem to have a Sk.

 

I have had Womby hovering between scum and town since day 1. But saying that Yates has been into path too.

 

What we know

 

Dice and Seph town

I know I'm town.

CS - we have all had him as town except Zander...could he have been right.

 

Eld...he has done some odd things wants wants to lynch not on someone he thinks maybe scum...I have no idea about his wolf game.

 

Yates and Sili, it always comes back to them.

 

Looking at the list of roles that is quite a town power. I still wonder if there are 2 wolves left.

 

I can't go back and check on phone on a train and in a course all day. Tomorrow should be better but day will be over by then.

 

Let's get this mason team checked once and for all

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Yates[/v]

[csarmi]

Who posted in: [Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Member name Posts Zander 980 csarmi 709 WWWwombat 613 Sili Quirrels 599 seph 567 alannalynn 486 Darthe 473 Eldrick4221 395 Andrej 368 Talya 344 鲍勃不是我的名字 329 Yates 298 Shad_ 251 dicetosser1 143 Aiel Heart 130 Hallia 125 Clovdyx 94 Thane Vakarian 90 Leelou 88 Verbal32 85 Sooh 58 Turin Turambar 31 cory caboose 23 Mawthtex 8

 

[csarmi]

Five of us passed Darthe - nuts.

[seph]

Darthe did that in like 120 pages....

355 now

[Sili Quirrels]

Do me a favor everyone?

 

there might be two scum, but two scum doesn't make us scum. And the number of scum depends on their roles as much as it does ours, so it is very much circular. It's easy to rationalize a vote on us, 'to test the claim' but it doesn't make it +ev, so if you're voting Yates or me, from now on justify it substantively so there is more information to use.

 

Just my 2c.

 

As for the mechanics of it, a conditional masonizer is not abnormal in a game with a godfather and a role-blocker. It actually makes sense tbh.

[Sili Quirrels]

Darthe did that in like 120 pages....

355 now

Darthe really did outdo himself.

 

like he literally spammed the thread to get to that point and half of it must have been fluff, but still... it was impressive XD

[csarmi]

Gonna have a pass thru this during the day and on my evening (still way before deadline).

[dicetosser1]

Csarmi we are testing your claim before lylo. Don't wanna lose cause you were mafia.... I don't think you are but I would kick myself.

 

 

Last time I my gut was telling me darthe and I went aj...

Going with my gut here.

 

No we arnt

 

We shouldnt be lynching thew masons either

[Eldrick4221]

Some math

(in this, we will be assuming Salami is telling the truth, and that the PoE is Talya, Wombo, and me)

 

Last scum between Talya, Wombo, and Me:

9 alive now. 8 town (1 hated). 1 scum.

Lynch one. wrong

Townie NK'd

7 alive. 6 town (1 hated). 1 scum.

Lynch wrong again

Townie NK'd

5 alive. 4 town (1 hated). 1 scum.

We lynch the last one and win.

 

Sili and Yates are scum.

9 alive. 7 town (1 hated). 2 scum.

Lynch wrong

Townie NK'd

7 alive. 5 town (1 hated). 2 scum

Lynch wrong

Townie NK'd

5 alive. 3 town (1 hated). 2 scum

Lynch wrong and lose.

 

Those are the scenarios we have to face if we aren't lynching Sili or Yates.

 

Now then. If we do, and they are telling the truth.

 

9 alive. 8 town (1 hated). 1 scum

Mislynch Sili/Yates

Mason confirmed.

Townie NK'd

7 alive. 6 town (1 hated). 1 scum. (PoE 3 people)

Lynch wrong

Townie NK'd

5 alive. 4 town (1 hated). 1 scum (PoE 2 people)

Lynch wrong

Townie NK'd

3 alive. 2 town (1 Hated). 1 scum (PoE 1 person)

It comes down to who votes first.

 

9 alive. 7 town (1 hated). 2 scum

Mislynch Sili/Yates

Mason confirmed.

Townie NK'd

7 alive. 5 town (1 hated). 2 scum. (PoE 3 people)

Lynch wrong

Townie NK'd

5 alive. 3 town (1 hated). 2 scum (PoE 2 people)

Remaining scum is obvious. Again comes down to who votes first.

 

IMO, if Salami or Notbob are scum...we lost.

If I missed something, or did something wrong, please let me know.

[Eldrick4221]

I would rather you were NBs action for tonight than Womby.

 

By you I mean you or Sili.

 

I've also been thinking about the backup (Zander). If he had told us he was universal backup it would have made heart's doc more plausible. Why would there be a commuter and a back up doc/cop.

 

I think the lynch should not be Sili or Yates, That leaves Eld me and Womby.

 

I agree on this 100%. Analysis post before this detailing why.

 

Can someonw link me to Eldrick wolf game? I wanna check smth.

 

They are linked in my sig. Feel free to check them out.

[Eldrick4221]

Last mafia is between Talya, Wombo and myself. I am willing to take the bullet to shrink the pool. If there is one scum left, we already won.

[Eldrick4221]

Actually, after looking over my own analysis, it is actually safer to confirm the alignment of sili and yates today then to not.

 

If they aren't scum, and I don't believe they are, there's a good chance this game will boil down to voting before scum lynches Salami.

 

But if they are and we don't vote them, we lose before the PoE is gone.

 

I suppose you guys could lynch Wombo and me, and then race against Yates and sili instead of lynching Talya. It seems most people have her as last of the 3 of us (if an option at all).

 

That being said, and taking into account what Yates said about his and Sili's play..

 

[unvote]

[v]Yates[/v]

 

Safest and smartest way to go, IMO.

[csarmi]

@Eldrick: if you believe the masons are town, don't lynch them, it's that simple. Lynhing someone to prove they are town is not very useful.

 

Assume we lynch one of Sili/Yates.

 

If we hit mafia, game over.

 

If not, tomorrow starts with two confirmed town (two of the remaining masons + Seph + Dice) out of 7 players. How is that a better situation? You are faced the very same choice between your 3 suspects.

[Eldrick4221]

It's better because it removes the ambiguity. Yes I believe they are town, but this won't be dropped until one is lynched. And IF they are scum, now's the time to find out.