[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[csarmi]

I read the quotes as a proof how her role fits (someone said it wouldn't fit the char while it definitely does).

[dicetosser1]

I said that Csarmi and I read the quotes she gave the same tho i teased her about quoting phantom menace

[seph]

So just lynch wombo.

If notbob has a shot he can shoot sili if needed?

[dicetosser1]

im more tempted to lynch sili. Has more benefits.

 

Either I get a confirmed Townie out of it

 

or

 

I kill 2 lovers  one of which may be scum.  Either way it reduces the posibile scum numbers by 2

 

or i get a confirmed town who gets killed tonight  but then a confirmed town is probably gonna die tonight.

 

 

Thats my logical thinking.

 

 

My gut says lynch wombat/aj.

[csarmi]

@Sili - are you absolutely sure you are masons? Is Yates alignment guaranteed to you? Could he have neighbourized you?

 

@Dice - if lovers they are the same alignment here. Theme you know.

[seph]

If notbob can say if he has a shot or not it would be nice.

 

 

The thing that makes me curious is yates says to lynch him over sili.

 

I am fine with lynching aj.

Would be nice if notbob had a shot though

[Talya]

I'm with you Dice.

[Sili Quirrels]

If notbob can say if he has a shot or not it would be nice.

The thing that makes me curious is yates says to lynch him over sili.

I am fine with lynching aj.

Would be nice if notbob had a shot though

I think a shot to prove our claim doesn't cost a mislynch, due to salami's role.

 

i.e. 1 scum: 9-> 6 -> 4 (2 to majority) -> loss

or 2 scum: 9 -> 6 (3 to majority) -> loss

 

with no vig. shot

 

1 scum: 9 -> 7 -> 5 (2 to majority) -> loss

2 scum: 9 -> 7 (3 to majority) -> loss

 

So i agree, either one of us will do. Would be good.

[Sili Quirrels]

going to try to catch up a little. will have more time over the next day for mafia thankfully.

[csarmi]

Just a note: 3 town and 2 mafia with me alive is no an automatic loss, it's just whoever (town or mafia) votes faster wins...

 

which is loltastic but whatevs

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

 

 

 

If you wanna drive a lynch, you either gotta be an investigative role, a buffoon, or a jerk.

 

 

...and the scum resorts to name calling.  

 

@ Mod,  please modkill now.

 

Lol srsly?  You know exactly what I meant there.

 

You admittedly drove the mislynch yesterday in clear knowledge of a better alternative.  My response is to lynch you.  You blow off my case with name calling.  Sorry, I do not like insults nor will I pull back from pursuit of your lynch.  Good luck,

 

I was saying that in order to drive a lynch there, AJ and I needed to either be buffoons or jerks.  I don't like being a jerk.  We didn't think Zander's alternative was better, but we were willing to go with it if we had to.  It had a better best worst case scenario, but we were over 95% on our Heart read there.  We were wrong.  If getting lynched is the price of being wrong, fine.  But we're not going to take it lying down.

 

So you admit putting your own interests (reads) above the town's.  Got it.

 

Please lynch this scum.

 

Garbage rhetoric, dude.  Townies follow strong reads because it's in the town's interest to do so.

I agree with this btw. just cause someone tunnels a townie doesn't mean they're scum. i was tunneling too, to a lesser degree. i was fairly confident she would flip scum after her posting, and the redundent claim. she was also the only person who wasn't spewed strongly villager by circumstance. plus wombat had a couple mislynches available before heart even claimed. last time wombat was scum in a game with me he went the path of least resistance.

[Sili Quirrels]

Just a note: 3 town and 2 mafia with me alive is no an automatic loss, it's just whoever (town or mafia) votes faster wins...which is loltastic but whatevs

u mean like a fastest to lynch to majority?

 

i've had those before. they suck. =/

[Sili Quirrels]

[v]Talya[/v]

 

It's not us. If we aren't going to test the Mason claims today then it's either Talya or Eldrick imo.

y talya over eldrick?

[Sili Quirrels]

Misrepping AH just a bit too much then come in after lynch and say she was lolcatting (she definitely wasn't).

As for the masons - it can wait a day (not more though).

I think NB is either out of shots or not a vig as he should be shooting here.

i skimmed. i must have missed where they said heart was lolcatting postlynch. :/

 

i think heart gave up as either alignment. but easier for scum to give up in context than town.

[Sili Quirrels]

im more tempted to lynch sili. Has more benefits.

 

Either I get a confirmed Townie out of it

 

or

 

I kill 2 lovers  one of which may be scum.  Either way it reduces the posibile scum numbers by 2

 

or i get a confirmed town who gets killed tonight  but then a confirmed town is probably gonna die tonight.

 

 

Thats my logical thinking.

 

 

My gut says lynch wombat/aj.

we aren't lovers.

[Sili Quirrels]

@Sili - are you absolutely sure you are masons? Is Yates alignment guaranteed to you? Could he have neighbourized you?

@Dice - if lovers they are the same alignment here. Theme you know.

like an evil c3po? lol.

 

no. It was specifically, 'masons'.

[dicetosser1]

@Sili - are you absolutely sure you are masons? Is Yates alignment guaranteed to you? Could he have neighbourized you?

 

@Dice - if lovers they are the same alignment here. Theme you know.

 

csarmi keeps the good points rolling in.

 

I'm with you Dice.

 

with me for which? sili, wombat or either?

 

 

 

 

Sili  if we lynch a mason  who is better to lynch? You or Yates?

[Sili Quirrels]

me. i'm multitabling, plus yates is the better player even though he won't admit it.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

One problem with Yates plan. If they both are Mafia how do we know they have no roles left. Why would they want NB to kill one of them at night. Maybe they have a bus driver role and can move the kill by NB. If that is the case they get a free night kill. It would be better to test them today. If one comes up Mafia the we have NB to shoot the other if he has s shot left. If not wolves will have 3 confirmed townies to choose from.

I can't believe impulse reading this so early.

If Womby is to believed and there is no Al then the chances of there being two wolves is higher. That is a powerful town. So I would expect a powerful wolf team.

The only other thing is the Sk was thwarted twice...highly unlikely but possible.

I think we should do Zanders original plan and test the masons. If it's not them I would be looking at Womby, Eld and CS (we have kept him in the game on that claim and not once has he been in a wolf lynch if memory serves. Not much wolf hunting neither)

i imagine if there are two kills tonight and none of them is one of us, it would look pretty bad, so same result. =/

 

i can't blame you for lynching a doc with the rest of us, but not a good look imo. Ideally nb has a shot to use.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

I don't see a reason not to clear up the masons right now. It seems to be the best play.

 

As for your list wombo. Seph is mod confirmed. Dice was clearly cop peek. What you're saying is you have salami as town.

Yeah, I didn't phrase that the best. Csarmi is the only one of those that's purely a read. I am kind of getting town vibes from Yates and Sili here, but that's sketching me out because I can never trust Yates and I tend to scum read Sili a lot. Talya gives me intermittent town vibes with things she does. She's also a very experienced player though. I think the only way you are scum is if you've set yourself up brilliantly with your D3 play. From my experience playing with you, it doesn't seem like something you'd intentionally do, but it could be something that just happened. Very unlikely though imo. NotBob I have been reading as town for a while now and I don't see anything to change that atm.

 

So basically, I have some faulty town vibes here and that's making me uneasy. At this point, I think Talya and the mason claimants are the most likely ones for me to be wrong on, but I'm still kinda tilted from the Heart lynch.

aren't you usually scum when you scumread me?

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

I don't see a reason not to clear up the masons right now. It seems to be the best play.

 

As for your list wombo. Seph is mod confirmed. Dice was clearly cop peek. What you're saying is you have salami as town.

Yeah, I didn't phrase that the best. Csarmi is the only one of those that's purely a read. I am kind of getting town vibes from Yates and Sili here, but that's sketching me out because I can never trust Yates and I tend to scum read Sili a lot. Talya gives me intermittent town vibes with things she does. She's also a very experienced player though. I think the only way you are scum is if you've set yourself up brilliantly with your D3 play. From my experience playing with you, it doesn't seem like something you'd intentionally do, but it could be something that just happened. Very unlikely though imo. NotBob I have been reading as town for a while now and I don't see anything to change that atm.

 

So basically, I have some faulty town vibes here and that's making me uneasy. At this point, I think Talya and the mason claimants are the most likely ones for me to be wrong on, but I'm still kinda tilted from the Heart lynch.

aren't you usually scum when you scumread me?

[Sili Quirrels]

Wombat, aren't you usually scum when you scumread me?

[dicetosser1]

allright then

 

 

TY Sili

 

 

vote sili

[Sili Quirrels]

allright then

 

 

TY Sili

 

 

vote sili

for being the lamb that get's gutted so his team can have a worst chance to win than when he left them?

[Eldrick4221]

 

Lynch sili

Notbob gets the pleasure of shooting wombo?

 

Then we have eld and tayla left if it's even needed

This would be a good way to prove our role.

 

I really like this idea. Notbob, do you have a shot left?

 

Just a note: 3 town and 2 mafia with me alive is no an automatic loss, it's just whoever (town or mafia) votes faster wins...

 

which is loltastic but whatevs

For the record, if we get down to less than 6 people, and I am still alive, I will consider voting Salami a lynchable offense.