Alien mafia [BASIC] - Game Over - Town won

[Sili Quirrels]

Maybe Darthe can give his input.

[Darthe]

Cop/Doc is standard on DM for 3 goons, it's also standard for 2 goons and a GF.

 

Could go either way.

 

Lynch Notbob IMO

[Darthe]

Thematically a GF is possible and I might even say likely but we can't really know and nobody can character claim so it's a moot point anyhow.

[Sili Quirrels]

Are you thinking about the android when you talk about theme?

[Darthe]

Yeah, looks like a person and pretends to be a good guy for most of the movie. 

 

I could see GF.

[Leelou]

Vote Count
 

Notbob (2) - Shad, Hallia

Shad (1) - Notbob 

 
With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. 
 
Deadline - Tuesday 10 am EDT

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

All roads lead to Shad.  Lynch this scum.

[Sili Quirrels]

All roads lead to Shad.  Lynch this scum.

Only shad?

[Darthe]

All roads lead to Shad.  Lynch this scum.

make the case or concede, I don't care to watch you do neither.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

3rd game at the same time! Whoohoo! I promise I'll try to definitely not be very confused at all...

I used to get up to 5 games at a time. The addiction was strong

 

5 games was too much for me. I had to shut down in one, and not post in another.

 

V peeked Eldrick N0 btw. Yes there was an N0, mod just didn't say it.

 

Leave your peeks people, don't make me yell about it

for post-game.

 

Vote Verbal

 

Padding post count this early is one of his signature moves.

 

 

 

That said its not like verbals callous attitide doesnt concern me

 

Looks like he ran for cover after the votes...but in his defense...he usually misses the weekends.

 

 

So up to this point it seems NB wants to tunnel Verbal for whatever reason. I have a hard time taking it seriously, but later Dae adds credibility to NB's train of thought, which might be significant.

 

AH starting off on her overly jokey wolf meta

were you serious btw?

 

Eld as there was no N0 I think it's safe to say they were joking.

 

 

If anyone actually thinks Eld is mafia, I'm surprised.  He's reading derptown to me. XD

might be mafiasplainin, but later dae takes up the same angle, and sooh does too, and I just find it really hard to believe all three scum have the same strategy of defending eldrick early day 1.

 

Eldrick basically always posts in catch up mode, w or v, so that's not indicative IMO.

 

Alanna seems to really want to vote him.

 

obviously said to get town cred., and maybe sooh is angling for laine here which might make her town.

[Darthe]

If Hally voted Eld and held off of Dae she is a wolf.

[Sili Quirrels]

If Hally voted Eld and held off of Dae she is a wolf.

I can't make sense of this.

[Darthe]

 

 

If Hally voted Eld and held off of Dae she is a wolf.

I can't make sense of this.

Just in your review plz quote if she did or didn't do these things in the end.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

If Hally voted Eld and held off of Dae she is a wolf.

I can't make sense of this.

Just in your review plz quote if she did or didn't do these things in the end.

 

Okay.

 

I think she voted Talya actually.

[Sili Quirrels]

Vote Count

 

Eldrick (7) - Laine, Darthe, Sili, Notbob, Verb, Daetirion, Talya

Darthe (2) - Eldrick, Shad

Verbie (1) - Yates

 

Not voting - Hallia, Aiel <3, Sooh

 

With 7 votes, Eldrick has been lynched.

^final vote count day 1.

[Shad_]

Hallia was no vote D1 and Tally D2, initially AH D3 but ultimately hammered Sooh.  She didn't give Sooh a chance to claim any roles.  It's a little odd in retrospect because Hallia was not going to get lynched yesterday, but I can understand her getting a little panicky with three votes on her.  I had a hunch she was seer and got a scum view of NotBob so I wasn't about to vote her D3.  (I asked if there was a seer kind of at random while we were still thinking about who to vote, partly because I wasn't sure myself and partly to plant the idea without saying anything obvious.)  I figure Sili would have hammered Sooh once she had a chance to speak, so the hammer itself doesn't look quite as good as it seemed.  What Hallia really had going for her imo was a train in the first place.  Didn't make much sense for scum Sooh to vote her when cleared town was mostly ignoring Hallia and debating between Sooh and AH

 

I guess the move for Hallia made sense whatever her alignment, because at town she knew she needed to do something to clear her name.  Sooh voting her over AH says a lot imo and it's really why I'm much more interested in NotBob and AH right now.  NotBob looks like he's just waiting around to die right now and holding out for a last ditch hope that we all turn on each other.  AH is, eh, not inherently scummy to me but after not voting D1 and missing both the Dae and the Sooh trains I don't think there's anything she can do to clear her name at this point.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Hallia was no vote D1 and Tally D2, initially AH D3 but ultimately hammered Sooh.  She didn't give Sooh a chance to claim any roles.  It's a little odd in retrospect because Hallia was not going to get lynched yesterday, but I can understand her getting a little panicky with three votes on her.  I had a hunch she was seer and got a scum view of NotBob so I wasn't about to vote her D3.  (I asked if there was a seer kind of at random while we were still thinking about who to vote, partly because I wasn't sure myself and partly to plant the idea without saying anything obvious.)  I figure Sili would have hammered Sooh once she had a chance to speak, so the hammer itself doesn't look quite as good as it seemed.  What Hallia really had going for her imo was a train in the first place.  Didn't make much sense for scum Sooh to vote her when cleared town was mostly ignoring Hallia and debating between Sooh and AH

 

I guess the move for Hallia made sense whatever her alignment, because at town she knew she needed to do something to clear her name.  Sooh voting her over AH says a lot imo and it's really why I'm much more interested in NotBob and AH right now.  NotBob looks like he's just waiting around to die right now and holding out for a last ditch hope that we all turn on each other.  AH is, eh, not inherently scummy to me but after not voting D1 and missing both the Dae and the Sooh trains I don't think there's anything she can do to clear her name at this point.

 

So scummy.

[Aiel Heart]

Alanna--Doc
--N1 Self protect
--N2 Self protect
--N3 Protected Darthe (no kill this night) 

Darthe--Cop
--Sili=town
--Laine=town
--Talya=town
(also treating Hallia as clear)
*Note that Godfather is still a possibility*

@Darthe--out of curiosity, were these listed in chronological order? If so is there any particular reason you chose Talya last night when a lot of people counted her as basically cleared? 
 
Officially Claimed Vanilla Townies 
Talya
Shad
NotBob
Heart

Hallia can we have your thoughts on the scum contenders?

NotBob--why Shad? Give me continued reason to trust you.

Shad I like your posting right now.

Need to reread things again...

[Aiel Heart]

Ninja'd by NotBob not liking the post. 

 

 

Can we have reasons not just words?

[Sili Quirrels]

Y

 

 

Hallia was no vote D1 and Tally D2, initially AH D3 but ultimately hammered Sooh.  She didn't give Sooh a chance to claim any roles.  It's a little odd in retrospect because Hallia was not going to get lynched yesterday, but I can understand her getting a little panicky with three votes on her.  I had a hunch she was seer and got a scum view of NotBob so I wasn't about to vote her D3.  (I asked if there was a seer kind of at random while we were still thinking about who to vote, partly because I wasn't sure myself and partly to plant the idea without saying anything obvious.)  I figure Sili would have hammered Sooh once she had a chance to speak, so the hammer itself doesn't look quite as good as it seemed.  What Hallia really had going for her imo was a train in the first place.  Didn't make much sense for scum Sooh to vote her when cleared town was mostly ignoring Hallia and debating between Sooh and AH

 

I guess the move for Hallia made sense whatever her alignment, because at town she knew she needed to do something to clear her name.  Sooh voting her over AH says a lot imo and it's really why I'm much more interested in NotBob and AH right now.  NotBob looks like he's just waiting around to die right now and holding out for a last ditch hope that we all turn on each other.  AH is, eh, not inherently scummy to me but after not voting D1 and missing both the Dae and the Sooh trains I don't think there's anything she can do to clear her name at this point.

 

So scummy.

 

[v]not bob[/v]

 

-_-

[Sili Quirrels]

smh

[Sili Quirrels]

my tolerance capacity was exceeded.

[Sili Quirrels]

[unvote]

[Sili Quirrels]

Hallia was no vote D1 and Tally D2, initially AH D3 but ultimately hammered Sooh.  She didn't give Sooh a chance to claim any roles.  It's a little odd in retrospect because Hallia was not going to get lynched yesterday, but I can understand her getting a little panicky with three votes on her.  I had a hunch she was seer and got a scum view of NotBob so I wasn't about to vote her D3.  (I asked if there was a seer kind of at random while we were still thinking about who to vote, partly because I wasn't sure myself and partly to plant the idea without saying anything obvious.)  I figure Sili would have hammered Sooh once she had a chance to speak, so the hammer itself doesn't look quite as good as it seemed.  What Hallia really had going for her imo was a train in the first place.  Didn't make much sense for scum Sooh to vote her when cleared town was mostly ignoring Hallia and debating between Sooh and AH

 

I guess the move for Hallia made sense whatever her alignment, because at town she knew she needed to do something to clear her name.  Sooh voting her over AH says a lot imo and it's really why I'm much more interested in NotBob and AH right now.  NotBob looks like he's just waiting around to die right now and holding out for a last ditch hope that we all turn on each other.  AH is, eh, not inherently scummy to me but after not voting D1 and missing both the Dae and the Sooh trains I don't think there's anything she can do to clear her name at this point.

 

 

Probably. I regret not being there.

[Darthe]

Not in order ah I don't think listing order matters