Alien mafia [BASIC] - Game Over - Town won

[alannalynn]

My spidey sense was tingling. I like Darthe's list.

[Darthe]

Hey darthe, can u help me out by elaborating on laine?

Oh she isn't, I just don't know what to make of her and like to see how people take things.

 

Sometimes my list doesnt equal out perfectly.  I'd say that she is less likely to be a wolf than most others so she rose in comparison to them.  Also I like her activity.

[alannalynn]

SIli what do you want to know from me? I've played a lot of mafia, I'm certainly somewhat capable of playing a good town game, I'm not putting forth enough effort in this one though I should after coming out strong day one; I like cheesecake.

 

She did awkwardly suggest that the choice between Tayla and Dae was hard because one had all her scum reads and the other had all her town reads but that seems pretty trivial, like the words just came out wrong.

I just thought it was too easy that my suspects were on the Talya train and my town reads were on the Dae train. Too easy is suspicious. But I did go with gut on Dae and I'm glad I did

[alannalynn]

I've sort of granted Laine town all along, because I feel like she's an easy person to understand.  I know that's going to bite me but until it does it's a hard feeling to get over.

That's because if you take the things I say at face value instead of reading into them, you'll generally be right. Also, hello. And no I wont bite

[Darthe]

SIli what do you want to know from me? I've played a lot of mafia, I'm certainly somewhat capable of playing a good town game, I'm not putting forth enough effort in this one though I should after coming out strong day one; I like cheesecake.

 

She did awkwardly suggest that the choice between Tayla and Dae was hard because one had all her scum reads and the other had all her town reads but that seems pretty trivial, like the words just came out wrong.

I just thought it was too easy that my suspects were on the Talya train and my town reads were on the Dae train. Too easy is suspicious. But I did go with gut on Dae and I'm glad I did

YOU CANT COPY ME

[alannalynn]

Darthe? Are you okay?

[Shad_]

 

I've sort of granted Laine town all along, because I feel like she's an easy person to understand.  I know that's going to bite me but until it does it's a hard feeling to get over.

That's because if you take the things I say at face value instead of reading into them, you'll generally be right. Also, hello. And no I wont bite

 

 

Oh hi villager.

 

I wonder how this game would go if people didn't condemn themselves through silence.  It's kind of funny that I got to the point of labeling Aiel town for the simple fact that she actually posts things and doesn't blatantly contradict herself.  But that is more than three others have going.

 

So do we have a seer?

[Shad_]

There's none in the rules and I never did figure out if it's implied.

[alannalynn]

Basic game will generally have a seer/cop and a doc, but role fishing is no bueno so I wouldn't continue with that questioning if I were you

[Darthe]

Darthe? Are you okay?

In what sense?

 

There's none in the rules and I never did figure out if it's implied.

probably

[alannalynn]

Nevermind, terrible question, shouldn't question sanity, it's rude

[Darthe]

Perfectly insane!

[alannalynn]

Darthe who are you voting? Sooh?

[Darthe]

I don't know.

 

Probably should be.

 

[v] sooh [/v]

[alannalynn]

I don't think they count it if you don't unvote lol, so this is the current count

 

Unofficial Vote Count
 
Sooh (2) - Talya, alannalynn
Hallia (2) - Notbob, Aiel Heart
Heart (2) - Darthe, Hallia

Darthe (1) - Sili

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[Darthe]

We mislynch sooh so often because she has no idea how to do what she wants to do

 

=/

 

Worries me that she is always a mislynch and town just wouldn't know.

[alannalynn]

Is that why you didn't unvote.

 

You still haven't convinced me on Heart.

 

And I'm still not convinced on Hallia either, she doesn't feel like she did in Middle Earth, so I don't know what to do with her.

[Darthe]

I didn't unvote because the mod explicitly told me early on that unvotes didn't have to happen.  

[Darthe]

I'm not trying to convince you of anything.  Make your own impressions and judge mine when you see them and I'll do the same with yours.

[Talya]

@sili - With ref to Hallia, in the Middle Earth game she was full of snark in her comments and was town, in this one she hasn't been at all. She is different in this one.

 

Thank you Darthe, I have some fireworks. I'm fairly confident of Darthe being town at this point. I can see what you are saying about sooh, she does seem to get mislynched, but they have been D1 lynches.

 

I would like to hear a lot more from Sooh and Hally. I would be just as willing to vote Hally.

 

Do we have a deadline, I'm out for the day soon and will be back about 5pm my time (it's 8:40am now)

[Darthe]

Someone impress me.  I think I managed to clear myself more with ~ 20 posts and the last three pages of spew than most of you have all game.

[alannalynn]

Well then if you think Sooh is a mislynch then you may have to convince someone. All I'm asking is for you to defend your reads

 

Talya, do you mean Hallia was mafia in Middle Earth? That's kinda where I'm getting at in defending her, I'm not seeing that same snark and attitude here, so I'm not entirely getting the mafia feel that I did last game

[Sili Quirrels]

@sili - With ref to Hallia, in the Middle Earth game she was full of snark in her comments and was town, in this one she hasn't been at all. She is different in this one.

 

Thank you Darthe, I have some fireworks. I'm fairly confident of Darthe being town at this point. I can see what you are saying about sooh, she does seem to get mislynched, but they have been D1 lynches.

 

I would like to hear a lot more from Sooh and Hally. I would be just as willing to vote Hally.

 

Do we have a deadline, I'm out for the day soon and will be back about 5pm my time (it's 8:40am now)

she was a wolf in the middle earth game.

[Sili Quirrels]

Someone impress me.  I think I managed to clear myself more with ~ 20 posts and the last three pages of spew than most of you have all game.

 

 

GJ! =D

[Talya]

There has to be at least two mafia on my train, I can't believe they wouldn't put another one me apart from Dae. Sooh wasn't on either, so another place a wolf might want to be.

 

@alanna  and sili - i had it in my head she was town. Ok that changes her meta side of for me. I still want her to explain her thoughts on why she thinks people are town. and her lack of understanding what i was after wasn't a good response. I'm going to have to read her again, now that I have that wrong.

 

Hally - can you please do a list of where you think everyone is and why. Show me you are town.

 

Everyone should do a list like this, with one sentence on why you have them there.

 

I've got to go, otherwise I'm going to miss my train.