Alien mafia [BASIC] - Game Over - Town won

[Talya]

And why?

[Leelou]

Vote Count
 

Dae (4) - Verbs, Notbob, Sili, Shad

Talya (4) - Dae, Heart, Hallia, Darthe

Darthe (1) - Sooh

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

Deadline - Friday noon EDT

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Sili seems to be conflating putting a lynch at l-1 with being as bad as a hammer (something i disagree with).

 

They're equally bad, but someone always has to do it. That's my opinion.

[Sili Quirrels]

TBf I don't much care yet. 20 page game with snap reads and people degenerating into chaos with things like "my wolf read says this person is town so ima vote that person instead of the wolf read"

 

I'm prob not really gonna step up and batman this thing before tomorrow

I've noticed.

[Sili Quirrels]

Dae's last post hasn't changed my mind at all.

[Talya]

Well, here are my general thoughts so far.

 

Probably Town:

Sili - I've liked pretty much everything he's said and done since page 10.  It feels to me like when his American Gods wolf game fell apart he decided to give town his all in this one.  He throws his vote around a lot in a positive sort of way--puts it where questions need to be answered.  And a quick scan of his wolf game there makes me feel like I'm definitely not seeing one here.  Also

 

 

 

I didn't notice this, but interesting connection. My voting you has nothing to do with you pushing me.

 

 

[unvote]

[v]eldrick[/v]

 

 

This was the only thing Eldrick said that made me second-guess my stance on him.  It felt like in the off-chance he was wolf he was setting me up for the next lynch.  Obviously Sili wasn't defending me in any way there, but it does make me feel good about his vote that it came on the heels of the shadiest thing Eldrick said in this game imo.

 

I have to start trusting somebody sooner or later.  Sili's clear as far as I'm concerned.

 

Leaning town:

 

Verbal - He gave the best explanation for voting Eldrick.  When almost everyone else was bandwagoning an easy target to see what happens and move the game along, he popped off with an explanation that made perfect sense.  I don't know if wolf Verbal would go to the trouble or not, because I don't know Verbal, but I don't think most wolves would.

 

Laine - Hunts witches instead of wolves, but with so much vigor...  If she manages to lead a charge it's going to be a mislynch, but I've felt she was town from pretty early on and still do.

Neutral:

Sooh - I feel like she's not an aggressive person and would rather answer questions than dig hard at a target.  Nothing she's said has bothered me, and...  I don't know, she seems like a really nice person, and I can't help but think that nice people are easy to catch being dishonest.  I feel like if she was wolf I'd see it.  That's probably a really bad way for me to approach this game, so I'm not going to allow myself to trust her just yet.

 

Aiel <3 - Post #384 is pretty hard to complain about, and also pretty hard to fully take in in one sitting.  If I dig through it long enough I might find something suspicious, but it read as a very honest assessment of the game so far on the surface.  If she's wolf, she's pretty good at blocking that fact out of her mind when necessary.  She's definitely off my radar for now.  I'll revisit that post and adjust accordingly when/if the time comes.

 

Hallia - Hasn't said much, but hasn't said or done anything suspicious either.  I liked that she called Eldrick derptown early on, before he had a bandwagon and it was no guarantee that things would spiral into a mislynch.  I'm expecting her to go town, but she was so inactive day 1 that I have to hold off forming much of an opinion just yet.

 

Leaning scum:

 

NotBob -- He's starting to feel like a spectator with a vote to me.  I kind of naturally like him, but that doesn't mean anything.  I feel like I have nothing to judge him by, and the more that time goes on the more that's going to make me suspicious of him.

 

Talya -- Considering how much heat Eldrick got for a derp post he made 12 minutes into his game, Talya's hammer merits pretty heavy grilling.  And unlike Eldrick, it's not screaming honest mistake to me.

 

Daetirion -- His reasons for voting Eldrick felt contrived.  Lots of CYA in prep for Eldrick flipping town instead of detailing what finally pushed him to the vote, but he wanted us to believe that he put a great deal of thought into that vote.  He also gave a pretty fluffy, hollow argument against Sili.

 

Probably Scum:

 

Darthe -- If I'm wrong when this game ends, I really hope someone offers me a thorough explanation for why so many people consistently thought he was town.  Not going to beat a dead horse about why I don't like him atm, but nothing has really shaken my day 1 thoughts so far.

 

Going to [v]Talya[/v] for now, would rather see Darthe or Dae lynched though.  If Darthe's wolf I doubt he'll be the first one we catch.  If Dae's town and gets to 5, I don't know, might Talya take one for her team and immediately hammer again?  4 Talya votes and 4 Dae votes is a nice balance.  I want to see how both of them respond.

 

Would that even make sense?  An already suspected wolf Talya revealing to hammer a town Dae at 5 votes?  Or would that be a really dumb move for mafia to make?

 

In the large bold

[Talya]

Sorry Shad it was sili you mentioned in the American Gods game.

[Verbal32]

TBf I don't much care yet. 20 page game with snap reads and people degenerating into chaos with things like "my wolf read says this person is town so ima vote that person instead of the wolf read"

 

I'm prob not really gonna step up and batman this thing before tomorrow

 

This bravado was absent to this degree in the House of Cards game you were an obv villager in.

 

Curious.

[Darthe]

Can we stop talking about an ongoing game?

 

Talya I'm voting you because in 23 pages you've warranted town reading once or twice and a half dozen times over you've been practically outted through poor, misleading, strange performances that don't make sense.

 

If you're town the onus is on you to step up and show it.

[Darthe]

 

TBf I don't much care yet. 20 page game with snap reads and people degenerating into chaos with things like "my wolf read says this person is town so ima vote that person instead of the wolf read"

 

I'm prob not really gonna step up and batman this thing before tomorrow

 

This bravado was absent to this degree in the House of Cards game you were an obv villager in.

 

Curious.

 

Was it?

 

I never knew my cockiness negatively affected peoples ability to read me.  Prob not an issue on my end.

[Sili Quirrels]

Talya sounds okay. Dae claimed vanilla. Dae's defense is to redirect at Talya, appeal to wifom, and not understand window dressing isn't the same as explaining, then spend a paragraph explaining where he was at.

[Sili Quirrels]

Can we stop talking about an ongoing game?

 

Talya I'm voting you because in 23 pages you've warranted town reading once or twice and a half dozen times over you've been practically outted through poor, misleading, strange performances that don't make sense.

 

If you're town the onus is on you to step up and show it.

I don't know what you're referring to.

[Darthe]

I DONT KNOW JUST GO WITH IT OKAY

[alannalynn]

What Laine? I said it wasn't bad, why would that imply you were being annoying?

You didn't imply, I'm pretty sure I remember my state of mind being annoying. >.>

 

/snip/

 

I don't know why I quoted you, actually.

 

But on the last part there, why are you uncomfortable.  If your town reads are on train A and your scum reads are on train B, and you feel better about the person train B is on.....I'm failing to see why you're uncomfortable.  Actually, I'd say that's a pretty darn comfortable spot to be in!

 

Well mystery's solved! lol

Uncomfortable because it feels easy

 

A nice longish post coming up.

 

Alanna

• She's the one that started the push on Eld after his mistake, as we know it is now. Keeps her vote on him
• She does tend to make sweeping statements on how she thinks people play, and isn't too happy when people disagree with her. - not indictative as alignment
• I think the Eld stuff has been done to death, so moving on after that, she thinks Shad,is probably scum with Me and Heart
• Day 2 and she could go with a Shad or Me lynch. But also wants to hear from Heart
• She then says she didn't like my Hammer and that I have been condescending to her (sorry I never meant to be at all...not sure where neither)
• She is then good with Me, AH or Dae as a lynch
• Now she is not willing to vote me and is uncomfortable on the two trains.

Earlier she agreed with sili that she would be happy with either of us on a lynch and now she seems unwilling to put a vote on and is uncomfortable, surely this should be heaven for her. Makes me think she is not willing to put a hammer vote on town (which I know I am), the only other reason not to would be if one of us was a wolf with her (which has to be Dae as far as I'm concerned).

 

I'm going to do this in bits, because I'm off to a spinning class soon, so can whizz off and come back and finish later if need be.

I like your WoTs :) *Reminder to come back to these later

[alannalynn]

Vote Dae

[Talya]

Sili

• Day 1 thinks Darthe and Alanna are town, which he repeats later on as well.
• He accuses Eld of giving up
• Darthe is 90% town
• Day 2 he thinks that Dae is setting up lynches (post #303)
• Prefers to vote for me, AH or Dae
• Thinks that Dae knew Eld was town
• Thinks that Shad maybe a villager

There has been flitting a lot around votes a bit. I'm having a hard time reading him. I came under fire in the Middle Earth game for thinking he was wolf. Everyone went on about he was on town meta it was obvious. Can someone tell me if this is still on his meta, I'm drawn more towards town than wolf. I like what he has had to say on Dae

[Leelou]

Vote Count
 
Dae (5) - Verbs, Notbob, Sili, Shad, Laine
Talya (4) - Dae, Heart, Hallia, Darthe
Darthe (1) - Sooh
 
With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

Deadline - Friday noon EDT

[Sili Quirrels]

I DONT KNOW JUST GO WITH IT OKAY

 

I think Talya's response to the pressure is okay. She's going over everyone commenting on individual players and making her own reads. Although I haven't read her early game in enough detail to comment.

[Talya]

Can we stop talking about an ongoing game? Sorry, I thought it was finished because he mentioned it, I only wrote down what I was reading when I was.

 

Talya I'm voting you because in 23 pages you've warranted town reading once or twice and a half dozen times over you've been practically outted through poor, misleading, strange performances that don't make sense. I'm trying, never said I was good at this game. You too are not making sense in a lot of your posts. If you have problems with me quote the post and say what your question is, this is not helping anyone

 

If you're town the onus is on you to step up and show it. See above, the onus is also on you to step it up

[Sili Quirrels]

There has been flitting a lot around votes a bit. I'm having a hard time reading him. I came under fire in the Middle Earth game for thinking he was wolf. Everyone went on about he was on town meta it was obvious. Can someone tell me if this is still on his meta, I'm drawn more towards town than wolf. I like what he has had to say on Dae

 

I have suspects and apply pressure to feel them out. When they warrant, for whatever reason, a vote, I vote them.  That's my process.

[Verbal32]

 

 

TBf I don't much care yet. 20 page game with snap reads and people degenerating into chaos with things like "my wolf read says this person is town so ima vote that person instead of the wolf read"

 

I'm prob not really gonna step up and batman this thing before tomorrow

 

This bravado was absent to this degree in the House of Cards game you were an obv villager in.

 

Curious.

 

Was it?

 

I never knew my cockiness negatively affected peoples ability to read me.  Prob not an issue on my end.

 

 

We can agree to disagree on this one, heh.

 

You were confident, not cocky, in that game.  You were the #1 consensus villager.

 

This game, you're more cocky than confident.  I can't put my finger on you yet due to this swagger you're using.  I mean, I have an easy solution - I'll string you up if I think it needs to be done.....but I just wanted you clear on what my reason would be.

 

;-)

[Talya]

I have been going through my notes I did today on the game and I don't have much on Verb...which is odd.

[Darthe]

String me up, make me dance.

 

I love it all.

 

Also Talya villa, sili villa, verb maybe not, why am I voting in this group?

 

Something odd here.

 

Let's all lynch sand instead.  I keep forgetting his 4 letter S name among the rest of them.

 

oh yeah it's [v] shad [/v]

[Verbal32]

I have been going through my notes I did today on the game and I don't have much on Verb...which is odd.

 

Verb

 

-BAMF

-nuff said

[Clovdyx]

Vote Count

 

 
Dae (5) - Verbs, Notbob, Sili, Shad, Laine
Talya (4) - Dae, Heart, Hallia, Darthe
Darthe (1) - Sooh
 
With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

Deadline - Friday noon EDT