A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[seph]

Seph when did I move from town to mixed for you?

during d1.

I need to re read the you/yates incident, I don't believe I have really agreed with much you have said lately. I remember early on you felt like town aj, after yates is blurry to me.

that is a quick reads list, I plan on diving into this head first tomorrow. I will give a list+explanations for my listings.

 

 

@eld also why are you ignoring my question...

[seph]

ebwodp end day 1, excuse me.

[Eldrick4221]

I was having trouble with the thread/game, he posted a link to help me.

your right I was baffled, it made me iso him to look at his posts.

I feel like the sooH incident was Wifom and I didn't like how eldrick went at her.

and that is were my suspicion post came from.

I don't get how any of that is suspicious.

I sent you a link to help you understand how advanced mafia works. That's one player helping another player enjoy the game.

What Sooh incident are you referring to? I am actually quite lost on this.

[Eldrick4221]

 

Seph when did I move from town to mixed for you?

during d1.

I need to re read the you/yates incident, I don't believe I have really agreed with much you have said lately. I remember early on you felt like town aj, after yates is blurry to me.

that is a quick reads list, I plan on diving into this head first tomorrow. I will give a list+explanations for my listings.

 

 

@eld also why are you ignoring my question...

 

I didn't mean to. I thought I was replying to you. What was the question?

[seph]

he link here eld

 

 

 

 

 

yea sili's was the only vote.
 

 

Well I can't sleep, so I might as well eat. Sleeping and eating, my two favorite hobbies.

I am leaning voting for Zander, I have not done so because I see others have voted for him and I do not wish to create a runaway wagon which may harm discussion and relieve pressure on everyone else as well.

If the game is multiball, as I understand the term, that means we have a large number of guilty parties.

The discussion will, invariably, die if there are a large number of guilty parties and almost no reason for them to feel under pressure.

What will happen next is easy smokescreening. It is more pro-village to keep the tally low.

But for the record, Zander is my lynch choice today.

Sooh seems villagery, only because I've spoken to her before the game.

I have not a whole lot to read the rest of you based off of.

If you would interact with me more, it would be helpful. Vote me, say why I'm guilty or not guilty, ask me questions, engage in a joke contest, anything.

 

 

 

This is my first advanced game, so I am pretty clueless besides the town and mafia role.

 

This is an advanced game, meaning you can expect ANY of these, and anything else Darthe decided to throw in here, to be here. feel free to read up on it, so you kow what to possibly expect.

 

Link

 

 

 

 

also I misread this quote to sooh.

You say if you had a phase changer, you would be paying attention to the votes, and then point out that you were paying attention to them.

 

I misread this quote^^ I thought it was more accusing but you were just stating what you got from her post.
 

 

 

I am? I hardly remember ever talking to you, or you ever saying i was a suspect. Plz explain

[Darthe]

You all have averaged roughly 20 pages a day thus far.

 

Good job!

[seph]

Darthe this guy above me edited a post^

[Eldrick4221]

If your 'question' was for me to explain why you're a contender, which I think is what you're trying to say there, I did answer that. I just didn't directly quote the question itself.

 

 

I am pretty suspicious of eld with his interaction with sooh and pizza,

also basically calling me scum out of no where seems weird. he hasn't even mentioned my name before that post, except to try and help me.

Part of it has to do with the fact that you were the contending train at the end of the day. Mafia could have stopped the phase when they did so you wouldn't die.

 

Part of it is from points EP made at the beginning of the game. You built a case on him using his opening post. You focused on him instead of looking at other people around.

 

You're right. I didn't notice you. I didn't interact with you. You are a contender for recent developments in my thought process.

 

[Gabriel Kross]

okay weird I could have swore Andrej had made an off-handed comment about Cult, but apparently again I was mistaken. For the record, that was why I asked for the redirect N1 I was under the impression that there was a cult team bcus of something I thought I read. I suspected that if there were any question of whether I was safe from the target they'd target Zander and then I could've tricked Zander into telling me if he was recruited. Clearly that's not at all what happened and the post I thought I saw was indeed just my imagination apparently, so Andrej has been removed from my potential list of mafia for the majority of my reasons for suspecting them being mistaken.

[Eldrick4221]

@Pizza

 

I now realize that I thought your reac

 

okay weird I could have swore Andrej had made an off-handed comment about Cult, but apparently again I was mistaken. For the record, that was why I asked for the redirect N1 I was under the impression that there was a cult team bcus of something I thought I read. I suspected that if there were any question of whether I was safe from the target they'd target Zander and then I could've tricked Zander into telling me if he was recruited. Clearly that's not at all what happened and the post I thought I saw was indeed just my imagination apparently, so Andrej has been removed from my potential list of mafia for the majority of my reasons for suspecting them being mistaken.

He did talk about recruiting. That may be what you're remembering.

[Eldrick4221]

Blah. Ignore the first part of that. i was typing a different post when you posted yours.

[Gabriel Kross]

@Pizza

 

I now realize that I thought your reac

 

okay weird I could have swore Andrej had made an off-handed comment about Cult, but apparently again I was mistaken. For the record, that was why I asked for the redirect N1 I was under the impression that there was a cult team bcus of something I thought I read. I suspected that if there were any question of whether I was safe from the target they'd target Zander and then I could've tricked Zander into telling me if he was recruited. Clearly that's not at all what happened and the post I thought I saw was indeed just my imagination apparently, so Andrej has been removed from my potential list of mafia for the majority of my reasons for suspecting them being mistaken.

He did talk about recruiting. That may be what you're remembering.

can you find it and quote it? because I could not

[Darthe]

Turbo about to start for anyone interested

[Andrej]

I have literally never mentioned recruiting or that there would be a cult or any other recruiting element in this game.

[Eldrick4221]

@ Pizza

 

I now realize that I thought your reaction to Sili's comment about how you are more careful as a wolf was taken out of context. It doesn't sound as bad when given the proper light.

 

That being said, I do want to know your thought process on why you wouldn't vote the person to intend to vote, and still question other people.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I just got in, I'm exhausted but, if you catch me before I fall asleep, and I will check in again before I do, and you direct me to your question(s)...

 

[Yes, I know, it sucks having to repeat yourself]

 

I will answer any and all, within a reasonable number of questions.

 

I have the WIM but my body is failing me. All day with this work related crap.

[Gabriel Kross]

You all have averaged roughly 20 pages a day thus far.

 

Good job!

now if only it weren't the same 7 or so people talking while everyone else hides under a desk

[Eldrick4221]

Sure can. It was on the page I just read.

 

 

This is my first advanced game, so I am pretty clueless besides the town and mafia role.

Multiball means there will be more than 1 scum team. And they have to beat each other as well as Town.

If the game is multiball, as I understand the term, that means we have a large number of guilty parties.

The discussion will, invariably, die if there are a large number of guilty parties and almost no reason for them to feel under pressure.

We may have 1 more guilty party than you would normally find in a game this size BUT that also means each scum team will be smaller in size. So the smaller scum teams make finding scum mates much more difficult than in a normal game PLUS both scum teams have to actually scum hunt to find the other team which, in turn, forces them to post more villagery.

Multiball could also mean this is a recruiting game. So you need to be on the look out for interactions that do a 180. That could be a cop clear or that could be a recruit that got recruited. It's a mess and typically doesn't end well for the Town.

 

[Gabriel Kross]

I just got in, I'm exhausted but, if you catch me before I fall asleep, and I will check in again before I do, and you direct me to your question(s)...

 

[Yes, I know, it sucks having to repeat yourself]

 

I will answer any and all, within a reasonable number of questions.

 

I have the WIM but my body is failing me. All day with this work related crap.

what are your current reads?

[Andrej]

@Pizza

 

 

It still bugs me that Zander was Pizza's lynch choice, but that he never moved his vote to him.

I would actually like to hear him expound on his scum read for you.

[Gabriel Kross]

 

Sure can. It was on the page I just read.

 

 

This is my first advanced game, so I am pretty clueless besides the town and mafia role.

Multiball means there will be more than 1 scum team. And they have to beat each other as well as Town.

If the game is multiball, as I understand the term, that means we have a large number of guilty parties.

 

The discussion will, invariably, die if there are a large number of guilty parties and almost no reason for them to feel under pressure.

We may have 1 more guilty party than you would normally find in a game this size BUT that also means each scum team will be smaller in size. So the smaller scum teams make finding scum mates much more difficult than in a normal game PLUS both scum teams have to actually scum hunt to find the other team which, in turn, forces them to post more villagery.

 

Multiball could also mean this is a recruiting game. So you need to be on the look out for interactions that do a 180. That could be a cop clear or that could be a recruit that got recruited. It's a mess and typically doesn't end well for the Town.

 

 

that was Yates u.u

[Andrej]

 

You all have averaged roughly 20 pages a day thus far.

 

Good job!

 

now if only it weren't the same 7 or so people talking while everyone else hides under a desk

ikr

[Eldrick4221]

You're right. It is. I don't know why I thought that's who you were talking about.

[Eldrick4221]

Are you going to ignore me again, Pizza?

[Askthepizzaguy]

@ Pizza

 

I now realize that I thought your reaction to Sili's comment about how you are more careful as a wolf was taken out of context. It doesn't sound as bad when given the proper light.

 

That being said, I do want to know your thought process on why you wouldn't vote the person to intend to vote, and still question other people.

 

Eldrick, you have impeccable timing. Yours were the questions I saw while catching up that I felt needed a response.

 

Early read on someone being scum probably because they were behaving differently, they had a knowledge role which can cause folks to behave differently.

 

After leaving suspicion on him I saw what I felt was better day one reasons to vote for you. Returning to the original suspect became less and less valid, to me, and that's before the mason-ish behavior.

 

Then you basically began questioning why I wasn't following up on him, while my vote was on you, it made it seem to me like you were attacking me for consistency reasons (wolfy process, villagers understand basic inconsistency) and also trying to get my vote off of you.

 

I didn't think your questioning of me was legitimate, and I thought it would be telling to see if anyone took sides in our dispute.

 

I didn't see a whole lot of support for or against either of our positions. Either we have some scumbags who are good about not flinching or we have a villager villager interaction, or you could be one of the multiballs.

 

I can't figure you out but given the lack of agreement on your wolfishness I think it would be more productive for me to table it and suggest another guess rather than tunnel you all game.

 

If you could begin acting more villagery that would be quite helpful to me.