A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Verbal32]

I'd say aj and yates seems v/v but I said that about cory and yates last game and lolme

 

Ha, xpost.  I'm thinking the same thing........but w/w.

[Verbal32]

Like, scum from different teams "scumhunting" at one another.  That's my feeling right now.

[monstrman]

 

I'd say aj and yates seems v/v but I said that about cory and yates last game and lolme

 

 

Ha, xpost.  I'm thinking the same thing........but w/w.

Yeah the fight almost doesn't feel natural in these coming posts. It's a lot of "no you're scummy." "No YOURE scummy." "No YOU. You're the scummy one."

[Verbal32]

@Yates-

 

Who is your #1 for scum right now?

[monstrman]

Like, scum from different teams "scumhunting" at one another.  That's my feeling right now.

nice xpost also. I think you're one of my strongest villager reads now not kidding lol

[monstrman]

I remember dice being villagery at one point but haven't read in prolly 20 pages

 

Verbal what do you think of dice?

[monstrman]

I mean I only ask because last game I called him a villager for a similar reason I think and he was a villager then.

 

I feel so out of sync with this thread being this far behind

[Leelou]

 

Wrong answer, Yates.

Then you are looking at the wrong answer sheet. It's the right answer because it happens to be the case. I could make something up for you if you would like? But I'll put it in spoilers along with a warning that the post does not reflect my actual opinions. LMK?

 

 

No, Yates. I'd like your actual thoughts as to how you got from he's scummy and an independent read from EP's soft claim to pulling info out of him like you are pulling teeth. 

[Verbal32]

 

Like, scum from different teams "scumhunting" at one another.  That's my feeling right now.

nice xpost also. I think you're one of my strongest villager reads now not kidding lol

 

 

Heh, random question:  why did you capitalize random letters in one of your early posts?  I checked to see if it was a breadcrumb, but I couldn't discern if it was....so my apologies if I'm blowing something up right now....

[Verbal32]

I remember dice being villagery at one point but haven't read in prolly 20 pages

 

Verbal what do you think of dice?

 

I don't have a read on him yet.  I'm still plowing through the middle of this thread, so I'll see what I end up with when I return to "current".

[monstrman]

Oh that's my phone autocorrect it's annoying as all bloody hell

[Verbal32]

Ok.  I felt funny asking in case it was some elaborate ruse I just screwed up, but when I can't decipher something I get uneasy.  I feel better now.

[Yates]

I'd say aj and yates seems v/v but I said that about cory and yates last game and lolme

The difference in that game is we invented a meta argument.

 

This argument is based on events that actually occurred in THIS game. And you are more than welcome to weigh in on it giving your impressions/understanding of how this actually went down.

 

 

***

 

Basically, AJ claimed he found Tina suspicious for voting Zander because when she voted for Zander she quoted Sili's case. AH! But she quoted the WRONG Sili case! TOWN Tina would not have quoted the WRONG Sili case!

 

When pressed, he also said that SCUM Tina HAD to change her post or face scrutiny while ignoring the fact that TOWN Tina would ALSO change her post recognizing that she simply made a mistake in quoting.

 

Now he is trying to say that he never implied that her changing her post was in any way alignment indicative. And I am arguing that he is making a demonstrably false statement with regards to this assertion.

 

Please tell me if you think I'm misconstruing any of this.

[Talya]

I can't believe you have done it again. I have been trying to catch up on my phone all day, but hard when your boss is around all the time.

 

Going to try this:

 

[v]Sili[/v]

 

I'll keep it there for the time being. Plus I wanted to try it out.

[Verbal32]

 

I'd say aj and yates seems v/v but I said that about cory and yates last game and lolme

The difference in that game is we invented a meta argument.

 

This argument is based on events that actually occurred in THIS game. And you are more than welcome to weigh in on it giving your impressions/understanding of how this actually went down.

 

 

***

 

Basically, AJ claimed he found Tina suspicious for voting Zander because when she voted for Zander she quoted Sili's case. AH! But she quoted the WRONG Sili case! TOWN Tina would not have quoted the WRONG Sili case!

 

When pressed, he also said that SCUM Tina HAD to change her post or face scrutiny while ignoring the fact that TOWN Tina would ALSO change her post recognizing that she simply made a mistake in quoting.

 

Now he is trying to say that he never implied that her changing her post was in any way alignment indicative. And I am arguing that he is making a demonstrably false statement with regards to this assertion.

 

Please tell me if you think I'm misconstruing any of this.

 

 

FTR, I think you've presented the situation pretty accurately.

[Talya]

A silly question how do I unvote?

[Yates]

A silly question how do I unvote?

[ unvote ]

 

Without the spaces.

[Leelou]

I can't believe you have done it again. I have been trying to catch up on my phone all day, but hard when your boss is around all the time.

 

Going to try this:

 

[v]Sili[/v]

 

I'll keep it there for the time being. Plus I wanted to try it out.

 

Eh. Have you played with Sili before? 

[Talya]

Thank you Yates and to Sili for giving me the first bit..

[Yates]

I'd like your actual thoughts as to how you got from he's scummy and an independent read from EP's soft claim to pulling info out of him like you are pulling teeth.

???

 

That's my point? I'm trying to pull info out of him so I can understand what he's thinking. Like, I didn't see why he would think Tina was scummy outside of OMGUS, for example. However, I can see where he thought she was demonstrating cognitive dissonance with regards to the bandwagon angle. So even if I disagree with his read, I at least have something to work with. I'm trying to go a couple of layers deeper but I'm still waiting for him to respond.

[Yates]

@Leelou - have you fleshed out your Skittles post yet?

[Talya]

 

I can't believe you have done it again. I have been trying to catch up on my phone all day, but hard when your boss is around all the time.

 

Going to try this:

 

[v]Sili[/v]

 

I'll keep it there for the time being. Plus I wanted to try it out.

 

Eh. Have you played with Sili before? 

 

 

Nope...not played with many so just going with how I see it at the time. Too many names to remember

[Yates]

Ha, xpost.  I'm thinking the same thing........but w/w.

TBF - you aren't very good at reading Town Yates...  

[Hallia]

TBF - Who is? ;p

[Yates]

TBF - Who is? ;p

3 people.  But I'm not saying whooooooo!!