A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Yates]

However I'm not going to argue this point out any longer, there's no reason to.

Do you see how more than one person interpreted your post in that way, though? And why we would interpret it that way? This is kind of important.

[Askthepizzaguy]

 

Hey, Yatesy, leave that Sooh alone. ;)

It's all your fault.

 

Why is Sooh Town? Besides the reason I gave AJ for your read, I mean?

 

She's still learning. I don't feel that she's confident enough yet to begin voting early and then unvoting a lot in an early part of a game.

 

I am not underestimating her, or her mentor, but let's say she were guilty. If so, she may wish to find a reasonable and safe vote and plop it down to minimize risk, park it on one person for a while.

 

If she's prodding people, she's contributing to the solve and leaving more information about herself in the thread with which to trip herself up or her guilty team later.

 

I don't know if she wants to do that yet.

 

I also haven't seen her play before, so I have selfish reasons. I want to see her work unpressured for a while, and learn what her baseline read is, for whatever role she may have, or alignment.

 

Then, I will feel more confident reading her later on in the game, or in future games.

 

If that baseline is spoiled by vote pressure, which is much harder for new players to deal with, it will be harder for me to know where she's coming from later on, at a critical moment in the game, should she survive that long.

[Sooh]

 

you've all been bust this weekend i see. Good, makes it nice to catch up and easier to find suspects.

 

I'll start reading when i can, weekend is done and was way too short (again)

 

 

 

the speed with which you people keep posting, i'll never get caught up in this game

 

Why this grand change in attitude towards much posting? Strange..

[Gabriel Kross]

Also @Sili in a previous game I've had 2 mafia teamates take the opposite sides of a single conversation, it's called distancing. It wasn't something I was even considering could have been happening because I had no read on you at the time. However with how sure of himself Eld is and how you came to Pizza's defense, basing on my current read of you, I feel you set the whole thing up.

 

Town reads on:

Pizza

Zander

 

not town reads on:

Sili

Eld

Hallia

 

No freaking clue on:

Verbal. (GET READING!)

[alannalynn]

 

EP you didn't answer my question.

I did go read my statement again. It's the fact that he is new and speculating with no actual information from flips coroner reports night actions or what have you that peaked my suspicion. None of the other speculators that I noticed fell under the same criteria that caused me to find Eld suspicious.

 

I don't like when people leave out information. So I linked pertinent information, if I missed something let me know.

 

Eldrick

Here

Here

Here

 

Yates/Pizza

Here

[Leelou]

Leelou I'd like to hear your thoughts on Seph. You voted him but you gave no details.

 

Verbal I'd like you to actually read the thread. A skimmy Verbal is a scummy Verbal.

 

Darthe have you tried to contact John Snow and Talya since initial role PMs went out? John has posted in other threads since this game has started.

 

1. I couldn't read through the multiquotes anymore, and I agree with Yates that it being one of you two isn't a bad option right now, I'm just not getting bad vibes from you yet so I voted for Seph. Could change after I see how he reacts in thread.

 

2. BS. That is all. (yes, take this as a defense of someone else).  

[Sili Quirrels]

<3 Pizza

[Sili Quirrels]

Also @Sili in a previous game I've had 2 mafia teamates take the opposite sides of a single conversation, it's called distancing. It wasn't something I was even considering could have been happening because I had no read on you at the time. However with how sure of himself Eld is and how you came to Pizza's defense, basing on my current read of you, I feel you set the whole thing up.

 

Town reads on:

Pizza

Zander

 

not town reads on:

Sili

Eld

Hallia

 

No freaking clue on:

Verbal. (GET READING!)

[Gabriel Kross]

 

 

EP you didn't answer my question.

I did go read my statement again. It's the fact that he is new and speculating with no actual information from flips coroner reports night actions or what have you that peaked my suspicion. None of the other speculators that I noticed fell under the same criteria that caused me to find Eld suspicious.

 

I don't like when people leave out information. So I linked pertinent information, if I missed something let me know.

 

Eldrick

Here

Here

Here

 

Yates/Pizza

Here

 

Again I had specific criteria for only singling out Eld. Neither Yates or Pizza are new to mafia, I'm not understanding what you don't understand about this

[Askthepizzaguy]

Ok, so, catching up. 

 

Sili seems eager to get the game going and to figure people out. That is a good look. He also seems relaxed in his interactions, and picks up on a whole lot of things and questions them. Town

 

AJ feels pretty much the same as in our previous game together. He seems town to me.

 

Eldrick is someone I have only played with when he was scum, but he feels rather different this time around. More open, curious, asking questions. Villagery.

 

Tress is very relaxed and seems to be village. 

 

Tina seems to be poking a little bit at a few different people. Town lean. 

 

On the other end of the spectrum right now I see Yates. His tone seems off this game, and he seems to post a lot of fluff. Biggest lead I have so far. 

 

[v]Yates[/v]

This is what I was looking for.

 

A leans list, mostly generated without being under severe vote pressure.

 

If these leans change I'll want to know the reasons.

 

<3

[alannalynn]

I feel like I'm being called dense.

[seph]

Well I had a post written up here with a reads list, but for some reason my electricity went out, ruining it and all the notes I just made.....
I am re-workin the reads list now as it helps me gather my thoughts.

[Sooh]

**snip**

 

This is what I was looking for.

A leans list, mostly generated without being under severe vote pressure.

 

If these leans change I'll want to know the reasons.

 

<3

 

Well... I tend to do that, so... 

 

Also Team Pootaloot won't be pushed around! We're busy winning a game! 

[Alot]

It may just be me today, but my eyes are actually blurring trying to make sense of you all and it isn't working.  I'm going to have to wait for alot of people to die and stop cluttering the thread and I'll go from there.

[Darthe]

I feel like I'm being called dense.

[Darthe]

Love that x post

[seph]

It may just be me today, but my eyes are actually blurring trying to make sense of you all and it isn't working.  I'm going to have to wait for alot of people to die and stop cluttering the thread and I'll go from there.

your posts have been encouraging and really make me want to keep playing this game... thank you 

[Sili Quirrels]

You're just being an ignorant blockhead if you're on my team.

 

You implied you didn't like it, that is actually what you happened. I believe the inconsistency along with your strawman response is scummy. It is not only obvious you dissaproved of me defending him, it is also obvious you approved of Eldrick's case on Pizza. It shows me you're not paying attention. The tinfoil that me and Eldrick are merely distancing doesn't make any sense to me and is horribly convenient for you. You literally don't have a good reason for having me as scum, and I'm not even sure you have a good reason why Eldrick is.

 

I have fos'd you because I interpreted something you said as inconsistent with something else you said, so it is important to me and it is important to you. What you have done so far is said I am ridiculous, put your blinders on, and said I am scum because I am ridiculous, and said it is not useful to explain why I am being ridiculous.

[Sili Quirrels]

^@ EP, obs.

[Sooh]

It may just be me today, but my eyes are actually blurring trying to make sense of you all and it isn't working.  I'm going to have to wait for alot of people to die and stop cluttering the thread and I'll go from there.

Parphrase: I won't help anyone until this game is smaller?

 

Also hi again!

[Gabriel Kross]

You're just being an ignorant blockhead if you're on my team.

 

You implied you didn't like it, that is actually what you happened. I believe the inconsistency along with your strawman response is scummy. It is not only obvious you dissaproved of me defending him, it is also obvious you approved of Eldrick's case on Pizza. It shows me you're not paying attention. The tinfoil that me and Eldrick are merely distancing doesn't make any sense to me and is horribly convenient for you. You literally don't have a good reason for having me as scum, and I'm not even sure you have a good reason why Eldrick is.

 

I have fos'd you because I interpreted something you said as inconsistent with something else you said, so it is important to me and it is important to you. What you have done so far is said I am ridiculous, put your blinders on, and said I am scum because I am ridiculous, and said it is not useful to explain why I am being ridiculous.

I fos'd you because you assumed things that weren't written. I'm nothing if not blatent when I have an opinion on something.

[Sili Quirrels]

I don't understand why someone who is new is less likely to ask about mechanics than someone who is more experienced. Seems to me it would be the opposite

 

.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

You're just being an ignorant blockhead if you're on my team.

 

You implied you didn't like it, that is actually what you happened. I believe the inconsistency along with your strawman response is scummy. It is not only obvious you dissaproved of me defending him, it is also obvious you approved of Eldrick's case on Pizza. It shows me you're not paying attention. The tinfoil that me and Eldrick are merely distancing doesn't make any sense to me and is horribly convenient for you. You literally don't have a good reason for having me as scum, and I'm not even sure you have a good reason why Eldrick is.

 

I have fos'd you because I interpreted something you said as inconsistent with something else you said, so it is important to me and it is important to you. What you have done so far is said I am ridiculous, put your blinders on, and said I am scum because I am ridiculous, and said it is not useful to explain why I am being ridiculous.

I fos'd you because you assumed things that weren't written. I'm nothing if not blatent when I have an opinion on something.

 

That is exactly what I'm talking about, and is exactly what you refuse to talk about or reconsider.

[Yates]

I'm going to have to wait for alot of people to die and stop cluttering the thread and I'll go from there.

Let me help you with that...

[v]Alot[/v]

[Alot]

 

It may just be me today, but my eyes are actually blurring trying to make sense of you all and it isn't working.  I'm going to have to wait for alot of people to die and stop cluttering the thread and I'll go from there.

Parphrase: I won't help anyone until this game is smaller?

 

Also hi again!

 

Hi again.

 

More like I don't have the mental effort to spare right now to try and get through hundreds of posts full of gross quotes and actually comprehend what I'm reading, let alone scumhunt through it.