A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Clovdyx]

I smashed it at the end. But for the wrong reason lol  As soon as I died i jumped on AJ being mafia.

 

 

but whatcha got clov?

 

This was my list from the first day of the game (not D1, the phase, but the literal opening day), as posted in Dead Thread:

 

 

 

17. Tress

12. Sili

20. Eternal Phoenix

15. Andrej- Better Than You

16. Alannalynn

18. Zander

5. Dice

22. Yates

24. Pizzaguy

 

 

1. Hally

2. Sooh - mentored by Corn

3. Alot

4. Alanna

6. John Snow

7. Thane

8. Verbal

9. Talya

10. Eldrick

11. Leelou

13. Krak

14. Taborline

 

21. TinaHel

19. seph - mentored by Kaylee

23. Cass/Monstr - Anola Gay

 

Didn't want to commit on Hallia, Sooh, Alot, Leelou, Thane, or Eldrick. Gun to my head, I would have thrown Sooh as town and MAYBE Eldrick for seemingly having an increased interest. If he rolled mafia for the fourth straight game after his hiatus, especially given how last game went, I think he would be pretty bummed out. Hallia/Alot/Leelou/Thane early nothing more than completely rand so I wouldn't have bothered with them. 

 

Almost went Pizza on mafia, but I felt that was too many mafia for the amount of nulls I had. Reasoning was I just got a different feeling from him in the champ's game, where I locked him in as town by EoD1. He had an insane amount of posts, but a lot of them were very substantiated, lengthy posts. This seems like more short multi-quotes to give the illusion of contribution.

 

Don't feel the least bit bad about being wrong on AJ or Lainey. AndreJ is - and will forever be - #BetterThanYou, so I accept that. I don't know anything about Lainey but I like what I've seen so far. Her alcoholism is +EV too

 

So my top four mafia candidates were all mafia, and 80% on my top ten town reads.

[dicetosser1]

yeah i think yates living makes a helluva difference.

\\Darthe  that role?  so for eg  Im it and I choose yates and AJ. Yates dies. Do I know what that means?  Do i find out that AJ is mafia? Do i even find out that it was MY role that killed yates? 

[dicetosser1]

What was it that made you put me as town?

[Darthe]

Let me give an example

 

Darthe is that role, which he just named Dredd 

 

Dice is a wolf

 

Clov is town

 

Cass is town

 

Darthe views clov and links clov to cass on D1.  Nothing happens.  Thus Darthe knows they must either be both mafia or both town.  

 

For whatever reason Darthe thinks clov is the townier of the two.  He views dice and links him to clov.  Dice, wolf has been shot.  Now Darthe knows that Clov and Cass are town and he killed a wolf.  Had he viewed clov again and linked him to dice then Clov would have died and flipped town and he would know dice is a wolf.

 

I think that's how it works.  For balance it might be that the townie is always the one to die in a pair and that you just get no result if people are the same alignment.  Similarly it might be that you can't target people twice to keep you from getting confirmed people and bouncing off of them.  It could be a very interesting role.  

[Eldrick4221]

It's like a vig/cop combo.  You select two players and if they are the same alignment neither die, however if they are a different alignment then the one you select first dies.  That could be fitting here.  I think town would have had a very different game had Yates not died N1 or had Krak submitted nightly but overall it was probably a bit biased against town.  

 

That role sounds awesome. I'm gonna have the remember that.

 

Could I get a link to the info?

[Eldrick4221]

By the way. Good job AJ. You had me completely fooled. Not gonna trust you anymore :P

[Darthe]

 

It's like a vig/cop combo.  You select two players and if they are the same alignment neither die, however if they are a different alignment then the one you select first dies.  That could be fitting here.  I think town would have had a very different game had Yates not died N1 or had Krak submitted nightly but overall it was probably a bit biased against town.  

 

That role sounds awesome. I'm gonna have the remember that.

 

Could I get a link to the info?

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/94166-a-tale-of-middle-earth-game-over/?p=3475474

[dicetosser1]

Darthe   you remeber how i was ure guinea pig for the Double voter role??  well i think you owe me one and i know how i wanna collect lol

[Darthe]

But if I do that I have the sense that you're going to vote Darthe.

[dicetosser1]

Howd you know that???  Are you the Seer!!???

[dicetosser1]

hehehe  unless AJ and Len are in the game. Cause then I view them straight away in a darthe game

[Darthe]

Oh yeah.  Len every time.  He wasn't even in this game and I advised Cass to view him.

[Clovdyx]

What was it that made you put me as town?

 

I try to put people in the spot that matches their alignment.

[Darthe]

 

What was it that made you put me as town?

 

I try to put people in the spot that matches their alignment.

 

You are on fire tonight

[dicetosser1]

 

What was it that made you put me as town?

 

I try to put people in the spot that matches their alignment.

 

 

Waves hand in front of clov   "you want to tell me what made you put me as town"

[Sili Quirrels]

 

It's like a vig/cop combo.  You select two players and if they are the same alignment neither die, however if they are a different alignment then the one you select first dies.  That could be fitting here.  I think town would have had a very different game had Yates not died N1 or had Krak submitted nightly but overall it was probably a bit biased against town.  

 

That role sounds awesome. I'm gonna have the remember that.

 

Could I get a link to the info?

 

[Darthe]

Sili <3 when are we gonna town together again?

[dicetosser1]

Also, never played where we don't get a kill every night... 

That a common thing if there's more than one faction of Wilves?

(This is exciting!)

 

 

clov u wanted to address this

[Sili Quirrels]

Sili <3 when are we gonna town together again?

Like, next game I hope, or we'll pretend to be anyway.

[dicetosser1]

oh and i notice noone caught my char hint lol

[Leelou]

gg guys

[Darthe]

oh and i notice noone caught my char hint lol

I sure didn't

[dicetosser1]

Well seems like today is my day. one of my favorite themes starts and im not at work  awesome!

 

Do you aj, and you tress use the same opening posts every game? Lol

 

Well I know AJ doesnt cause this one isnt gonna get me trying to lynch him.

 

 

Vote:Talya    welcome back hun!

 

Durins Day

[dicetosser1]

wonder what woulda happened if Cass HAD peeked Pizza.....

[Darthe]

 

Well seems like today is my day. one of my favorite themes starts and im not at work  awesome!

 

Do you aj, and you tress use the same opening posts every game? Lol

 

Well I know AJ doesnt cause this one isnt gonna get me trying to lynch him.

 

 

Vote:Talya    welcome back hun!

 

Durins Day

 

Oh of course!