Avatar The Last Airbender Town and SK wins!

[Eldrick4221]

Oh, and still feeling good about finding scum with seph, so [v]Seph[/v]

[Kaylee]

Official Vote Count

 

Sooh (1): Thane

Seph (1): Eldrick

 

Not Voting (5): Zander, Sooh, Seph, Tress, Turin

 

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch

 

Deadline is May 5th @ 4pm MST

 

Countdown Timer: http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20150505T16&p0=3862&fg2=0fa595&msg=End+of+D3&csz=1

[seph]

doing all of my iso atm.

[Turin Turambar]

doing all of my iso atm.

ALL YOUR ISOS ARE OURS!!!

 

[Thane Vakarian]

 

doing all of my iso atm.

ALL YOUR ISOS ARE OURS!!!

 

 

i think you meant:

 

All your iso are belong to us

[seph]

lol, I have only done 4, however I am pretty sure I should not talk off the top of my head anymore. a lot of things I had misinterpreted, still some questions.  I will have it posted soon I hope.

[Turin Turambar]

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

doing all of my iso atm.

ALL YOUR ISOS ARE OURS!!!

 

 

i think you meant:

 

All your iso are belong to us

 

yes. oops.

[Turin Turambar]

take your time Seph. No one getting lynched before I have lunch today.

[seph]

I think I am getting bbq, famous daves as I have yet to try it.

[Turin Turambar]

See you next game Ithi.

 

I do think that town has a vig. Which is great. I don't think there's another special ability out there. We're here:

 

Alive:

6. Thane

1. Zander (mentored by Cory)

8. Tress

12. Turin

7. Seph (mentored by Dice)

3. Eldrick

4. Sooh (mentored by Clov)

 

i know i'm town, that leaves 6. Zander made his VT claim, i think it was a n00b mistake, buying it for now. Leaves 5. Tress and Turing both strike me as town this game. Leaves 3.

 

More town feels than wolf for Seph and Eldrick, but i feel less confident about them.

 

by POE, Sooh is a wolf to me. She does have a good game, but... yeah... Being mentored changes her playstyle she said... though i think she has been mentored in previous games before. Doesn't add up.

 

dead ones:

 

 

5. Not Bob - Sokka, Town Cop Killed N1

9. AJ - Iroh, VT killed N1

11. Ithi - Aang, VT killed N2

 

2. Nolder - May, Mafia Goon Killed N2

10. John Snow - Azula, Mafia Goon lynched D2

 

 

[v]Sooh[/v]

What do you mean by the bolded at top?

What makes you think that?

 

What is the thing about Sooh's play this game that strikes you the most into thinking she would be mafia?

[Kaylee]

I think I am getting bbq, famous daves as I have yet to try it.

It's yummy! I like all the different kinds of sauce.

[seph]

 

I think I am getting bbq, famous daves as I have yet to try it.

It's yummy! I like all the different kinds of sauce.

 

I hope i get to go there for lunch, might have to wait for dinner though.

[seph]

This is going to take awhile, I will just post my iso's while I am going. I am doing the noted town. Seeing who they like/don't like. then going through noted mafia. then everyone else.

 

Aj noting views I think are important.

from reading aj I am most suspicious of eldrick, and thane. I am wondering about zander here. and Turin is null maybe slight town.(note aj has him as town through the entire game I believe)

 

 

Tress with some bite. I like it
 

(see tress for my thoughts)

 

 

 

 

EBWODP 

[v]NotBob[/v]

 

Blind lynching is a very bad idea. 

 

I agree, and I don't plan to.hoping to get more people in here.

 

 

 

I find this alarming. You agree that blind lynching is a bad idea, but you're doing it anyway.

 

That's the second time you've done something suspicious that caught my attention.

 

[v]Speh[/v]

 

Now you, I actually think could be scum. Considering the level of confidence I have in my read on Seph at this point, your vote coming here after he'd been getting whipped all day by others looks really bad to me.

 

I'm also feeling better about Not Bob from his posting today, he's another one trending up for me, so I no longer feel the need to be voting him.

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Eldrick[/v]

 

(see eldrick for my thoughts)

 

 

 

 

While seph is my strongest candidate, it is highly unlikely he'll be lynched today. I'm going to move my vote, so it doesn't go to waste, being i probably won't be on again before the deadline.
 
AJ is high on my suspect list, and has 2 votes. Seems like the smartest choice.
 
[unvote]
[v]AJ[/v]

  

Seph's points about john snow are ringing true. I find that interesting, being I still suspect seph. Is this a W/W thing?
 
Also willing to move my vote over to John Snow, should I wake up and see a train there. For now, sleep.

Neither of these posts look good for you.

First you jump ship as soon as Snow unvotes Seph to move onto me and then you talk about being willing to vote him later. Looks to me that you're just going with the flow and tossing your vote onto whichever wagon.

I could definitely rally here and see this dude get lynched.

 

 

 

Don't worry Eldrick, you'll be dealt with 

 

• Quote
• MultiQuote
•  
•  
•  

 Posted by Andrej on 30 April 2015 - 05:41 PM in DM Mafia Games

Thane Vakarian, on 30 Apr 2015 - 11:38 AM, said:

imo, it sucks that we probably will need this nights flips to work with. I have some doubts that anybody will reach majority

That statement rings especially hollow from you considering you aren't voting anyone.

 

 

 

AJ, seeing you're here, and Notbob isn't.... if i read correctly what he wrote, he accused you of having an agenda. Though he doesn't follow up on it, and you haven't commented on it. I pointed it out when i made my last reads list... 
 
care to tell me/us what you make of it?

I responded to it last night and like I said there you'll have to take it up with Not Bob. I can't tell why he used that word in particular or what he meant by it. My opinion? He probably meant the 'agenda' was me suggesting to run him up and then asking everyone their opinions on it. As to why he hadn't listed me as a suspect could be because he doesn't find my body of work as suspicious as others. I don't know but I did address his statement to explain my actions on the subject.

Why do you think he is voting you?

 

 

I find this statement of thane's rather fishy.

 

 

 

 

Justify it however you'd like Turin. You're still going to come out looking bad.

It's funny the way you like to characterize things so that they fit your means. I was going to mention this in your last post when you asked me about Nolder's "misreps" which was basically nothing more than you framing the argument beforehand. I'm not sure if you did this consciously, probably not, but it still amuses me a little.

I told you earlier I talk straight. When I say I don't have an opinion on it yet, it's because I don't. Watching the conflict between you two is going to help me shape my read on the both of you. But apparently that isn't the answer you are seeking so by nature you try to characterize it as negatively as possible by labeling as political speech.

 

He has turin as town, From aj posts I have mixed feelings. null- maybe slight town.

 

 

 

Was sort of hoping you'd come in with a home run @Tress

I was hoping the same here.

 

 

 

 

 

 

btw the fact that you're still voting AJ just further proves my point.
How can you say I'm your #1 suspect while you're voting someone else.
Doesn't make any sense.

Once again yiu have misrepped. Look at the original. Read the section properly.I am talking about your interaction with AJ as most troubling. It is all one paragraph. Not two.
try again...


Maybe you should be bussing AJ.

 

I already went over the entire post and explained why I think the context was irrelevant.

If you want to cry misrep (is that all you do?) why don't you explain how the context is relevant?

I'm not going over the post again. I just did it.

 

Turin was saying he thinks my most suspicious interaction was with you.

 

turin could be linking, but this is a slight doubt here.

 

[seph]

no bob seemed most suspicious of me thane and eldrick, noting on zander.

 

 

Zander why are you claiming like that?

 

^^^^This^^^^

 

early game thoughts

 

 

 

My possible mafia so far are within seph, thane,AJ and Eldrick.

 

It would these have an agenda...probably scum in this mix.

 

early game thoughts

 

 

 

 

EBWODP 

[v]NotBob[/v]

 

 

I feel the worst about snow, thane, or zander

I feel like ithi, Tress, turin are town

everyone else is null.

 

Ithi I hope you know I was provoking you hoping for that reaction. All of my intents are for the town.

 

Thane what made you have a gut feeling on me? Playing with dice last game I had the same problem as I just do not understand it.

 

^^^ non-sequitur ^^^

 

I explained this later to him. I believe it is what eldrick is voting me for?

 

 

 

Pretty sure Seph is scum...could also vote Eldrick...but for now...Unvote, Vote Thane

 

don't get the thane vote. seems he feels worst about me and eldrick.

 

 

 

 

 

FWIW I believe Tress is town.

 

How about a vote?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I feel like Seph is one I'd like to see live beyond D1, because I find his posts as of right now more like he's trying to find his way in the game and make his play his own. He doesn't feel at all like he has an agenda like he did after he returned as mafia in his first game. 

 

I also find Tress' posts to ring town to me, because she seems genuine in her frustration. 

 

As for Turin I need some more time to read him more accurately. 

 

I think I'd like to take a look at Ithi's posts and see if there is anything there now to start with. 

 

This is not comforting.

 

Ok. Why?

 

 

Seph looks more inconsistent than the others...thoughts on Thane?

 

this was all of his 1 page of posts.

 

 

[Thane Vakarian]

@Turin: This is a basic game, if i recall correctly. So, protective roles as bodyguard wouldn't be in. That was what i was thinking about. The only explanation for the double kill would be town vig (to me, unless someone has a better idea)

 

as for Sooh: when i look at the game, simply using POE, i get to her as most likely.

[seph]

Thane why would you announce who you thought was vig if you were town?

[Turin Turambar]

@Thane, fair enough for the first.

 

I think that there should be something that you could point to to make Sooh the most likely mafia. I have my reasons for suspecting her. I wanted to hear what yours were. Frankly PoE doesn't really cut it for me. 

[Thane Vakarian]

i don't think i'm pointing out a vig, Seph. No idea who he/she would be. But that's ok. Vig should only claim last second. My comment about Sooh, towards Turin, was why i have her as top suspect for wolf

[Turin Turambar]

Thane why would you announce who you thought was vig if you were town?

did he do this?

[Thane Vakarian]

you had my main point about Sooh in the quote you used.

 

"She does have a good game, but... yeah... Being mentored changes her playstyle she said... though i think she has been mentored in previous games before. Doesn't add up."

 

Also, this is her third game i think... looking at gameplay... i really don't know. She is likely to have help outside her mentor (nothing against you Clov)

[seph]

I was reading sooh to be the one he stated in the above comment.
It was directed at you from your previous sooh question. my bad

[Turin Turambar]

you had my main point about Sooh in the quote you used.

 

"She does have a good game, but... yeah... Being mentored changes her playstyle she said... though i think she has been mentored in previous games before. Doesn't add up."

 

Also, this is her third game i think... looking at gameplay... i really don't know. She is likely to have help outside her mentor (nothing against you Clov)

 

 

Thane, that isn't really a thing in her play. I guess what I'm asking for is an example of wolfy behavior.

[Turin Turambar]

oops wrong meme. LOL

 

supposed to be this one...

 

[seph]

 

Eldrick ... Why did you find the little bit of information that could make it seem Seph posted independently of Tress and why did you feel you should use that to defend Seph?

 

 

My possible mafia so far are within seph, thane,AJ and Eldrick.

 

ithi early game reads

 

Let me try and remember and summarise the Seph thing. He jumped in after Tress vote. He thought I was mafia. Then he thought I was town. When I didn't move my vote off him he thought I was mafia again. I think he also voted and then re voted me.

His syntax is strange sometimes ... but maybe now I've had a quick look back it makes his posts more honest.

He seems very reactive but so am I. If I change my perspective from my usual everyone is mafia to everyone is town I can see an unhappy pressured town behaving like that. It is true that Dice would caution him from provoking me if he were mafia. .. but that could also be a good way to hide.

Eldrick defence of his posts still causes me some concern.

Sooh did make a case on me that seems to indicate she thinks I'm mafia. I usually vote for people I think are mafia and so I'm still thinking that case was built as a nudge or to look like she's actively casing someone. Not actually voting me could be because she's worried I'll look at her more.

AJ has got a lot more in depth and involved since I posted his previous work. He was very unhappy that I did not think I was town. There was a lot of discounting and Ithi you are just wrong!

Too much perhaps for two votes. I would have thought a proactive town would have gone fair enough and continued to play and give alternatives with reasoning.

I'm still confident with my vote on him. My other choices would be Eldrick and Sooh. Seph has moved down. I have Tress as Town.

I can remake all of Dices siggies and change the name to Fufu maybe.

me eldrick and sooh seem to be her top reads.

 

 

I find it very difficult to believe anyone is town is what I actually said.

I start with everyone is mafia.

Very gradually I may start to trust some players. The only player I've thought is probably town so far is tress. I have said this several times.

Not sure why you'd re - angle my post like that.

 

 

 

 

 

If I remember right it was a big argument.
Off my head he has not contributed to solving this game.

He dropped his case from me entirely. Unvoted me.
made a case while contradicting alot of things he said.

Have found posts scummy. Off my head is his reads list, and a post about having a plea bargain deal.

I have also found he seems to be falling back on alot of comments with its just a joke. And he is not putting in spoiler tags for me.

the spoiler part was a joke

 

There's a word for you seph and it is 'git' lol

Wasn't he doing the posting while thinking. Voting. Saying he'd got it wrong. Saying oh crap I was right. Voting again.

That didn't seem like a planned thing. For one thing it drew attention to him. Of course it could have been a carefully scripted series of posts.

But now I'm wondering if that was snow ...

 

 

just read what git is. now im sad