[Advanced] Arthurian Mafia

[Nynaeve]

Also Yates, Zash said she was confused because she's not used to D1 on DM. dice and Lily's confusions stemmed from Clov's logic diarrhea that I myself had to ask him to clarify on cause I didn't get it. How are these two things even remotely related. You're making weird associations.

[Darthe]

 

 

Yates might be scum here.

We agree on something. I happen to think you could be his partner. Want to lynch him with me?

Im thinkin about it. Tough player to ever get anything solid on

[Darthe]

Nyn I think your point might have some value but atm its really getting bogged down by how heavily youre arguing it.

 

Can we take a breather from this and come back to it in an hour or so when it doesnt hold up discussion so gravely?

[Nynaeve]

 

I'm still laughing from getting bullying noobs lectures from Yates.  xD

*I* DON'T BULLY NOOBS, BOOBS!!!

 

 

*snerk*

[Verbal32]

 

...you fired from the hip without doing your homework first.

Where?

 

See below:

 

 

 

What I'm referring to is something she said. Which is that she's kinda caught up in the whole day 1 madness so she doesn't have much to say. Which serves as an awesome pretense to sit back and not bring anything to the table for a while. It's a cop out.

I can't argue this point. I more or less agree with it, though I'm not sure how great of a tell it is. My concern was you bringing up the other game - her first game - where you claim she didn't do that. To me; that's where it became a meta argument and a potential frame up.

 

I think you took a weak argument ["I think you are faking your confusion"] and tried to back it up with something more substantive ["because you didn't do it in our first game together"]. I get trying to strengthen an argument but what made you hone in on THAT particular argument in the first place? For example, Lily and Dice have both claimed to be having trouble following your argument [which is a similar sin to Zasha's] but I haven't seen you touch on that. See what I'm saying?

 

I don't know. I guess I'm not bothered by a new player feeling a little like a fish out of water in the early part of this game. So it struck me as odd that you made that the major tenet of your investigation into Zasha. I could almost describe that as bullying a noob. Maybe that's what's actually bothering me.

 

 

 

 

 

What I'm referring to is something she said. Which is that she's kinda caught up in the whole day 1 madness so she doesn't have much to say. Which serves as an awesome pretense to sit back and not bring anything to the table for a while. It's a cop out.

I can't argue this point. I more or less agree with it, though I'm not sure how great of a tell it is. My concern was you bringing up the other game - her first game - where you claim she didn't do that. To me; that's where it became a meta argument and a potential frame up.

 

I think you took a weak argument ["I think you are faking your confusion"] and tried to back it up with something more substantive ["because you didn't do it in our first game together"]. I get trying to strengthen an argument but what made you hone in on THAT particular argument in the first place? For example, Lily and Dice have both claimed to be having trouble following your argument [which is a similar sin to Zasha's] but I haven't seen you touch on that. See what I'm saying?

 

I don't know. I guess I'm not bothered by a new player feeling a little like a fish out of water in the early part of this game. So it struck me as odd that you made that the major tenet of your investigation into Zasha. I could almost describe that as bullying a noob. Maybe that's what's actually bothering me.

 

 

I'm not bullying a noob. First of all, Zasha is not a noob. Secondly I don't feel like I was bullying her at any point. I nudged her and her responses left a lot to desire. Thirdly, If she exhibited the same behavior on the first game she played here, I'd be inclined to let it slide as unfamiliarity. Because She didn't do that AT ALL in her first game, I feel more secure in my initial instinct which is that her OP was fishy.

 

dice and Lily both claimed they had trouble following CLOV's argument, not mine. And I did ask them both to give out more thoughts.

 

And why wouldn't I want to try and substantiate my suspicion? If I feel that there's information out there that can help me read people, you better believe I'm gonna use it. I don't care how it might or might not make me look. If it's up there for grabs, I'm gonna examine it and see where it takes me.

 

 

 

Blue bold.

[Yates]

Im thinkin about it. Tough player to ever get anything solid on

And invaluable to Town. These are the players you investigate, not castigate. And when the glove don't fit, you must acquit.

[Nynaeve]

Nyn I think your point might have some value but atm its really getting bogged down by how heavily youre arguing it.

 

Can we take a breather from this and come back to it in an hour or so when it doesnt hold up discussion so gravely?

 

I was asked about it so I answered. You can take a glue sniffing break if you please.

[Verbal32]

 

Im thinkin about it. Tough player to ever get anything solid on

And invaluable to Town. These are the players you investigate, not castigate. And when the glove don't fit, you must acquit.

 

 

You want a microphone or something?

[Darthe]

Verb I wish you didn't already trust nyn that much

[Nynaeve]

 

Im thinkin about it. Tough player to ever get anything solid on

And invaluable to Town. These are the players you investigate, not castigate. And when the glove don't fit, you must acquit.

 

 

 

So.... you're claiming godfather? cool.

[Nynaeve]

Verb I wish you didn't already trust nyn that much

 

Home wrecker 

[Darthe]

 

Im thinkin about it. Tough player to ever get anything solid on

And invaluable to Town. These are the players you investigate, not castigate. And when the glove don't fit, you must acquit.

Nobody is too invaluable to lynch before town has info validating them.

[Yates]

Blue bold.

Ah. I see. You guys are splitting hairs. I meant the argument she's at the center of. As in, she's in the center of Clov's argument as well.

[Leelou]

Verb I wish you didn't already trust nyn that much

So verb is town and you are scum?

[Darthe]

 

 

 

Im thinkin about it. Tough player to ever get anything solid on

And invaluable to Town. These are the players you investigate, not castigate. And when the glove don't fit, you must acquit.

 

So.... you're claiming godfather? cool.

Can we not? Also why arent you somewhat sus of verb?

[Darthe]

 

Verb I wish you didn't already trust nyn that much

So verb is town and you are scum?

Sure. Or you're all older and so have a particular perspective that isnt melding with this atm.

[Nynaeve]

Can we not? Also why arent you somewhat sus of verb?

 

 

Shinier objects

[Darthe]

 

 

Can we not? Also why arent you somewhat sus of verb?

 

Shinier objects

This makes me feel a lot better about you

[Verbal32]

Verb I wish you didn't already trust nyn that much

 

I wish you didn't assume that much.

 

 

 

 

 

Blue bold.

Ah. I see. You guys are splitting hairs. I meant the argument she's at the center of. As in, she's in the center of Clov's argument as well.

 

 

Dissecting what is posted and pointing out contradictions is kind of a major way to find scum.  Brushing it off as "splitting hairs" does not help.

[Darthe]

I really hate to be the one to make this argument but semantic arguments on Day one can be really conditional. I can see either side here and think that if it came down to it the strength of the argument would be secondary to the position and strength of the player.

[Verbal32]

I disagree that we're having semantic arguments.

[Thane Vakarian]

can you guys and girls slow down your posting habbits a bit, thanks? i feel like i'm already in catch-up mode here, after one bloody day. Admitted that my meds aren't helping and i tend to sleep all day, but still... wow....

 

So far, just one comment: why is Darthe so scummy to all of you D1?  He has quite some votes, but... yeah, don't get it...

[Nynaeve]

I'm gonna go work on my thesis, haters.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

 

My understanding is Darthe didn't want to read the thread, so when he saw a wagon on nyn he applied his vote to it.

What I'm getting at is Darthe was an idiot on purpose.

That is different from any other time how?

He did make more sense the last cpl times he randed scum, but im not using that for a meta read. Im just pointing it out and waiting for darthe to post better if he ever does.

[Darthe]

Post better about what? Leads come from interaction. Im interacting. Townies dont have the need to posture or play as carefully as mafia does (arguably WIFOM) and so Im skipping that part. Look at how much has come from it.