Escape From The Carnival Of Horrors! Game Thread [Mafia Win]

[Sili Quirrels]

This is going to be a provocative statement, but we can afford two mislynches and I'm close to a game solve. I am okay with anything but lynching outside of Hallia, Leelou, Thane, Red, and Kay today.

[Sili Quirrels]

Ok going to bed. Will be traveling home tomorrow so won't likely be on until tomorrow night.

Tomorrow is the lynch.

[Hallia]

Rereading, Up through page 32, AJ/Verb back and forth reads like town on town.  :(  Hate that we lost Nyn.

[Sili Quirrels]

Rereading, Up through page 32, AJ/Verb back and forth reads like town on town.  :(  Hate that we lost Nyn.

^ditto. lol.

[Hallia]

o.o

 

Dat Nol/Sili.  I'm fairly certain one of them is scum.  It doesn't read to me like town on town.

[Sili Quirrels]

Not ditto. But aj said the same.

 

Can you explain?

[Hallia]

Up through 37 - Feeling good about Leelou.  Her opinion on me is spot on, I haven't brought my town game the past two days, I forgot about my guests coming in. v.v'

 

That being said, I completely disagree that my vote on him was omgsus.

[Hallia]

@Leelou Can you explain why you have Sili and Nolder both in your town pile? I'm assuming it's from their exchange over the past 36hrs?

STAHP MINDMELDING WITH ME <3

 

I've got friends over this morning, give me a bit til they leave to catch up

You had a breakfast party without telling me?!

 

My wow guildies are here visiting

 

COME TO LUNCH WITH US TOMORROW

[Sili Quirrels]

I'm reminded of the fact you thought my interactions with thane were also awkward and one of us was scum when neither of us were.

 

I need more here, and probably something compelling to reconsider reconsidering nolder.

[Hallia]

I did?

 

Because I don't recall that.

[Sili Quirrels]

I did?

 

Because I don't recall that.

It was in Tom's game last year.

[Hallia]

RE:Thane and you that is.

 

 

 

I'd be willing to revote Nol, or you, as I'm pretty confident between you both there's a scum.

[Hallia]

OH!  I thought you meant in this game, hence the confusion.

[Sili Quirrels]

Basically, I don't think your assessment of us is reliable even if you are town, so I need to be convinced.

[Sili Quirrels]

Maybe... is there anything specific you can point to? Nolder seems to have been in a tunnel for most of his progression, but he apologizes eventually.

[Nolder]

Alright so I want to move past the whole thing with Sili and get some real scumhunting done.

 

Looking at Dice's train I see AJ at the front.

 

[v]Dice[/v]

 

Wanna get another wagon started so we aren't just piling onto one for EOD and I think there's a legit chance Dice is scum this game. He's been vocal to the point I wouldn't say he's lurking but the focus of his posts are more intrinsic in that he seems focused on talking about himself versus making actual observations.

 

You're still my boy Dice! But I'm just not getting that townie vibe from you and it's my job to kill you otherwise

Seems kind of weak but it was Day 1 so...ehhh.

 

...

 

Possible mafia:

 

Dice - when I got his post explained to me I can see why Red suspected him. It was a strange joke vote when everyone was into the game already. He has few posts and he isn´t really scum hunting in any of them. This is what I associate with his mafia game.

Leelou - annoyed Leelou can be both town and mafia. Busy Leelou can be both town and mafia. Her list was neither good or bad. But what stood out to me was that she asked Verb to post more Spiderman pics. I know she has found Verb as mafia when he is hiding behind spam so this is a strange request. 

Nolder - I´m not sure if we are playing the same game. Now that he showed up he focused on Sili´s old posts from the beginning of day 1. There are so much more to comment on. I also don´t like the comment about me earlier. 

 

[v] Dice [/v]

Tina's vote seems a little lazy but she's also kind of a slow starter.

Tina likes to build her game slow and become deadly to scum mid to end game.

So...ehhh. All in all not good but not really notable.

 

[v]Dice[/v]

Ummm...

 

I'd be willing to vote for Dice for being active yet not saying much. Less sure of Nol for his unclear reads list and since disappearing, willing to vote here as well. Still unsure on Lee and Verb, being a strong town read of mine, not trusting her makes me willing to vote here.

Oh, well ok. I get active lurking.

I'm a bit worried that several people used the same reasoning more or less, probably one scum in the bunch so note that for later people.

But this vote specifically isn't really notable.

 

[unvote]

 

[V]dice

 

Willing to switch to thane, Kay or leelou as well.

Nothing here in the way of reasoning which worried me so I looked back through the last few posts Red had before this and the closest thing I could find to a Dice case was this:

 

is it bad that i'm not looking forward to ISOing Sili  <_<

 

 

can someone do it for me  xD    nah, i'll ISO Sili, but wont be until after the deadline.  got to get back to work and then D&D until 10pm tonight.  will be keeping up with the game from my tablet though.

 

 

would prefer a Kay, Leelou or Thane over Dice, but Dice will give some info imo.

Which rings a lot of alarm bells for me. First because it's devoid of reasoning in itself. Secondly she says she prefers Kay, Leelou or Thane over Dice...but ends up voting Dice over the other three. And thirdly I really hate the "info" line. It's so scummy in my experience. Just an excuse to justify a lynch which otherwise isn't justifiable.

 

Killing Dice could be nice.   Nolder showed me the fire he was missing earlier.

 

unvote

 

vote Dice

Red flags from Crusher! Did he really say anything about the game D1?

I know he's been busy with work but still...

He usually at least quotes someone and says yeah that's good.

Might be a good idea to put some pressure on the fat man and see what he spews out.

[Nolder]

I want to note that I skipped Nyn's vote since we know she's town.

I also want to note that Sili wasn't on the train but says he would have voted Dice.

 

Now I want to go back and look at what reads Dice had if any and read through Nyn's read as well.

[Nolder]

Btw Leelou that trick you taught me sucks. It's telling me Nyn never posted in this thread.

[Andrej]

That entire interaction between you two is a pretty huge indicator imo.

 

Drowns the thread in a pointless conversation until finally you begin to realize it couldn't be from a genuine place and then corrects himself and apologizes. He took you for a ride Sili

 

And now you're town reading him lol

 

Anyway, the more reasonable he appears and the more he focuses on rhetoric and semantics the higher the chance he is scum.

[Sili Quirrels]

Nyn's full name is Nynaeve. Search that and you'll get results.

[Nolder]

Nyn's full name is Nynaeve. Search that and you'll get results.

I did search her full name actually lol.

[Andrej]

Welcome back Hallia!

 

Send me the deetz about lunch! I can probably make it

[Nolder]

Yeah doesn't look like Dice said anything useful.

If he did it was Pre Page 10 and that's pretty much useless because reads that early aren't reliable anyway.

[Nolder]

I'll check Nyn next but first a quick youtube break.

[Sili Quirrels]

That entire interaction between you two is a pretty huge indicator imo.

 

Drowns the thread in a pointless conversation until finally you begin to realize it couldn't be from a genuine place and then corrects himself and apologizes. He took you for a ride Sili

 

And now you're town reading him lol

 

Anyway, the more reasonable he appears and the more he focuses on rhetoric and semantics the higher the chance he is scum.

I'm at a place where I am cognizant of my own bias, and am trying to filter it out, but I still think the bulkiness of the conversation isn't a good indicator of scum since villagers are very capable of being passionate.