Escape From The Carnival Of Horrors! Game Thread [Mafia Win]

[Kaylee]

[v]Nolder[/v]

 

He's being too wishy washy. I feel like he's not trying at all and he seems lazy and disinterested. Feels like the entire opposite of how he played in the last game.

 

I liked Crusher's read list. His explanation rings true. I also think Red touched some good points in her Kaylee ISO. Kaylee has been way too agreeable and following others. I haven't really seen her producing much of an original thought. Could vote there too.

True I've been agreeable. Others have made good points and I've agreed and said as much. I've done my best at ordinal thought in my reads list. Also sometimes early game when I'm not real sure I'll follow my strongest town leans. May not be the best route but it's how I work sometimes.

[Red2111]

 

Red, you did move Tina down from Null to Town to just null.  You also moved Nol down, but I don't see a reason why. Other than that, there hasn't really been significant movement in your lists. 

 

 

i also stated that i was waffely on my town vibe i had for Tina in that original list meaning Tina was Null > TownLean for me.   she's still in the Null > Town Lean for me right now.

 

(ie: i dont have a clear read from her enough to make a concrete move up or down the list, but the vibe i'm getting isn't scummy).

 

Nol moved down because he was posting what i saw as good content and then did an MIA when crap got thick.  add into that, what others in my lawkclear list are saying, it makes me question my initial read of him.

 

 

other moves as been moving people to Lawkclear.  moving AJ up in the list.  moving more people to almost RedZone (to include Kay who jumped from Null to Red).

 

theres actually been significant movement between the two lists.

 

 

 

this still doesn't discount Kay's vote reason.  "Secondly in your original thoughts you had Tina, Dice and Crusher were your top candidates. Roughly 2 hours later your reads list had Tina as null to town saying she wasn't scummy."

 

do you agree with this reason, thats based off an initial joke post list?

[Kaylee]

Partly gut but still not sure about Red. I'd have to look at her posts to see if what Lee is talking about. Yes Red said Tina was Null to leaning town and now just Null. But I don't remember about her changing on Nol.

[Sili Quirrels]

Red is trenfing up. I like her recent posts.

[Kaylee]

 

 

Red, you did move Tina down from Null to Town to just null. You also moved Nol down, but I don't see a reason why. Other than that, there hasn't really been significant movement in your lists.

 

i also stated that i was waffely on my town vibe i had for Tina in that original list meaning Tina was Null > TownLean for me. she's still in the Null > Town Lean for me right now.

 

(ie: i dont have a clear read from her enough to make a concrete move up or down the list, but the vibe i'm getting isn't scummy).

 

Nol moved down because he was posting what i saw as good content and then did an MIA when crap got thick. add into that, what others in my lawkclear list are saying, it makes me question my initial read of him.

 

 

other moves as been moving people to Lawkclear. moving AJ up in the list. moving more people to almost RedZone (to include Kay who jumped from Null to Red).

 

theres actually been significant movement between the two lists.

 

 

 

this still doesn't discount Kay's vote reason. "Secondly in your original thoughts you had Tina, Dice and Crusher were your top candidates. Roughly 2 hours later your reads list had Tina as null to town saying she wasn't scummy."

 

do you agree with this reason, thats based off an initial joke post list?

I didn't realize it was a joke. Just saw the change. And now you've explained your change on Nol.

 

You have a tendency to fool me so still weary but not as sure about you being scum.

[Sili Quirrels]

Calls for a reread. Wondering if i missed something.

[Red2111]

 

 

Red, you did move Tina down from Null to Town to just null. You also moved Nol down, but I don't see a reason why. Other than that, there hasn't really been significant movement in your lists.

i also stated that i was waffely on my town vibe i had for Tina in that original list meaning Tina was Null > TownLean for me. she's still in the Null > Town Lean for me right now.

 

(ie: i dont have a clear read from her enough to make a concrete move up or down the list, but the vibe i'm getting isn't scummy).

 

Nol moved down because he was posting what i saw as good content and then did an MIA when crap got thick. add into that, what others in my lawkclear list are saying, it makes me question my initial read of him.

 

 

other moves as been moving people to Lawkclear. moving AJ up in the list. moving more people to almost RedZone (to include Kay who jumped from Null to Red).

 

theres actually been significant movement between the two lists.

 

 

 

this still doesn't discount Kay's vote reason. "Secondly in your original thoughts you had Tina, Dice and Crusher were your top candidates. Roughly 2 hours later your reads list had Tina as null to town saying she wasn't scummy."

 

do you agree with this reason, thats based off an initial joke post list?

I didn't realize it was a joke. Just saw the change. And now you've explained your change on Nol.

 

You have a tendency to fool me so still weary but not as sure about you being scum.

 

 

explain to me, what, prytell, makes my 1st post look anything like legit scum hunting o.0

[Leelou]

this still doesn't discount Kay's vote reason.  "Secondly in your original thoughts you had Tina, Dice and Crusher were your top candidates. Roughly 2 hours later your reads list had Tina as null to town saying she wasn't scummy."

 

do you agree with this reason, thats based off an initial joke post list?

 

 

Yes, but she wasn't the only one to vote based off your joke. I believe Dice did as well. He's since removed that vote but really hasn't added much to the game. 

 

I'm liking your responses so far and could vote for Kaylee, I've been meh on her all game. She seems really wishy washy. 

 

[unvote]

[The Crusher]

This doesnt feel like nolders scum game.

Please explain. slowly.

[Kaylee]

When I looked at your posts in ISO I just saw the change in reads. Basically i saw an inconsistency and pointed it out. I was wrong there.

[Red2111]

 

this still doesn't discount Kay's vote reason.  "Secondly in your original thoughts you had Tina, Dice and Crusher were your top candidates. Roughly 2 hours later your reads list had Tina as null to town saying she wasn't scummy."

 

do you agree with this reason, thats based off an initial joke post list?

 

 

Yes, but she wasn't the only one to vote based off your joke. I believe Dice did as well. He's since removed that vote but really hasn't added much to the game. 

 

I'm liking your responses so far and could vote for Kaylee, I've been meh on her all game. She seems really wishy washy. 

 

[unvote]

 

 

 

no, Dice voted for Crushluv using my joke vote as a shield, (one of the main reasons he's in the orange tbh)  Dice never voted me that i can recall.

 

Thane is shadowing Kay's vote reason to justify a SMA (save my assets) vote that was more so aimed at keepign him from being the only lead wagon (his vote tied me with him; i then unvoted cause he was actually posting and moved on to others i found scummy)

[Sili Quirrels]

He was a lot more selfconscious last time. His posts were shorter and he had an awkward opening. He didnt seem capable of strong read progression.

[Red2111]

When I looked at your posts in ISO I just saw the change in reads. Basically i saw an inconsistency and pointed it out. I was wrong there.

 

i get that you saw the change, i'm not asking about that.

 

what i'm asking is what, in the content of that first post, made you go "hmmm red is legit scum hunting".  thats what i'm asking about.  stop dancing around it.

[Kaylee]

 

 

When I looked at your posts in ISO I just saw the change in reads. Basically i saw an inconsistency and pointed it out. I was wrong there.

i get that you saw the change, i'm not asking about that.

 

what i'm asking is what, in the content of that first post, made you go "hmmm red is legit scum hunting". thats what i'm asking about. stop dancing around it.

I'm not dancing around it. Like I said I read it wrong saw you gave thoughts and then changed them, period.

[Leelou]

 

 

this still doesn't discount Kay's vote reason.  "Secondly in your original thoughts you had Tina, Dice and Crusher were your top candidates. Roughly 2 hours later your reads list had Tina as null to town saying she wasn't scummy."

 

do you agree with this reason, thats based off an initial joke post list?

 

 

Yes, but she wasn't the only one to vote based off your joke. I believe Dice did as well. He's since removed that vote but really hasn't added much to the game. 

 

I'm liking your responses so far and could vote for Kaylee, I've been meh on her all game. She seems really wishy washy. 

 

[unvote]

 

 

 

no, Dice voted for Crushluv using my joke vote as a shield, (one of the main reasons he's in the orange tbh)  Dice never voted me that i can recall.

 

Thane is shadowing Kay's vote reason to justify a SMA (save my assets) vote that was more so aimed at keepign him from being the only lead wagon (his vote tied me with him; i then unvoted cause he was actually posting and moved on to others i found scummy)

 

 

I didn't say he voted you, I said he voted based off your joke. 

[Red2111]

i'm not buying it.  i like where my vote is, not only for the opportunistic vote on me but for the other reasons i stated in my previous case on Kay.

 

i could go for Leelou as well *nods*  and woudl like more pressure on Dice and Thane to sort them out.

 

 

Hallia being quiet bugs me, and Nol going MIA isn't sitting well.    feeling better about Crushluv currently, i'm still Waffely on Tina though.

[Leelou]

 

 

 

this still doesn't discount Kay's vote reason.  "Secondly in your original thoughts you had Tina, Dice and Crusher were your top candidates. Roughly 2 hours later your reads list had Tina as null to town saying she wasn't scummy."

 

do you agree with this reason, thats based off an initial joke post list?

 

 

Yes, but she wasn't the only one to vote based off your joke. I believe Dice did as well. He's since removed that vote but really hasn't added much to the game. 

 

I'm liking your responses so far and could vote for Kaylee, I've been meh on her all game. She seems really wishy washy. 

 

[unvote]

 

 

 

no, Dice voted for Crushluv using my joke vote as a shield, (one of the main reasons he's in the orange tbh)  Dice never voted me that i can recall.

 

Thane is shadowing Kay's vote reason to justify a SMA (save my assets) vote that was more so aimed at keepign him from being the only lead wagon (his vote tied me with him; i then unvoted cause he was actually posting and moved on to others i found scummy)

 

 

I didn't say he voted you, I said he voted based off your joke. 

 

 

That's now twice you've put words in my mouth that I never said, Red. First time saying that I backed away from calling Nol town (which I never did, I only said I liked his post), and now saying that I said Dice voted you, which I didn't, I said he voted off your joke vote. 

[Sili Quirrels]

I think I'm at -

 

Nyn

Kay

Thane

Verb

Tina

Red

-as town

 

Hallia

Crusher

-as null

 

Nolder

Dice

Aj

-in flux (could end up anywhere upon reread)

 

Lee

-as scum

[Leelou]

 

Lee

-as scum

 

Why? 

[Sili Quirrels]

I think my reads are too weak to push or defend anyone so I'm going to hold on that until I've read the thread again.

[Andrej]

[v]Dice[/v]

 

Wanna get another wagon started so we aren't just piling onto one for EOD and I think there's a legit chance Dice is scum this game. He's been vocal to the point I wouldn't say he's lurking but the focus of his posts are more intrinsic in that he seems focused on talking about himself versus making actual observations.

 

You're still my boy Dice! But I'm just not getting that townie vibe from you and it's my job to kill you otherwise

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Lee

-as scum

 

 

Why?

You seem opportunistic with red, now kaylee. I didn't like that progression. And your tone is off. You got very defensive with verb. I'm looking for posts of yours that remind me of last game, but I'm not finding them yet.

 

It's weird.

[Leelou]

 

 

Lee

-as scum

 

Why?

You seem opportunistic with red, now kaylee. I didn't like that progression. And your tone is off. You got very defensive with verb. I'm looking for posts of yours that remind me of last game, but I'm not finding them yet.

 

It's weird.

 

 

I don't recall voting Kaylee, I haven't liked her posts so far and am willing to vote her. She is being wishy washy. 

[Sili Quirrels]

Way you said that to red irked me.

 

It seemed to come out of the blue, and it was phrased like I'm okay with lynching this villager here, if you are too.

 

That's how I took it. Not as genuine scum hunting, but an agendaee nudge.

[Leelou]

Way you said that to red irked me.

 

It seemed to come out of the blue, and it was phrased like I'm okay with lynching this villager here, if you are too.

 

That's how I took it. Not as genuine scum hunting, but an agendaee nudge.

 

If you look at my reads list from earlier, I have a meh feeling towards Kaylee. That is before Red even moved her down in her reads list. So pray tell, how is that me "being okay with lynching a villager here, if you are too."? To me, that is more me saying yeah, I have meh feelings towards her posts and she's being wishy washy so I can vote her.