[Advanced] The Scouring of the Shire - Game Over

[Zashara]

Seriously though, me during this entire exchange:

 

[Arsis]

Process of elimintion mostly. Looking at the vote wagons looks good for Crusher and Wbat. I'm VT. Yates just looks better from my conversations with him. That narrows things down a bit. Krak and Alanna look the worse. Before your reaction I honestly just threw you in for the hell of it. Your reaction is a bit troubling tbh.

[Zashara]

[Zashara]

Seriously though, how is my reaction troubling? 

 

Your attempts to deflect suspicion onto me are ridiculously transparent. 

[Arsis]

You seem to be overeacting to the person who is probably going to get lynched saying that you're a suspect. Like, I didn't even make a case. I put you on my suspect list and then said I didn't like your reaction. Your reaction is just a tad bit strong and defensive.

[Zashara]

I'll accept strong, but idk where the defensive is coming from. I've been going for amused condescension, but maybe that doesn't work so well here since no one knows me yet. Also, I need sleep.

 

Oh, yeah, mod, I'll be taking an LoA from Thursday to Saturday. I've got a wedding to attend ... and star in. 

[Yates]

I've got a wedding to attend ... and star in.

Congrats!

[Yates]

Your reaction is just a tad bit strong and defensive.

I wouldn't vote for Zashara until after her wedding at least...

 

Still looking for more info on Krak.

 

 

Anyone?

 

 

Anyone?

 

 

Krak?

 

 

Anyone???

[Niniel]

Arsis get bonus points for being active but I agree with Zashara about him and I´m not interested in changing my vote.

[WWWwombat]

Really don't like the way Zashara is coming at Arsis here.  Reads more like railroading than scumhunting to me.  And Yates, I didn't say that I felt strongly that Krak was town, idk where u got that from.  I had, and still have, Krak as a town lean.

[WWWwombat]

Arsis get bonus points for being active but I agree with Zashara about him and I´m not interested in changing my vote.

 

Why?

[Niniel]

It looks like he is ready to vote just anyone. I don´t even know why he brought up Crushers name at all and not Zashara´s either. 

[Yates]

And Yates, I didn't say that I felt strongly that Krak was town, idk where u got that from.

I guess from here:

Basically, I don't see what Krak has done that's so scummy and a couple of thing he's done have rung true to me.  I don't see what Pral is saying wrt his interactions with Sili.  They look like standard RVS to me.  If anything, I'd say Sili's end of that makes it look more likely that Krak is town.  Pral is basically latching onto a point Sili made (that Krak's vote was weird) and rephrasing it in a way that it can be re-purposed despite the fact that Sili was lynched for making that point and flipped scum.  I like how Krak handled you early D1, because it was similar to my line of thought.  I don't like how he is continuing to soft push you and that's tempering my read to a town lean atm.  The main thing isn't that I think Krak looks super town, but that he looks slightly town to me and that I don't think we should take our marching orders from dead scum, especially when Pral hasn't done a single thing to make me think he is town.

 

Maybe I'm overestimating your Town lean on him, but it doesn't sound to me like you would have interest in a Krak wagon. Is this a fair assessment?

[Yates]

It looks like he is ready to vote just anyone.

I can't tell if this is scum driven or disinterested Town, though. My biggest concern at this point is Arsis basically "forgetting" who was instrumental in the Day 1 lynch that netted scum. Sure, there is likely a hint of OMGUS informing my vote as well but overall his "gut" has been wrong about me, wrong about Sili, wrong about Pral, and wrong about Red. His statement that he could vote Crusher or Wombat earlier likely makes him 0 for 6. That is abysmal for Arsis, who typically pays better attention to the game.

[WWWwombat]

Yeah, I'd prefer to lynch someone else, but it's not a very strong preference.

[Yates]

Yeah, I'd prefer to lynch someone else, but it's not a very strong preference.

Who are your two top scum candidates if not Krak?

[WWWwombat]

It looks like he is ready to vote just anyone. I don´t even know why he brought up Crushers name at all and not Zashara´s either. 

 

Yeah Crusher is kinda WUT.  I get Zashara though.  Especially from Arsis' PoV.

[WWWwombat]

 

Yeah, I'd prefer to lynch someone else, but it's not a very strong preference.

Who are your two top scum candidates if not Krak?

 

 

Right now, probably Zashara/Alanna but Alanna is kinda PoE.

[WWWwombat]

Zashara's D1 looks to me like either a failed late bus or an orchestrated double-move trying to kill Sili's train.  Her D2 actually looks ok, but I don't get the Krak stuff.  Her D3 push on Arsis is bad imo.

 

I feel like Alanna should have come up with a post that has me nodding my head vigorously by now.

[WWWwombat]

[v]Zashara[/v]

[Zashara]

Arsis still hasn't really answered my questions. It seems like he's just regurgitating what Yates has posted (re: votes not looking good), and then ignoring the question I asked about the number of scum in the game. I've played games were it goes from 1/4 to 1/3 depending on the roles, which would be 3 or 4 total in this game. 

 

Arsis calling me "Zash the Stampede" cracked me up so much that I just couldn't really take him seriously anymore. I wasn't really following his posts before that either, since he didn't take back his suspicion of Yates until after I called him out on it. Saying Alanna and Krak are your top suspects isn't anything novel since quite a few people have been pointing at them. I understand gut feelings being wrong, but stuff like saying you'd vote for Crusher and Wombat goes a bit beyond that. I haven't played super close attention to the game (depression + wedding stuff + work), and I've got them marked as Town in my head. From what I gathered, Arsis is familiar with mafia, so him not remembering that kind of stuff is just weird.

[Yates]

I understand gut feelings being wrong, but stuff like saying you'd vote for Crusher and Wombat goes a bit beyond that. I haven't played super close attention to the game (depression + wedding stuff + work), and I've got them marked as Town in my head. From what I gathered, Arsis is familiar with mafia, so him not remembering that kind of stuff is just weird.

Now who's "regurgitating?"  

 

Seriously, though, start sharing stuff I didn't just post at the bottom of the previous page.

[Arsis]

Arsis still hasn't really answered my questions. It seems like he's just regurgitating what Yates has posted (re: votes not looking good), and then ignoring the question I asked about the number of scum in the game. I've played games were it goes from 1/4 to 1/3 depending on the roles, which would be 3 or 4 total in this game. 

 

Arsis calling me "Zash the Stampede" cracked me up so much that I just couldn't really take him seriously anymore. I wasn't really following his posts before that either, since he didn't take back his suspicion of Yates until after I called him out on it. Saying Alanna and Krak are your top suspects isn't anything novel since quite a few people have been pointing at them. I understand gut feelings being wrong, but stuff like saying you'd vote for Crusher and Wombat goes a bit beyond that. I haven't played super close attention to the game (depression + wedding stuff + work), and I've got them marked as Town in my head. From what I gathered, Arsis is familiar with mafia, so him not remembering that kind of stuff is just weird.

 

 

If you read my posts it's safe to assume anyone with an IQ over 100 would be able to see that I'm operating under the assumption of 3 scum in the game. I don't think you have an IQ under 100. So, When you say that I didn't answer how many scum I think are in the game it makes me think you're lying to make me look bad. Why would you be lying to make me look bad? Because you're scum. That's my train of thought.

[Krakalakachkn]

Alright, I'm going to catch up tonight.

[Niniel]

From my experience here there should be three mafia in a twelve player game.