[Advanced] The Scouring of the Shire - Game Over

[The Crusher]

Gone yesterday taking my so to a college recruiting trip.  I will read and give my opinion.

[Nolder]

Votecount

Arsis - Yates, Tina (2)

 

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch. 

Deadline: Thursday, 9PM PST

[Arsis]

[v]Yates[/v] gonna go with my gut here.

[WWWwombat]

Arsis, u got anything besides gut atm?

[Yates]

[v]Yates[/v] gonna go with my gut here.

Good posting. Because your "gut" has been helpful - slash - accurate. But at least you are participating.

 

This is sad, people. I have like half the posts for D2 and I've been putting in next to zero effort. Can we have some discussion before we lynch Arsis so we can find a partner?? Please and thank you??

[Niniel]

Since I´m about to go to bed I will just re-post this from yesterday. Not much has happened since so this is where I stand.

 

Crusher: feels like he is trying to solve the game and his vote on Sili gives him bonus points

 

Wombat: also voted Sili in the end when he could have just not voted like others did. 

 

Red: I don´t like her play but I think she is town. She started the Sili wagon. She did jump off but she was the one bringing focus on him. 

 

Yates: When I re-read the thread I didn´t get the townie feeling that I had on him yesterday. Again, his claim doesn´t mean anything to me, but the fact was that he focused his posting about his claim. Didn´t get the feeling of scum hunting. And he never voted Sili although he was about to get lynched. I´m not sure where he lives so it might have been dl when he slept. I don´t remember if he was here at dl. Sili didn´t vote Yates either. Although he didn´t vote at all. So I don´t think Yates being the counter wagon clears him. Yates: why didn´t you vote yesterday?

 

Alanna: Haven´t posted much. Question: Have you played with Sili before?

 

Zashara: Sorry to hear about the depression. I know all about how that is. Hope you will feel better. Over all I have a town feeling of Zashara.

 

Pral: I don´t get a scum feeling from his posts. Sure, he defended Sili, but as he said, it was early in the game. 

 

Krak: I don´t really understand Krak. Krak, why did you vote Yates on D1? And why bring up a third party? 

 

Arsis: His comment on not believing Sili´s claim and still not voting him was weird. And today he seems to just focus on whoever might get more votes than him. (= Pral)

 

 

[v] Arsis [/v]

 

[Arsis]

Arsis, u got anything besides gut atm?

It's more than you :shrug:

 

How am I suppose to read people that have 3 posts?

[Arsis]

 

[v]Yates[/v] gonna go with my gut here.

Good posting. Because your "gut" has been helpful - slash - accurate. But at least you are participating.

 

This is sad, people. I have like half the posts for D2 and I've been putting in next to zero effort. Can we have some discussion before we lynch Arsis so we can find a partner?? Please and thank you??

 

I have half of the other half. LOL.

 

My gut had been off so far but there really isn't much else to go on. It's not me. If it's not you... Who is it? Crusher and Wbat have absolutly nothing to judge them on so I'd vote for one of them. Everyone else seems pretty townish to me.

[WWWwombat]

 

Arsis, u got anything besides gut atm?

It's more than you :shrug:

 

How am I suppose to read people that have 3 posts?

 

 

More than I've done today, yes.  I'm conflicted on you.  Hence my question.  I don't understand why you have been pushing on Yates since very near the beginning.  Meta-wise, he is null to me atm.  Circumstance-wise, he is town imo given that he was the main competing train to Sili.

[Arsis]

 

 

Arsis, u got anything besides gut atm?

It's more than you :shrug:

 

How am I suppose to read people that have 3 posts?

 

 

More than I've done today, yes.  I'm conflicted on you.  Hence my question.  I don't understand why you have been pushing on Yates since very near the beginning.  Meta-wise, he is null to me atm.  Circumstance-wise, he is town imo given that he was the main competing train to Sili.

 

We could have been right about both of them day 1. I also thought Red was mafia so it's not like I know my ass from my elbow this game. I'm just one vote. Who is scum if we're both town?

[Yates]

Let's look at some VCA, shall we?

 

Votecount

Krak - Pral (1)

Pral - Nyn (1)

No Lynch - Red (1)

 

Sili - Crusher, Wom (2)

Yates - Arsis, Krak (2)

 

With 12 players alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: Monday, 7PM PST.

 

This is the final votecount before the deadline.

Randomizing results now...

Votecount

Pral - Krak, Arsis, Wombat, Alanna, Red (5)

Arsis - Zashara, Yates, Tina (3)

Krak - Pral (1)

[Yates]

Crusher and Wbat have absolutly nothing to judge them on so I'd vote for one of them. Everyone else seems pretty townish to me.

Nothing to judge them on. Except for the EOD VC that lynched scum. Oops.

 

Do Krak and Alanna seem "Townish" to you? If so, why? I don't like their votes/voting patterns. In fact; if you are scum I'm feeling very strongly that she's your scum buddy.

[Arsis]

That looks bad for me and Krak.

[Arsis]

Krak/alanna/zash are my new suspects after actually looking at the game for more than 5 seconds.

[Arsis]

 

Crusher and Wbat have absolutly nothing to judge them on so I'd vote for one of them. Everyone else seems pretty townish to me.

Nothing to judge them on. Except for the EOD VC that lynched scum. Oops.

 

Do Krak and Alanna seem "Townish" to you? If so, why? I don't like their votes/voting patterns. In fact; if you are scum I'm feeling very strongly that she's your scum buddy.

 

Yeah, I've been horrible this game. Even more so than usual. I'm not even going to pretend.

[Arsis]

[unvote] [v]krak[/v]

[Yates]

Now I guess I'm just looking for a better explanation from Wombat on why Krak is Town because he feels pretty strongly about that and I haven't heard enough from Krak to make an assessment.

[Zashara]

Arsis comes off more scummy after these last few posts for whatever reason. He's flipping on his suspicions quite a bit. Yates, Alanna, Krak, and I can't all be scum (5/12 mafia doesn't seem likely). Krak not posting anything remotely useful makes me more suspicious of him actually, but I feel like we'd get more information from Arsis's alignment than anyone else right now.

 

[unvote]

[v]Arsis[/v]

[Arsis]

That's only 4/12 actually. Also, I didn't incule Yates so it was only 3/12. Seeing as how there are probably 2 scum left it's not really that big of a list. Your reaction was terrible you just outed yourself.

 

So, Who is your partner Krak or Alanna?

[Arsis]

[unvote] [v] Zash the Stampede [/v]

[Zashara]

Sili was scum. You never said you weren't suspicious of Yates anymore. Then there are the three you mentioned, which brings the total to 5. There were 12 players at the start of the game. That's where the number comes from.

[Zashara]

Arsis: His comment on not believing Sili´s claim and still not voting him was weird. And today he seems to just focus on whoever might get more votes than him. (= Pral)

 

 

I was reminded of this comment also. I had a vote on the board for Krak (even if the mod ignored it D:), so going after him was totally cool, as Yates had said he could switch to that vote.

 

 

That's only 4/12 actually. Also, I didn't incule Yates so it was only 3/12. Seeing as how there are probably 2 scum left it's not really that big of a list. Your reaction was terrible you just outed yourself.

 

So, Who is your partner Krak or Alanna?

 

 

But when I switched my vote, then all of a sudden I'm totes mafia and just "outed myself". If you had said Sili instead of Yates in that post, then I may have given you the benefit of the doubt, but seriously how do you forget that Sili was scum? It's not something a VT would forget. 

[Arsis]

Krak/alanna/zash are my new suspects after actually looking at the game for more than 5 seconds.

 

 

Means those three are my new suspects. Notice the absence of Yates. I don't have to mention everything it's implied by the absence. Sili+ you+ one of the other two = 3 mafia. That's about right. Or was it just you and sili?

[Arsis]

 

Arsis: His comment on not believing Sili´s claim and still not voting him was weird. And today he seems to just focus on whoever might get more votes than him. (= Pral)

 

 

I was reminded of this comment also. I had a vote on the board for Krak (even if the mod ignored it D:), so going after him was totally cool, as Yates had said he could switch to that vote.

 

 

That's only 4/12 actually. Also, I didn't incule Yates so it was only 3/12. Seeing as how there are probably 2 scum left it's not really that big of a list. Your reaction was terrible you just outed yourself.

 

So, Who is your partner Krak or Alanna?

 

 

But when I switched my vote, then all of a sudden I'm totes mafia and just "outed myself". If you had said Sili instead of Yates in that post, then I may have given you the benefit of the doubt, but seriously how do you forget that Sili was scum? It's not something a VT would forget. 

 

I didn't forget he was scum. It was one of those pieces of information that everyone can assume everyone know so there is no need to explicitly mention it. Is Sili is scum and I still have 3 suspects it's obviously that I'm not saying that all of them are scum just that I narrowed down the pool of suspects.

[Zashara]

Why the change on your feelings about Yates? Why are you suspicious of the three of us? What's the order of suspicions on us?

 

To be fair, I'd definitely vote for Krak and probably would vote for Alanna. The vote patterns don't look good for either of them and they haven't been sharing their thoughts in thread, so it's hard to get any kind of read on them.

 

Also, why are you so convinced there are only 2 more scum? There could be 3 more, we don't know the exact number. Got some inside info that the rest of us don't have?