[Standard] 11/10 Top Tier Vanilla+ Game Thread

[WWWwombat]

Cass/Kivam has w/w equity now imo.

[Cass]

I thought it was a 'town consensus then make up your own mind who's lying' thing. That's a lot easier to do if everyone rationalises their votes. Not providing reasons makes it easier for the wolves to say "Vote X person - no reason" and get away with it. Like with Sili... 

 

[WWWwombat]

Darthe, Des and I have all talked about Kivam extensively.  Idk why we should have to reiterate our reasoning.

[Cass]

That's not helping...

[WWWwombat]

Have you caught up on thread?  It's all right there.

[WWWwombat]

[v]##Cass[/v]

 

Take a stance.

[Verbal32]

I find it weird that you think I got in my head that they're scum and then everything seems scummy to me. I had an iffy feeling about them. READ their posts and decided that they were scummy. They can dress it how they like...... Barm can go on with his mantra of why the hell should he share his thoughts on thread... which...lol... and Verbal can go on saying that townies make more inconsistencies than scum really. Which is false, IMO. I usually find myself agreeing with Verbal's points when he rolls town. Totally not getting that feel in this game.

You're using early D1 as your sample while I'm still shooting blind and trying to get a feel for things.

 

That's a mistake. Or done on purpose.

[Kivam]

Ooh, look, a Chinese fire drill on me, led by wombat near EoD, while I'm in meetings and can't really respond. All this after saying for days that "kiv is kiv". Wombat is playing the "Any lynch is a good lynch game right now, " and no matter where this day ends up you guys need to remember that layer. Will try and post more if I can get back to my comp before deadline

[WWWwombat]

Hey Verb, can you quit arguing with Nyn and post something meaningful?  We have just over 3 hours.

[hazelkrs1]

[v]##Cass[/v]

 

Take a stance.

Guess you weren't really that committed to that Kivam vote.

 

Kivam/Wombat has w/w equity now imo

 

C wut I did thar?

[WWWwombat]

 

[v]##Cass[/v]

 

Take a stance.

Guess you weren't really that committed to that Kivam vote.

 

Kivam/Wombat has w/w equity now imo

 

C wut I did thar?

 

 

Touché

[WWWwombat]

Cass is FROZEN

[Kivam]

Oh, and since I'm suddenly at the gallows, [v]##verbarm[/v] in a pure "no other choice" move. Would very much prefer an aj lynch if people would be willing to move back there

[Nynaeve]

 

I find it weird that you think I got in my head that they're scum and then everything seems scummy to me. I had an iffy feeling about them. READ their posts and decided that they were scummy. They can dress it how they like...... Barm can go on with his mantra of why the hell should he share his thoughts on thread... which...lol... and Verbal can go on saying that townies make more inconsistencies than scum really. Which is false, IMO. I usually find myself agreeing with Verbal's points when he rolls town. Totally not getting that feel in this game.

You're using early D1 as your sample while I'm still shooting blind and trying to get a feel for things.

 

That's a mistake. Or done on purpose.

 

 

Why should it matter when your content is from. Besides, I've used the entirety of your content. The fact that you were hardly around D2 is all on you. 

[WWWwombat]

Yo Kivs, in your opinion, what info did we get from the Sili lynch?

[WWWwombat]

If I have a gun (which I might cuz I'm obv the SK rite) I will shoot whichever one of the survivors of Cass/Verb/Kiv is least useful this EOD.

[hazelkrs1]

Yo Kivs, in your opinion, what info did we get from the Sili lynch?

[Nynaeve]

Bedtime for me. Ni ni

[Cass]

Lol. Yes I'm frozen (at least if that mean's I'm stuck deliberating what to do). I'm getting flustered   . You don't seem interested in my reasons, but you're not giving me yours and if you're voting against me do you really care about catching Kiv? I don't understand what CFD is, and that's not helping the issue either.

 

And I've brought up extensive reasons why I don't like Kiv too - didn't see anyone rushing to vote when I mentioned them. So it's probably natural that I'm nervous now, when you suddenly go 'Vote Kiv!' and then jump all around on me - after I tell you that I think it's a good vote, but that I'd like to know why.

 

I do get a higher feel of scum from Kiv, but one thing that makes me nervous about it is the way my reread highlighted to me that Kiv and DPR might be working together. Neither of them has provided a read on the other, and they've refused to answer anything about each other directly for the entire game - both of them for fear of interrupting 'things at play'. As if they might be in on something together. 

 

Kiv is worse than DPR for this, but the way they set up their 'Cass is scarier than you think she is' posts weirds me out - it's as if they were pushing slightly different points, points which, again, worked incredibly well together to cover all suggestions that I might be Scum. 

 

Clever set up, if you think of it, both of them covering each other and opposite sides of the field for most of the game? Doesn't that feel slightly relevant to you? In that light - if you're really reading Kiv as Scum, what makes you so sure DPR is on the other side?

[WWWwombat]

Hiya Cass

 

Now; CFD = Chinese fire drill. Usually happens at EOD (End of Day) to move votes from one train to another to possibly achieve a lynch. 

 

It is true that Wombat seemed off end Day 1. For the moment, i have a scumlean on him. Pral however, pings at me more. I did make a post explaining why i think so and i did vote him for that. 

 

 

 

Thane posts a massive ‘Townie’ post and switches focus from Wombat, mentioning his association against DPR, to a vote on Pral for reasons I actually don’t understand – probably because I’m a noob and don’t understand the nuances of CFD (Help, please, someone?). Could also possibly be because I'm wondering if Thane just wanted in on a rolling target.

 

Nyn/Thane? Your thoughts?

 

CFD is a Chinese fire drill. It's basically everyone switching to X person last minute. Though Thane has a lot more experience with it than me  *snerk*

 

This is where I basically state my opinion of why I think Pral is full of it: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/91702-standard-1110-top-tier-vanilla-game-thread/?p=3379696

 

Arsis/Pral slot was the leading train for a big chunk of D1. Pral showing up all.... Good try Yates... and trying to portray it like a now confirmed scum was trying to "CFD" him is iffy . First of all, it wasn't a CFD. He and Sili were neck in neck ages before the deadline. I think he overplayed it. I also didn't like his defense at me suggesting that Yates was bussing him by saying scum are very unlikely to do it in this setup. I think it's a bunch of woo-aaah.

 

 

 

Such ... distant... love... lol

 

 

Pretty odd that you'd forget what CFD is, Cass.

[WWWwombat]

CASS CFD IS GO FOR LAUNCH!

[Kivam]

Yo Kivs, in your opinion, what info did we get from the Sili lynch? ___€___€€__€

 

1) arsis/pral, darthe, you look cleaner (no distancing possibility iirc from odd sili votes interactions).

 

2) verbs defense is less suspicious

 

What I recall from my reads when I went over the recap after shabbos and saw silis flip. Would need access to my comp to give a more detailed breakdown.

 

And yes, I'm posting on a break from the meeting top tale care of 2 things. This addiction Better not get me fired ...

[Verbal32]

Hey Verb, can you quit arguing with Nyn and post something meaningful? We have just over 3 hours.

Sure, give me the top 3 reasons you think Kiv is scum.

[WWWwombat]

 

Hey Verb, can you quit arguing with Nyn and post something meaningful? We have just over 3 hours.

Sure, give me the top 3 reasons you think Kiv is scum.

 

 

1.  He keeps saying I'm the SK

2.  *redacted*

3.  He's Kiv

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

I find it weird that you think I got in my head that they're scum and then everything seems scummy to me. I had an iffy feeling about them. READ their posts and decided that they were scummy. They can dress it how they like...... Barm can go on with his mantra of why the hell should he share his thoughts on thread... which...lol... and Verbal can go on saying that townies make more inconsistencies than scum really. Which is false, IMO. I usually find myself agreeing with Verbal's points when he rolls town. Totally not getting that feel in this game.

You're using early D1 as your sample while I'm still shooting blind and trying to get a feel for things.

 

That's a mistake. Or done on purpose.

Why should it matter when your content is from. Besides, I've used the entirety of your content. The fact that you were hardly around D2 is all on you.

It matters. I thought you knew that. My bad for making an assumption.