[BASIC] Discworld Mafia - MAFIA win

[Cory Caboose]

 

AFAICT the only difference is in previous games I correctly had you as a villager early and in this game I don't see villager!Nyn at all

 

It's true that you usually read me very well. But I don't know what to tell you about your gut read other than it's wrong. 

 

 

Anyways, Lee and I are talking right now, so we'll post our reads in a bit. I'll try to be more transparent so maybe you can understand my line of thought better.

 

 

This sort of things I remember Nyn saying when Darthe revealed a peek on her in the Tron game

 

"I get it but you are wrong"

 

I expect Villager!Nyn to have more nails than this

Her expressing desire to be understood just doesn't make sense to me, typically as a villager she's right and she's not going to let it go

 

Just gets under my skin and I don't want to let her off the hook because she made some okay posts after she became lead wagon

 

UGhhhhhhhhhhhh

[Krakalakachkn]

I don't get how me egging Dice on is a scumtell. He pretty much cleared himself in one post.

 

My vote on Nolder didn't need an explanation.

 

I don't remember soft FoSing Mish that early. I'll go back and look though.

 

No, what I challenged Kronos on was why he labeled Nolder's vote one of the most random votes he's ever seen without asking Nolder for a reason and despite the fact that, as it appeared to me, both my votes on Nolder and Lee's vote on me were both more random. And I wasn't being obtuse, but throwing words like that in sure makes your narrative more believable don't they? Unfortunately they offer nothing but an appeal to emotion in any player reading your narrative, putting a bad taste in their mouth. Furthermore, there had been little to no discussion on Nol's vote up to that point and for me it was weird because in knew exactly where Nol was coming from wrt his vote on Verb. I hardly think challenging Kronos on his comment is scummy, unless you thought like Mish did that my vote on Nolder came after Nol's vote on Verb.

 

As far as me asking people questions regarding your post on Nolder, yeah Tina responded and Yates responded and I don't know how you didn't realize that I didn't know what he meant with his bob's burger gif

. And how are you going to tell me you know what's in my head about my questioning and playing? How are you going to call me scum hunting a scumtell? Maybe if you want to know my thoughts about something you should ask and engage with me until waiting until near the deadline and then trying to get everyone on my train.

 

 

Tell me how a town read on Misheros is not "following through" on my questions. I got exactly what I wanted from that whole exchange than you very much.

 

You say "feeling" a whole lot in this narrative and it doesn't provide anything to push back against on my end. Nor does it do anything but fling mud without proof. If you have a gut feeling on my play then let's boil most of this down to what it is: a gut read. You writing this huge post is a verbal barrage that looks great bc you're accusing me of scummy things without calling them gut reads.

[Krakalakachkn]

^part 1 of my response to Nyn's post.

[Verbal32]

FYI I'm here and won't miss deadline.

[Leelou]

FYI I'm here and won't miss deadline.

 

Oh, hey. 

[Verbal32]

At my son's new karate class lol.

[Leelou]

At my son's new karate class lol.

 

Sounds um fun. :p

[Verbal32]

Meh

[Leelou]

Meh

 

I'm waiting for the hockey game to start. 

[Verbal32]

Why do I think you're scum? Why?

[Verbal32]

This bothers me.

 

I'm bothered.

 

Like whoa.

[Krakalakachkn]

Wrt paragraph 8, I don't know what you're pushing at here. You've accuse me of false scum hunting but admit that I've been actively engaged in the game, engaged in questioning, testing, etc. so how can you tell me that directing attention back to my scum read is scummy? Of course I'm going to try to engage you and see if I can get other people to see what I see. To do otherwise is foolhardy and anti-town.

 

My unvote on Nolder don't need no explanation because it should have been clear that, once again, i voted for Nol before he had entered the game

 

Your whole schtixk about me not sharing is really trite at this point. It's nothing more than filler. Lots of filler.

 

The next point I don't have a response to. I stated how it felt to me and moved on. The other bit is your first valid point that I come even close to considering a reason why you would think I'm wolfy.

 

You start repeating yourself.

 

More repeating.

 

Once more, I saw something there and so did Nolder. Not everyone is going to agree on what constitutes a scumtell but that's not the issue here. And how are you "supposedly defending" Verb? You're blatantly defending him!

 

QUIT BRINGING UP MY VOTE ON NOLDER LIKE ITS A SCUMTELL!!!

 

 

I think that's about it.

[Leelou]

Why do I think you're scum? Why?

 

Me? Dunno. Why do you? Lets talk this out. We have 18 mins. 

[Leelou]

Ignore Krak. Lets just talk. 

[Verbal32]

You aren't on the offensive - you're entire D1 has been largely defensive. I know you need to defend from multiple players, but any counterattack has been nonexistent.

[Krakalakachkn]

TL:DR

 

Nyn's post is a whole lot of repeating the same argument which is that she has a gut read and scant else to support her claim.

 

The rest I have refuted and a lot of it is going on and on about me questioning but not sharing and my vote on Nolder.

 

So, basically, she has a gut read and doesn't like I haven't offered a concrete reads lost.

[Leelou]

You aren't on the offensive - you're entire D1 has been largely defensive. I know you need to defend from multiple players, but any counterattack has been nonexistent.

 

I know you hate this, but I haven't had the time to get into this game. I've tried whenever I had 5 mins and I had people to defend against and by today, meh. 

[Krakalakachkn]

You aren't on the offensive - you're entire D1 has been largely defensive. I know you need to defend from multiple players, but any counterattack has been nonexistent.

Nyn offered a giant counterattack just a bit ago. How did you not see it or my response to it?

 

 

How is Leelou telling you to ignore me a town play less than 15 minutes to deadline?

[Leelou]

 

You aren't on the offensive - you're entire D1 has been largely defensive. I know you need to defend from multiple players, but any counterattack has been nonexistent.

Nyn offered a giant counterattack just a bit ago. How did you not see it or my response to it?

 

 

How is Leelou telling you to ignore me a town play less than 15 minutes to deadline?

 

 

I'm done talking to you for today. 

[Leelou]

 

 

You aren't on the offensive - you're entire D1 has been largely defensive. I know you need to defend from multiple players, but any counterattack has been nonexistent.

Nyn offered a giant counterattack just a bit ago. How did you not see it or my response to it?

 

 

How is Leelou telling you to ignore me a town play less than 15 minutes to deadline?

 

 

I'm done talking to you for today. 

 

 

And he's not talking about Nyn, he's talking about me. 

[BFG]

Current Vote Count :

 

Krak (3): Sexy LouNy , Wolfish, Hallia

 

Nolder (2): Yates, Dice 

 

Sexy LouNy (4): Barm, Tina, Krak, Cory

 

Hallia (1) : Nolder

 

 

Not voting (1): Verb

 

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch

 

No change

[Verbal32]

Somebody needs to move a vote.

[Verbal32]

Ugh

[Leelou]

No one will. 

[Krakalakachkn]

Nah, we good.