[BASIC] Physics Mafia: GAME OVER, Town and Lenlo wins!

[dawnflower8]

 

 

 

#Vote Nolder

Why?

 

I'm wondering that too. Don't we all think Nolder is town? He sure seems like it.

 

 

My conspiracy theory goes that Jack and Nolder is scum, and for every mislynch Jack spearheads, Nolder will come and give a thorough explanation why mislynched player was playing badly, and how he/she should have played 

 

But yeah, for now I think Nolder is in the "probably town"-category. 

 

Out of Jack and Nolder, who do you think is more likely to be scum? 

[nervositee]

Amega:

 

whats the vote count... im probably going to add my vote on des. nolder's post pretty much sold it for me. 

 

You voted des because of Nolders post. So, following Nolder.

 

aawwwh.. i was hoping for a lynch tonight

 

Eager for the lynch to get hammered as fast as possible

 

how is nolder clean he was one of spearheads on the des lynch.

 

Suddenly, since Des flipped town, the very person you followed with your vote is scummy, out of all the people on the train? Even scummy enough to...

 

#Vote Nolder

 

 

Is that your only reason, or?

[Sedai]

I spearheaded cloud. He was scum.

 

I wasn't the only one who thought des was scum as most in game did since he played very scummily and saying how good he was and got bad everyone else was and how this game was beneath him. I honestly don't see what's wrong with either if those lynches tbh.

[Sedai]

I really like your last post.

[Sedai]

So I was thinking.

 

Completely out of the box but wanted to get it out there.

 

It's a consensus that the mafia targeted the doc last night. The doc probably self protected so the mafia knows who they are. All though they could have held their kill but that would be odd. Anyways basically IMO the mafia know who the doc is. So if the doc wanted to reveal that would basically narrow the suspect pool. But just my thoughts.

 

Feel free to call it stupid or whatever. ^^

[dawnflower8]

So I was thinking.

 

Completely out of the box but wanted to get it out there.

 

It's a consensus that the mafia targeted the doc last night. The doc probably self protected so the mafia knows who they are. All though they could have held their kill but that would be odd. Anyways basically IMO the mafia know who the doc is. So if the doc wanted to reveal that would basically narrow the suspect pool. But just my thoughts.

 

Feel free to call it stupid or whatever. ^^

*didn't know this game had a doc*

 

*feels stupid*

 

Or the doc could've been someone else, and they actually protected the person that the mafia decided to kill.

[Lenlo]

I would say no, the Doc shouldnt reveal unless theres a possibility of us lynching them on the off chance that the scum didnt target them and the doc just got a lucky protect. Play it safe you know?

[amegakure]

call it a hunch

[nervositee]

I'm gonna follow up my vote from yesterday and

 

## Vote Amega

 

Not really interested in following your soft-claim here. If you got anything on Nolder we don't know feel free to share. If not then your flip will say alot about anyhow. 

[Sedai]

We are looking at 3 mafia members left. Since obviously no series killer.

 

We have Ameg soft claiming cop (waiting in him to clarify)

 

And Nervo voting a soft claim he pointed out.

 

Ice wants to lynch am inactive. Or that could of been dawn.

 

I wanna lynch Chae

 

Chae hasn't said much

 

Lenlo is against the doc revealing

 

Nolder hasn't said anything of note

 

Lily hasn't said anything of note

 

Daps put together a case

 

Wolverine is quiet.

 

I think I got everyone. That's my views since day started.

[Sedai]

Wait. Nolder went for Lenlo. Just read back ^*

[dawnflower8]

We are looking at 3 mafia members left. Since obviously no series killer.

 

We have Ameg soft claiming cop (waiting in him to clarify)

 

And Nervo voting a soft claim he pointed out.

 

Ice wants to lynch am inactive. Or that could of been dawn.

 

I wanna lynch Chae

 

Chae hasn't said much

 

Lenlo is against the doc revealing

 

Nolder hasn't said anything of note

 

Lily hasn't said anything of note

 

Daps put together a case

 

Wolverine is quiet.

 

I think I got everyone. That's my views since day started.

It was Ice.

[Sedai]

Kk. So that's basically where things are at right now IMO.

 

Dawn what do you think of that break down in actions?

 

Vos would you be averse to lynching Chae?

 

Lenlo, what do you think of the Ameg soft claim?

 

Nolder, what do you think of my doc reveal?

 

Lily what do you think of Dap's case on dawn?

 

Chae what do you think of checking the inactives for possible scum?

 

Ameg, what do you think of Vos?

 

Ice, who is the most town in your oppinion?

 

Dap, why where you off both lynches?

 

I'd like you all to answer these. Plz

[nervositee]

Vos would you be averse to lynching Chae?

 

 

Don't know what you are fishing for here. Chae hasn't pinged hard for me. If she was under more heat I'd have to ISO her to make a definite statement

 

In the sense if I'd be averse to lynching Chae today, then yes, because I think there are better candidates. 

[Sedai]

What has she done to stay under your radar?

[amegakure]

i dont know. my gut doesnt really throw me at vos.. i like him for town.. we will see. 

[Sedai]

@vos

His explanations could be interesting; and it would be bad for him to be hammered without having the chance to say anything

Although i'm quite convinced about my vote. So i'll vote again tonight, after work, unless something would have happened.

Her explanation of why she unvoted des after he had already been dropped to L-2 seems very off

 

Would you agree or disagree

[Sedai]

i dont know. my gut doesnt really throw me at vos.. i like him for town.. we will see.

I like your honesty. So you'd have no problem voting him since your just waiting on a gut ping?

[dawnflower8]

Dawn what do you think of that break down in actions?

 

 

Are you talking about all these? 

 

We are looking at 3 mafia members left. Since obviously no series killer.

 

We have Ameg soft claiming cop (waiting in him to clarify)

 

And Nervo voting a soft claim he pointed out.

 

Ice wants to lynch am inactive. Or that could of been dawn.

 

I wanna lynch Chae

 

Chae hasn't said much

 

Lenlo is against the doc revealing

 

Nolder hasn't said anything of note

 

Lily hasn't said anything of note

 

Daps put together a case

 

Wolverine is quiet.

 

I think I got everyone. That's my views since day started.

• How are you so sure that there are 3 mafia left?
• I'm not entirely sure what a soft claim is.
• I'm not sure exactly WHY Ice wants to lynch Wolverine.
• Why do you want to lynch Chae, if she hasn't said anything much?
• Even if the doc does reveal, couldn't they be lying and not actually the doc?
• If neither Chae, Lily, or Nolder have said everything, why do you think Chae is scum but not Lily or Nolder? I think Lily and Nolder are most likely town and am not too sure of Chae.
• Wolverine seriously needs to post more, we cannot figure out anything with him unless he does.

 

Now, you did forget someone- me. The only thing you said about me was that it was maybe me who wants to lynch Wolverine - but it wasn't me, it was Ice.

[Sedai]

1. It's an educated guess based off the number of players who started this game. And the apparent lack of a SK (serial killer)

 

2. Soft claim is when you hint at a role and don't actually claim it

 

3. It's his inactivity

 

4. Because I've been suspicious of her since day one and her couple of recent posts have been glorified fluff

 

5. Yeah they could. But this is a basic game so set ups are pretty standard. If someone claimed doc and was lying there would be a counterclaim and we'd have at least one gauranteed mafia

 

6. I never said I didn't think lily was scum. Said I have a neutral vibe there. Chae I think is scum based on over all play. I was wrong Nolder. He built a card on Lenlo and I've liked his gameplay. It's been very clean.

 

7. Agreed

 

8. You hadn't really done anything of note. Good observation though.

[dawnflower8]

1. It's an educated guess based off the number of players who started this game. And the apparent lack of a SK (serial killer)

 

2. Soft claim is when you hint at a role and don't actually claim it

 

3. It's his inactivity

 

4. Because I've been suspicious of her since day one and her couple of recent posts have been glorified fluff

 

5. Yeah they could. But this is a basic game so set ups are pretty standard. If someone claimed doc and was lying there would be a counterclaim and we'd have at least one gauranteed mafia

 

6. I never said I didn't think lily was scum. Said I have a neutral vibe there. Chae I think is scum based on over all play. I was wrong Nolder. He built a card on Lenlo and I've liked his gameplay. It's been very clean.

 

7. Agreed

 

8. You hadn't really done anything of note. Good observation though.

If someone soft claimed a role, it most likely means they are not a regular townsperson. Either they actually are the cop or scum trying to convince you they are not scum. What were you "wrong" about with Nolder? His role is not confirmed, although we do think he's town, he still could be scum. (I highly doubt it, though)

 

Besides Chae, who do you think seems the most scummy?

[Sedai]

I fused Nolder hasn't said much since day break. I was wrong. He built a case on Lenlo. Who's the we? When did I say anything about his role? That's very odd thing for you to say.

 

Chae

Vos

You after that potential slip

Lenlo

 

Lily

 

Dap

Nolder

Ice

Wolverine

Me

 

Top my best suspect pool for scum

 

Middle = neutral

 

Bottom my best reads for town

[Lenlo]

 

Lenlo, what do you think of the Ameg soft claim?

 

 

About the soft claim? I dont like soft claiming personally, claim or dont but im not gonna push him to full reveal. Have no reason to.

 

I fused Nolder hasn't said much since day break. I was wrong. He built a case on Lenlo. Who's the we? When did I say anything about his role? That's very odd thing for you to say.

 

Chae

Vos

You after that potential slip

Lenlo

 

Lily

 

Dap

Nolder

Ice

Wolverine

Me

 

Top my best suspect pool for scum

 

Middle = neutral

 

Bottom my best reads for town

Really? You have the two really quiet/inactive people as your top town reads besides yourself? Based on what might I ask?

 

Also are you still hung up on the "Tieing the trains" on D1 for me or did you add to that?

[Krakalakachkn]

 

 

[Lenlo]

Sorry what was that Krak? Not in this game? Not a giant WoT? I cut it down to what I was responding to? Ok kool.

 

Post count for those interested.

 

Jack_D 136 Nolder 83 Lenlo 70 nervositee 68 TGlems 47 amegakure 42 LilyElizabeth 42 iceknight27377 39 WWWwombat 39 dawnflower8 37 _CLOUD 34 Chaelca 29 dapianoplay3r 29 Despothera 18 WolfbrotherKronos 6 Xthrax 3 theWolverine 1

 

Just look for a sec Jack. Im concerned about parts of your list. Your high town reads mostly seem to be on either the low post count side or the posts with no content side. Example: Wolverine. 1 post. 1. In 37 pages. Problem I have. Ice, mostly fluff and short 1 sentence posts. Another problem I have, but abit more excusable cause I did and still kinda do that. Still though. Would like actual reads from him.