[Basic] Call of Cthulhu Mafia- MAFIA VICTORY!

[Blackhoof]

Please submit Night Actions in the same message that I sent your Role PM's in please. It will make it easier for me thanks :)

[Blackhoof]

Also, Night will end once I have all the Night Actions, it will not continue until Wednesday if I get them all before hand.

[LilyElizabeth]

AJ, have you not heard of courtesy? It's a courteous thing to do to allow a person to speak when they are at L-2. I'm truly sorry you don't see that, but that's the way it is, or is supposed to be, anyway. 

[Andrej]

Let's not make this a matter of personal sensibility Lily, please. If that's how you feel then that's fine and it's something I really can't comment on one way or the other. What I can do is announce how your actions came across to me, which I have done.

 

Did you think X was lying when he claimed VT?

 

Now that we have his flip what do you think we learned from it?

 

What are your reads in general?

[Sedai]

@AJ do you still think I was buddying towards X, and trying to save him?

 

All in all minimum damage for day 1.

 

However I will know for certain if I'm going to vote you day 2 soon enough. :)

[Sedai]

unvote vote X

 

L-1 on the claimed VT, I feel comfortable at this point securing a lynch for a coroner in order to progress.

 

Hammer away Jack.

Contrary to your deadline statement we had time to debate more. Agree it probably wouldn't of changed the outcome.

 

I had no problem hammering, however your over apparent provacation to do so is teh scummy

[LilyElizabeth]

Let's not make this a matter of personal sensibility Lily, please. If that's how you feel then that's fine and it's something I really can't comment on one way or the other. What I can do is announce how your actions came across to me, which I have done.

 

Did you think X was lying when he claimed VT?

 

Now that we have his flip what do you think we learned from it?

 

What are your reads in general?

 

I did think X was lying when he claimed VT, yes. 

 

I'm in the process of rereading now, so I'll let you know what I think when I have something. 

 

I don't usually have a lot of reads by this time in the game. You, sir, feel like scum to me. Pushing a point as hard as you did, as if you keep saying it people will believe it, is scummy. If your case had merit, or you thought it did, you wouldn't have felt the need to repeat it ad nauseum. 

[LilyElizabeth]

And I agree with Jack about your directing him to hammer. It was scummy. 

[LilyElizabeth]

Here are my reads as of this moment. 

 

1:Err – not enough content that stuck out to me
2:Ishy - null
3:Jack – leaning town
4:Lily – town of course
5:Quibby - null
6:Leelou  - gut says might be scum
7:Des – Post #185. Spinning my meta into incorrect statements. Scum
8:Verbal – not enough content
9:Andrej – Hammering a case home, hoping someone else will believe it if they see it enough. Scum.
10:Zanube – not enough content
11:Wombat – need to look at him closer to get a read. 

[Andrej]

@AJ do you still think I was buddying towards X, and trying to save him?

 

All in all minimum damage for day 1.

 

However I will know for certain if I'm going to vote you day 2 soon enough. :)

 

Firstly, I wasn't the one to push the angle that you were trying to protect X. You should refer that question to Wombat and Despo. I did say that their theory had merit though, if that's what you're referring to.

 

I see what you're doing in the last bit and honestly it's pretty foolish on your part.

 

 

unvote vote X

 

L-1 on the claimed VT, I feel comfortable at this point securing a lynch for a coroner in order to progress.

 

Hammer away Jack.

Contrary to your deadline statement we had time to debate more. Agree it probably wouldn't of changed the outcome.

 

I had no problem hammering, however your over apparent provacation to do so is teh scummy

 

Meh, call it a gut check. Some others were beginning to think you were trying to protect X, so I decided to test it since I had the opportunity.

 

I don't usually have a lot of reads by this time in the game. You, sir, feel like scum to me. Pushing a point as hard as you did, as if you keep saying it people will believe it, is scummy. If your case had merit, or you thought it did, you wouldn't have felt the need to repeat it ad nauseum. 

 

I feel like it has plenty of merit. I wasn't just repeating it to repeat it. Several people commented on it so I was attempting to express more clearly the point I was making.

[Sedai]

And I agree with Jack about your directing him to hammer. It was scummy.

I love it when were on the same page

[LilyElizabeth]

So do I, Bro.

[LilyElizabeth]

That's it from me for tonight. Night, all. 

[Sedai]

 

 

@AJ do you still think I was buddying towards X, and trying to save him?

 

All in all minimum damage for day 1.

 

However I will know for certain if I'm going to vote you day 2 soon enough. :)

Firstly, I wasn't the one to push the angle that you were trying to protect X. You should refer that question to Wombat and Despo. I did say that their theory had merit though, if that's what you're referring to.

 

I see what you're doing in the last bit and honestly it's pretty foolish on your part.

 

unvote vote X

 

L-1 on the claimed VT, I feel comfortable at this point securing a lynch for a coroner in order to progress.

 

Hammer away Jack.

Contrary to your deadline statement we had time to debate more. Agree it probably wouldn't of changed the outcome.

 

I had no problem hammering, however your over apparent provacation to do so is teh scummy

Meh, call it a gut check. Some others were beginning to think you were trying to protect X, so I decided to test it since I had the opportunity.

I don't usually have a lot of reads by this time in the game. You, sir, feel like scum to me. Pushing a point as hard as you did, as if you keep saying it people will believe it, is scummy. If your case had merit, or you thought it did, you wouldn't have felt the need to repeat it ad nauseum.

I feel like it has plenty of merit. I wasn't just repeating it to repeat it. Several people commented on it so I was attempting to express more clearly the point I was making.

If you see it. Your smart like a fox. ^^ and don't point it out. :p would hate for other non intendeds to a something. Al though I've never said anything. Insinuating and pointing something out is bad.

 

If you say you agree with a theory or it has merit, it's the same as you reiterating it verbatim. So yes I was referring to you cause you were on. Womby and des will also be called to answer.

 

My gut should have never been in question. Since I did but X at L-2 and you were the initial player to derail the lynch.

[Sedai]

Same. I'm calling it a night. Look forward to what's gunna unfold

[hazelkrs1]

Here are my reads as of this moment.

 

1:Err – not enough content that stuck out to me

2:Ishy - null

3:Jack – leaning town

4:Lily – town of course

5:Quibby - null

6:Leelou - gut says might be scum

7:Des – Post #185. Spinning my meta into incorrect statements. Scum

8:Verbal – not enough content

9:Andrej – Hammering a case home, hoping someone else will believe it if they see it enough. Scum.

10:Zanube – not enough content

11:Wombat – need to look at him closer to get a read.

A lot more I want to respond to but I just wanna point out that this reads list is as good as a scum claim.

[Xthrax]

Bah! GG Town, lynch those scum!

[LilyElizabeth]

So, anybody who catches you on your spinning is automatically scum. Noted. 

[Zanube]

@X: the reason that des originally for mentioning the C word (used 3 time so far by you and once by Quibby). It had to do with the fact that he and also i believed that it might be a trigger word to activate something worst like a SK (which is in line with the theme of the game). All your defense does not mention this fact that may be u just didnt think it was a trigger word instead it comes out as over defensive. These are pretty much what makes u look scummy (a lot). 

the only reason that i am not voting for you at this moment is that if you were a scum u wouldnt like to activate a other killer on the loose and also because you got 5 votes building up on you within 24 hours of the game being started (even tough you were kind of asking for it). 

 

I don't think a SK mechanic trigger is possible in a basic game. Not that it could not happen. I have heard that it is more likely to happen in advanced mafia games.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

here is a summary that i have always found useful... let me know if i missed something,

 

DAY 1:

 

Err:                 
Ishy:                
Jack:                Lily,
Lily:                  Andrej, Quibby, Zanube, Xthrax,
Quibby:           
Leelou:                       
Des:                
Verbal:             Wombat,
Andrej:             Leelou, Jack, Ishy, Err, Jack,
Zanube:           Xthrax,
Wombat:          Jack,
Xthrax:            Des, Andrej, Verbal, Leelou, Jack, Lily, Wombat, Jack, Andrej, Jack,

 

Not counting Quibby’s initial vote on Jason

 

P.S. Post edited to correct for the bold mishap after coping from MS Word.

edit second time to correct for a mistake, 

[Sedai]

here is a summary that i have always found useful... let me know if i missed something,

 

DAY 1:

 

Err:

Ishy:

Jack: Lily,

Lily: Andrej, Quibby, Zanube, Xthrax,

Quibby:

Leelou:

Des:

Verbal: Wombat,

Andrej: Leelou, Jack, Ishy, Err, Jack,

Zanube: Xthrax,

Wombat: Jack,

Xthrax: Des, Andrej, Verbal, Leelou, Jack, Lily, Wombat, Jack, Andrej, Jack,

 

Not counting Quibby’s initial vote on Jason

 

P.S. Post edited to correct for the bold mishap after coping from MS Word.

edit second time to correct for a mistake,

It is irrelevant who X voted for as he was vanilla town and it was day 1. He'd have no knowledge as to who was scum or town.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

@AJ: let me tell u in detail y i went after you.... when i was reading the posts i found X to be scummy and wanted to place my vote for him but also didnt put a L2 vote on him thinking things were going too fast.... when Lily said the same thing i was thinking, i related to that.... and you pushing her a little to vote irrespective of the remaining lynch votes came off as scummy.... then you yourself said that so many votes on X so soon was kind of suspicious while still going after lily... this made you look more scummy to me... so i am still leaning scum on you. 

 

@ des: you seem to be scum hunting more then throwing random mud around... so i m leaning a little town

 

@ lily: even tough i related to you in D1.... i still kind of have a null read

 

@ jack: you are my second most likely on my scum list.... AJ and you seem to be on the opposite team so i realize i m wrong about one of you. 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

here is a summary that i have always found useful... let me know if i missed something,

 

DAY 1:

 

Err:

Ishy:

Jack: Lily,

Lily: Andrej, Quibby, Zanube, Xthrax,

Quibby:

Leelou:

Des:

Verbal: Wombat,

Andrej: Leelou, Jack, Ishy, Err, Jack,

Zanube: Xthrax,

Wombat: Jack,

Xthrax: Des, Andrej, Verbal, Leelou, Jack, Lily, Wombat, Jack, Andrej, Jack,

 

Not counting Quibby’s initial vote on Jason

 

P.S. Post edited to correct for the bold mishap after coping from MS Word.

edit second time to correct for a mistake,

It is irrelevant who X voted for as he was vanilla town and it was day 1. He'd have no knowledge as to who was scum or town.

 

well i think its relevant... and will become more so when we have more red(scum)/green(town) colors as the game continues 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

@X: the reason that des originally for mentioning the C word (used 3 time so far by you and once by Quibby). It had to do with the fact that he and also i believed that it might be a trigger word to activate something worst like a SK (which is in line with the theme of the game). All your defense does not mention this fact that may be u just didnt think it was a trigger word instead it comes out as over defensive. These are pretty much what makes u look scummy (a lot). 

the only reason that i am not voting for you at this moment is that if you were a scum u wouldnt like to activate a other killer on the loose and also because you got 5 votes building up on you within 24 hours of the game being started (even tough you were kind of asking for it). 

 

I don't think a SK mechanic trigger is possible in a basic game. Not that it could not happen. I have heard that it is more likely to happen in advanced mafia games.

 

well this wouldnt be the first time when i would have come under fire for speculating on the game... even as early as day 1.... but i still do believe that a good thing to do.... and i m going to continue speculating.... and so here goes... 2 mafias, 1 godfather, 1 cop, 1 doc, 1 more role (SK?, miller?, etc)

[Babar Hasan Khan]

if AJ turns out to be scum then based on the voting pattern either Lily or Wombat would be his teammates