[Basic] The Circle Mafia - Game over

[LilyElizabeth]

If your playstyle efffectively caught mafia I wouldn't have issue with it Lily. Not trying to be rude here but even a gut feeling deserves some reason if you want it to be considered credible.

 

unvote vote kaylee sure.

 

Btw, starting to get into this again thoigh Key is offputting.

So, what you're saying is that you don't think I'm good at mafia. I can't say I don't agree with you there, but it's fun to play. 

[michellem]

Official Vote Count:

Key (1): Dice
Dice (1): Krak
Cloud (3): Kaylee, Tom, Des,
Tom (1): Luci
Kaylee (3): Cloud, Lily, Kaylee
Ishy (1): Key




With 11 alive, 6 is needed to achieve a lynch.
Not Voting (4): Ishy, Dice, Des

Deadline 2am Saturday GMT+1 http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131214T02&p0=1375&msg=End+of+D2

[Kaylee]

Unvote Vote Ishy

[Kaylee]

He's my next highest read..then Darthe ouor Krak.

[Kaylee]

Lynching me means losing a townie, but I guess that happens when you change how you play.

 

Can't say it's because I haven't given solid reads because I have recently.

[LilyElizabeth]

From Golden:

 

Was leaning scum on you yesterday. This does it for me. Nudge and a no vote=so scummy

 

Vote Kaylee

 

 

 

I wasn't nudging him. I was pointing out a possibility. In fact I think it makes him less likely scum. That's why I didn't vote him.

I agree with this. Back to reading....

[John E. Kelley]

Lynching me means losing a townie, but I guess that happens when you change how you play.

Can't say it's because I haven't given solid reads because I have recently.

So fencesitting = solid reads now?

[Kaylee]

Skimming again? There is two players I don't have a solid read on out of 10 others. Sue me. That's not fence sitting

[John E. Kelley]

Funny how those "solid reads" only materialized once you were called out for fencesitting the entire game. Miraculous.

[Kaylee]

With only 10 hours to deadline Cloud and I are the only trains with more than 1 vote. We really shouldn't let this go random. Those not voting should vote.

 

Have I switched my reads on people? Yes, I'm having a hard time reading some tbh.

 

I do think Ishy and Cloud are scum.

 

There are some I'm not sure of but that always happens to me. I'm getting a town vibe from Tom and thinking Key is more likely town. (The reason is the bulk of my case on her seemed to be wrong on my part).

 

Krak I'm leaning scum due to Golden's play. Lily I can't really say as Hallu went quiet so long ago and hadn't posted much.

 

Darthe seems disinterested and I'm not sure if he's scum or possibly survivor but I'm not leaning town anymore.

 

Despo seems to be honestly trying to scumhunt so even though I liked the points Key made, still leaning town here.

 

Those I'm unsure of are: Dice, and Lily.

 

As for Luci...I really wasn't sure as the majority of the case against her was that post to Dice about fluffing when he wasn't. Her recent posts however strike me more as caring an aweful lot how she appears. She also got heated with me a bit and seemed to be getting emtionally involved. (Like I hit a nerve so she said she had hit one on me...) This could just be her being new. I thought she'd played in more than just this game..pretty sure she has but it might have been only one other. If that's the case then it could just be newness, if not, then she's playing us.

 

Luci: how many games, besides this one, have you played?

 

To sum up:

 

Luci: new so harder to read, could be scum

 

Town reads:

Despo, Tom and Key

 

Scum reads:

Cloud, Ishy and Krak

 

Darthe: Either survivor or scum

 

Unsure: Lily due to little from Hallu and Dice

There you go. Quoted it for you. Do you have a solid read on Hallu/Lily? Or Luci? If so I'm willing to listen to them and consider the points

[Tommyrod]

Leave Kaylee alone

 

She's as pure as white snow

[Tommyrod]

[Kaylee]

Funny how those "solid reads" only materialized once you were called out for fencesitting the entire game. Miraculous.

Actually no I have said I thought Des was town since D1. Golden I also gave reads on in fact I had voted him before he was replaced. I was giving Krak a chance to play for himself and so far I'm not impressed. The rest I'm entitled to change my mind as cases are made.

[Tommyrod]

Cloud or Dice is the lynch for today

 

Anything else is hogwash and poppycock

[Kaylee]

Ishy: If I get lynched and you see I was telling the truth about being town...who then will you look at?

[Kaylee]

Cloud or Dice is the lynch for today

 

Anything else is hogwash and poppycock

Cloud is unCC'd cop

[Tommyrod]

Hogcock.

[Tommyrod]

Cloud claimed cop? I really need to read the thread

 

But it's not too smart to claim cop when there are like 2/6 votes on you

 

A smart cop wouldn't CC him this early anyway

 

But meh

 

Unvote Cloud

 

Vote Dice

[LilyElizabeth]

Cloud claimed cop? I really need to read the thread

 

But it's not too smart to claim cop when there are like 2/6 votes on you

 

A smart cop wouldn't CC him this early anyway

 

But meh

 

Unvote Cloud

 

Vote Dice

This. I'm inclined to believe that Cloud isn't the cop and is scum trying to save himself. If the real cop (if there is one) is smart, they won't CC, so this is a good play for a mafia to make. But I'll err on the side of caution on this. 

[Tommyrod]

 

Cloud claimed cop? I really need to read the thread

But it's not too smart to claim cop when there are like 2/6 votes on you

A smart cop wouldn't CC him this early anyway

But mehUnvote Cloud

Vote Dice

 

This. I'm inclined to believe that Cloud isn't the cop and is scum trying to save himself. If the real cop (if there is one) is smart, they won't CC, so this is a good play for a mafia to make. But I'll err on the side of caution on this.

Get out of my head!!!!!

[Tommyrod]

Who did Cloud claim to peek?

[_CLOUD]

I had 4/6 votes on me. And both of you should also start actually reading the thread instead of post whatever comes to your mind at the moment, maybe then you will also notice my defense against Despo and Tom. Could be helpful.

[_CLOUD]

Who did Cloud claim to peek?

 

Despo.

[Luciena]

Official Vote Count:

 

Key (1): Dice

Dice (1): Krak

Cloud (3): Kaylee, Tom, Des,

Tom (1): Luci

Kaylee (3): Cloud, Lily, Kaylee

Ishy (1): Key

 

 

 

 

With 11 alive, 6 is needed to achieve a lynch.

Not Voting (4): Ishy, Dice, Des

 

Deadline 2am Saturday GMT+1 http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131214T02&p0=1375&msg=End+of+D2

Mish Your vote count is wrong again.... please fix it.

 

 

 

 

Unvote Tom

[Tommyrod]

I had 4/6 votes on me. And both of you should also start actually reading the thread instead of post whatever comes to your mind at the moment, maybe then you will also notice my defense against Despo and Tom. Could be helpful.

You guys made this game really hard to read though

 

So many inaccurate reasons to be FOSing each other, and such long winded ways to say nothing

 

Anyway, gimme the deets. Or just link me to it