[Basic] The Walking Dead Mafia - Game Over. Theo Wins!

[michellem]

Ok I'm back. Sorry, let outside issues affect me.

 

Unvote vote Ishy

[Andrej]

Added.

[John E. Kelley]

I told AJ that this would be an issue eventually. No way that this should be in a basic game, but whatever.

 

I'm Morgan, and I'm a third party Survivor. I can win with either team as long as I'm one of the last three players remaining.

[John E. Kelley]

So you weren't trying to be friendly to me Ishy, you were just trying to get on my good side because you were mafia. I'm disappointed now.

 

Ok I gotta walk off for a while, I'm a bit upset.

We can talk about this after the game if you want. Or not. But it wouldn't matter in the slightest what my alignment was, I didn't like Nolder talking to you that way. Even if he had been on my team at the time I'd stick up for you. For you to think that what I said was actual gameplay is disappointing.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

I told AJ that this would be an issue eventually. No way that this should be in a basic game, but whatever.

 

I'm Morgan, and I'm a third party Survivor. I can win with either team as long as I'm one of the last three players remaining.

 

it seems everyone in the game has a role except me :P excuse me if i dont believe u :P u were number 1 on my list :)

 

vote Ishy

 

Mish.... u need to save Golden period.... and u will be NKed for it.... but this game is not going beyond D4 so we probably dont need a doctor after it as much as we need a cop to survive to D4.... 

 

however if golden dies i am coming after u... i will not take oh i was taking a chance saving myself as an excuse

[Babar Hasan Khan]

my next 2 scum reads

 

Des (80%)

Peace (70%)

 

when i pointed out to Des that according to his analysis peace should be a candidate for a scum not theo.... he did not comment anything on it.... he clumps theo and peace together but wont go after peace??? 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

before we end the day without discussing other pending things BFG and Theo hold on a little longer before lunching Ishy

 

unvote AJ

[Babar Hasan Khan]

sorry 

 

unvote

[Babar Hasan Khan]

i want to discuss Des and Peace a little more

[Babar Hasan Khan]

BTW...the standard/basic issue has come up often.  It even has it's own thread.

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/67426-what-constitutes-a-standard-game/?hl=standard

i dont see a bomb in the list can u point it out to me??

[BFG]

Although it should be obvious

 

Intent to vote Ishy

 

*runs away to check mafia wiki on survivor*

[BFG]

Also Err, seriously stop telling other people how to play :cross:

[peacesells]

Err. It wasn't a list of roles. It was a discussion about the fact that standard and basic games here are both played under the "basic" tag.

[peacesells]

But I do see you spinning. Good try.

 

Oh and stalling the the lynch??? Are you trying to come up with a way to get ishy out of this in your scum topic?

[BFG]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Survivor

 

Ok, so numbers.

 

Thought we were at 5v3

 

If Ishy's telling the truth about being 3rd party, then we're at either 4v3v1 or 5v2v1

 

2 seems underpowered for a mafia team, but a town team that includes lovers and a third party seems underpowered as well.

 

After Mishes reveal, and assuming that Des/Dora isn't some massive gambit and thus they're not mafia together then that left Ishy on 5 of the possible 7 teams with the information that I had.

[BFG]

^esp. since survivors seem to be considered anti-town

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Des and Peace were trying to get townys to vote for Theo or Me.... just to get only 2 of towny votes on them then all the scums could add their votes in and speed hammer lynch and end the game

 

Des was annoyed that we were withholding votes.... if by chance 2 towny votes fell on the other towny the game would have been over...... it was a great thing that the townys were not pushed into this ploy.... but i must say it was u when accusing Theo that made me think over peace being a godfather 

 

Des also became paranoid on purpose to get people to cast votes quickly..... 

 

Peace - when golden made it clear that golden, me, theo and presumably BFG werent voting for Theo.... you started to go after me :)   most of your efforts were to convince Mish that i was a scum (of course u didnt have to convince Des or Ishy)... u actively told her to vote for me..... and Des at this point also started to move his focus on me a little bit too at that point

[John E. Kelley]

Just lynch me and get rid of the wifom. AJ and I can discuss the b.s. balancing after the game. I'm done.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

But I do see you spinning. Good try.

 

Oh and stalling the the lynch??? Are you trying to come up with a way to get ishy out of this in your scum topic?

 

 

Just lynch me and get rid of the wifom. AJ and I can discuss the b.s. balancing after the game. I'm done.

 

 

to both of you......    no......  lets talk numbers a bit more :) 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Survivor

 

Ok, so numbers.

 

Thought we were at 5v3

 

If Ishy's telling the truth about being 3rd party, then we're at either 4v3v1 or 5v2v1

 

2 seems underpowered for a mafia team, but a town team that includes lovers and a third party seems underpowered as well.

 

After Mishes reveal, and assuming that Des/Dora isn't some massive gambit and thus they're not mafia together then that left Ishy on 5 of the possible 7 teams with the information that I had.

it doesnt say anything about what happens when survivor gets inspected... is he read as a towny or mafia

 

even if he is telling the truth its most probably 5v2v1 ....    which means if we lynch him now... we still dont lose and make it to the other day... with 4v2 the same outcome we would have if he was even a mafia

 

so at this point his claim gets us at the same position as if he was mafia..... so lynching him is the best thing.... since his vote could be used to speedhammer someone as the article says and with less and less numbers of players he is a liability.

 

so ya we vote for him even if his claim is true

[Babar Hasan Khan]

we are all assuming that something has gone wrong with the setup of the game... 

 

what if there is actually only mafia, townys, cop, a doctor and lovers only.... no savior or bomb.... i mean these are claims at this point and only claims

[peacesells]

Err uou better recheck your facts. I was on to you before day 3.

 

But keep spinning. And I'm not buying your little exchange with ishy there.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Err uou better recheck your facts. I was on to you before day 3.

 

But keep spinning. And I'm not buying your little exchange with ishy there.

i find it interesting with everything that has happened... u still suspect me and not Des...... and what do u think about theo now??

[BFG]

Peace - any input on numbers if Ishy is telling the truth?

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Peace - any input on numbers if Ishy is telling the truth?

i dont know what he is supposed to say that there is no Savior.... then we can also ask him about if there is a bomb or not too