November 7th, 1606: Day 4 (CONCLUDED)

[csarmi]

Oh yea and I know I haven't because I didn't have the time to separate my three plays yet. That's the next step, obviously. Analyzing thread by thread

[peacesells]

Obviously.

[dapianoplay3r]

I think thread 1 was the one I had Csarmi as most likely mafia on

[csarmi]

Well, you got a better idea?

[csarmi]

I think thread 1 was the one I had Csarmi as most likely mafia on

 

t1=1052, t2=1603 and t3=2000?

[dapianoplay3r]

Yea I'm just calling them 1, 2, and 3

 

The names are too confusing

[Pralaya]

Call them ancient, medieval, modern ! :)

[csarmi]

I think thread 1 was the one I had Csarmi as most likely mafia on

 

So any basis or reasoning attached to that?

[dapianoplay3r]

Call them ancient, medieval, modern ! :)

  

1050 something isn't really ancient

That just pre Norman conquest

 

But I'll grudgingly give you the others two

 

 

 

I think thread 1 was the one I had Csarmi as most likely mafia on

 

 

So any basis or reasoning attached to that?

I think it was how you reacted to cloud on that thread in particular compared with the other two

If I had to pick you as mafia on a thread my money was on that one

[Leelou]

 

This is game 2 right?

Cloud has been pretty scummy in this thread. He is one of my top pics

 

I even quoted him and explaind in my first post. How do you not see clouds scummy?

 

A couple of things wrong with your statements here.  First...All those quotes I made came long before your first post in this thread.

 

Second...If Leelou is distancing from Cloud that makes him scum right?

 

 

He was coming off scummy in this thread, he deserved a vote. I think he's the best bet for scum in this thread. 

[csarmi]

 

Call them ancient, medieval, modern ! :)

  

1050 something isn't really ancient

That just pre Norman conquest

 

But I'll grudgingly give you the others two

 

 

 

I think thread 1 was the one I had Csarmi as most likely mafia on

 

So any basis or reasoning attached to that?

I think it was how you reacted to cloud on that thread in particular compared with the other two

If I had to pick you as mafia on a thread my money was on that one

 

 

Fair enough. Just so you know, there's no particular reason for the placing of my posts. As far as I know, I've referenced the global reactions to my play only in a global scale so far (not on a thread by thread basis). 

[dapianoplay3r]

Here herE!

[dapianoplay3r]

Here here!

[dapianoplay3r]

Stupid DM

 

Well that's how it looks dude. It looks thread specific

[csarmi]

Good, it's time to get thread specific soon anyway. Global is outdated.

 

Yea I had DM troubles too.

[dapianoplay3r]

Lol I love how you are now pushing the thread specifics when you just said you were being global

 

I'm not sure if that can even be called an attempt for cred or you just like to look like you are a leader. Either way I loled

[csarmi]

Lol I love how you are now pushing the thread specifics when you just said you were being global

 

I'm not sure if that can even be called an attempt for cred or you just like to look like you are a leader. Either way I loled

 

There's no contradiction here. I was being global and yes we need to switch to local.

I don't need cred. I'm doing just fine without it. I play to win, not to survive.

[peacesells]

 

 

This is game 2 right?

Cloud has been pretty scummy in this thread. He is one of my top pics

 

I even quoted him and explaind in my first post. How do you not see clouds scummy?

 

A couple of things wrong with your statements here.  First...All those quotes I made came long before your first post in this thread.

 

Second...If Leelou is distancing from Cloud that makes him scum right?

 

 

He was coming off scummy in this thread, he deserved a vote. I think he's the best bet for scum in this thread. 

 

 

He had made 1 post when you voted him.  He voted Yates for self voting.  Not buying your explanation. 

[dapianoplay3r]

It just amused me

Seemed like you were like "the tides are turning. People aren't keen on the global thing. Gotta get in with the individual thread to keep being cool"

 

Anyway you are right. You don't need to survive to win

 

Either ways I think you are mafia in thread 1. Not so sure on the others but hey

[dapianoplay3r]

Peace he made one post here

You are right

 

But he made it differently to the other posts he did in the other two threads.

[Leelou]

 

 

 

This is game 2 right?

Cloud has been pretty scummy in this thread. He is one of my top pics

 

I even quoted him and explaind in my first post. How do you not see clouds scummy?

 

A couple of things wrong with your statements here.  First...All those quotes I made came long before your first post in this thread.

 

Second...If Leelou is distancing from Cloud that makes him scum right?

 

 

He was coming off scummy in this thread, he deserved a vote. I think he's the best bet for scum in this thread. 

 

 

He had made 1 post when you voted him.  He voted Yates for self voting.  Not buying your explanation. 

 

 

He jumped on an easy train and it was the way he did it. Just slipped in going with everyone else. 

[peacesells]

 

 

 

 

This is game 2 right?

Cloud has been pretty scummy in this thread. He is one of my top pics

 

I even quoted him and explaind in my first post. How do you not see clouds scummy?

 

A couple of things wrong with your statements here.  First...All those quotes I made came long before your first post in this thread.

 

Second...If Leelou is distancing from Cloud that makes him scum right?

 

 

He was coming off scummy in this thread, he deserved a vote. I think he's the best bet for scum in this thread. 

 

 

He had made 1 post when you voted him.  He voted Yates for self voting.  Not buying your explanation. 

 

 

He jumped on an easy train and it was the way he did it. Just slipped in going with everyone else. 

 

 

Right..but you removed your vote.  Yet mentioned him a few more times.  Distancing.  You and Cloud...scum team?  Add Ishy too?

[Leelou]

 

 

 

 

 

This is game 2 right?

Cloud has been pretty scummy in this thread. He is one of my top pics

 

I even quoted him and explaind in my first post. How do you not see clouds scummy?

 

A couple of things wrong with your statements here.  First...All those quotes I made came long before your first post in this thread.

 

Second...If Leelou is distancing from Cloud that makes him scum right?

 

 

He was coming off scummy in this thread, he deserved a vote. I think he's the best bet for scum in this thread. 

 

 

He had made 1 post when you voted him.  He voted Yates for self voting.  Not buying your explanation. 

 

 

He jumped on an easy train and it was the way he did it. Just slipped in going with everyone else. 

 

 

Right..but you removed your vote.  Yet mentioned him a few more times.  Distancing.  You and Cloud...scum team?  Add Ishy too?

 

 

They could be scum, I'm not. I removed my vote to go along with the salami plan. I've mentioned him because he keeps acting scummy in this thread. He's my best bet for the next phase and I don't want to forget which thread I've mentioned him in or why. 

[Nolder]

I am new to mafia but I don't think the strategy of voting csarmi in all the three thread works. Sure, he is mafia in one of the games. But, assuming he is mafia in one and town in the other two, voting him in all three means that we lose out on two of them and I don't like the odds.

 

Looking at the extra effort that he puts in this thread "trap" etc, I think it is here.

 

vote csarmi

That may be true but we haven't got a real choice otherwise. I think we all agree it's highly likely he's mafia in at least one game but how do we tell which one? All we can really do is lynch him. Either all at once just to be sure he wasn't mafia twice or staggered (not fan of this option).

[Nolder]

 

I am new to mafia but I don't think the strategy of voting csarmi in all the three thread works. Sure, he is mafia in one of the games. But, assuming he is mafia in one and town in the other two, voting him in all three means that we lose out on two of them and I don't like the odds.

 

Looking at the extra effort that he puts in this thread "trap" etc, I think it is here.

 

vote csarmi

 

Your reasoning is even worse than those who advocate lynching me in all three threads.

 

Again, the unbased assumption that I'm scum in at least one of the threads. I'm town in all three. 

But if your assumtion was true, getting a 1/3 chance to catch scum wouldn't be a bad thing. Random chance would be around 1/4.

 

Also I didn't put in any extra effort in this thread.

 

If that's true then you made an awful play and we're all going to suffer for it. Seeing as we can't distinguish between bad play and scummy play you're gonna hang either way.