[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[John E. Kelley]

And as of right now, I believe EP.

Your actions contradict this statement, just sayin

 

Wait, what? Did he really say that? After every post all game has been calling EP out?

 

Will scroll back and look for this.

[RandA lThor]

Right, but obviously, if Jon Snow reveals, he will be one of the mafia's top targets, and if he is the doc, I don't think he would want to reveal. I'm not saying I think EP is mafia, I think he's town, but I don't think its as proven as Nol thinks it is.

Whether he's the doctor or not is irrelevant because whoever IS the doctor can protect him

 

And as of right now, I believe EP.

Your actions contradict this statement, just sayin

 

And then Ed Stark dies? I assume he must be pretty powerful.

[John E. Kelley]

A smart Mafia won't take out any of the claimed characters anyway.

 

Much better for them to take out someone that gives Town no info. That's just Mafia 101.

[Gabriel Kross]

Not sure why Rand is tying in the Role at the moment. I kinda understand, but since that isn't what this is about, pinging.

 

 

And also, because of FB.

 

Ferdinand Braun? Has someone watched Steins Gate?

 

 

Serious thoughts to come.

[Nolder]

Right, but obviously, if Jon Snow reveals, he will be one of the mafia's top targets, and if he is the doc, I don't think he would want to reveal. I'm not saying I think EP is mafia, I think he's town, but I don't think its as proven as Nol thinks it is.

Whether he's the doctor or not is irrelevant because whoever IS the doctor can protect him

 

And as of right now, I believe EP.

Your actions contradict this statement, just sayin

 

And then Ed Stark dies? I assume he must be pretty powerful.

WIFOM it

 

It's all we can do in this case

If none of us had claimed we'd already be down a Stark wouldn't we?

[Nolder]

Kind of worried about Ishy taking my position so hard

Smacks of buddying but it's nothing to worry about for the moment I think

Just bear it in mind later

[Gabriel Kross]

Ed = Eddard = Ned. just saying

 

this is not news to me.

 

What QT was this copied from? It's like the second or third thing you posted like that.

 

thbis is from one of Red's WOTs I have been copying from the game thread I have only done it twice and the first time was even stated that I did

[John E. Kelley]

Kind of worried about Ishy taking my position so hard

Smacks of buddying but it's nothing to worry about for the moment I think

Just bear it in mind later

 

How exactly am I taking "your" position?

 

Trusting a mod confirmed townie more than unknowns is logic, not buddying.

 

But bear it in mind if you like.

[Gabriel Kross]

Interesting that it's only my respons that got backlighted though I hate c/ping stuff here.

[Red2111]

Rand & ishy, why are ya;ll so concerned with what their roles might be? isn't it bad enough that they've outted their characters, if their telling the truth. imo only scum would be concerned about their roles now.

 

Ed - you know better than this on the vetted town thing. his words hold more weight because we know he's not WIFOMing anything and we can take them at face value. also, whats up with that complete 180 on EP. up until a few posts ago you were saying you still didn't trust any of what he was saying.

 

 

You and Ed and anyone else who is expressing doubt about me, EP, or John need to take a step back and seriously analyze the situation here

 

i get anyone doubting you. but John and EP could be lying. infact i think theres a good chance they are lying, especially EP. the lack of a CC be damned on EP his actions are just too anti-town for me to believe his claim.

 

also, you keep saying as if its 100% fact that you know the Starks are town this game. is this your assumption or do you have proof of this aside frm your own character and alignment?

 

also, i think your over reacting on Cyan and Ed with this. there just saying your not finder or anythign and know 100% that Ep and John are telling the truth. Nightstrikes the only one that i've seen thus far try to openingly question whether your mod confirmedness is true or not.

 

 

Ed = Eddard = Ned. just saying

 

this is not news to me.

 

What QT was this copied from? It's like the second or third thing you posted like that.

 

dude he got that from a previous post of mine. stop skimming

 

also interesting who latched onto the above.

 

 

I also found it funny that Red asked me why I voted BG then voted BG next post :p

 

and you still haven't answered the quesiton. i gave my reasoning for voting BG, you have yet to post yours. your mid way up on my list and i have no problem moving my vote to you to add to the pressure Darth.

 

 

Glad you decided to join us here in the deep end of the pool Cyan.

 

On Wednesdays, we lynch Nol. true

 

Ed's fleas aren't spreading. false

 

Red loves the Washington Redskins. false, she loves the Niners

 

And no, your eyes aren't deceiving you. I really am this handsome.

 

we can now lynch Rand and Ishy. just sayin. their obviously scum

[John E. Kelley]

Where exactly was I interested in roles Red? I was merely saying that noone has claimed roles, only characters.

[John E. Kelley]

And don't hate because I revealed your closet Redskins fetish. It's kinda petty.

[John E. Kelley]

Lastly, please tell me that you aren't actually suggesting that the Stark's won't be Town. The mods have already confirmed that Rikon is Town. So Rikon is, but Ned might not be? How would that even be conceivable?

[RandA lThor]

Ishy, I think you are getting mixed up with NFL teams. Its the San Francisco 49ers, not the San Francisco Redskins. *pats Ishy on the head*

[RandA lThor]

A smart Mafia won't take out any of the claimed characters anyway.

 

Much better for them to take out someone that gives Town no info. That's just Mafia 101.

 

a smart mafia would take out claimed characters, more probability of them not being lynched if there are less people that are almost sure to be town.

 

Rand & ishy, why are ya;ll so concerned with what their roles might be? isn't it bad enough that they've outted their characters, if their telling the truth. imo only scum would be concerned about their roles now.

 

Ed - you know better than this on the vetted town thing. his words hold more weight because we know he's not WIFOMing anything and we can take them at face value. also, whats up with that complete 180 on EP. up until a few posts ago you were saying you still didn't trust any of what he was saying.

 

 

You and Ed and anyone else who is expressing doubt about me, EP, or John need to take a step back and seriously analyze the situation here

 

i get anyone doubting you. but John and EP could be lying. infact i think theres a good chance they are lying, especially EP. the lack of a CC be damned on EP his actions are just too anti-town for me to believe his claim.

 

also, you keep saying as if its 100% fact that you know the Starks are town this game. is this your assumption or do you have proof of this aside frm your own character and alignment?

 

also, i think your over reacting on Cyan and Ed with this. there just saying your not finder or anythign and know 100% that Ep and John are telling the truth. Nightstrikes the only one that i've seen thus far try to openingly question whether your mod confirmedness is true or not.

 

 

Ed = Eddard = Ned. just saying

 

this is not news to me.

 

What QT was this copied from? It's like the second or third thing you posted like that.

 

dude he got that from a previous post of mine. stop skimming

 

also interesting who latched onto the above.

 

 

I also found it funny that Red asked me why I voted BG then voted BG next post :p

 

and you still haven't answered the quesiton. i gave my reasoning for voting BG, you have yet to post yours. your mid way up on my list and i have no problem moving my vote to you to add to the pressure Darth.

 

 

Glad you decided to join us here in the deep end of the pool Cyan.

 

On Wednesdays, we lynch Nol. true

 

Ed's fleas aren't spreading. false

 

Red loves the Washington Redskins. false, she loves the Niners

 

And no, your eyes aren't deceiving you. I really am this handsome.

 

we can now lynch Rand and Ishy. just sayin. their obviously scum

 

I'm not concerned about what their roles are, I was just saying that their role might be a reason that someone would not CC if they were Jon Snow.

[Nolder]

You and Ed and anyone else who is expressing doubt about me, EP, or John need to take a step back and seriously analyze the situation here

 

i get anyone doubting you. but John and EP could be lying. infact i think theres a good chance they are lying, especially EP. the lack of a CC be damned on EP his actions are just too anti-town for me to believe his claim.

That's the rub though

Unless someone is being dumb and not CCing there is no reason to think they are lying

There has been no CC therefore there is no reason NOT to trust John and EP

 

also, you keep saying as if its 100% fact that you know the Starks are town this game. is this your assumption or do you have proof of this aside frm your own character and alignment?

You must have missed my character claim

I am Rickon Stark

[RandA lThor]

You and Ed and anyone else who is expressing doubt about me, EP, or John need to take a step back and seriously analyze the situation here

 

i get anyone doubting you. but John and EP could be lying. infact i think theres a good chance they are lying, especially EP. the lack of a CC be damned on EP his actions are just too anti-town for me to believe his claim.

That's the rub though

Unless someone is being dumb and not CCing there is no reason to think they are lying

There has been no CC therefore there is no reason NOT to trust John and EP

 

also, you keep saying as if its 100% fact that you know the Starks are town this game. is this your assumption or do you have proof of this aside frm your own character and alignment?

You must have missed my character claim

I am Rickon Stark

 

As I argued before, may not be a dumb move.

[Nolder]

Lastly, please tell me that you aren't actually suggesting that the Stark's won't be Town. The mods have already confirmed that Rikon is Town. So Rikon is, but Ned might not be? How would that even be conceivable?

The only Stark I'd be concerned about is Jon

There is the possibility he's Night's Watch aligned or somesuch but for now I see no reason not to trust that he's town

[Nolder]

As I argued before, may not be a dumb move.

You argued for role claiming

I am talking about character claiming

 

This has already been pointed out to you, why are we going over it again?

[Nolder]

Kind of worried about Ishy taking my position so hard

Smacks of buddying but it's nothing to worry about for the moment I think

Just bear it in mind later

 

How exactly am I taking "your" position?

 

Trusting a mod confirmed townie more than unknowns is logic, not buddying.

 

But bear it in mind if you like.

It's an easy way to build townie cred

Just sheep the clear

Seen it hundreds of times

Hell I've done it hundreds of times

[RandA lThor]

As I argued before, may not be a dumb move.

You argued for role claiming

I am talking about character claiming

 

This has already been pointed out to you, why are we going over it again?

 

OK, fine different argument if you don't want to look at that. If someone knows they're lying scum, they can obvserve their interactions now that they know, and possibly net some more scum.

[Gabriel Kross]

I'm good with a lynch on Darthe LZM or Red at this point

 

My reasoning on Red is previously stated.

Darthe I stated some things previously, but him throwing the "QT" suspicion because I c/p'ed something is weak. I debunked that C/P stuff in the last Pokemon game.

LZM Where is he? LZM is never this quiet, especially with multiple claims. We can rule out silenced at this time, because odds of a day silencer are slim. LZM went quiet after his habbit of flipping his lid on claims was brought up.

[ed2funy]

And as of right now, I believe EP.

Your actions contradict this statement, just sayin

 

I unvoted him awhile ago. And I do believe I stated it was not a strong belief.

 

Ed - you know better than this on the vetted town thing. his words hold more weight because we know he's not WIFOMing anything and we can take them at face value. also, whats up with that complete 180 on EP. up until a few posts ago you were saying you still didn't trust any of what he was saying.

His words hold no more weight. Yes, his best interests are for the Town, but that does not mean he knows who is who.

And it isn't a complete 180. I still don't fully believe him. I just don't think he is a viable lynch option at the moment. That is why I don't have my vote placed anywhere. I might decide to revote him, for not right now. lol

[Red2111]

okay Nol, i'm gonna ask striahgt out then, are you on a Mason board with Jon and EP, or do you know 100% for fact, mod confirmed, that they are town? cause imo, your just basing this off your own role.

 

unless your on a Mason board with them, i'm taking both their reveals with a large spoonfull of salt, especially EP's. both for how he revealed and becuase of his anti-town actions.

 

John's i'm still undecided on. the reveal doesn't ping and tbh i didn't relaly see the case on him, not enough for that many votes.

 

 

as for CCs. i'll tell you this much. if i was Jon Snow in this game, which i'm not, i'd not bother CCing EP. the way he's playing, h's on the fast track to lynch ville and theres a solid case on him.

 

 

Where exactly was I interested in roles Red? I was merely saying that noone has claimed roles, only characters.

 

the last exchange between you and Rand aside fromt eh football spam. also, Nol claimed a role, just sayin.

 

i agree that Rand was the most focus, but i dont exactly trust you; so i'm also wary of the possability that your scum edging the convo along enough to both make peopel want to laynch Rand over it and so you can still wash your hands clean of it

 

 

Lastly, please tell me that you aren't actually suggesting that the Stark's won't be Town. The mods have already confirmed that Rikon is Town. So Rikon is, but Ned might not be? How would that even be conceivable?

 

its an advanced game, i'm not goign to assume anyones town except for myself and Nol at this point. and given its an advanced game, i'll likley not consider Nol 100% confirmed tomorrow JIC theres a recruiting faction. he'd be the best target for rectruiting imo. but the role "innocent child" makes him sound liek a tree stump tbh, unrecruitable, maybe even unlynchable. discussing this is WIFOM, but he is last on my list of possible scum and will stay last until i see reason to believe otherwise.

[beanie]

its an advanced game, i'm not goign to assume anyones town except for myself and Nol at this point. and given its an advanced game, i'll likley not consider Nol 100% confirmed tomorrow JIC theres a recruiting faction. he'd be the best target for rectruiting imo. but the role "innocent child" makes him sound liek a tree stump tbh, unrecruitable, maybe even unlynchable. discussing this is WIFOM, but he is last on my list of possible scum and will stay last until i see reason to believe otherwise.

 

O.o what is this?