The Ape's --- OUTBREAK MAFIA: GAME OVER!

bgrishinko · October 14, 2011

Also, with only 4 needed, last minute lynches aren't common.

You know Tina, this feels slightly familiar to me, reminds me of the Halo Mafia game we were in.

How so? (right after I post about meta being bad, I'm now........doing it) O_o

Offtopic: A little different... Basically we were down to end game, Tina was a watcher and Amadine was scum. I was a Vig/Doc combo... and Aemon was there too. Amadine didn't kill on final night to frame me. Long story short, there were only 4 of us left. I admitted that I made the previous NK. Tina had to choose whether me or Amadine were scum, she did use tricky wording to try and weasel her way out of our questions. Kind of a reversed situation actually.

In any case, just it is close to endgame and the 3 of us are here again.

Leyrann · October 14, 2011

Well, this time, we have backup of some more Townies. If we lynch someone else than BG or me, we can show I don't have a Night Action. And, by not having a Night Action, we know that I am not mafia then.

Niniel · October 14, 2011

Also, with only 4 needed, last minute lynches aren't common.

You know Tina, this feels slightly familiar to me, reminds me of the Halo Mafia game we were in.

How so? (right after I post about meta being bad, I'm now........doing it) O_o

Offtopic: A little different... Basically we were down to end game, Tina was a watcher and Amadine was scum. I was a Vig/Doc combo... and Aemon was there too. Amadine didn't kill on final night to frame me. Long story short, there were only 4 of us left. I admitted that I made the previous NK. Tina had to choose whether me or Amadine were scum, she did use tricky wording to try and weasel her way out of our questions. Kind of a reversed situation actually.

In any case, just it is close to endgame and the 3 of us are here again.

Still off topic: I think that game is the only game where I felt satisfied with my play. First time cop.

bgrishinko · October 14, 2011

Did I say watcher? I meant cop.

Niniel · October 14, 2011

I had a one time watcher ability but pretended to have it the last night too. :biggrin:

/Stops spam

Blackhoof · October 15, 2011

O, and I too have an idea why they did that earlier one on Ishy, if I am right. They knew a Townie would die, and this made Hoof look more innocent. Only, he made that mistake of the "first Mafia lynch he had spearheaded", before we knew Ishy was mafia. Do you agree with this?

Really? People are STILL clinging to this? It was clear from the scene prior to the coroner report that Dave had died. Ishy=dave and dave=scum therefore, we had just lynched scum.

FOS Leyrann for dredging all this stuff that we had already put to bed long ago.

Sorry for the triple post - I should have included this info in a prior one...

bgrishinko- 83

Blackhoof- 44

Leyrann- 32

Verbal32- 31

TinaHel- 30

Amadine- 13

Hybrid- 10

Hybrid is skating by. The question is whether he's doing this as town or scum. There isn't enough content for me to really case him, and that bugs me. It makes me feel like I can't even vote him, and at this point in the game, players in that position are extremely dangerous.

Thoughts?

did you REALLY go through the ENTIRE thread and count our posts one by one O.o

u mad, bro

i agree that Hybrid and Amadine have been barely skating by, but that is not highly unusual for them to have low post counts in my experience. It is a bit of a null tell, really.

right now i am tossing up between Hybrid, Amadine and Leyrann....

i shall go with Leyrann, i think. vote Leyrann

Also, with only 4 needed, last minute lynches aren't common.

You know Tina, this feels slightly familiar to me, reminds me of the Halo Mafia game we were in.

How so? (right after I post about meta being bad, I'm now........doing it) O_o

Offtopic: A little different... Basically we were down to end game, Tina was a watcher and Amadine was scum. I was a Vig/Doc combo... and Aemon was there too. Amadine didn't kill on final night to frame me. Long story short, there were only 4 of us left. I admitted that I made the previous NK. Tina had to choose whether me or Amadine were scum, she did use tricky wording to try and weasel her way out of our questions. Kind of a reversed situation actually.

In any case, just it is close to endgame and the 3 of us are here again.

i modded that game. i was pretty happy with how it ended too- Chief, cortana and Johnson surviving as Gravemind dies. epicness.

bgrishinko · October 15, 2011

"Can ya stick it?"

Leyrann · October 15, 2011

O, and I too have an idea why they did that earlier one on Ishy, if I am right. They knew a Townie would die, and this made Hoof look more innocent. Only, he made that mistake of the "first Mafia lynch he had spearheaded", before we knew Ishy was mafia. Do you agree with this?

Really? People are STILL clinging to this? It was clear from the scene prior to the coroner report that Dave had died. Ishy=dave and dave=scum therefore, we had just lynched scum.

FOS Leyrann for dredging all this stuff that we had already put to bed long ago.

We did not know that Ishy was Dave. Dave could as easily be Wombat, who was killed by the Bomb (Ishy).

But you know, I don't see anyone really playing scummy.

(yeah, of course that could also mean that Verb is scum, and just didn't make a mistake, but I don't want to vote the best player of the game just because no one is looking scummy)

John McClane · October 15, 2011

Day 5 vote count:

Verbal (1) - Tina

Hoof (1) - Leyrann

Hybrid (1) - Amadine

Leyrann (1) - Blackhoof

Not voting (3): bg, Verbal, Hybrid

-----

With 7 players left, it takes 4 to lynch.

DEADLINE: Sunday 11PM EST

Verbal32 · October 15, 2011

O, and I too have an idea why they did that earlier one on Ishy, if I am right. They knew a Townie would die, and this made Hoof look more innocent. Only, he made that mistake of the "first Mafia lynch he had spearheaded", before we knew Ishy was mafia. Do you agree with this?

Really? People are STILL clinging to this? It was clear from the scene prior to the coroner report that Dave had died. Ishy=dave and dave=scum therefore, we had just lynched scum.

FOS Leyrann for dredging all this stuff that we had already put to bed long ago.

Sorry for the triple post - I should have included this info in a prior one...

bgrishinko- 83

Blackhoof- 44

Leyrann- 32

Verbal32- 31

TinaHel- 30

Amadine- 13

Hybrid- 10

Hybrid is skating by. The question is whether he's doing this as town or scum. There isn't enough content for me to really case him, and that bugs me. It makes me feel like I can't even vote him, and at this point in the game, players in that position are extremely dangerous.

Thoughts?

did you REALLY go through the ENTIRE thread and count our posts one by one O.o

u mad, bro

i agree that Hybrid and Amadine have been barely skating by, but that is not highly unusual for them to have low post counts in my experience. It is a bit of a null tell, really.

right now i am tossing up between Hybrid, Amadine and Leyrann....

i shall go with Leyrann, i think. vote Leyrann

Hahaha - god no! You don't know me very well, yet. I would not spend that kind of time counting posts. You can click on the # of replies and it pops up and tells you. hehe

Also, it isn't really a null tell with Hybrid. I've been playing mafia with him for at least 3 years -- he is a logical player that ramps up as the game goes on. I won't use the fact that it is Hybrid with the low post count to meta him, but I will say that a player with this low of a post total can be dangerous (we just don't have info on them). Same goes for Amadine, even though I understand she's always been low key like that. For low count players, it is really difficult to not meta with them, which is bad (as I've mentioned).....but we just don't have a lot else to go on.

Honestly, I'm holding back a vote right now in the hopes that perhaps Hybrid & Amadine have more input to share.

Niniel · October 15, 2011

I´m also waiting to hear more from Ama and Hybrid.

Leyrann · October 15, 2011

I think that would be best.

We just have to know who thinks who is scummy, then some rational thinking.

If we play this well, I think we can end the game this Day.

bgrishinko · October 15, 2011

I still think we are looking for someone more active than Hybrid or Ama.

Hybrid · October 15, 2011

Hey guys,

I'm sorry for my recent bout of inactivity. I caught a cold at a really bad time, right before I had a couple big school assignments due, so I haven't had the time or energy to really check in. I'm going to try to catch up today.

Hybrid · October 16, 2011

I don't have any overwhelming observations to make, but:

I still dislike Blackhoof's "jumping the gun" post, though maybe I'm just slow this game. Did anyone else quickly jump to the conclusion that a mafioso had died after reading the first mod post?

I'm wary of the late hammers (Blackhoof, Amadine).

And the Blackhoof/amegakure discussion at the start of Day 4 (?) feels contrived.

Vote Blackhoof

Also, if there's a serial killer, I think I'm tentatively leaning Verbal, but it's really just a gut feeling.

Blackhoof · October 16, 2011

We did not know that Ishy was Dave. Dave could as easily be Wombat, who was killed by the Bomb (Ishy).

But you know, I don't see anyone really playing scummy.

(yeah, of course that could also mean that Verb is scum, and just didn't make a mistake, but I don't want to vote the best player of the game just because no one is looking scummy)

you do know that makes absolutely no sense, right?

Dave was a bomb.

ishy was dave.

therefore, dave =/= wombat.

secondly, we did not know that wombat had died at that point, only that we had just lynched ishy, and in the next post Dave had clearly died. wombat COULD have been Dave, but if he was, why would he have died from lynching an innocent, non-bomb ishy?

ur grabbing at straws, leyrann

I don't have any overwhelming observations to make, but:

I still dislike Blackhoof's "jumping the gun" post, though maybe I'm just slow this game. Did anyone else quickly jump to the conclusion that a mafioso had died after reading the first mod post?

I'm wary of the late hammers (Blackhoof, Amadine).

And the Blackhoof/amegakure discussion at the start of Day 4 (?) feels contrived.

Vote Blackhoof

Also, if there's a serial killer, I think I'm tentatively leaning Verbal, but it's really just a gut feeling.

once more, it is not jumping the gun when you are practically told something.

i find your lack of faith... disturbing.

i highlky doubt therer is a serial killer OR second vig. we have NEVER had more than 1 kill per night, sometimes less.

Leyrann · October 16, 2011

We did not know that Ishy was Dave. Dave could as easily be Wombat, who was killed by the Bomb (Ishy).

But you know, I don't see anyone really playing scummy.

(yeah, of course that could also mean that Verb is scum, and just didn't make a mistake, but I don't want to vote the best player of the game just because no one is looking scummy)

you do know that makes absolutely no sense, right?

Dave was a bomb.

ishy was dave.

therefore, dave =/= wombat.

secondly, we did not know that wombat had died at that point, only that we had just lynched ishy, and in the next post Dave had clearly died. wombat COULD have been Dave, but if he was, why would he have died from lynching an innocent, non-bomb ishy?

ur grabbing at straws, leyrann

No, that's not what I said. You acted if you were sure that Ishy was Dave, when we didn't knew he was. But of course, it was not likely someone else was Dave, and that there were two deaths. Did I still have my vote on you? In that case, UNVOTE. I'm going to reread that discussion between you and Amega Hybrid talked about, then I'll put my vote on one of you again. Because, if I feel the same about it as Hybrid, I'll vote you again, if I think that it is not, he will have my vote.

Leyrann · October 16, 2011

And the Blackhoof/amegakure discussion at the start of Day 4 (?) feels contrived.

I don't see a discussion anywhere. Not long, not short. VOTE Hybrid.

Hybrid · October 16, 2011

At work..a bit suspect of ed right now..hoof also..so when I get bak ill try to dig up some stuff. Id like to see some stuff from hybrid. He isn't making bad vibes but who knows.

Well, the way i see it we have two choices- lynch amega again to see if his lynchproofyness is limited or lynch Ed as a lying liar who lies.

however, ed MAY be an insane finder, in which case they are BOTH likely town.

so, either a potentially lynchproof townie or our last claimed finder?

VOTE Amega

sorry...

Well Idk wat ed is. A liar or a insane cop either way he's wrong. Another thing is he sorta cased on sakeae. Also said he knew her role. Then said he thinks he knows. Also how did he go through and not view anyone else?. Fake claim or he knows he's insane?

Also hoof casing sakeae the other day. And im sure he threw out an Fos.

really?

very well, you raise some good points. i will switch my vote accordingly.

vote Ed

Not disengage lol dosent* Bloody phone does its own things these days!

i know what you mean :P

Blackhoof · October 16, 2011

No, that's not what I said. You acted if you were sure that Ishy was Dave, when we didn't knew he was. But of course, it was not likely someone else was Dave, and that there were two deaths. Did I still have my vote on you? In that case, UNVOTE. I'm going to reread that discussion between you and Amega Hybrid talked about, then I'll put my vote on one of you again. Because, if I feel the same about it as Hybrid, I'll vote you again, if I think that it is not, he will have my vote.

At the time i did not know that there were two deaths- only one, ishy. i am positive that other people saw the mods first posat and thought "yay we got scum!" but i was the only one who posted in time to ninja the mod.

And the Blackhoof/amegakure discussion at the start of Day 4 (?) feels contrived.

I don't see a discussion anywhere. Not long, not short. VOTE Hybrid.

i think he is referring to the time i ACTUALLY jumped the gun and decided that amega was innocent since he was apparently Lynchproof. i was wrong about that i admit, but it was a logical assumption to make at the time.

Hybrid · October 16, 2011

And the Blackhoof/amegakure discussion at the start of Day 4 (?) feels contrived.

I don't see a discussion anywhere. Not long, not short. VOTE Hybrid.

If you're going to accuse someone of lying, you should at least check to . . . you know . . . see if they're lying.

Niniel · October 16, 2011

I agree with you, Hybrid. But Blackhoof was the one in the lead on Ishys lynch. Hmmm... Blackhoof always do weired things in every game. I would like to hear from all of you again but right now I will keep my vote on Verbal. I could also vote Blackhoof or Ama. BG, do you have any more information for us?

Leyrann · October 16, 2011

And the Blackhoof/amegakure discussion at the start of Day 4 (?) feels contrived.

I don't see a discussion anywhere. Not long, not short. VOTE Hybrid.

If you're going to accuse someone of lying, you should at least check to . . . you know . . . see if they're lying.

I DID look. But I just wouldn't have called it a discussion myself. UNVOTE, because you also have defended yourself properly, in my opinion.

Verbal32 · October 16, 2011

That's a decent handful of vote flopping, Ley. I was neutral on you, but this is starting to feel like you're looking for a lynch that sticks....

I don't have any overwhelming observations to make, but:

I still dislike Blackhoof's "jumping the gun" post, though maybe I'm just slow this game. Did anyone else quickly jump to the conclusion that a mafioso had died after reading the first mod post?

I'm wary of the late hammers (Blackhoof, Amadine).

And the Blackhoof/amegakure discussion at the start of Day 4 (?) feels contrived.

Vote Blackhoof

Also, if there's a serial killer, I think I'm tentatively leaning Verbal, but it's really just a gut feeling.

I agree with you up until the SK thing....there has been no evidence of that - why bring it up now?

Leyrann · October 16, 2011

That's a decent handful of vote flopping, Ley. I was neutral on you, but this is starting to feel like you're looking for a lynch that sticks....

You know, it is a bit weird for mafia to unvote the person with the most votes. I hate not having a vote on someone, so I had my vote on the person who was most scummy at that point. But I really don't see anything scummy now.

The Ape's --- OUTBREAK MAFIA: GAME OVER!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook