[Advanced/Experimental] Game of Thrones Mafia

[JF80]

  On 8/24/2011 at 2:41 AM, Sharrow said:

 

Cause trying to lynch Slats over the past two days, and listing him as one of my top 2 cult suspects last night was scummy.

 

 

Its an easy bus if you're the deputy cult leader, or whatever you want to call it. I was right about slats being the CL. I'm going to parlay that into my guess that you were his second in command, and Verbal is a convert. Or at the least its a good a guess as any that ONE of you two is cult.

[Kivam]

It's been a bloody night. Sorry for the lack of scene, but I wanted to get this night in so you could play tomorrow:

 

 

Janos Slynt (Sharrow), Survivor turned Stark Bannerman, is dead.

 

 

Robb Stark, (Bleedin Green) Backup Paymaster, is dead

 

And one very shaken player is still alive

 

With 16 players alive, it takes 9 to lynch

[Sharrow]

Sorry, posted before I knew I was dead. Damn i wish I would have beaten that scene. Not very happy right now. I just wasted a bunch of time on a huge post there. Second time this game I wasted hours of my time for no damn reason.

[Sharrow]

Btw, everyone that was a complete idiot and thought I was cult can refer to rule 14. Good luck Starks.

[CTM]

still not feeling good about verb, barm and the dude

 

the chicks who all seem to think I'm cult aren't really pinging much...

 

vote the dude

[WWWwombat]

Vote: Verbal

 

Don't like how he was pretty much begging to be converted.

[Bleedin Green]

14

[Vicious89x]

  On 8/24/2011 at 4:34 AM, Bleedin Green said:

14

 

tl;dr

[Vicious89x]

I don't get the vote on the dude. Feel like his reasoning on the mass reveal was sound. I feel like the best spot to start flipping rocks are the uber inactives.

 

On iPhone, please count

 

Vote- J80

 

Feel for someone who has played I AINT CARE SON has been absent and completely different.

[WWWwombat]

Idk, 80 has picked it up lately and hasn't done anything overly scummy to my eyes. He has been a bit different but then again, this is a PG-13 site. I'd say he might still be within his "range" considering.

[John McClane]

Waiting on smash results

[Smash]

Since no one really weighed in on who I should track I decided to track Verbal and he did not visit anyone.

[Kivam]

Vote Count

 

Dude (1) - CTM

Verbal (1) - Wombat

JF80 (1) - Vic

[Barmacral]

The Dude did not manage to explain off his slip very well.

 

Vote: The Dude

[CTM]

i could also go vic... forgot to mention...

[JF80]

VOTE VERBAL

 

 

Don't like that he called for a mass reveal last day phase, especially since there are some non-starks still out there with killing ability. Unless of course one of those kills/failed kill attempt last night was from a rogue survivor.

[John McClane]

Smash, why would you have tracked verbal? It obvious if he is anything, it is a convert or survivor... Again you show no sign of looking for a potential converter, in this case original cult and backup. Puzzled by this choice.

 

Again we have shots fired at Starks, but the stark watcher alive? Again a moot result. Logically would cult leave smash alive for the wifom? Or would they just convert him and use him to mislead us?

 

Vic, dude, verb, or smash... Okay with a vote on any of them. Sakea too.

 

For now Vote Verb

[John McClane]

  On 8/24/2011 at 11:37 AM, CTM said:

i could also go vic... forgot to mention...

 

Do you see what I'm talking about with Smash?

[CTM]

  On 8/24/2011 at 12:19 PM, John McClane said:

  On 8/24/2011 at 11:37 AM, CTM said:

i could also go vic... forgot to mention...

 

Do you see what I'm talking about with Smash?

Yeah, but I'm not convinced cult is killing.. It's possible it's an un declared survivor..

 

 

The a cult leader thing bothers me... makes me want to keep looking for shady since the get go players, rather then start killing potential converts... Smash is def in the latter group

[DPR]

Correct me if I'm wrong, but so far this game, Smash is the only person who has claimed a role and continues to provide results with it?

 

Does that not strike anybody else as strange?

[Smash]

  On 8/24/2011 at 12:16 PM, John McClane said:

Smash, why would you have tracked verbal? It obvious if he is anything, it is a convert or survivor... Again you show no sign of looking for a potential converter, in this case original cult and backup. Puzzled by this choice.

 

Again we have shots fired at Starks, but the stark watcher alive? Again a moot result. Logically would cult leave smash alive for the wifom? Or would they just convert him and use him to mislead us?

 

Vic, dude, verb, or smash... Okay with a vote on any of them. Sakea too.

 

For now Vote Verb

 

I asked 2 times for suggestions on possible Tracks not one person answered. If your so concerned about who I track why not at least suggest something ?

[John McClane]

  On 8/24/2011 at 12:55 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

Correct me if I'm wrong, but so far this game, Smash is the only person who has claimed a role and continues to provide results with it?

 

Does that not strike anybody else as strange?

 

Already pointed this out - that said, IF there is a Lannister bannerman with similar watcher/tracker abilities to balance Smash out on their team - I doubt that person is going to say anything to vouch for him.

[John McClane]

  On 8/24/2011 at 1:08 PM, Smash said:

  On 8/24/2011 at 12:16 PM, John McClane said:

Smash, why would you have tracked verbal? It obvious if he is anything, it is a convert or survivor... Again you show no sign of looking for a potential converter, in this case original cult and backup. Puzzled by this choice.

 

Again we have shots fired at Starks, but the stark watcher alive? Again a moot result. Logically would cult leave smash alive for the wifom? Or would they just convert him and use him to mislead us?

 

Vic, dude, verb, or smash... Okay with a vote on any of them. Sakea too.

 

For now Vote Verb

 

I asked 2 times for suggestions on possible Tracks not one person answered. If your so concerned about who I track why not at least suggest something ?

 

Why suggest you track someone, when I don't believe you?

[John McClane]

  On 8/24/2011 at 12:34 PM, CTM said:

  On 8/24/2011 at 12:19 PM, John McClane said:

  On 8/24/2011 at 11:37 AM, CTM said:

i could also go vic... forgot to mention...

 

Do you see what I'm talking about with Smash?

Yeah, but I'm not convinced cult is killing.. It's possible it's an un declared survivor..

 

 

The a cult leader thing bothers me... makes me want to keep looking for shady since the get go players, rather then start killing potential converts... Smash is def in the latter group

 

I agree that Smash comes across as a converted player, same point I made to him about Verbal. Worst case for Verbal was he is a converted - so tracking him was a waste, it looks more like Smash trying to steer us off of Verb's trail than it does a sensible target for a tracker trying to find a potential backup cult converter.

 

Normally, I would say it DOES make sense to start lynching those we think could be converted in the off chance that there is not a second converter. However, I believe 100% that Slats converted at least 1 JN player - and JN players would have cried to have Slats replaced way before he was lynched IF Slats was the only converted. The fact that the CL went out quietly, makes me pretty damn confident that there is a 2nd converter out there.

[DPR]

  On 8/24/2011 at 1:36 PM, John McClane said:

  On 8/24/2011 at 12:55 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

Correct me if I'm wrong, but so far this game, Smash is the only person who has claimed a role and continues to provide results with it?

 

Does that not strike anybody else as strange?

 

Already pointed this out - that said, IF there is a Lannister bannerman with similar watcher/tracker abilities to balance Smash out on their team - I doubt that person is going to say anything to vouch for him.

 

So, out of 4 speculated Bannermen, and 4 days/nights worth of play, we think that only has a role and continuously gives results that don't really matter?