[Advanced/Experimental] Game of Thrones Mafia

[Hybrid]

So do we want to just work towards eliminating lannisters or cult hunt?

 

Let's leave the Lannisters for the night. Cult's got three members now, unless there's something funky with the mechanics, so we can start cult hunting during the day.

[BooBoo]

And with that Booboo is obviously getting desperate. Unvote, Vote: Booboo

 

No, not desperate. Just a rookie mistake, I'm trying to correct. I was trying to catch someone and didnt realize I was actually putting myself in danger. I was hoping to see if anyone followed and then about 10 minutes later I realized what I did and its why I switched. No biggie - you'll see once I'm lynched. I do understand though, makes sense why you guys are coming here, I just screwed up.

[Hybrid]

Unvote, vote BooBoo

 

Like I said, he did more deflecting away from the Mynd lynch than slats.

[John McClane]

Strong feeling Mynd or Slats are Cult or CL .

 

I would just like to pop in and point out how Smash quickly OMGUS voted me for voting him, in a time where it would have served his best interest to lynch Red. Methinks that I struck a nerve or something. You know what they say about those who point the cult finger? They are the cult leader.

 

My vote for the betterment of.....the land of course......and the people.......is to once again, vote Smash!

 

See, now this is a terrible play for you... with Smash out in the open as a tracker/watcher, the person that wants his dead most is likely the CL. Unless I'm confused about how this game works, Smash revealed as a character name, and if he was lying he'd have been called out on it. So... basically, you are voting for a somewhat confirmed Stark here.

[WWWwombat]

So do we want to just work towards eliminating lannisters or cult hunt?

 

Let's leave the Lannisters for the night. Cult's got three members now, unless there's something funky with the mechanics, so we can start cult hunting during the day.

 

Cult could have 4 imo. I think they started with 1 but I could also see 2. I agree on cult hunting though. We have given them enough time.

[John McClane]

I kind of agree on the Mynd train. If Smash followed him and he didn't do anything, wouldn't that preclude him from being the cult leader?

 

 

Smash followed Mynd and he didn't do anything, but Smash's conclusion was that Mynd is not a survivor, and perhaps CL.

 

I doubt that. Smash cited that "maybe Cult converts during the day", however if you remember I told you all that I asked Doggin when cult converts and he told me flat out at NIGHT.

 

Survivors may or may not be active at night, but stealing happens in day phase, so its feasible that Mynd could be survivor. I don't like Mynd's play and am glad to see him getting pressure, BUT Smash's conclusions about Mynd not visiting anyone are vastly inconclusive - and its actually a flimsy case.

 

My case on Mynd first and foremost was due to his timing and his vote on me which at this point in time makes no damn sense to anyone but him . I put out the info on my track and said my peace but that was not the main reason for my suspicions. I put that info out there for us all to discuss weather my conclusions were right or wrong. Also I made it pretty clear that I was now aware of the cult conversions at night after Sharrow pointed it out, we didnt need you to revisit because you talked about it on day 1.

 

 

I got that - and to the bolded, all I was doing was discussing it and pointing out where its an inconclusive case. Not trying to case you based on it, just giving input.

[John McClane]

also, tubbyfluffybutt has all but dissappeared, he does this as an evil

 

I'm assuming any references to larger than normal human beings = Crusher?

 

He's definitely Lannister, though. He made the same slip up as Lanth, which Alys caught.

yep... remember now..

 

So do we want to just work towards eliminating lannisters or cult hunt?

 

Pretty much the same thing - in BooBoo's case, he's clearly a lannister or cult. I pointed out best/worst case above. Lynch him, and its a win/win.

[BooBoo]

Looks like this is inevitable. I'm Samwell Tarly, a survivor.

 

Honest rookie mistake, trying to trap cult or lannister.

[The Crusher]

Wow, Someone needs to teach BooBoo how to pay attention. The Starks own the game right now. If you aren;t Stark your scum. The Lannisters are no different than the cult, except a hell of alot less dangerous. Basically jesters at this point. LOL

 

 

I want to vote for cult so Im voting for J80. Try to get one before they get another chance to recruit tonight.

[Adella]

Also, did anyone else notice that on N1 we have 3 kill attempts, but last night there were 4? I know it's possible that someone could have just gotten bribed a lot, but they shouldn't have been able to use an item last night IIRC...

[Smash]

Bleedin Green is a Stark.

 

Slats is cult.

 

I'd be willing to lynch either of those today and I'm curious why we are allowing BG to slide by when he's guilty of the same thing everyone nailed Red on.

 

This Mynd train, seems pointless.

 

 

You'd be willing to lynch a Stark right now? Guess that means you aren't a survivor... so that makes you cult or Lannister, and Lannister's are useless to us.

 

Vote BooBoo

 

This should be a no-brainer.

 

You really crack me up. You bitch out my case on Mynd who actully came in the thread, made no sense, then voted me a known Stark, but you make NO MENTION of that in defending him. But you easily vote booboo because he mentioned BG another known stark ?? really ?? Tell me who's not makes sense here ? booboo may very well be a good target but you seem to be another possible recruit IMHO not CL but very possible recruit.

[Smash]

Also, did anyone else notice that on N1 we have 3 kill attempts, but last night there were 4? I know it's possible that someone could have just gotten bribed a lot, but they shouldn't have been able to use an item last night IIRC...

 

I noticed this right away but didnt say anything

[Smash]

Wow, Someone needs to teach BooBoo how to pay attention. The Starks own the game right now. If you aren;t Stark your scum. The Lannisters are no different than the cult, except a hell of alot less dangerous. Basically jesters at this point. LOL

 

 

I want to vote for cult so Im voting for J80. Try to get one before they get another chance to recruit tonight.

 

The lannisters are still very dangerous all they lack is numbers it appears they can still attempt NK's and Pass out gold if they have any left

[Adella]

Also, did anyone else notice that on N1 we have 3 kill attempts, but last night there were 4? I know it's possible that someone could have just gotten bribed a lot, but they shouldn't have been able to use an item last night IIRC...

 

I noticed this right away but didnt say anything

Lol, which means I'm gonna get a ton of flack for being the one to point it out...

[Smash]

Looks like this is inevitable. I'm Samwell Tarly, a survivor.

 

Honest rookie mistake, trying to trap cult or lannister.

 

Booboo revealing as a survivor means nothing since no one can vett you. Do you have a role ? That might help

[Smash]

Also, did anyone else notice that on N1 we have 3 kill attempts, but last night there were 4? I know it's possible that someone could have just gotten bribed a lot, but they shouldn't have been able to use an item last night IIRC...

 

I noticed this right away but didnt say anything

Lol, which means I'm gonna get a ton of flack for being the one to point it out...

 

Nah it is what it is I dont see why pointing it out should bring any negative attention your way.

[Vicious89x]

As far as the case people are making on Vic, I know this isn't going to mean a lot because I know he's tried to play things off like this in the past as scum, but for whatever its worth this strikes me as different. I think the fact that he was even late to check-in on the game and things like that makes me a little more inclined to believe him, but who knows. Or maybe I'm just a bit sympathetic to his current work situation given my past circumstances , but I'd probably be more apt to wait and address him later. Between the size of this game and the amount of NKs that could be used to take him out, I don't see a big rush unless people think he's the CL, and I'm certainly not leaning that way right now. If people think he is, then I certainly get wanting to go there first and foremost. But for me, I don't see much to work with there other than relatively low posts counts and meta-ness, so I'm in no rush to go that way.

 

 

 

P.S. Sorry Vic, but Charlotte from Lost was 1000000x more hate-worthy character than Claire ever was. I've never cheered so much for a characters death.

 

You just hate Gingers. Racist.

 

CHA-LEE MAH BAY-BEE!!!!! Die. Die. Die. Die. Die. Die. Die. Die.

 

@ slats. The imp is the only decent Lannister and it's only because he's practically an outsider. The rest are in-breeding rednecks with boat loads of cash. I dislike any violence towards women but god do I want to choke out Cersei, hate her with the fire of 1000 suns. Although I don't think anyone can deny this was the best moment of the show and could watch this on continuous loop forever.

 

 

 

Glad to see Vic posting.... too bad he's posting fluff about Lost and the characters he likes and dislikes. I don't know the source material at all... "liking" characters will have NO bearing on Vic's play, he's too competitive to let the actual source material skew his competitive nature.

 

I hope nobody is buying this fanboy crap.

 

The Starks are kinda winning right now. Your argument is invalid.

[Adella]

What in the world do you guys do for a living to make it so you can just get online and play mafia alllll day?!

[John McClane]

Strong feeling Mynd or Slats are Cult or CL .

 

I would just like to pop in and point out how Smash quickly OMGUS voted me for voting him, in a time where it would have served his best interest to lynch Red. Methinks that I struck a nerve or something. You know what they say about those who point the cult finger? They are the cult leader.

 

My vote for the betterment of.....the land of course......and the people.......is to once again, vote Smash!

 

See, now this is a terrible play for you... with Smash out in the open as a tracker/watcher, the person that wants his dead most is likely the CL. Unless I'm confused about how this game works, Smash revealed as a character name, and if he was lying he'd have been called out on it. So... basically, you are voting for a somewhat confirmed Stark here.

 

 

Bleedin Green is a Stark.

 

Slats is cult.

 

I'd be willing to lynch either of those today and I'm curious why we are allowing BG to slide by when he's guilty of the same thing everyone nailed Red on.

 

This Mynd train, seems pointless.

 

 

You'd be willing to lynch a Stark right now? Guess that means you aren't a survivor... so that makes you cult or Lannister, and Lannister's are useless to us.

 

Vote BooBoo

 

This should be a no-brainer.

 

You really crack me up. You bitch out my case on Mynd who actully came in the thread, made no sense, then voted me a known Stark, but you make NO MENTION of that in defending him. But you easily vote booboo because he mentioned BG another known stark ?? really ?? Tell me who's not makes sense here ? booboo may very well be a good target but you seem to be another possible recruit IMHO not CL but very possible recruit.

 

See the post above, as soon as I came across his post, I reacted to it... usually how it works when you read IN ORDER, dumbass. Unfortunately, I can only vote 1 person at a time, and right now I like my vote on BooBoo. Mynd and BooBoo are perfect competing trains for today... and I've said throughout my posts about your case on Mynd that I like the train on him, but don't like your "I tracked him" case. I think he's a perfect candidate for lynching, based on your other observations, so chill the eff out... I just don't want a dumb person leading us around with an "open/shut" case that has huge holes in it. So, I'm not defending Mynd, just making sure you don't pied piper us with a case full of doots.

[Vicious89x]

I assume that Bleeding, DPR, and Wombat will be taken care of by Stark night kills if they aren't Starks. So they aren't really high on my list.

 

Huh? Bleedin is a stark...it should be obvious. Very confused why nobody is seeing that based on his interaction with Red.

 

However, going for cult now makes more sense now that I think about it.

 

Unvote Bleedin

Vote Slats

 

So why is the Mynd thing pointless if Smash tracked him? Did I miss something on that?

 

 

I explained it above, but its like this... a survivor doesn't necessarily move at night, and I've asked Doggin when conversions happen and its at night. If Mynd didn't move he probably isn't the cult leader - could still in theory be a survivor. Smash's watch doesn't give us anything conclusive. Love the idea of pressuring Mynd as one of two trains, but I'm not going to pile behind Smash's case when its far from open/shut.

 

Makes sense. I generally struggle with understanding watcher/tracker roles and all that jazz. No idea why but I can't wrap my head around it.

 

Gonna follow the lead on it here as BooBoo seems to have made a BooBoo (SEE WHAT I DID THERE?!!!!111!!)

 

 

Unvote

Vote: Boo Boo

[Vicious89x]

What in the world do you guys do for a living to make it so you can just get online and play mafia alllll day?!

 

Columbia Sportswear in PDX. Friday is a light day for me since everyone leaves at like 1:30.

[Alys Kinch]

This brings to mind the Double Blind, where half the game was actually just figuring out how the game worked

More love for Kivam.

 

Of course, there was the epic fail of McCarthy...

 

I have no idea what you are referring to . . .

 

(ran it on jn and it flopped just as bad)

 

My very first bastard mid game, back before is ever heard the term. Good times

Maybe you should have changed the name. I think that was exactly what gave it away to Verbal(?) when we played.

 

Yeah, Vic is notorious for posting what he thinks he should say next in the scum QT's... and just as notorious for rabidly posting 101 suggestions for what his mates should say. I'm telling you guys, my read on Vic is usually pretty reliable... he is not on the level.

This is true. One of my favorite mafia moments would be Vic, as mafia, having this whole long post full of his defense story with the very beginning of the post starting with: "Can you guys read this and let me know what you think..." (or something like that) followed by lots of paragraphs of his story, as he had just copied and pasted it straight from the QT and forgot to take that out. And nobody alive freakin' noticed. I remember those of us in the dead thread laughing our asses off about it.

That’s just hilarious.

 

Lanth (Tyrion Lannister), Backup Paymaster, has had his life cut short

 

[/b]And as with last night, more of you - two - seem more worried than they had been before.

 

Day 3 Has Begun: with 22 players alive, it takes 12 votes to lynch

I like to know that I saw stuff as it happened. Love dead LLL’s.

 

Also, using this quote for later. Some of you noted the 2 attempts that didn’t work and forgot about them later. It’s been less than 24 hours, guys. C’mon!

 

I am VERY happy my parents are here. I just am choosing to spend my evenings with them rather than on my phone. I am very prickly due to work. Just miserable to be honest, I'm sure tons of people are like me but I'm 29, in a job I greatly dislike and feel trapped by needing to pay bills for my family. Plus I'm the token whipping boy for my boss who is a spaz. I shouldn't be posting this but whatever, I have reached a point that it's impacting me and my home life. Blah. Ok that's the last I'll say about it.

I think I got the quote tags right. The game isn’t the best place for this, but just wanted to say that if that’s true, you gotta do something before the situation implodes on you. (So just went through similar leading into my soon to be ex-husband’s midlife crisis…)

 

 

I love you and respect you, making you the polar opposite of my ex-wife.

 

The only Lannister I liked was the Imp, I'm glad the Starks are kicking ass.

 

You directed off of Mynd yesterday and your doing it again today. I suspected you as cult unless I missed something along the way

 

I did not direct off of Mynd yesterday or today. Mynd has three posts in the game. If he doesn't show up to defend, or shows up and defends poorly, I'll have no prioblem voting him off. Seemed more practical and, perhaps, discussion creating to vote someone who's at least a little active.

I don’t think a Mynd lynch will help us in general. If he’s cult, that’s awesome, but it leaves us with nothing much to track. He’s not done much- admittedly more today, but still not much. Info tends to win the day with me since there is no use in lynching ourselves into a corner. So, if you want to pursue this, who is he linked to? WHat other (read: real) info is there to go on?

 

Bleedin Green is a Stark.

 

Slats is cult.

 

I'd be willing to lynch either of those today and I'm curious why we are allowing BG to slide by when he's guilty of the same thing everyone nailed Red on.

 

This Mynd train, seems pointless.

 

Do you have an outside source for this information, or are you just drawing your own conclusions from previous posts?

This. BG is Stark; Slats is for sure cult, but Imma go with BG. Didn’t Red do similar yesterday? Didn’t that make it harder for her to win friends and influence people (even with her cash)?

 

Slats is far an away playing the most cult like game. Not really a close 2nd in fact.

Based on?

 

I assume that Bleeding, DPR, and Wombat will be taken care of by Stark night kills if they aren't Starks. So they aren't really high on my list.

 

Huh? Bleedin is a stark...it should be obvious. Very confused why nobody is seeing that based on his interaction with Red.

 

However, going for cult now makes more sense now that I think about it.

 

Unvote Bleedin

Vote Slats

Flip flop. That’s fun. Especially when you’ve not defended where you are flipping to. Now, I don’t know about Slats. I’m totally pinging on your lack of case though.

 

I agree with that last statement but I cant get past him showing up minutes after Kiv was going to replace him. Im cool with more than one player getting pushed a bit. But in the case of directing that was my impression both days since you came right in with another case immeidately after my case on Mynd. We've at least heard from Vic and I doubt he would go down the same road he chose a few games ago since I was one of the players going aganist him pretty hard at the end.

 

How does this make him cult? Or anything. The option to do something not being taken by an absentee player says what??

 

 

Starks are in the lead right now. Why would anyone but cult or Lannister aligned players want to kill them?

 

I realized that...thats why I switched pretty quickly. Im still getting a hold of this thing, but I think I'm showing I'm down the right path. BG is Stark, but you're right...there's a reason beside being a Lannister that I'd want either or dead...but not right now. Cult makes more sense and Slats is cult.

No, I don’t buy this first part.

 

And the second makes me grin. Yes, there is a reason you’d want him dead besides being a Lannister… Maybe more than one, but for sure one I’m interested in pursuing. And that's not a survivalist case.

 

You know what they say about those who point the cult finger? They are the cult leader.

 

It's interesting that when your wagon is growing, BooBoo pops up to finger slats as cult. Then you come out of nowhere with a vote that makes no sense -- Red was probably telling the truth that House members know their bannerman's characters, so Smash being alive today suggests that he is, in fact, a Stark.

 

Maybe. Remember that quote above from the scene? There were 2 misses.

 

BooBoo is a dodo or one of the 4 remaining lannisters... why would anyone want to lynch a stark at this point...

*cough* So misread that at first.

 

Notice how quickly Smash has unvoted me? Pretty erratic play this whole game by the man, who nearly got lynched last time, and so easily removes his vote when I question him. Only later as an afterthought does he call OMGUS back on me. His mind is elsewhere. He has an agenda. If there was a Cult Leader in this game, the behavior of Smash has been the most telling.

 

Mynd the only person here not really paying close attention to this game is you. My play is far from erratic since both you and Slats were on my radar. You really should pay better attention before trying to make a case with absolutely nothing to back it up. Im already confirmed Starks its been pointed out that it makes entirely no sense to lynch me unless your remaining Lannister or cult so what excatly are you trying to do here ? Please explain

Um, yes, it has been erratic. How many times did you vote and unvote yesterday???

 

I kind of agree on the Mynd train. If Smash followed him and he didn't do anything, wouldn't that preclude him from being the cult leader?

 

 

Smash followed Mynd and he didn't do anything, but Smash's conclusion was that Mynd is not a survivor, and perhaps CL.

 

I doubt that. Smash cited that "maybe Cult converts during the day", however if you remember I told you all that I asked Doggin when cult converts and he told me flat out at NIGHT.

 

Survivors may or may not be active at night, but stealing happens in day phase, so its feasible that Mynd could be survivor. I don't like Mynd's play and am glad to see him getting pressure, BUT Smash's conclusions about Mynd not visiting anyone are vastly inconclusive - and its actually a flimsy case.

I don’t think he’s a survivor, but I think I should leave the rest alone. It’s not currently relevant to me.

[John McClane]

As far as the case people are making on Vic, I know this isn't going to mean a lot because I know he's tried to play things off like this in the past as scum, but for whatever its worth this strikes me as different. I think the fact that he was even late to check-in on the game and things like that makes me a little more inclined to believe him, but who knows. Or maybe I'm just a bit sympathetic to his current work situation given my past circumstances , but I'd probably be more apt to wait and address him later. Between the size of this game and the amount of NKs that could be used to take him out, I don't see a big rush unless people think he's the CL, and I'm certainly not leaning that way right now. If people think he is, then I certainly get wanting to go there first and foremost. But for me, I don't see much to work with there other than relatively low posts counts and meta-ness, so I'm in no rush to go that way.

 

 

 

P.S. Sorry Vic, but Charlotte from Lost was 1000000x more hate-worthy character than Claire ever was. I've never cheered so much for a characters death.

 

You just hate Gingers. Racist.

 

CHA-LEE MAH BAY-BEE!!!!! Die. Die. Die. Die. Die. Die. Die. Die.

 

@ slats. The imp is the only decent Lannister and it's only because he's practically an outsider. The rest are in-breeding rednecks with boat loads of cash. I dislike any violence towards women but god do I want to choke out Cersei, hate her with the fire of 1000 suns. Although I don't think anyone can deny this was the best moment of the show and could watch this on continuous loop forever.

 

 

 

Glad to see Vic posting.... too bad he's posting fluff about Lost and the characters he likes and dislikes. I don't know the source material at all... "liking" characters will have NO bearing on Vic's play, he's too competitive to let the actual source material skew his competitive nature.

 

I hope nobody is buying this fanboy crap.

 

The Starks are kinda winning right now. Your argument is invalid.

 

 

Not reading much are you? Thanks for explaining that about the Starks - I didn't have any idea, even when I mentioned it multiple times while voting/addressing Booboo.

 

What argument btw? I simply stated that you making fanboy comments about who you do and don't like, relative to things you might do in the game, is pure crap - I know how competitive you and your small man complex are. Knowing hte material is irrelevant to you... you are blowing smoke.

[Adella]

What in the world do you guys do for a living to make it so you can just get online and play mafia alllll day?!

 

Columbia Sportswear in PDX. Friday is a light day for me since everyone leaves at like 1:30.

I forgot about that! When I played my one game on JN you offered to let me come shop at the company store for super cheap (woot for being a chick) cause I live in PDX too. Sweet beans, I totally forgot about that. Nice to have at least met someone who lives in the same city, even if you're not really on DM for anything to do with DM...

[WWWwombat]

Unofficial Vote Count

 

Mynd (2) - Bleedin, Sakaea

Slats (6) - JF80, BooBoo, DPR, Sharrow, Smash, CTM

Smash (1) - Mynd

BooBoo (7) - John McClane, Alys, Adella, slats, Barm, Hybrid, Vic

JF80 (1) - Crusher

 

12 to lynch