[Basic] Mafia with Quibby- GAME OVER

[csarmi]

You must be enjoying this.

[Quibby]

Yup.

[bhskeeper11]

Quibby indeed.

 

vote Kate

 

Kate, care to explain why did you visit Tiinker tonight?

 

Track List:

 

Day 1: Red - Red

Day 2: Christine - BG

Day 3: Kate - Tiinker

 

I don't think Christine is lying. That makes me think Leelou really is healer too.

I was against the healer lynch day 2 because I couldn't tell if Red was healer or not and leelou's CC seemed fishy to me - in a good way: I just couldn't imagine him doing this so soon as maffia.

 

I had no read on amegakure.

 

I think we must be on Lylo btw. With so many power roles I just don't see how it could be less than 4 maffia players to start with. We lynched only one.

 

Come again? I don't understand this "track list" you have.

[John E. Kelley]

Quibby indeed.

 

vote Kate

 

Kate, care to explain why did you visit Tiinker tonight?

 

Track List:

 

Day 1: Red - Red

Day 2: Christine - BG

Day 3: Kate - Tiinker

 

I don't think Christine is lying. That makes me think Leelou really is healer too.

I was against the healer lynch day 2 because I couldn't tell if Red was healer or not and leelou's CC seemed fishy to me - in a good way: I just couldn't imagine him doing this so soon as maffia.

 

I had no read on amegakure.

 

I think we must be on Lylo btw. With so many power roles I just don't see how it could be less than 4 maffia players to start with. We lynched only one.

 

Come again? I don't understand this "track list" you have.

Are you claiming tracker Cs? If so, that'd be neat, first game I've been in that has had that role in it.

[bhskeeper11]

Ah, thanks Ishy.

 

You are claiming tracker, eh? That would be interesting to see in a game, but you are not telling the truth. First, I did not visit Tinker in the night phase. Second, you list that Red visited Red, seeming to imply that Red made Red immune to NK. Sorry, but if you recall (which, I guess you didn't), Red fake-claimed Healer. She was mafia, with no role/action according to the coroner's report.

 

Care to explain why you are trying to claim tracker?

[csarmi]

Yes I do claim tracker.

 

I'll spell it out for you then.

 

Night 1, I asked about Red and I was told she didn't go anywhere (she didn't visit anyone). Yes I did ask and I was told that a player targetting himself/herself is 'not going anywhere'.

 

Night 2, I asked about Christine and I was told that she visited BG. I suppose that might mean she NK'd BG (I find that unlikely), or that she investigated BG.

 

Night 3, I asked about Kate (you) and I was told that she visited Tiinker. As far as I'm aware, that means Kate used a Night Action on Tiinker. I assume that accounts for the NightKill on Tiinker, I see no other possible explanation.

 

 

Kate, I believe that Red was your teammate so of course you do remember her role. But so do I.

[bhskeeper11]

Yes I do claim tracker.

 

I'll spell it out for you then.

 

Night 1, I asked about Red and I was told she didn't go anywhere (she didn't visit anyone). Yes I did ask and I was told that a player targetting himself/herself is 'not going anywhere'.

 

Night 2, I asked about Christine and I was told that she visited BG. I suppose that might mean she NK'd BG (I find that unlikely), or that she investigated BG.

 

Night 3, I asked about Kate (you) and I was told that she visited Tiinker. As far as I'm aware, that means Kate used a Night Action on Tiinker. I assume that accounts for the NightKill on Tiinker, I see no other possible explanation.

 

 

Kate, I believe that Red was your teammate so of course you do remember her role. But so do I.

 

Red had no role. I went back and looked it up...on page 19 or somewhere around there. She had no night action as far as the coroner's report says and therefore she couldn't have "visited" herself.

 

Of course you know Christine visited BG...we all do. She announced it a couple of RL days ago.

 

I did not visit anyone last night. I have no actions.

 

It sounds like you forgot Red's healer claim was a fake or just didn't think it through, bolstered your tracker claim with common knowledge of the game, and are trying to FoS me with your "knowledge."

[csarmi]

Night 1, I asked about Red and I was told she didn't go anywhere (she didn't visit anyone).

[John E. Kelley]

Night 1, I asked about Red and I was told she didn't go anywhere (she didn't visit anyone).

I dunno Kate, if Red had no role, obviously she wouldn't have visited anyone. It doesn't sound as if your argument refutes Cs's claim (at least as far as Red is concerned). The fact that she had no role wouldn't have caused him to NO read whatsoever, anyone who didn't have arole that he read should have said that same thing, yeah?

[bhskeeper11]

That is not what you said in your first tracker claim post. You put that she visited herself.

 

But you can keep backpedaling if you so desire.

[Sakaea]

Interesting, csarmi. However, I am more convinced than ever that JLM is scum, and I have a sneaking suspicion she's more than likely responsible for Jack's death.. I will try to check back later, see what comes of the csarmi/Kate thing, and my vote.

[Sakaea]

Bugger. VOTE JLM And I got sniped.

[bhskeeper11]

Night 1, I asked about Red and I was told she didn't go anywhere (she didn't visit anyone).

I dunno Kate, if Red had no role, obviously she wouldn't have visited anyone. It doesn't sound as if your argument refutes Cs's claim (at least as far as Red is concerned). The fact that she had no role wouldn't have caused him to NO read whatsoever, anyone who didn't have arole that he read should have said that same thing, yeah?

 

I can't exactly refute it with authority because I am not a tracker and didn't track her that night. However, I have watched games where people claimed tracker and announced in thread that the person did not visit anyone.

 

Csarmi's chart thing indicates that Christine visited BG, I visited Tiinker, and Red visited Red. He could have written no one, but he didn't. I think it was a slip on his part.

 

 

And...I am off for a bit. Having a good ol' Southern supper for my grandmother's birthday. I'll be back around later tonight.

[JenLenaMom]

What makes you think I'm responsible for Jack's death? You're not claiming Tracker too are you?? LOL Does everyone left in the game have a role but me?

[csarmi]

I can't exactly refute it with authority because I am not a tracker and didn't track her that night. However, I have watched games where people claimed tracker and announced in thread that the person did not visit anyone.

 

Csarmi's chart thing indicates that Christine visited BG, I visited Tiinker, and Red visited Red. He could have written no one, but he didn't. I think it was a slip on his part.

 

 

And...I am off for a bit. Having a good ol' Southern supper for my grandmother's birthday. I'll be back around later tonight.

 

Have a nice evening. I'm going to sleep.

Kate, if you read up, you may notice that in my first post I did indicate that I couldn't decide whether Red was the healer or not.

Sorry if I wasn't clear in my first post, in the few games I've seen with a tracker, he/she seemed to just announce where said player spent the night. So I did just that myself.

[Sakaea]

No I'm not claiming tracker. I'm vanilla town. I don't know if you really were responsible for jack's death but my gut says you're scum

[John E. Kelley]

No I'm not claiming tracker. I'm vanilla town. I don't know if you really were responsible for jack's death but my gut says you're scum

 

So you don't really know if he was responsible for Jack's death but you're voting him anyways. Nice. Early game I can see you voting with your gut, but in Lylo, that just reeks of scum.

 

Vote Sakaea.

[Sakaea]

i voted for her last day phase too. i still think she's scum.

[JenLenaMom]

So you're just going to ignore the tracker claim? To me that smells of scum trying to distract from a teammates vote train.

[Sakaea]

I'm not ignoring it, but the way csarmi wrote the whole "Red visited Red" thing makes me kinda leary about believing him. I'm not sure I do, that's all.

[Leelou]

I'm not 100% sure on csarmi's tracker claim. I have a little time to think on it. Kate has been pinging me.

 

JLM, why call out sakaea for voting against what the "tracker" suggests, but then you don't place a vote on Kate or make any comment towards how you feel about cs's claim?

[csarmi]

Strange indeed. But you see leelou, we have 7 players left and 3 of those should be maffia (LyLo confirmed by Quibby + game setup considerations).

 

What we do seem to know is that you and Christine are town.

 

So three of the other five are scum. If you do believe me (honestly I don't know if you should, at this point), then three of the other four are (Kate included).

 

Maybe we could figure out something of the interactions there, maybe not.

 

I wish it wasn't LyLo. If it wasn't, I could say that we should check if I'm true by lynching Kate, but now any promise is meaningless.

 

I did vote Kate, because from my point of view, it's either a sure scum lynch on Kate, or a 2 in three chance to find one by lynching someone else.

 

By the way, I do not know whether voting OR not voting is more scummy at this point. We are at a dangerous situation. Shouldn't be hasty.

 

Sakaea: I suspect you misinterpret my words intentionally. When did I say Red visited Red? Quote please.

[csarmi]

On JLM, I certainly think her actions scummy. She keeps jumping in and out of thread, not much to say. Lurking (or whatever it is called) is something that's always pinging me. That may be me disliking that playstyle, but there it is.

 

Sakaea hadn't been pinging me at all, but his recent posts do seem to indicate to me that he's teamed with Kate.

 

Ishmael I don't know. I was very suspicious of him the first days with his jumping on any train just to see a lynch.

 

Sakaea, care to make a case on JLM? I'd really like to hear your opinion. What do you think of Kate and Ishmael?

[csarmi]

---OFF---

 

On a private note: please forgive me if I mistake someone's gender. We have a much easier time in Hungary, there being no genders in our language. Sometimes it's just not easy. I'm pretty sure I did refer to leelou as male. Maybe we should start maffia games with introductions?

 

 

---ON---

[csarmi]

Gosh: Sakaea, sorry about you too :)