[BASIC] Star Wars Mafia GAME OVER!!!

[Nolder]

unOFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Amadine (1) -- Nolder

Nolder (4) -- Christine, Kate, BG, Red

Adella (1) -- Jack

Jack (1) -- Amadine

 

 

you know after rereading the votes to get this count it seems to me like there was a lot of OMGUS voting going on

[Nolder]

;__;

I took so much time to track down those votes and you ruined it

[Sakaea]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Nolder (3) -- Christine, Kate, BG

 

Jack (2) -- Amadine, Red

 

Amadine (1) -- Nolder

 

Adella (1) -- Jack

 

Not Voting: Adella, Millon, Wolf

[Nolder]

*shrugs* if someone claims a major villian i'm not goign to bat an eye;ash at voting them. it woudl be like someone claiming Padin Fain in a WoT mafia game but people saying "he killed a Mydraal so he's not all that bad of a guy"

 

sorry, just doesn't float my boat

eh

I think it'd make more sense to compare it to Ingtar

 

there is an actual theme of redemption for both him and DV (remember that his ghost appears alongside Yoda's and Obi Wan's)

whereas Fain is...well...do we even really know what he is?

 

not true IMO. there can be alot of gleam off the role and character you claim. i've already explained how claiming a Miller role with your character works to your benefit with the finder dead and the character your claiming.

how does it work for my benefit?

I'm the closest to being lynched and a very large part of that is because of my role despite what people say

 

it doesn't matter if we have a cop or not

if at any time in the game, past or future, I had claimed either DV or Miller or both there would be an immediate air of suspicion followed by a lot of WIFOM reasoning

[Red2111]

actually Nol it does make an impact how the Miller claim is veiwed as far as when it's claimed.

 

 

if the finder is still alive, and you claim Miller; it's looked at that your setting up to counter a finder reveal on you. if you claim Miller after the finder is dead, it looks better on you because technically speaking it doesn't benefit you as scum to claim this without the finder posing a threat.

[Sedai]

Tbh Nolder could of claimed anyone. The fact that he opted to claim DV makes me believe him.

 

Red why are you opposed to lynch Adella? The only thing she has done is played the field and lightly fosed the three main people day 1 and then bandwagon voted our finder. She hasn't took a stand on anything an that's scummy. :p

 

You all wanna try our luck with random? The only hree people I'd consider lynching is Adella, red, and Millon. So if none of those is okay, then I'm fine with that.

[Christine]

I can never sleep again. Y'all just blew up these pages.

 

 

I am sticking with my Nolder vote with my eyes wide on Adella, but I am going to have to reread through these past few pages.

[Nolder]

but you and I and hopefully everyone else all know this

 

it just becomes a matter of WIFOM and meta

 

it's better imo to discard such things as there is no solution to the thought process

it's better to base your decision based on my actions

 

at least that's what I believe

you obviously disagree

so I suppose we'll just agree to disagree on this

[Nolder]

ninja'd twice

my post was @red

[Nolder]

The only hree people I'd consider lynching is Adella, red, and Millon. So if none of those is okay, then I'm fine with that.

none of those is ok imo

 

I personally don't believe Adella is scummy

 

Red is...aggressive

it makes it hard to tell

but so far I don't think she's had much of an impact on the game so I think it's best to just dismiss her as a "neutral" for now

 

Millon has posted 10 times

while Adella has posted less I feel like she's said more

he/she definitely seems like someone to keep an eye on but that's for later when there's less people and less choice

 

for today I'd rather go with BG or Amadine

they seem the most scummy to me

 

me and Jack are also viable candidates, though I'd rather leave Jack for tomorrow and obviously I'd rather live

but if you choose either of us there's plenty of information to be had from our deaths

[Sedai]

Might night be a tomorrow if we lynch wrong

[Red2111]

Nol - how am i disagreeing with you when i'm basing my vote on Jack over his actions rather than his character claim. also, you twist my reason for voting you. part of it was for the character claim, the other part was over the role claim, i wasn't voting for you souly on the fact that you've claimed Darth.

 

 

Jack - i never said i was opposed to an Adella lynch, infact i stated i was fine with a lynch on her. again, here you are twisting my words. what i said was that i'm more inclined to lynch either you or No (and more so you given recent events) because a lynch on your or Nol will give more info than one on someoen who hasn't posted all day and there for hasn't had the opportunity to reveal.

 

also, if yoru goign to use the vote on Balckie as evidence on her, hen you need to remember that Blackie hadn't revealed and that almost everyone voted him. so i fail to see how Adella's D1 vote implicates her.

 

 

also, your claim of LYLO on D2 sounds more like fear mongering if you ask me. theres 10 people alive, and it takes 6 people to lynch. we wont be in a LYLO situtation for another day or 2 Jack.

 

 

honestly, i think jack is scum in this, and for reasons i've already listed. i'd prefer a lynch on him as i'm 95% certain he's scum but will be willing to move my vote to Nol for the majority as his lynch will give us info as well.

 

 

[Nolder]

Might night be a tomorrow if we lynch wrong

how many people are left in the game atm?

[bgrishinko]

I think Jack is running on the assumption that there might be 4 mafia. So LYLO if we lynch wrong. That leaves 8 total people w/ 4 scum.

[bhskeeper11]

Even though Red did change votes, I felt like it was a bit slick to jump on Nolder just because of his character role. That puts up a red flag, because it seems like it was a move to try and get a quick lynch without much reason, other than character. That seems subject to suspicion.

 

I don't want to put a lot of money in who people say they are because, in the end, I only know who I am and who the cop and vigilante are.

 

I'm still suspicious of the others, but the aggression against Jack and jumping on Nolder for character pings on the radar.

 

Unvote.

 

Vote Red.

 

Of course, as we're nearing the deadline, I would not be against voting Adella (for her lack of a claim) to avoid a random lynch.

[Nolder]

Nol - how am i disagreeing with you when i'm basing my vote on Jack over his actions rather than his character claim. also, you twist my reason for voting you. part of it was for the character claim, the other part was over the role claim, i wasn't voting for you souly on the fact that you've claimed Darth.

if you say so...

that's not how it looked to me

but maybe I'm just being too defensive at this point

I haven't slept yet and it feels like I've been defending myself for pages and pages (I know that in reality I've done just as much accusing as defending but that's not how it feels)

 

I think maybe it's time for me to call it a day night and get some sleep

[Sedai]

Damn your right red. I thought it was day 3. I've got my games mixed up. 6 at one time is to many. Lynch mr if you want, because tbh I've said all I'm going to say. I like Adella for scum. I am not using that against her, I'm just saying her bandwagon vote was opportunistic. If hoof would have been vanilla I'd of said the same thing. I've got to get my game prepared to be modded. (I pre signed you up red

Cause the spots were going fast and I haven't posted sign ups yet) and if I'm playing in three or four games and moddin then things will unravel.

 

Red how have my actions been scummy? I've played my usual game.

[Nolder]

Jack did you ever address the whole thing about the Miller teams?

because it doesn't look like anyone had any idea what you were talking about and I think that could use some clarification

I'm surprised you haven't addressed it already tbh

[Sedai]

Well when I mod I put them in teams to balance out the guilty viewing. Kinda lynch one to prove the other. And most of the games I've played in there have been miller groups and not just a single miller. That's the way I've played it and saw it played

[Red2111]

Red how have my actions been scummy? I've played my usual game.

 

 

for a slew of reasons jack

 

- push for Mass Reveal

- chiding Ama on her vote on you (Luke Skywalker) over a vote on Nol (Darth Vader). heres the quote so you can't deny it

 

So Amadine, you vote for Luke over Darth Vader?

 

- your mis-information concerning the Miller role. you adamently claim it's in the wiki that Millers are assigned on teams when i've clearly proven they aren't by quoting the entire wiki pages on Millers.

- your fear mongering by claiming we're LYLO when we're not.

 

 

 

given these reasons, versus the only reason i have to vote Nol (his role/character) you are the better choice.

[Red2111]

also add in you linking players together to the list as well.

[Sedai]

Red I link players. I did it in Krak's game and I was town. Moot point.

 

Neve pusher for a mass reveal. I said i thought it was best and did so myself. I said if uo don't feel comfortable doing so ten don't. (and you say I twist things around :p )

 

Again I do that. I debase the value of the votes on myself to deter others from lynching me. Why is that scummy?

 

Wasn't misinformation cause that's how I've saw it played

 

I was mistaken I thought this was day 3

[Red2111]

- you did push for the mass reveal by claiming you thought it was the best option and then pressuring people when they don't reveal with votes or the threat of a vote. case & point Adella, as part of your reason for voting her is her lack of a reveal. you also FoS'd alot of people over the course of this day for posting and not revealing. imo, this is pushing the reveal idea.

 

- i never like linking players, it's a technique i see scum use on average more than town. i always FoS people over this and call them out for it reguardless of play style as it tends to benefit scum more than catch scum.

 

- you claimed rather loudly and alot that it was written in the wiki that Millers come in groups. havign it down as fact in the wiki and goign on how mods manipulate the role are two different things with two different implications. and you've been in a game before where a Miller was by himself. i believe Rey's game or DPR's game last year had a Miller that wasn't on a team.

 

- it says Day 2 in the title. how can you be mistaken about that?? sounds more like your back tracking because soemoen called you out on it.

[Sakaea]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Nolder (2) -- Christine, BG

 

Jack (2) -- Amadine, Red

 

Amadine (1) -- Nolder

 

Adella (1) -- Jack

 

Red (1) -- Kate

 

Not Voting: Adella, Millon, Wolf

[Sedai]

Red I don't lie over things like that. That's a cheap strategy and I lose respect for anyone who does something like that. This game is preloaded on my web browser on my phone. I just refresh periodically.