[STANDARD] Alanna's Robin Hood Mafia - Congrats to the Town!

[Talya]

*shrugs*

 

If she can't get her facts right...not my fault, and I wasn't the only one who picked up on it. So you're just getting me back from the beginning of the game...Poor excuse!

[mnwhiterose]

have to agree with you Pete! *Lifts a glass to Talya* Sorry, babe, but my vote has to go to you.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Talya[/glow]

[Pookie]

It has nothing to do with getting facts straight, as I mentioned after you questioned it the first time.  It's simply a matter of whether you're looking at partial facts (voting patterns, as Aemon suggested we look at when he posted the vote counts) or all the facts (voting patterns plus what we can delve out of people's game posts). 

 

[glow=red,2,300]Talya[/glow]

 

That should come as no surprise since that's where my vote was yesterday. 

 

My feelings on Tigs were a little less solid until her last posts.  Her vote on Aemon mentioned the "thing" between him and Pete, but left Talya totally out of it even though she was saying just as much as both guys that night.  We'd already discussed that the NK on Pete was likely the work of a vig.  She said her initial vote for me was random and that she didn't know if she believed my claim or not, but it certainly seems like she doesn't from her last post where she says I'm just trying to look like I'm doing good for the town.

 

Also, did anyone besides Tigs and Talya pick up inconsistencies in my post?  Because it seemed to me that I explained pretty clearly from the start what criterion I was using for each list.  Does no one else make both a "just from votes" and a "from everything" suspicion list?

[LilyElizabeth]

Well, the game is certainly heating up!  ;D

 

I can see both sides of this one. It could be a misunderstanding or it could be Talya being scummy. I've seen her like this when she's in too many games. On the other hand, I've never caught her as scum yet. I have, however, lynched her when she was innocent. (I'm still embarrassed over that one, Mary Poppins  ;)) And Pete is either making a lot of sense or misleading us. Too soon for me to tell.

 

For now, I'm going to watch closely, and make up my mind.

 

[aemonkristen]

Talya is my top suspect right now, but I want to do another reread before I make a vote. I want to try and see what (if anything) I can find out about Bela since I have to distance Pete from his last role in the game. By the way, sorry about the arrow through the heart.  ;D

[LilyElizabeth]

His heart is strong. He can take it.  :P

 

*snuggles her bro*

 

[Alanna]

Vote Count:

Talya (3) - Pete, Rose, Pookie

 

Not Voting (5): Lily, Talya, Tigs, Lia, Aemon

 

Deadline is Wednesday @ 2PM CST.

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[LilyElizabeth]

Good. That's plenty of time. I really need to do a reread and see what I can see. I don't want to just bandwagon.

 

[aemonkristen]

Actually, there's one piece of info I think we might have.  Unless there's someone who hasn't been on in the last two days when the vote was clearly looking to swing my way (besides Kati) then I'm pretty sure the mafia were all on me.  Otherwise they would have swapped there to make that last vote and get rid of an innocent.  

 

ooh

thats good. Im going to use that in other games too. It makes so much sense

 

Sounds like Player is trying to make us believe Pookie's theory, which leads me back to the same conclusion that made me shoot Pete. I don't think all of the mafia voted for Pookie and the only one not confirmed by a coroner's report is Lia.

 

After a reread, I get tend to think Talya is innocent for a couple of reasons. Several times she stated her suspicions of Player and she even voted him after he voted for himself. This was before the bandwagon on me started, so her vote could easily have started a bandwagon on Player.

 

Da Players (something I picked up from Mynd in Talya's LoTR game)

1. Kati Lily

2. Talya

3. Som1else - Mutch, Outlaw, Killed Night 2

4. Pete - Alan a Dale, Outlaw, Killed Night 1

5. Bela Pete 2.0

6. Tigs

7. Lia

8. Rose- Friar Tuck?

9. Player - Guy of Gisbourne, Mafia, Killed Night 2

10. Moghedian - Robin Hood, Tracker, Killed Night 1

11. Aemon- Vigilante, cried at Robin's death

12. Pookie- (I still have no idea which character she is)

 

At this moment, I feel that the remaining mafia will be found among Lily, Pete, Tigs and Lia. I have n o read on Lily. Pete just came in and Bela only made 2 posts while she was in the game, neither with any content. That means that for the moment I will have to vote between Lia and Tigs. I am going to vote [glow=red,2,300]Tigs[/glow] Because she was involved in both bandwagons and it looks like she and Player may have been double teaming to try and force through my lynch, as they posted withing 10 minutes of each other.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

Well, the game is certainly heating up!  ;D

 

I can see both sides of this one. It could be a misunderstanding or it could be Talya being scummy. I've seen her like this when she's in too many games. On the other hand, I've never caught her as scum yet. I have, however, lynched her when she was innocent. (I'm still embarrassed over that one, Mary Poppins  ;)) And Pete is either making a lot of sense or misleading us. Too soon for me to tell.

 

For now, I'm going to watch closely, and make up my mind.

 

 

Sis, that is the most middle of the road post ever.  :P

 

Nice position you are putting yourself in if Talya is lynched and she flips scum. I like how you retain your vote so you can jump on another wagon if one arives.  ;)

 

The misleading part is priceless, I haven't even tried to lead anyone anywhere, just stated why Talya was pinging me.  :-*

[LilyElizabeth]

It was a compliment, bro. I KNOW you! And it IS too soon to tell, although it's getting warmer...

 

So, you'd rather have me mindlessly bandwagon? Yeah. That's not scummy at all...

 

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

It was a compliment, bro. I KNOW you! And it IS too soon to tell, although it's getting warmer...

 

So, you'd rather have me mindlessly bandwagon? Yeah. That's not scummy at all...

 

 

Not mindlessly bandwagon, just having an opinion. That was a filler post, basically saying you are going to bandwagon later if Talya's is inevitable. I know those aren't your words, but I have saw this dance before.  :-*

[dapianoplay3r]

blah!

You may have killed my but there are four of you dead

 

Long live the king!

 

(i think its king john, the evil one anyway)

 

Go Team!

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

How many kills do you have Aemon?

[aemonkristen]

I have 1 more, then I'm vanilla.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

I don't want to know on who, but are you planning on using it tonight?

[aemonkristen]

I figure I better use it tonight. That way the doc doesn't have to try covering me till I decide to use it. I use my last arrow tonight and even if they take me out, I'll just be another vanilla out of their way. No more power role. I'll let ebveryone know who my target is as soon as I decide. I think a lot will depend on today's lynch. I still think Tigs is our best bet at the moment.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

I believe Talya is mafia, and from the way Lily was posting, if Talya is scum, she is my next suspect.

[LilyElizabeth]

Good to know. Still gonna reread, though.  :P

 

[aemonkristen]

I have a feeling that Aemon is telling the truth (and no I don't believe it 100%) mainly because of Pete on day one.

 

I'm thinking now either Player or Pookie :-\

 

This is one of th main reasons that I think Talya is innocent. I admit that she might be throwing a teammate under the bus on this one, but in a standard game that's not very likely. Maybe if she is scum she put Player in there because she thought I'd go for Pookie instead. That is also a possibility. The thing is that those possibilities don't really convince me. I'm going to leave my vote on Tigs for the time being.

[LilyElizabeth]

THAT is something I do have an opinion on, without rereading.  (:P @ my bro)

 

After all that has been said, I mostly believe Pookie is innocent. Like Talya, I never believe 100% until I see a coroners report, but mostly.

 

 

[LilyElizabeth]

I've been on this reread for hours, between housework that HAD to get done and DM going down. I got to pg. 14 and I'm tired. Can somebody please tell me why Talya is suspicious? I'll read the rest tomorrow. I might already have known that, but not at 5:00 AM when I haven't slept.

 

 

[Talya]

What concerns me about this game is that so many do not seem to be posting. All I see is Lily, Aemon and Dragon (not forgetting pookie though she seems a little quiet) that are really getting involved in this game.

 

Do we have a vote count?

[aemonkristen]

Vote Count:

Talya (3) - Pete, Rose, Pookie

 

Not Voting (5): Lily, Talya, Tigs, Lia, Aemon

 

Deadline is Wednesday @ 2PM CST.

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

Nothing has changed since then. I haven't heard much from Lia the entire game, but she's always a quiet one.

[Talya]

I would still like to see some reasons for my vote. Pookie and Tigs still haven't said anything (and Pookie you haven't you've just put me in your 'everything' category, which explains nothing about reasons).

 

It also could be that Pete has actually taken over a Mafia role. He seemed to do a reread pretty quickly and come to the conclusions that I was mafia...because what I said was 'polished'..that I find funny, I have never written anything polished..maybe I should take that as a compliment!! :D so he didn't like the things I said to him on the first day and so is gunning for me now..

 

I happen to still think there was something wrong with Tigs vote on Lily when we were after a lynch. To say a name is fine, but why not one of the other names? We could have had a lynch and more information. And now she votes with nothing apart from following Pete...trying to get an easy lynch?

 

Lily has been way too quiet (even if she is amongst the active ones) I know she has been away this weekend, I would like to here from here.

 

I'm sure there are others but those are the only ones that I remember actually saying much in this game.

 

Pookie, I actually believe she might be innocent, though I can't help thinking I'm having the wool pulled over my eyes. Pete, I'm not willing to vote for him just because of his bee in his bonnet. Lily, I'll keep an open mind. that Leaves[glow=red,2,300] Tigs[/glow] for my vote.