[STANDARD] Alanna's Robin Hood Mafia - Congrats to the Town!

[LilyElizabeth]

I figured that, Lia, but since it escaped me that we were that close to endgame, I thought I would make sure everyone knew.

 

[Talya]

For information, if she is using the BBC version Guy of Gisborne turns to the good side in the end! (which is great because Richard Armitidge is yummy)

 

I do find it odd that the Mafia chose to kill someone that Aemon said he was going to kill. It seems like a wasted kill.  :-\

I think that out of everyone here, Aemon is the most innocent. I still can't get Pookie out of my mind, but there is still something nagging at the back of my mind that she is innocent. Apart from Lia who is low, that leaves Lily and Rose.

 

I can't see how Lily being guilty would make me automatically, Mafia are very good at hitching on to people they know to be innocent to put suspicion on them if they are lynched or if that person is lynched and innocent, they hope it will make them too. That however is an obvious thing to do and Lily is way too experienced for that.

 

Rose hasn't really said much through out the game, been her quiet self so it makes it really hard to judge, it's also a good place to hide as Mafia/roled player. I don't believe she is roled, if I have everything straight! I can't see how she can think that about Aemon though, there is only proof. And Lia confirmed it (unless they are working together - now that would be some move,)

 

As Lily said it is important this lynch so I'm going to think more before I cast my vote!

[mnwhiterose]

I never say much in any game, do I, Talya?

 

Just made some rum cake, which has more rum than cake. And I think I'm going to make some Scotch eggs, but I'm out of Scotch. Out of rum, too.

 

*shares the rum cake with the rest of the class*

[aemonkristen]

The decision on who to vote for is much more difficult than I had anticipated. This could very well be endgame between the lynch, the NK. All the same, I shall vote for [glow=red,2,300]Rose[/glow]. The only reason I can give is what Lily already pointed out.

[Alanna]

Vote Count:

Lily (2) - Pookie, Rose

Rose (2) - Lily, Aemon

 

Not Voting: Talya, Lia

 

Deadline is Friday @ 9PM CST.

 

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

[Talya]

I know you don't say much in games Rose and it makes it very difficult to read you. But it was odd what you said about Aemon where he is almost someone we can be sure of is innocent. If this wasn't a standard game I wouldn't think like that but it is.

 

I just can't beleive that Lily would be so obvious as to try and attach herself to an innocent if she was mafia. I know in games I have questioned people about voting for people when there is little evidence that people can provide. So I can see where she is coming from. But I'm trying not to let that cloud my judgement.

 

As we are this close to endgame, i also find it odd that even though Rose thinks that Aemon is mafia, she goes for Lily just to get a lynch. That sounds like a mafia doing anything to get a lynch so we can go to night!

 

I think I will go with [glow=red,2,300]Rose[/glow]

[aemonkristen]

Deadline is in 5 hors. We should probably decide something soon.

[LilyElizabeth]

I agree. I'm pretty sure Rose and I aren't changing our votes, so that means it's up to the rest of you. Talya and Pookie (she's in the UK, right?) aren't on this time of day, so that leaves you and Lia to work this out.

 

[aemonkristen]

LOL. It really just comes down to Lia. If she votes Rose, it's a lynch, if she votes for you, Lily, I'll have to change my vote to you. The only other option would be a no lynch, and I'm not sure if that would help us or hinder us.

[LilyElizabeth]

No pressure, Lia.  ;D

 

[aemonkristen]

Based on character names from dead folks, I'm 95% certain Alanna is using the BBC version. 

 

Main characters:

 

Robin -- Moggy, nk night 1

Marian-- 

Little John -- Tigs, lynch day 3

Much -- Som1, nk night 2

Allan A Dale -- Pete, nk night 1

Will Scarlett-

Djaq-

Tuck-

Kate -- BelaPete, nk night 3

 

Guy of Gisborne-- Player NK night 2

Sheriff of Nottingham

Isabella or Prince John

 

 

If you haven't seen the BBC version, what's your only association with Tuck?  Drunken Disney Friar.  Tuck is too "main" to be left out, in my opinion.  With no counter claims this entire time, I'm inclined to believe her.  I know who the rest of the innocents are by role.  Which leaves me with Talya and Lily.  I'm fine with voting for Lily first to "prove" Talya or whatever, hence the reason my vote was on Lily, who had Aemon's vote already.  Aemon's slip gave the facts no wiggle room as far as I'm concerned.  We have 2 scum left and 2 people whose characters haven't been demonstrated by either hints or roles.

 

Well, here we go again. I just did a reread and went to check movie quotes to finally figure out who Pookie is. Now that I know, I am reluctant to lynch Rose. As she already stated (in the bolded text) we should know by role who the players are. Can you give us a hint Lily or Talya?

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

[glow=red,2,300]Lily[/glow]

[LilyElizabeth]

Talya won't be on before the deadline, so that isn't going to be of any help.

 

I'm not a movie person, and I only know the basic legend of the story. My character is someone I'm not familiar with so I can't hint. I'm sorry. I would if I could. I will say that he's obviously not a major character, or I would recognize the name, I think.

 

[LilyElizabeth]

Even though is doesn't work out well for me, nice strategy there, Aemon.  ;)

 

[Pookie]

I'm on pacific time, though I hold late night hours generally.  ;)  I don't intend to vote for Rose at this point.  I'm not certain of her allignment, but NO ONE has said "she's not Tuck" directly and I'm certain he's in the game.  A no-lynch gives us another shot at another day whereas an incorrect lynch does not.  I know many of you hate a no-lynch, but it's worse to sacrifice a townie just to get a lynch.

[aemonkristen]

I'm not certain of her allignment, but NO ONE has said "she's not Tuck" directly and I'm certain he's in the game.

 

This is the kind of information we need, but we seem to be a bit bogged down by not being able to reveal our character names. And Lily really does have a valid point. Many of the name on the list I do not recognize and would be hard pressed to give a clue about. I am still mostly convinced of who is who right now, though.

[Liathiana]

Yeah, thanks guys!

 

I don't think Rose is doing much to defend herself here. I think it'd be weird if the Mod gave her a PR and made her Mafia, though it seems to have worked in her favor thus far if so. I have been suspicious for her for awhile and I'm more inclined to believe Lily is innocent.

 

Who are you Pookie?

[aemonkristen]

From the hints she gave at the beginning of the game, she is Will Scarlett. Can anyone guess who I am?

[Liathiana]

Hmm okay. How long until the deadline?

[aemonkristen]

about 40 minutes

[LilyElizabeth]

Decision time. 5 minutes left.

 

[aemonkristen]

And we have a no lynch day. I'm going to decide this once and for all. Goodbye, Lily.

[LilyElizabeth]

Aemon, your play has been so erratic this game. I hope you know what you're doing. If you go for me, that's endgame as long as the mafia's nk goes through. But, whatever. It was fun.

 

 

[aemonkristen]

True, but I'm feeling pretty good about my choice. Sleep well.  ;D

[LilyElizabeth]

Never fear, I will. And it's nothing to do with this game...lol.

 

I just took evil to a new height in another one....

 

[Alanna]

Deadline has passed.

 

NO LYNCH REACHED.

 

It is now Night. Please get your night actions in by Sunday, May 30 @ 10PM CST.