WOT: Seanchan Succession Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[ed2funy]

And if we lynch the healer, we have none.  Are you actually saying that no healer at all is the better course?

 

Sarah...I am confused how you pulled that from my post.

o.0

 

I said one of them is most likely lying. That means:

If Ty is lying, she is not the healer.

If Tal is lyning, he is not another finder.

 

 

[Alanna]

I think she was talking to Pookie, but I could be wrong.

 

And the problem with your theory, Pookie, is that there is still a mafia roleblocker out there. So if the healer dies, then one of the finders gets nightkilled, and the other gets blocked. Of course, if Tynaal really is a healer, then Talmanes is probably not a finder anyway. Either that, or we really will have to start looking at Pete (those of us who aren't really looking at him already ;)).

[Alanna]

Not that I'm saying you shouldn't vote for Tynaal, because if you suspect she's not the healer, then of course I understand your vote. I'm just pointing out why, if she is a healer, it wouldn't quite work out that way.

[ed2funy]

lmao...ok.

I didn't think she was because I didn't think many people were on. :D

Should have read the time stamp.

 

I get it now. :P

Sorry Sarah. You threw me there, and I could not see the connection. Turns out because it wasn't there. :D

[Tigraine]

I know it's late in the game but I believe that Talmanes is innocent...therefore [glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

 

I could be wrong but I have a hunch that this game has a lot of different screwed up roles or half roles for the same thing so that they can all equal one role between them!

[ed2funy]

Tigs, you know if you don't vote back on him, or for someone, you could be killed.

Especially since we will have no majority.

[Alanna]

You know, someone may have said this before, but is just occurred to me. I was thinking about the roles that Pete, Talmanes, and Tynaal have all claimed, and trying to think which would be a non-town role. Talmanes seems the most likely to me. So, he could be telling the truth about his ability, but be a solo win or a mafia finder. There are sometimes finders not on the townies' side. Just pointing it out.

[ed2funy]

Alanna, you are making this so much more confusing. lol....Need to decide.

 

*goes to a corner and rocks back and forth*

[Tigraine]

So what do we do then?  We have a "finder" and a "healer" that we are down between and we basically have a 50/50 chance of making the wrong choice...We're stuck!

[ed2funy]

Exactly Tigs...

We can't really go random, but at this point is sort of is, even if you vote for the person you think is non-town (for the benefit of Alanna ;D).

 

We need more evidence...or something!

[Tigraine]

Ugh!!!  :'( :'(

 

How can we switch our votes off of those two?

[ed2funy]

We really can't. Unless the whole group switched to Tigs (for example), it is pretty much between those two.

With the deadline in a few hours, it is time to vote.

 

IF there is no lynch, we are in the same predicament tomorrow.

[Alanna]

LOL, I keep wanting to say mafia, but really all we know is that someone is non-town haha.

 

Actually, we have a lot of 'evidence' at this point. A lot more than you often get in mafia games. But in the end, you never really know for sure that someone is innocent. I've lynched or used role abilities against people before that I was sure was mafia, and they turned out innocent. And I've trusted people I was sure were innocent, that turned out to be mafia. You just have to go with your best educated guess, or your strongest gut feeling. Or with whatever's best for the town.

[ed2funy]

:-\

Right now...

Agh. I just don't know atm.

It is 5 to 6.

I wish more people were on to weigh in.

[WWWwombat]

My gut says Tynaal is innocent.  Furthermore, she has been acting like a healer all game long.

[ed2funy]

Well, my call worked. :P

 

How so? I know she dropped some hints a few pages ago before her reveal, but I don't know how a healer 'acts'.

[Tigraine]

My gut instinct is telling me they are both telling the truth...but God knows how that has worked for me in the past so I don't know what to do.  

If I vote for Tynaal and she is innocent then I would be the hammer vote-right?...but I really don't know what to do!  If I thought that they were both scum and voted for one that turned out innocent then I wouldn't feel as bad.  If I vote for either, with me feeling they are innocent, and they turn out to be innocent then I'm gonna be pretty down on myself along with everybody else!

[ed2funy]

I have to go in about a half hour for Explorers, and I don't know if I should change my vote or not.

 

Tigs, I think you would. I don't think anyone wants to be the hammer right now. Having it so close and so unsure....

:-\

[WWWwombat]

I would hammer Talmanes in a heartbeat if I could.

[ed2funy]

I wish I had your certainty.  :-[

[WWWwombat]

When in doubt I go with my gut.  Also, Explorers eh?  I got two merit badges back when i was a Boy Scout: Fingerprinting and BASKETWEAVING lol

[ed2funy]

lol...I got up to Life or Star before I had to move. New troop sucked, so I stopped. I joined JROTC in high school, and found out about Explorers through a few of the cadets. It is a great program.

 

Now, to the game: My gut says they are most likely telling the truth. Both. But, then my logic tells me one has to be lying.

 

I have to go now....I am just going to leave my vote. I'll check it if was a good idea or bad idea when I get home.

[Tigraine]

I guess I'm gonna go back for [glow=red,2,300]Talmanes[/glow]

 

I don't feel comfortable about this but I don't know what else to do!

[Talmanes]

It's ok Tigs I understand.

[Tigraine]

You're supposed to be a donkey about it so I can feel better!  :'(