Newbie Mafia Game Over!

[peacesells]

You guys are still missing the point.  Even if I had the ability to protect myself then the WIFOM is still the greatest chance that we BOTH live.  Everyone stating I have to protect Lily lessons the chance in the mafia's mind that I may protect myself. 

 

The best scenario is that we both live through the night and the only way that happens is if the mafia think there is a chance that I protect myself.  Tayla..you looked scummy to me because you are an experienced player and I'd think you would know this.  By trying to direct the doctor role you looked like you were trying to expose me for the night kill.  THat is why I would have targeted you if I was the cop role...and wasted it.

[Toy and Minion]

I see your point and agree.

 

However, had you been able to protect yourself, you still could have and stopped the mafia.

 

Just saying.

 

Sometimes the town doing that could be in your favor.  If you could protect yourself.

 

But again, I see your point.  And the town generally should not be telling the Doc or Finder what to do.

[Talya]

There is also the possibility that I could have been getting you to do it so you would protect yourself and then you would have gone through and the finder not, What I'm saying is I don't normally do that, so i would be really dumb if I had been mafia to do something like that. But I knew how close it was to end game! And it was important. As it was it made no difference. It might have made me look scummy, but it also got the point across to the newbies that as finder sometimes you have to sacrifice yourself.

[Toy and Minion]

You mean as the Healer.  The finder should be the last one to have to sacrifice themselves.

[Talya]

:D thanks yues i do, I mean the healer..*slaps head*

[peacesells]

It might have made me look scummy, but it also got the point across to the newbies that as finder sometimes you have to sacrifice yourself.

 

Well..as instruction this is a very good statement and probably one of the most important to make about mafia games.

[LilyElizabeth]

Peace, I actually did figure out that you were creating a false WIFOM situation, but I figured it out after I posted what I did. That was one of the mistakes I learned from this game. You did a great job, and your sacrifice was not in vain. We avenged you.....lol

 

 

[peacesells]

Lily's first game.   And she was awesome.

[LilyElizabeth]

Thanks. It was a fun one, for sure!

[hazelkrs1]

This was a really fun read. I even got nostalgic, and I wasn't even in it!