BSG Mafia - Day 4

[Liathiana]

Lynch Votes:

 

Hybrid (3): Rose, Jeran, Illiara

Kivam (4): JLM, Hybrid, Thorum, Barm

 

Day 3 ends July 18 at 7 pm. 7 votes are needed for a successful lynch.

[Verbal32]

*sigh*

 

Ok...

 

[glow=red,2,300]Kivam[/glow]

[Liathiana]

Lynch Votes:

 

Hybrid (3): Rose, Jeran, Illiara

Kivam (5): JLM, Hybrid, Thorum, Barm, Verbal

 

Day 3 ends July 18 at 7 pm. 7 votes are needed for a successful lynch.

 

[Jeran]

Just keep in mind when voting for Kivam that if 2 town people die (since he is/was linked), the town could be down to only 6 people vs 2 cult and 4 mafia.

 

These numbers are calculated using worst case scenarios for the town.  This is why I think voting Hybrid is the better choice.

[Thorum]

Indeed. Only, you would have a known-cylon in that case. Me.

 

That't why I'm quite sure it won't happen ;D

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

I am voting [glow=red,2,300]Kivam[/glow] since Thorum claimed first, and I feel that Jeram's claim is a bit bogus.

[Quibby]

Okay, guys, random thought.  So if Kivam's guilty (I'm seeing arguments from somebody who claims to have been linked to him, and somebody who claims to be a Finder), and somebody else is now linked to him, killing Kivam is killing somebody else, too.  And that somebody could be an innocent.  I'm not too keen on killing Kivam, guilty or not, if it means losing an innocent anyway.

 

Thorum may well be a true Finder, and Jeran the fake.  Likewise, Jeran may be the true Finder, and Thorum the fake.  I'm not sure.  However, Thorum claimed first in a convenience claim to avoid the lynch(extremely sloppily, but he claimed first).  Jeran counterclaimed, likewise in a rather convenient moment, labeling Hybrid as a Cylon.

 

I've given Thorum the benefit of the doubt thus far, and I feel that I'll give him another chance, but because I don't like the idea of potentially killing an innocent along with a Cylon, and actually losing ground like that, I vote for [glow=red,2,300]Jeran[/glow].

[Toy and Minion]

I hope this doesn't offend you, but I don't think you thought that all out properly.  And if you did, I'd have to bring to question your logic.

 

Now that there are two players claiming Finder, I don't think either should be voted for, but rather, the two they have revealed.  EI, Kivam or Hybrid.

 

I am more inclined to vote Hybrid because of the risk of losing two innocents in one go with Kivam.  I think it's the smarter choice.  If Hybrid is guilty, then we take out Jeran.  If Hybrid is innocent, we take out Thorum.

[Quibby]

I very well could be reading it wrong.  Just got off work, and the brain's not quite caught up yet.  However, I'm probably going to stand my ground on this one because I like the somewhat random approach.

[Liathiana]

Lynch Votes:

 

Hybrid (3): Rose, Jeran, Illiara

Kivam (6): JLM, Hybrid, Thorum, Barm, Verbal, Dragonsworn

Jeran (1): Quibby

 

Day 3 ends July 18 at 7 pm. 7 votes are needed for a successful lynch.

 

[Toy and Minion]

I'll vote [glow=red,2,300]Hybrid[/glow] for reasons stated above.

[Barmacral]

So you're all aware, I'm on a short loa from tomorrow until Sunday. I'll try stop in tomorrow morning, but then I'll see you all Monday.

[Thorum]

If Hybrid is innocent, we take out Thorum.

 

I believe we're both of us true finders. Because of the way Jeran says things, ... it sounds like he gets the same kind of information I do in the same kind of manner. Just a gut feeling, I could be wrong.

 

Which also works the other way around (if Kivam is innocent, it doesn't mean Jeran isn't)

[Hybrid]

If Hybrid is guilty, then we take out Jeran.  If Hybrid is innocent, we take out Thorum.

Whoa now.  Major alarm bells ringing.  If Finder B says that Innocent C is guilty, and Innocent C flips guilty, why would you lynch Finder B?

[mnwhiterose]

I don't think that's what he's saying. But his course of action is contingent on there being only 1 true finder and the other is mafia. The logical course of action would be for both Finders to look at the same person and post the results. this will give us 1 of 3 results:

 

A) we have 2 finders in the game and both are reliable.

B) Jeran is the true Finder and Thorum is mafia (or just plain lying to draw out the real Finder)

C) Thorum is the true Finder and Jeran is mafia and lying to get the town to lynch the Finder.

 

but then, I'm not the most logical person in the world.

[Toy and Minion]

If Hybrid is guilty, then we take out Jeran.  If Hybrid is innocent, we take out Thorum.

Whoa now.  Major alarm bells ringing.  If Finder B says that Innocent C is guilty, and Innocent C flips guilty, why would you lynch Finder B?

 

Sorry, innocent and guilty verdicts switched.

 

So, it should read:

 

If Hybrid is innocent, we take out Jeran.  If Hybrid is guilty, we take out Thorum.

[Liathiana]

Lynch Votes:

 

Hybrid (5): Rose, Jeran, Illiaram, DSage

Kivam (6): JLM, Hybrid, Thorum, Barm, Verbal, Dragonsworn

Jeran (1): Quibby

 

Day 3 ends July 18 at 7 pm. 7 votes are needed for a successful lynch.

 

 

[Liathiana]

6.5 hours folks! If you don't come to a majority it will be another random lynch.

[mnwhiterose]

Has everyone voted?

[Hybrid]

Has everyone voted?

Dae and Kivam haven't yet.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

It is looking like another random lynch, and it is definately not a good thing for the town

[Liathiana]

Lynch Votes:

 

Hybrid (6): Rose, Jeran, Illiaram, DSage, Kivam

Kivam (6): JLM, Hybrid, Thorum, Barm, Verbal, Dragonsworn

Jeran (1): Quibby

 

Day 3 ends in 3 hours. 7 votes are needed for a successful lynch.

 

I have yet to find a replacement for Kivam but I'm assuming he would vote for Hybrid considering the only other viable vote would be for himself. Dae has the majority vote unless someone decides to unvote from one and switch to the other.

 

 

 

[mnwhiterose]

okay - to prevent a random lynch and to gain information....

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote

 

Kivam[/glow]

[Toy and Minion]

Honestly?  You'd risk losing two innocents over one?  Okay.

[Liathiana]

Sharon and Simon were whispering quietly to each other in the hallway. Simon’s fingers traced lightly along her arm, a smile quirked the edge of her mouth, and they laughed. Everything was going perfectly. Stupid humans. They could be fooled so easily. It was almost child’s play. Well…if the Cylons had children that is.

 

Suddenly Helo pressed his pistol against the back of Sharon’s head. She stiffened and Simon eyed the man warily. Maybe they had pushed it a little far with their hidden trysts. Could the man know of their affair?

 

“Karl!” Sharon sputtered.

 

“Athena never calls me Karl.” And the gun went off. The bullet went through Boomer’s head and into Simon’s skull. Helo shot twice more just to make sure. He turned and faced the rest of the crowd.

 

“Cylons.”

 

Kivam the Treacherous Lover and a Cylon and Jeran the The Mad Doctor and Doublevoting Lover and a Cylon have been lynched.

 

Night has begun and will end Monday night at 7 pm.