Sailor Moon Mafia [Advanced] Game Thread

[Eldrick4221]

 

While I don't agree with Fred's read on spades, his approach does seem towny. Have liked his posts so far (even though they are wordy)

I don't believe he issue isn't the read on Spades (my read is null with some positive and negatives)

 

It's the fact that I'm saying a Darthe wolf flip looks good for her. I think she's thinking that I want a lynch eventually from those 3 based solely on this, which I don't.

I got what you were saying. I think you explained yourself well.

 

And I agree that they are probably not teammates. Then again I also have both of them on the town side of null (spades more so) so /shrug

 

Darthe is a tough nut to crack. My initial reason for moving him out of null was when he felt the same way I did about one of sooh's posts. I have also liked the way he has responded to me about stuff. The flippant idc attitude is more likely to be town imo.

 

Everything else people have pointed out about him he does as both alignments.

[Eldrick4221]

 

I think both spades and Fred are misreading things in the back and forth. I'm not seeing what they are pointing out in each other.

fred's not considering the eldrick read because thats not what pinged him. it was the darthe back and forth. He doesn't have all her reads/reason on his mind he's just seeing the connection of what he's reading and noting. Whereas spades is acutely awae of her reads because its how she feels and her initial reaction is "im interacting with/reading eldrick similarly, why cherrypick the darthe read and not mention eldrick"

 

its a perspective issue IMO

Pretty much.

[Fredwood]

 

I think both spades and Fred are misreading things in the back and forth. I'm not seeing what they are pointing out in each other.

 

fred's not considering the eldrick read because thats not what pinged him. it was the darthe back and forth. He doesn't have all her reads/reason on his mind he's just seeing the connection of what he's reading and noting. Whereas spades is acutely awae of her reads because its how she feels and her initial reaction is "im interacting with/reading eldrick similarly, why cherrypick the darthe read and not mention eldrick"

 

its a perspective issue IMO 

 

 

I think this is a fair assessment.

[Eldrick4221]

My collection of town reads is growing. This is either awesome, or I'm horribly off somewhere.

 

Town

Linz (duh)

Mmmmmspades

 

Town lean

Darthe

Fred

Sooh

 

Null

Everyone else

 

Scum leans

Zander

Scruff

[Fredwood]

 

 

 

 

 

 

Eldrick name the reasons you think Im pushing Sbop

All I can see is that you pursued asking him if he knew if penny subbed out as scum. But because this has no bearing on the game being she subbed out before the game started, I don't understand the reason for this.

You said there was something else about his posts you didn't like, but I'm blanking on what it was. I actually wanted to ask you for example of it.

For someone who claims to be trying to figure me out, this shows the fact youre not man.

Youve like at least 3-4 posts saying im not reading Zander Town, Zander you need to show me youre Town and Im not getting what youre saying/pushing yet Ive got like prolly at least 20 posts explaining why I sussed for the original reason. multiple posts explaining other issues ive had with them and youre still like I cant figure out you out Zander....this is why I cant read you Town.

ISO me and look if youre a Villager man.

Already said I'm not gonna ISO you. I never do. You say too much.

People likely never ISO me either :P

If you're a villager you can answer my questions directly so I can understand you. If you're scum, you can just ignore me and let my suspicion stay.

 

 

[v] Eld [/v]

 

This is such a cop out post.

 

Town!Eld dont speak in absolutes like this....only Sith do

 

 

 

 

Zander can you explain why you think it's a cop out, or what you mean by cop out.

 

I'm having trouble here with the correlation between accusing him of copping out and also him speaking in absolutes.

 

Or is the cop out the refusal to ISO you? Which if this is the case why are you voting Eldrick over Iron who also said he doesn't ISO you as a policy. 

[Eldrick4221]

Had to stop and think about who "everyone else" was

 

Cory/clov - As has been already discussed, these are experienced players. I'm gonna have trouble getting a read on them so they will likely be null for a while. Haven't really seen anything that i had an issue with except the tinfoil tmi I mentioned.

Marsh - read hasnt really changed from when I moved him back to null. I think I remember him being mislynched in the past, so also want to give him time to develop.

Cuth - ehhh? He's acting like he did in the last game, and he was a villager there, but he's doing it with people I don't think he knows as well so....I'm not sure how I feel about him

Coward - still waiting for actual game content. Lowest of my nulls.

[Eldrick4221]

NEW AND IMPROVED READS LIST (NOW WITH RAISINS!!!)

 

Town

Linz (duh)

Mmmmmspades - Really liked spades' read list, as I mentioned when she did it. Haven't seen any reason to think this slot as scum. Easily my highest non-confirmed read.

 

Town lean

Darthe - As I just said I liked how he handled his responses to me. I've caught him as scum before on little things, and it's not really something I can describe well. Haven't had an issue with him yet so I'm leaning town.

Fred - Mostly tone. Like his recent posts.

Sooh - I have trouble reading sooh. Liked the tone of the post darthe and I vibed on. Kinda sheeping a bit on other people liking her.

 

Null

Cory/clov - As has been already discussed, these are experienced players. I'm gonna have trouble getting a read on them so they will likely be null for a while. Haven't really seen anything that i had an issue with except the tinfoil tmi I mentioned.

Marsh - read hasnt really changed from when I moved him back to null. I think I remember him being mislynched in the past, so also want to give him time to develop.

Cuth - ehhh? He's acting like he did in the last game, and he was a villager there, but he's doing it with people I don't think he knows as well so....I'm not sure how I feel about him

Coward - still waiting for actual game content. Lowest of my nulls.

 

Scum leans

Zander - Refusing to explain his reasons for sussing bop is irking me. All I want to do is understand, and he's voting me for not already getting it.

Scruff - Pretty sure my reason for this read is obvious. His initial post was bad, but his response to being asked about it was horrible. I explained why people were having issues with his post, and he said I was casting shade. Don't like that he seems to not be reading the thread (as evidenced by his throwing suss at the IC). Best bet for scum today.

[Darthe]

I love all the new players and whatnot but guys im gonna hold off on reading you today unless something really stands out. The game state was better for me to resolve when it was smaller.

[Eldrick4221]

I love all the new players and whatnot but guys im gonna hold off on reading you today unless something really stands out. The game state was better for me to resolve when it was smaller.

So what reads do you have now?

[Fredwood]

I love all the new players and whatnot but guys im gonna hold off on reading you today unless something really stands out. The game state was better for me to resolve when it was smaller.

 

[Eldrick4221]

Awww snap. Aw snap.

Come to our macaroni party then we'll take a nap.

[Darthe]

 

I love all the new players and whatnot but guys im gonna hold off on reading you today unless something really stands out. The game state was better for me to resolve when it was smaller.

So what reads do you have now?

The best reads.

[Eldrick4221]

I don't know why I expected differently.

[Eldrick4221]

Uniiiited. You broke my Taylor guitar.

Uniiiited. Some big help you are.

You broke it you should fix it.

You're liable just admit it.

I should have flown with someone else or GONE BY CAR.

Cuz United breaks guitars.

[Darthe]

No but seriously, this is gonna be on the fly but roughly im at

 

Mrs clov

Eldrick

Sooh

 

Zander

Cordyx

Spades

Cuth

 

New people and marsh sorta share a line

 

 

Scruff

And then if distance is relative about here is where someone would need to be for me to find them actively wolfy. This game doesnt have a ton of unclean.

[Darthe]

 

I love all the new players and whatnot but guys im gonna hold off on reading you today unless something really stands out. The game state was better for me to resolve when it was smaller.

Had this siggy for like three weeks and you're the first person to reference parks and rec. Isnt that sad?

[Eldrick4221]

Is everyone above "new people and marsh" town reads? Where's the town/null/scum lines?

 

I know you sorta explained scum at the end, but even that is unclear.

[Darthe]

I dont think that list is right yet but I think its trending the right way. Dont wanna give yall the whole enchilada yet, just a little appetizer. Just some chips and salsa. Thats all, little baby list with a bit of room to grow.

[Eldrick4221]

Had this siggy for like three weeks and you're the first person to reference parks and rec. Isnt that sad?

Still need to watch that. I've gotten like 2 episodes in.

[Eldrick4221]

I dont think that list is right yet but I think its trending the right way. Dont wanna give yall the whole enchilada yet, just a little appetizer. Just some chips and salsa. Thats all, little baby list with a bit of room to grow.

It's day 1 lol. Partial lists are welcome.

[Darthe]

Yeah it's obviously town to scum, but I think that the best definition for the bottom is "this player has me wary atm". Cause actively a wolf read is below that. And id not call the marsh line null, id call it muddled. Warrants a bit of review, a bit more caution than others, but earned a spot where it is below the other players.

[Cory Caboose]

Morning all

 

See we got some SPICY SUBS

[Darthe]

 

Had this siggy for like three weeks and you're the first person to reference parks and rec. Isnt that sad?

Still need to watch that. I've gotten like 2 episodes in.

Just zkip season one entirely. Makes the whole thing way better.

[Darthe]

Morning all

 

See we got some SPICY SUBS

Also, new players!

[Eldrick4221]

Mmmmm SPICY