[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[DPR]

 

 

 

not a blatant refusal, am just occupied otherwise

 

will do it either before deadline or shortly thereafter, probably

 

Deadline is 10 minutes? 

 

 

I have some quotes, but I'm still comfy with Seph and Cuth fighting today.

 

correct

 

and evidently nobody's around who cares enough to unvote me in the first place

 

it'd be a waste to stop doing what i'm doing right now

 

I'm here and still comfy with voting you unless you give a reason otherwise.

 

 

 

Here's a classic.

 

I'll have more in a bit - gotta run some errands.

[seph]

I may have copied you on that 1... but.stop agreeing with me dpr. It's creepy

[seph]

I need to decide now because running on 19.hrs and no sleep to do this

.

[Ironeyes]

Iron who besides dpr is the last scum?

I'm thinking if DPR is scum his most likely partner is Dice. He's sussing Ed too hard for them to by m/m, since if there are two left we're at LyLo and that isn't the time to bus. Obviously I'm town (and the same point goes for him sussing me, besides), and between the remaining two, he's paying less attention to Dice. ie trying not to draw attention to his partner. 

 

Problem is, Dice has been towny all game, and I prefer to trust his gameplay rather than my speculation about who he could be partners with. That's why I haven't voted him.

[ed2funy]

1. I believed Darthe. I mean, that simple. I'd have to actually go pull quotes to show you what persuaded me. I don't think I was the only one, though? I'd remembered feeling awkwardly alone in believing him.

 

2. I came in late; can't remember if I was busy or sleeping or what, but I didn't have time to get to the thread in time. Also, those notes were just lacking because I didn't flush them out, which I believe I said. Then I got caught up in following then-current thread activities.

 

3. Point that yes those notes/half-case I did on you from d1 have left a bad taste of you in my mouth (heh) that certain posts have prolonged. I've pointed them out and they've kept you toward the top of my list of scum.

Scum can be a *bit* more brazen today and can push harder if they're careful. Which is why our quick vote made me suss you higher again

[ed2funy]

 

No offense, but DPR knows my claim is more valid than anyone's. He even dissed out a dead Tress to throw shade at Zander because he knew Zander's claim was pretty legit (obviously beforehand, it's more difficult than anything to prove, so I'm not trying to say I'm a hard yes townie by proof of some sort). I get that, but so does DPR.

 

Now you're going legit scummish - I don't think your claim is legit at all. I think it's something you and Darthe cooked up and you've been there at every opportunity to sell it. Every. Opportunity.

 

I "dissed" Tress for putting together a tinfoil mess, wasting everyone's time and attention, making it easier for scum to lay low.

 

Zander's claim was easier to prove because it was already proven. Tress saw him. We just didn't know *what* he was.

 

Your claim requires our complete faith. You revealed your schedule after Tress died.

Except it wasn't every opportunity. I first started to try and protect Tress by drawing the NK. Also, I've lied about my exact schedule. I could have picked Even or Odd nights and picked Odd. I mentioned it so much N4 to try to keep the Mafia off of me so I could stay alive and help Town win.

 

You also haven't explained how you think Commuter is opposite Darthe's false Coroner claim in any way. But keep saying it like it'll magically resolve in people's heads.

 

There was no reason to claim my schedule before Tress died. Why would I give thrnmafia more info so they could select who to kill easier????

[seph]

I would like a who so you shoot with dpr.to win the game answer.

 

My opinion if dpr is scum he likely votes his partner and a townie. If scum get lynched he could get some credit to make it the next day alone for the win.

 

If iron is scum he likely tried to preserve his teammate unless they are already under high suss.and his vote can make sense.

 

Ed I think he votes same way as dpr as it is the most logical play for scum as long as it's a vote that just doesn't make sense in any shape or form.

 

I'm rereading dpr, and I might hold off on them not being m/m but I think it is unlikely.

 

Is there anything in particular that (what part of the suss ) makes you think they are not m\m

[seph]

Ed the answers don't make me feel better :(

Can you post what Darth and cuth notes you have?

[ed2funy]

Wtf is m/m?

[DPR]

Presumably Sooh was Town as well.

10 people left, and at least 3 Mafia, depending on other power roles, could be four. We gotta nab scum today.

 

If we Lynch Town, that's 3/9 at EOD, and then 3/8 after Night. if they have 4... well, we gotta Lynch scum today guise.

 

Coming in with some notes and deeper reads soon as I can get on my laptop.

 

Darthe and Tress both have some posting to do.

 

 

The mongering of teh fear.

[ed2funy]

When I get home to my laptop, I can. I'm out and about right now doing errands. Short Term Disability people finally sent me my check for being out of work for almost a month.

[ed2funy]

I'm not gonna lie about how I felt during my posts just to try to make myself look better. Or else I'll end up making up a web of lies I can't crawl out of

[Ironeyes]

Wtf is m/m?

mafia/mafia 

 

Slang for saying two players are scum teammates. 

[Ironeyes]

I would like a who so you shoot with dpr.to win the game answer.

 

My opinion if dpr is scum he likely votes his partner and a townie. If scum get lynched he could get some credit to make it the next day alone for the win.

 

If iron is scum he likely tried to preserve his teammate unless they are already under high suss.and his vote can make sense.

 

Ed I think he votes same way as dpr as it is the most logical play for scum as long as it's a vote that just doesn't make sense in any shape or form.

 

I'm rereading dpr, and I might hold off on them not being m/m but I think it is unlikely.

 

Is there anything in particular that (what part of the suss ) makes you think they are not m\m

Was this @ me?

[ed2funy]

 

Presumably Sooh was Town as well.

10 people left, and at least 3 Mafia, depending on other power roles, could be four. We gotta nab scum today.

 

If we Lynch Town, that's 3/9 at EOD, and then 3/8 after Night. if they have 4... well, we gotta Lynch scum today guise.

 

Coming in with some notes and deeper reads soon as I can get on my laptop.

 

Darthe and Tress both have some posting to do.

 

The mongering of teh fear.

Obvious DPR being obvious. You've been guessing the "game setup" all game but now wanna call it fear monger if. All the while admitting the math makes sense.

[seph]

Yes it was iron

[ed2funy]

 

Wtf is m/m?

mafia/mafia

 

Slang for saying two players are scum teammates.

Thanks, I figured it meant teammates but didn't know what the acronym meant

[Ironeyes]

Yes it was iron

OK, so who I would shoot right now if I could. I believe Ed's claim, so it comes down to you and Dice. That's a hard decision because both of you haven't been as heavily involved in the game, so I have less of a set impression in my head to go by). I'd have to ISO you both and I hate ISOing. 

[seph]

Goin to bed. Ed dpr is the safest way to get 1 mafia in the ring.

Iron ed have the best chance to be m/m and i have them both above dpr.

[unvote]

[V]iron [/v]

 

Iron also has more equity to be with dpr than ed imo.

 

If it's dpr and Ed it's probably gg cause voting them both would be difficult for me

[seph]

I have a strong case on ed I think.

But iron might be the safer bet??? I'm just not sure.and I think I'm banking on dpr being town

[DPR]

 

 

No offense, but DPR knows my claim is more valid than anyone's. He even dissed out a dead Tress to throw shade at Zander because he knew Zander's claim was pretty legit (obviously beforehand, it's more difficult than anything to prove, so I'm not trying to say I'm a hard yes townie by proof of some sort). I get that, but so does DPR.

 

 

Now you're going legit scummish - I don't think your claim is legit at all. I think it's something you and Darthe cooked up and you've been there at every opportunity to sell it. Every. Opportunity.

 

I "dissed" Tress for putting together a tinfoil mess, wasting everyone's time and attention, making it easier for scum to lay low.

 

Zander's claim was easier to prove because it was already proven. Tress saw him. We just didn't know *what* he was.

 

Your claim requires our complete faith. You revealed your schedule after Tress died.

The problem I'm running Into dpr is why would two scum make up pr roles that would obviously throw off game balance. Arm with the reveals it doesn't see that unbalanced which is why I'm confused

 

 

The "why" is something I don't have figured out. 

 

Why did Darthe choose Coroner? We haven't seen another Janitor shot. When would he have been able to use it? I get where it would have come in real handy if there was/is another Janitor shot, which I've been waiting for, which was why I jumped when Liz posted those results.

 

Commuter is much easier to figure because it gives town cover, it explains why he never dies and he can play silly games with when he's out. 

 

Why would they both claim? Dunno. Because it's too outrageous to suspect? Because they have a lurker as backup? Dunno. 

 

 

 

No offense, but DPR knows my claim is more valid than anyone's. He even dissed out a dead Tress to throw shade at Zander because he knew Zander's claim was pretty legit (obviously beforehand, it's more difficult than anything to prove, so I'm not trying to say I'm a hard yes townie by proof of some sort). I get that, but so does DPR.

 

Now you're going legit scummish - I don't think your claim is legit at all. I think it's something you and Darthe cooked up and you've been there at every opportunity to sell it. Every. Opportunity.

 

I "dissed" Tress for putting together a tinfoil mess, wasting everyone's time and attention, making it easier for scum to lay low.

 

Zander's claim was easier to prove because it was already proven. Tress saw him. We just didn't know *what* he was.

 

Your claim requires our complete faith. You revealed your schedule after Tress died.

Except it wasn't every opportunity. I first started to try and protect Tress by drawing the NK. Also, I've lied about my exact schedule. I could have picked Even or Odd nights and picked Odd. I mentioned it so much N4 to try to keep the Mafia off of me so I could stay alive and help Town win.

 

You also haven't explained how you think Commuter is opposite Darthe's false Coroner claim in any way. But keep saying it like it'll magically resolve in people's heads.

 

There was no reason to claim my schedule before Tress died. Why would I give thrnmafia more info so they could select who to kill easier????

 

 

Look, if you were planning to claim Commuter, part of that would be to breadcrumb trying to divert the NK. 

 

Lying about your exact schedule benefits you as mafia as well. That way it could be any night...

 

I also have questions: at some point you made a big deal to point out you were not claiming doc - was that before or after N3 (no kill that night). 

 

See, you have full latitude to say it was any night. Makes a perfect cover for a night when there is no kill...

 

You laid it all out a bit too thick.

 

 

 

Presumably Sooh was Town as well.

10 people left, and at least 3 Mafia, depending on other power roles, could be four. We gotta nab scum today.

 

If we Lynch Town, that's 3/9 at EOD, and then 3/8 after Night. if they have 4... well, we gotta Lynch scum today guise.

 

Coming in with some notes and deeper reads soon as I can get on my laptop.

 

Darthe and Tress both have some posting to do.

 

The mongering of teh fear.

Obvious DPR being obvious. You've been guessing the "game setup" all game but now wanna call it fear monger if. All the while admitting the math makes sense.

 

 

 

There were never 4. That's the kind of talk that makes it easier to push a mislynch. Nice try though. 

[Ironeyes]

Goin to bed. Ed dpr is the safest way to get 1 mafia in the ring.

Iron ed have the best chance to be m/m and i have them both above dpr.

[unvote]

[V]iron [/v]

 

Iron also has more equity to be with dpr than ed imo.

 

If it's dpr and Ed it's probably gg cause voting them both would be difficult for me

I think you have to specify which person you're unvoting. 

 

Also I disagree with you writing off the chance of DPR being scum. That's the sort of move I expect from someone's teammate at lylo

[seph]

It would be worth more to focus on darthes teammate than a unknowns teammate.

 

You and Ed both have dpr as scum. And I have ed as my lowest and you around dpr. Though I think I vote you over him, I do think he is town

 

The best chance I get scum in the fight is with you and ed, so that's who I'm going to be pushing.

[DPR]

Just to keep things in focus, my top for scum:

 

1. ed

2. Iron

3. Seph

4. dice

[DPR]

 

Goin to bed. Ed dpr is the safest way to get 1 mafia in the ring.

Iron ed have the best chance to be m/m and i have them both above dpr.

[unvote]

[V]iron [/v]

 

Iron also has more equity to be with dpr than ed imo.

 

If it's dpr and Ed it's probably gg cause voting them both would be difficult for me

I think you have to specify which person you're unvoting. 

 

Also I disagree with you writing off the chance of DPR being scum. That's the sort of move I expect from someone's teammate at lylo

 

 

Iron, will you list your top for scum? Reasons wouldn't go amiss - you've been a bit tight-lipped with those.