mb
-
Posts
5343 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Store
Gallery
Blogs
News
Downloads
Events
Posts posted by mb
-
-
I do not recall Galad claiming any character stupid/wrong either in thought or in speech.
Galad to me seems to think things through before saying/doing anything.
about Egwene; she does not seem to be a know-it-all to me either.
-
Elaida seemed like-able (at least partly) until Shadow Rising.
and her treachery/cowardliness seemed to start long before the Sanderson books. treachery, I think deposing Siuan; cowardliness, I think mostly her commands in books 5 through 11 and into the Sanderson books (she never attempted to do any of those things herself).
-
actually, each reader's reason/reasons could be different. and I recall some readers that seemed to dislike him after his first POV; if I recall correctly, those were around books 10 & 11.
from what I recall of the first books, he seemed to change quite a bit before his first POV; so his thoughts could have been different in his earlier scenes.
Books 10&11?
Mat's first PoV is chapter 19 of The Dragon Reborn when he wakes up.
Up till that point we had only seen Mat though someone else's eyes and, except for a handful of chapters in the beginning, a tainted Matt at that.
was referring to the things the readers disliked about Mat; not Mat's first POV.
shall edit the post.
-
actually, each reader's reason/reasons could be different. and I recall some readers that seemed to dislike him after his first POV; if I recall correctly, the things those readers disliked were around books 10 & 11.
from what I recall of the first books, he seemed to change quite a bit before his first POV; so his thoughts could have been different in his earlier scenes.
-
Elmindreda; the girly-girl phase of Min? I can see how that would be hate-able (or dislike-able).
Lini; main reason for a reader to hate/dislike her I would guess would be her various sayings. or possibly her trying to hitch Morgase & Tallanvor.
by the way, I do not hate any of those characters/actions.
-
about whitecloak hate; my impression was (and is) that the attack gave reason to hate that group. not necessarily more reason to hate Aes Sedia in general.
more reason to suspect; it seems to me that the attack did not change whitecloak's level of suspicion.
about Egwene being jealous; from what I recall of those scenes, she did not express any jealousy in thought or speech or action. I recall only concern in those scenes towards Rand. and I do not recall Min being mentioned within any character's thought or speech in those scenes.
-
only told where the info would be; not the info itself. like other posts of mine in this thread; and the original poster seemed to not think of "too much" being revealed with those posts.
-
Noam; the last books reveal stuff about him.
your question about Perrin's future; part of the answer is revealed in the same set of chapters. the rest, in the last books.
-
I'll try to be more careful from now on.
-
next time we see Egwene and Nynaeve I think is several chapters from where you are at.
Min's next on-screen appearance is in next book.
next time Min & Egwene are together I think is in the last book; though only for short periods of time.
Masema is spelled right.
-
from going through the scene, it seems to me that Perrin did not summon the wolves at that time. but he will in later books.
Leya; it seems to me that there was not much Perrin (or anyone) could have done. and it seems to me that Perrin did try to step up but was too late.
-
the original poster has told in several posts to not be provided specifics.
also, anyone's understanding about anything can be influenced.
-
from what I recall of this book, Rand's POVs in this book occur in between 2 other "main" characters; until the end of the book.
Sorry. Been sick with stomach flu. Haven't done much reading.
I think sickness would be a good time for reading; for anyone.
edit:: anyone able to read.
-
As I learned from Ingtar, you never know who can be trusted so I'll be having a weary eye towards any new characters from here on.
a better basis for judging any character ("new" or "old") would be their actions.
-
the identity of Bors is revealed in book 4.
Ingtar was at the Darkfriend gathering.
-
I recall several book series that have more than 1 author. James Bond; Left Behind (though it was co-authored); Infinity Ring; Dr Who. and maybe Sherlock Homes.
some chance of Robert Jordan's ghostwritten book not published by Tor/Forge; especially if any of his other books (under any name) were published by different company/companies.
to the original poster:: could you provide the link of the Wikipedia page?
-
wiki sites; I would trust mainly the stuff they tell the source of. also the stuff other sources repeat.
not much beyond those.
-
the 4 month portal stone trip; the books do not explicitly tell the visions of the others, but we get hints of one other character's towards the end of the book.
Liandrin; several things are revealed about her in about several chapters from where you are at. and more in upcoming books.
Fain's next on-screen appearance I think is within several chapters; but I do not quite remember.
you are not wrong about Black Ajah; their first on-screen appearance I think was in Great Hunt's Prologue.
edit:: the identities of some of that chapter's characters and the identities of various Black Ajah characters are revealed throughout the series.
-
the paperback release of New Spring (novel) was in 2004; which was between Crossroads of Twilight (2003) and Knife of Dreams (2005). those are books 10 & 11 respectively.
my first time through the prequel was at the start of my second time through the series.
-
trollocs; found the scene last night.
Shadow Rising; at the Stone, after Rind picked up Callandor from his room.
do not recall it happening to any human character.
-
love/hate/like/dislike/etc can differ between different readers and between different times through.
me; I pretty much liked both Perrin and Mat in all my times through.
-
first on-screen appearance of Rand's 3rd lover I think is in book 3. later books give more clues.
some later scene in book 2 gives an indicator of her; chapter 37.
about Nynaeve's hatred of Moiraine; scenes you already read kind of give Nynaeve's reasons. Moiraine taking the boys and Egwene out of Two Rivers; and Nynaeve feeling responsible for the safety of those 4 (she was their Wisdom). Nynaeve's arrival at Baerlon and her discussion right after Shadar Logoth are the scenes I am referring to.
Selene; book 4 confirms several things about her.
-
from my understanding, the Companion is based on what was originally intended. I recall another thread mentioning some differences between Companion and books; one being Bela's fate.
edit::
in books she dies; in companion she retires to some farm.
-
from re-reading the scene, fire came out of Aginor's mouth and eyes. not sure if Rand could have caused that at any time; or any channeler.
as far as I recall; Fire always started outside of its victims.
A First Time Reader's Impression of The Wheel of Time
in Wheel of Time Books
Posted
where are you in Song of Ice & Fire? I read through book 4.
Wheel of Time has had violence up to where you are; mostly towards fictional creatures and mostly in battle.