I think right now I'm feel mostly okay with leelou, hallia, maybe darthe because he's at least been around and asking questions.  i've never seen mafia darthe, but idk if mafia darthe wouldn't bother mentioning being annoyed about people not posting and he seems like he's trying to sort people out.

I think leelou and hallia have both felt pretty natural/comfortable in the thread and particularly in leelou's case, i'm not sure someone coming back from a 3 year mafia hiatus would necessarily vibe that way as mafia.  That said, i have no idea if they have an alignment preference or if they are exceptionally good as mafia, so lmk if that's a bad take.

AJ seems ~okay, but he definitely fooled me pretty hard in Corey's game when he was teamed with hallia.  I think it's a ~good look for him to question some of the town reads on him, especially if he thinks they aren't deserved.

zander is zander.  He seems okay so far.  Nothing he's doing seems particularly agenday, but it's still early.  I feel like the game I spectated, I got more...idk...slippery vibes from him later in the game.  @Hallia do you have a decent track record reading zander?  What about darthe? 

Chris is hard for me to read because he and I think similarly and sounds reasonable as either alignment, so I tend to judge him based on his actions more than what he says.

3 hours ago, Zander? said:

 

I can answer this lol

Go ahead if you want since Darthe answered.

3 minutes ago, Darthe said:

Clov would have wolf equity for early baseless WIM, right?  Somewhere mid-late game that flips and we expect that WIM from townie him though iirc? I'm honestly asking, that read's so old it can legally drink.

I do think he cares more about thread control as wolf than he does as town.  As town he cares more about being right.

8 minutes ago, Darthe said:

G2H so far, let me toss out something I hesitate to even call a reads list.  Let's say an impressions list.

 

Feelin familiar/comfortable

Whiskey Delta

Zander

Hally

Leelou

 

familiar but unsure

Clov

Dice 

Cory

 

really no impressions/wary

Tripped

Sinister

Voodoo

Verb

 

 

Do you think AJ or Zander being comfortable in the thread is AI?

1 minute ago, Zander? said:

 

Oh ya my post count NAI for me but there's many other tells....I could list thrm vht im sure youd like others to answer that prolly if youre a Villa too

I think the last game we played i was able to eventually get to a town read on you towards the end of D1.  the first game we played was...well...something lol.  let's just say being in F3 with zander isn't the most fun i've ever had in a mafia game where the mafia were "cleared" mechanically (spoiler: mafia was not cleared).

Just now, Zander? said:

 

Yes it to Hallia....I mean she CAN take it a bit early for awhile as Wolf....especially if she's on a good Wolf team or has a strong friend or player with her but generally a realxed Hallia is a Villagery Hallia.

I did consider that might change depending on who she is wolfing with, but I think the game Chris and I caught her in Corey's lawyer game, she was teamed with AJ so idk.

Just now, Zander? said:

 

What's youre read on me?  Why?

 

Also is relaxed Hallia AI of her for you?

I don't have a read on you because I know you can high post as either alignment, and I think i've only played with town!you.  I spectated one game where you were a wolf, but that was forever ago.

and yeah, I think town!hallia is more likely to be relaxed, but i've only played against mafia!hallia once and it was quite awhile ago.  Do you think hallia being relaxed is AI?

5 minutes ago, Hallia said:

What vibes did her response give you

I agreed with her that you seemed relaxed.  beyond that, without having any meta on her, she seems fine/comfortable in the thread.

1 minute ago, Hallia said:

 

Why do you wanna talk about me?

I wanted to know why leelou said you seemed fine.  it was less about you and more about leelou.

Just now, Clovdyx said:

 

I'd say remind me in postgame about the comment I made to myself while searching for those, but you're just going to use it to incriminate me.

that doesn't sound like something I would do

2 minutes ago, Clovdyx said:

 

You randed mafia, didn't you?

 

</4

1 minute ago, Clovdyx said:

 

...

This is not helping me change my mind about the taylor swift thing lol

28 minutes ago, Leelou said:

I hear that lol 

 

How long has AJ had the changed name, who are VooDoo and Tripped? Do they have play styles? 

I've played a few games here, but i haven't played mafia in over a year.  I don't think i've played more than 2 games with anyone here except Chris and maybe Hallia (i think i've played 3 maaaaybe 4 games with her?).

24 minutes ago, Leelou said:

Dice obv sleeping. Cory way too quiet. Hallia seems decent. On the fence about Chris. And tbh I always think AJ is scum

Talk to me about Hallia.

Wait...is wiskeydelta AJ?

7 minutes ago, Clovdyx said:

Literally couldn't care any less about Leelou's unvote but think Darthe's reaction to it is probably townie?  

 

If you're feeling froggy, Darthe is like 95% town and 5% scum with Zander specifically.

I didn't take Darthe's vote on you initially as particularly serious but then he kind of doubled down on it so then I wasn't sure.  Do you think town!darthe is more likely to vote you right out of the gate than wolf!darthe?

RIP mentioning no longer sleeping

Just now, SinisterDeath said:

First word you used is on an auto-mod approval because people can't be nice, so we can't have nice things.

I did think that was potentially the problem, thanks for the clarification 

Also not sure why my last post needs moderator approval???

Woke up and checked the thread, saw it was at 3 pages and thought to myself, Zander must have checked in lol

2 minutes ago, Clovdyx said:

 

You spelled first wrong.

I was thinking it.  I was not going to say it.

First.

I am also here to play a game of mafia, assuming I remember how to play.