NVM VERBAL GOATED

HE DID ITHI ONE SEC LET ME FIND

He messed up 😂😂😂 omg if he couldn't deliver himself on a silver platter any better.

He just said "Yeah I made reasonable choices for the character -> role associations"

Thats a spy 😂

Trust your gut, Ed is by far the better vote, and is so clearly mafia, its ok to take the slight risk. Mafia voting is not a risk free game, and voting some potentially town because the scummiest scum threw out an obvious bad claim is not the move

I believe DPR, he gave great proof of his character, and hider will always cc since he can hide. Dice, while Ive been sus, has reasonable chance of being true, he started cc-ing before it became a thing, and has some logic in his votes. Also cop can cc at some time and we'll see what to do. Doc cant CC. It falls to the rest of us to call out the fake doc claims, that are done so obviously/desperately

Cmon Zander work with me here. Ed is bad, very bad, and he should be voted out now. All the signs point to it

What am I showing the breadcrumb of?

Dice lets take our squabbles out the picture and focus on the probability, the fake claiminess of Ed strolling in at the perfect right before time, the learnings I had at the end of day 1 that I am utilizing now, and the doc being the perfect claim

You were so close to the truth

Murder me if Im wrong lol, Im done with this bs

Maybe this time we should be making a strong exception for such an obvious untrue case. Im telling you, put it on my head if Im wrong

We're not gonna get a doc cc, they would die immediately after, they can't self protect. I knew this from the start, so did ed, and he's trying to exploit it. This is the next closest thing. Caught him lurking, awful claim, 3rd one in a row.

Come on Dice, think about it, you should be voting for Ed. He was following along the votes for 30 minutes before hopping in with his lame ass Im the doc

He is lying, and if Im wrong, you can kick me next, on my momma

Finding all 3 roles back to back to back (IE didn't get a chance to counterclaim) would be (3/13 * 2/11 * 1/10) = 3/715 = 1/272. It DID NOT HAPPEN

If this is wrong, I swear I'll take the blame, but this is getting f'ing ridiculous

Except we've already had the cop, and hider claim, both when about to die. This is the straw that breaks the camels back

This is as close to CCed as it gets, we HAVE NOT found all 3 roles in town in a row, the odds are SIGNIFICANTLY lower than mafia false claiming

Ed was also reading this thread when I started my re-read some 20-30 minutes ago btw

So sick and tired of this claim whatever you want strategy.

Vote: Ed Not falling for a 3rd one of these bs-es and this one rings the least true. We haven't stumbled across all 3 roles

Ugh tried to catch up on a bathroom break, work things breaking, but I got in time to at least unvote Waste of my D2 fml, I get what DPR's strat was, but imo mafia will want to kill off townie town more than aggressors, unless he aggressed the right ppl. Valid strategy, but makes me reset here. Initial voteable suspects are Ithi, Tigs, and Ed. Caught up to page 65, will catch up more after

Still waiting for a response on this? I've reformatted to my original in plain, your response in italics, and my response to those in bold * Why are you discounting the world where doctor believes the above and decides to protect someone else? * Why are you discounting the world where mafia knows doctor may believe the above, and try to not use their strongman shot on D1, and see if they can get a safe kill on cop (and maybe doc did protect Dice) Because mafia want to win - they already know that dice would never false claim cop if he was town, so if he’s not mafia, they will strongman him every time. It’s a game winning move - why do anything else? This is not nearly as straightforward as mafia just kills cop all the time, and I'm concerned that this is the angle that you're taking because you should be smart enough to delve deeper here. The cop is useless when known because they have a roleblocker (albeit using their roleblocker every night, but now with 100% success as opposed to like a 22% chance to get doc or hider, and 11% if they can't affect the hider. Additionally, the cop is pulling a lot of suss energy, so it'd be good for mafia to keep that around if that's the case, even if he won't be voted for yet. * Why, when you were obviously online during the deadline yesterday, and Verbal, Dice, IE, and myself were scrambling to figure out the best decision to move forward when Dice caused complete chaos by first soft hinting a power role within the last hour, and hard claiming cop 2 min before deadline? Town is trying to help out as much as possible during the deadline, and you were useless I was watching. Why do I want to disrupt players from showing us who they really are? Having a spasm doesn’t help the town. No, but providing insight into whether someone is soft/hard claiming fr or lying when they're about to die, being available to help build alternate trains instead of laying back and letting a train build out of desperation on IE, and putting your concrete thoughts down before flip are all good for town. Observing and doing nothing is scummy, since it suggests you have more knowledge of you enjoying what's going on, and trying not to disrupt it by interrupting.