[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

[Lenlo]

I disagree completely that wolves have to be absent/lazy, since so many people didn't vote yesterday. I'd be.more inclined to believe the opposite, that wolves took a direct hand in yesterday's lynch since wolves generally, at least for me, have a higher case of WiM and knowledge of what's going on.

 

It's still probably not true, but that's where I would lean. Especially since it was the weekend.

[Lenlo]

AJ and mrsclov are likely town yes, but get less and less so each day that goes by, entirely because of deepwolf equity. I find it doubtful that anyone here except AJ or Darthe would think it a good idea as a wolf to let those to live, because it gets an easy F3/5 lynch. That's a big gamble that AJ/Mrsclov doesn't find the wolves before that point and I don't think most would risk it.

 

On phone, forgive spelling errors.

[Lenlo]

Unless of those two were town reading the wolf team. In which case it's a safer bet.

 

Requires thinking

[Eldrick4221]

Unless of those two were town reading the wolf team. In which case it's a safer bet.

 

Requires thinking

That's a good point.

[Andrej]

Unless of those two were town reading the wolf team. In which case it's a safer bet.

 

Requires thinking

Could be. Or Bop was correct in his reads or someone wants us to think that. It's all speculation.

[Lenlo]

 

Unless of those two were town reading the wolf team. In which case it's a safer bet.

 

Requires thinking

Could be. Or Bop was correct in his reads or someone wants us to think that. It's all speculation.

 

Exactly, its all speculation, but some speculation has greater... leverage(?) behind it. Either way, you two are no longer 100% guaranteed oh sweet jesus to be town. Your in the 80% for me atm. Its also possible one of you is a wolf leaving the other alive and gambling on a 50/50 end game scenario of getting the other lynched.

[Verbal32]

 

2.  @Marsh - why are you so focused on 1 detail (me sussing you), while I'm trying to figure out multiple slots on the roster?  Tunnel vision ain't a good thing, yo.

If you think my problem with you is that you've sussed me, then you misunderstand me completely. You don't notice me biting MrsClov's head off, or Niniel's. They've both sussed me in recent pages, but they did it in a towny way. You did it in a scummy way. 

 

 

Yeah no

 

You're saying I ignored you, but I didn't.  If you can tell me exactly how I was scummy, then perhaps I can respond.

[Verbal32]

Still not sure how I feel about Verb. As I said before it's bugging me that he's using the term "casting shade" to describe his own actions, because that's a phrase I attribute to scum.

 

But the fact that he's saying it about himself makes the issue confusing.

 

Then ask yourself an easy question:  does it make sense for me to do that as scum?  Or are you perhaps nitpicking and making a mountain out of a molehill?

[Verbal32]

Just a question for all of you before I have to leave. There were only two trains yesterday and we know Nolder was town. What do that mean for Verb (who was the other train) and those that never voted at all? Just something I would like your thoughts on when I come back tomorrow. 

 

Oohhh, a soft push for me.  I like it - I bet you come back tomorrow and continue to push this angle.  :-)

[Andrej]

I'm just gonna run down the roster because I don't feel like we're any closer to getting something done and while waiting on people to post, when they finally do, there's not much to it.

 

MrsClov - solid posting throughout D1. Second vote on Hallia wagon before it became a popular vote. Completely unprompted for the case work leading up to it. Don't lynch.

 

Dice - first one to vote Hallia D1. Tone is a little different than I am used to and normally there are a couple of posts I could point at to say "this is Town dice" which I don't recall off the top of my head. I'll need to iso him and reevaluate. Hasn't been posting much and doesn't seem as aggressive as I'm used to. Could just be busy. Still gets points for being first to vote Hallia. Wouldn't lynch today.

 

Nini - not a ton of posts. Mostly catch ups and reads list so it's hard to judge her real time actions. Voted Nolder D1 for ~okay reasons and stayed there until the Wifi wagon popped up and then switched. Tied the wagons of Wifi/Hallia at 4. Voted Verb D2. Like I've said before, I don't think they will be w/w. T/T I'm not sure of yet. I'd consider lynching here.

 

Lenlo - had a decent start. Pushed Wifi early on and stayed there all of D1. Next to nothing since then. I'd consider lynching here.

 

Verb - had good tone early on. Claims to have been suspicious of both Wifi and Hallia but put Wifi in the lead coming towards DL. Has Nini/Marsh as scum from what I've gathered. Would consider lynching here.

 

Eldrick - jumpy and hard to follow at times. He makes comments that I completely disagree with on a philosophical level but I can't attest to that being scummy or a difference in theory. Avoided both wagons D1 and voted Darthe instead. D2 didn't want to lynch Verb because he wouldn't be around but happily voted Nolder who flipped Town. Questionable. Might consider lynching here although had him as one of her sole scum reads D1.

 

Darthe - early claim was null. Showed decent progress later before voting Nolder for D1. Hasn't been around much since then. Openly defended by Hallia and another Town read she assigned easily. Might consider lynching.

 

Marsh - need to ISO because I don't have a firm grasp on his play yet. Voted Wifi D1 to "even the trains a little" and then swapped to Eldrick later after Wifi's claim. Questionable. Don't see him and Verb as w/w either.

[Verbal32]

AJ and mrsclov are likely town yes, but get less and less so each day that goes by, entirely because of deepwolf equity. I find it doubtful that anyone here except AJ or Darthe would think it a good idea as a wolf to let those to live, because it gets an easy F3/5 lynch. That's a big gamble that AJ/Mrsclov doesn't find the wolves before that point and I don't think most would risk it.

 

On phone, forgive spelling errors.

 

The way you word that, one would think you're saying only AJ or MrsClov are actually scumhunting......

[MrsClov]

Verbal's looking a bit better to me this day phase. Not convinced he's town yet, but still leaning more towards Niniel and Iron at the moment. Lenlo could be a possible alternate, but I find it less likely.  It still seems too easy for both remaining scum to be in that four.  Not sure who I'd put as deep wolf yet.

[Verbal32]

Well, I did put some gel in my hair and trimmed the beard a little, so thank you!!

[Verbal32]

Oh wait, mafia.....right.

[MrsClov]

Well, I did put some gel in my hair and trimmed the beard a little, so thank you!!

Thank you for coming to the thread presentable then.

[Verbal32]

I do what I can.

[Eldrick4221]

 

AJ and mrsclov are likely town yes, but get less and less so each day that goes by, entirely because of deepwolf equity. I find it doubtful that anyone here except AJ or Darthe would think it a good idea as a wolf to let those to live, because it gets an easy F3/5 lynch. That's a big gamble that AJ/Mrsclov doesn't find the wolves before that point and I don't think most would risk it.

 

On phone, forgive spelling errors.

The way you word that, one would think you're saying only AJ or MrsClov are actually scumhunting......

That's not how I read it at all. I read it as paranoia that one of them is wolf and we will end up at f3 with both of them alive because of it.

 

And it's a very good point imo. The longer they both continue to live, the better the chance is that one of them is scum.

[MrsClov]

With all of this talk about me still being alive, now I know how Clov feels in games. :( 

[Andrej]

The more you guys talk about one of us being a deep wolf the more incentive the actual scum have to keep us alive if we mislynch again today.

 

Table it for now.

[MrsClov]

The more you guys talk about one of us being a deep wolf the more incentive the actual scum have to keep us alive if we mislynch again today.

 

Table it for now.

^^^^^

[Eldrick4221]

The more you guys talk about one of us being a deep wolf the more incentive the actual scum have to keep us alive if we mislynch again today.

 

Table it for now.

This assumes both that neither of you are a deep wolf and that we mislynch today. Neither assumption I'm willing to make.

[MrsClov]

Leaning towards Eldrick or Darthe IF there's a deep wolf, but would rather vote within the four I already mentioned. I think there's a lot more information to gain in that pile right now.

[Andrej]

 

The more you guys talk about one of us being a deep wolf the more incentive the actual scum have to keep us alive if we mislynch again today.

 

Table it for now.

This assumes both that neither of you are a deep wolf and that we mislynch today. Neither assumption I'm willing to make.

Then don't. It doesn't detract from my point though

[Eldrick4221]

And the point Lenlo made, which I agree with is that if one of you is a deep wolf, and this gets to f3 with you, Mrsclov, and someone else, that it could be a difficult situation.

 

I have said and stand by the statement that I am going to work with my POE before I even consider you guys. Talking about your deep wolf equity doesn't change that. If you are both town and scum wants to continue to keep you alive, by all means let them.

[Lenlo]

The more you guys talk about one of us being a deep wolf the more incentive the actual scum have to keep us alive if we mislynch again today.

 

Table it for now.

How do you know thats not my plan? A con within a con?