[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

[Eldrick4221]

It's actually what stuck out the most while I was digging up those posts, so that's a thing.

[MrsClov]

 

verbal,

 

haven't gotten a response from wifi yet about hallia

 

Ok, thanks.  I also don't recall any type of defense from Hallia, seeing as she's the main train with < a day left until DL.  Hmm.

There wasn't one. If it was just this one incident I might chock it up to the weird page thing preventing her in some fashion, but she had said she found Nolder and Eldrick scummy. I tried to get her to elaborate on it, but she said she was waiting for some responses from them and never followed up on that either.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

verbal,

 

haven't gotten a response from wifi yet about hallia

 

 

Ok, thanks.  I also don't recall any type of defense from Hallia, seeing as she's the main train with < a day left until DL.  Hmm.

There wasn't one. If it was just this one incident I might chock it up to the weird page thing preventing her in some fashion, but she had said she found Nolder and Eldrick scummy. I tried to get her to elaborate on it, but she said she was waiting for some responses from them and never followed up on that either.

Not sure what response she wanted. I asked her directly about it and got nothing in return.

[Eldrick4221]

Interesting to note. Nolder and I suss darthe. Hally defends darthe and susses us.

 

Might be something.

[MrsClov]

 

 

 

verbal,

 

haven't gotten a response from wifi yet about hallia

 

Ok, thanks.  I also don't recall any type of defense from Hallia, seeing as she's the main train with < a day left until DL.  Hmm.

There wasn't one. If it was just this one incident I might chock it up to the weird page thing preventing her in some fashion, but she had said she found Nolder and Eldrick scummy. I tried to get her to elaborate on it, but she said she was waiting for some responses from them and never followed up on that either.

Not sure what response she wanted. I asked her directly about it and got nothing in return.

 

 

I think that adds to the concern about her not following up then.

[Eldrick4221]

If hally dors indeed flip scum I'm sticking to darthe tomorrow unless something huge happens.

[Andrej]

I hate blind lynching.

[Eldrick4221]

 

I think that adds to the concern about her not following up then.

Of course. That's why I mentioned it.

[bopolis]

i agree about darthe being a concern if hallia does end up being scum for level 1 reasons

[Eldrick4221]

I hate blind lynching.

And your solution is?

 

I'm currently voting darthe. Do you have an issue with that train?

 

Who would you suggest?

[Eldrick4221]

Also, you are voting Hally. If you hate it so much, why are you still on her train?

[Eldrick4221]

It's also not a blind lynch. She has had ample time to reply and hasn't. It's not like she just got this far.

[Andrej]

Easy there kiddo.

 

I'm voting Hallia for a good enough reason, I would've just preferred to hear from her and we likely won't today

[Eldrick4221]

Your statement just felt strong, and out of place once I thought about it.

[Eldrick4221]

Anyway I'm heading to bed now. Might be up for DL

[Lenlo]

Have to say, I did like Eldricks remaking of pg 23. Its alot of effort that I dont see anyone making unless they really care about the solve. Wolves typically wouldnt have that level of care.

[Andrej]

However you wanna chalk it up, it's a blind lynch. Say what you want about how her not responding or following up looks worse (I don't disagree) but I still would've liked something. I don't nail scum D1 with 100% accuracy and without hearing from her there's no way to reconsider or reaffirm my suspicions. So if that doesn't make you nervous then I'd say that's a little suspect.

[Andrej]

@Dice - you're just going to have to get over it. I likely won't be fully trusting your slot for a long time yet. It has been a long time where I have actually played with you without knowing your alignment beforehand. I'm pretty much never ever getting lynched this game so before you try to twist it on me with the "he's supposed to read me well" angle I'd suggest you put in a fork in it now.

[bopolis]

Have to say, I did like Eldricks remaking of pg 23. Its alot of effort that I dont see anyone making unless they really care about the solve. Wolves typically wouldnt have that level of care.

 

 

If he made a comment about the content on page 23 I could see giving him a village read  but since he didn't comment on it until prompted a little while ago I don't think it means anything. Just alot of busywork and it's a type of busy work i've seen people do as wolves in the past for village credit(example, in larger games i've played in wlvs would make death charts or claim charts or some other type of thing chronicling something in game to make it look like they are doing work and contributing. i've even done it myself). It could be good solely for eldrick but i dont have the experience with him to make that call.

[Verbal32]

i agree about darthe being a concern if hallia does end up being scum for level 1 reasons

 

What does this mean?

[bopolis]

 

i agree about darthe being a concern if hallia does end up being scum for level 1 reasons

 

What does this mean?

 

 

level 1 reason is the most basic reasoning for a read basically(some say level 0 but i start at 1)

 

so if someone flips wolf, people they are pushing look good and people they are defending look back on the first most basic level.

 

Then you take into account other things like their past history, what they have done previously(ie are they a busser) and how the people theyre interacting with are contributing and then you make a more informed read.

 

so hallia flipping wolf would look bad for darthe on the most basic level because of her defense of darthe 

[MrsClov]

Interesting to note. Nolder and I suss darthe. Hally defends darthe and susses us.

 

Might be something.

Might be worth looking into after a flip. Not prepared to completely link them off of "Darthe being Darthe" though when several others said similar things.

[MrsClov]

Is Eldrick usually this jumpy?

[Lenlo]

 

Have to say, I did like Eldricks remaking of pg 23. Its alot of effort that I dont see anyone making unless they really care about the solve. Wolves typically wouldnt have that level of care.

 

 

If he made a comment about the content on page 23 I could see giving him a village read  but since he didn't comment on it until prompted a little while ago I don't think it means anything. Just alot of busywork and it's a type of busy work i've seen people do as wolves in the past for village credit(example, in larger games i've played in wlvs would make death charts or claim charts or some other type of thing chronicling something in game to make it look like they are doing work and contributing. i've even done it myself). It could be good solely for eldrick but i dont have the experience with him to make that call.

 

I guess. I just dont think someone who is a wolf would put that effort in unless they really needed it to avoid a lynch, and Eldrick isnt even close to being lynched.

 

Im not town reading him for it btw, it was just something that bumped my read of him alittle. Doesnt offset his early game.

[Andrej]

How's that middle ground Lenlo?