[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

[Eldrick4221]

So I will try again without the quotes...

 

@AJ, IRT my response to his voting/unvoting Darthe

 

The quotes were not to say I thought you did it on purpose. I stupidly used them for emphasis.

 

I have given some thought into why it bugged me, and it's because if you were talking about him or to him (i.e. on your qt) then the wrong name would be in your head when you typed the post.

 

It's admittedly a small thing, but dropping wrong names is worth attention.

 

@Darthe IRT him calling Watcher a weak power as response to my sussing and voting him

 

I agree that watcher is a weak power, but it is effectively our cop this game. They just need to watch the victim, not look for the killer.

 

My issue was with you wanting to talk about you being the role, who believes it or not and why. This directly leads to talking about how to figure out who the watcher is, which is why it was a problem for me.

 

Talking about who is the watcher in any form isn't a towny idea.

 

(FTR I treated AJ's response to your claim as a mimicy joke. He wasn't pushing for us to discuss it like you were)

 

@Hally IRT her saying she is reading Nolder and me scummy

 

Care to share with the class why?

 

Also to Hally IRT defending Darthe because he has given reads

 

Your defense of him is noted. I don't get why you are defending him so strongly.

 

It's also not weird that others hadn't yet, nor is it towny that he did.

[Andrej]

Just for emphasis so you can see better where I'm coming from:

 

Demonology

 

Unvote Vote Darthe

  

 

 

Unvote Vote Darthe

 

 

Dare I ask?

Saw a quote saying he wasn't paying attention.

Unless the quote was altered it seems like as good a reason as any.

 

Also I don't like him.

 

 

This game

 

[v]Darthe[/v]

 

See you guys tomorrow.

  

 

How much of that is personal bias Nold? Or is it because of his claim? I'm legit curious, not trying to be a smarty pants.

 

If he gives me a good reason I will vote him every time.

 

Tell me claiming Watcher D1 is anything but anti town behavior.

Nothing good can come of it.

 

 

Not a perfect match but close enough in reason/tone that it pinged me immediately when I read it this morning.

[Eldrick4221]

Nolder, how do you feel about AJ claiming watcher after darthe?

[Andrej]

I believe I have a very good reason to do so in this game.

No one except Dice has even attempted to challenge that and I am waiting on him to explain his position.

I disagree with your assertion because Mafia is not black and white or played in a vacuum.

 

The play is unconventional and potentially stupid but it's hard to find scummy motive to it unless you believe it would have caused an immediate counter claim and that was his ultimate goal.

[Nolder]

Nolder, how do you feel about AJ claiming watcher after darthe?

I see it as a panicked cover by a vanilla townie.

[Eldrick4221]

 

I believe I have a very good reason to do so in this game.

No one except Dice has even attempted to challenge that and I am waiting on him to explain his position.

I disagree with your assertion because Mafia is not black and white or played in a vacuum.

The play is unconventional and potentially stupid but it's hard to find scummy motive to it unless you believe it would have caused an immediate counter claim and that was his ultimate goal.

You mean besides "scum wouldn't do that so he had to be town"?

 

Or my already established reason of getting us to talk about who is and isn't the watcher.

[Nolder]

 

I believe I have a very good reason to do so in this game.

No one except Dice has even attempted to challenge that and I am waiting on him to explain his position.

I disagree with your assertion because Mafia is not black and white or played in a vacuum.

 

The play is unconventional and potentially stupid but it's hard to find scummy motive to it unless you believe it would have caused an immediate counter claim and that was his ultimate goal.

 

It might have, yeah.

 

Instead of going through the possibilities though why don't you go get it from the horses mouth what he intended so he can't just piggy back off our speculation?

[Eldrick4221]

Nolder: "Tell me claiming Watcher D1 is anything but anti town behavior.

Nothing good can come of it."

 

Eldrick: "Nolder, how do you feel about AJ claiming watcher after darthe?"

 

Nolder: "I see it as a panicked cover by a vanilla townie."

 

Why the distinction? Why is darthe doing it scummy iyo and AJ isn't?

[Andrej]

Because I'm not particularly worried about it and I would rather spend my time elsewhere than continuing to drag on a conversation that was most likely meant to kick off gameplay.

 

No one CC'd so crisis averted.

[Eldrick4221]

I'll start doing post numbers too, for reference

[Andrej]

 

Nolder, how do you feel about AJ claiming watcher after darthe?

 

I see it as a panicked cover by a vanilla townie.

Good my cover isn't blown then

[Nolder]

Nolder: "Tell me claiming Watcher D1 is anything but anti town behavior.

Nothing good can come of it."

 

Eldrick: "Nolder, how do you feel about AJ claiming watcher after darthe?"

 

Nolder: "I see it as a panicked cover by a vanilla townie."

 

Why the distinction? Why is darthe doing it scummy iyo and AJ isn't?

Because Darthe opened the door while AJ followed.

AJ was only reacting to what Darthe did.

[Eldrick4221]

That makes sense.

 

Be careful with your absolutes.

[Eldrick4221]

Light town read on Nolder only cuz we are on similar thinking. Good enough for a D1 read.

[MrsClov]

Nolder: "Tell me claiming Watcher D1 is anything but anti town behavior.

Nothing good can come of it."

Eldrick: "Nolder, how do you feel about AJ claiming watcher after darthe?"

Nolder: "I see it as a panicked cover by a vanilla townie."

Why the distinction? Why is darthe doing it scummy iyo and AJ isn't?

 

Good grief, I go away to read a book for a few hours and you guys blow up the thread. My posts may look wacky. I'm on my tablet.

 

Anyways, Eldrick, per the question regarding both AJ and Darthe claiming, do you feel both are scummy for it?

[Andrej]

Light town read on Nolder only cuz we are on similar thinking. Good enough for a D1 read.

Yeah, Nolder's not so bad after all.

[MrsClov]

Nolder, I appreciate the info you gave regarding previous games. It was helpful.

[Eldrick4221]

 

Nolder: "Tell me claiming Watcher D1 is anything but anti town behavior.

Nothing good can come of it."

Eldrick: "Nolder, how do you feel about AJ claiming watcher after darthe?"

Nolder: "I see it as a panicked cover by a vanilla townie."

Why the distinction? Why is darthe doing it scummy iyo and AJ isn't?

Good grief, I go away to read a book for a few hours and you guys blow up the thread. My posts may look wacky. I'm on my tablet.

Anyways, Eldrick, per the question regarding both AJ and Darthe claiming, do you feel both are scummy for it?

No I don't. I have no issue with AJ's followup claim.

 

If he's scum, that's not a reason to pin him for it. Either alignment could make that post. It was clearly a joke.

 

I asked Nolder because of his wording (bolded).

[Andrej]

Players:

2. MrsClov

3. Darthe

4. Bopolis

5. Niniel

6. Verbal

7. Wildfire

8. Zander

9. Eldrick

10. Nolder

11. Lenlo

12. Ironeyes

13. Hallia

 

I'm gonna scratch off the people I don't wanna lynch this phase and see where that takes me. Get on the list while it's hot imo

[Eldrick4221]

ZanderDice

 

Reminder :P

[Eldrick4221]

Tried to fix it via quote and the quote screwed up.

[Nolder]

 

Nolder: "Tell me claiming Watcher D1 is anything but anti town behavior.

Nothing good can come of it."

Eldrick: "Nolder, how do you feel about AJ claiming watcher after darthe?"

Nolder: "I see it as a panicked cover by a vanilla townie."

Why the distinction? Why is darthe doing it scummy iyo and AJ isn't?

 

Good grief, I go away to read a book for a few hours and you guys blow up the thread. My posts may look wacky. I'm on my tablet.

 

Anyways, Eldrick, per the question regarding both AJ and Darthe claiming, do you feel both are scummy for it?

 

What book are you reading?

 

Nolder, I appreciate the info you gave regarding previous games. It was helpful.

Well, no one else is going to try to clear my good name. 

[Eldrick4221]

Today I take my first step to being an old man :P

 

(Taking alka seltzer)

[Eldrick4221]

Oh that was nasty

[Andrej]

Goodnight owlettes.