[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Shad_]

 

If he was a benefit to town he would have given us details on his role before the hammer.

When you get your results what do you get?

 

Bc both times you have only voted the player and you clearly didnt know that NotBob would flip Jacob.

 

Guilty/I assume Not Guilty but lol I've only gotten Guilties so far.

[Pralaya]

This discussion does not make me want to watch Lost lol

Haha. It is one of the most complex storylines created for a TV series.

[Pralaya]

Also AJ didn't flip Immune iirc and NB did, Lenlo claimed some sort of immunity early.

Like bop said, Len is likely the anti-thesis of Jacob. In that case, both are 3p, I would guess.

[Lenlo]

 

Again, because a recruiter reveals the existence of a recruit mechanic on D1 when its clearly in his best interest not to.

 

I dunno what a Protector is, whether thats cult or what. Who do you want checked tonight?

 

here's the thing, even IF you are telling the truth,

 

if you are the guy who kills recruits then i don't see how you could ever be a villa; because you'd have to be the smoke monster and he is in no way ever a town character

 

I guarantee you, I am not the Smoke Monster. Smoke monster would be SK if anything, cause he murders literally everyone.

[Lenlo]

This discussion does not make me want to watch Lost lol

Dont. Its alright in the first few seasons and then gets meta and bullshitty.

 

 

 

Also AJ didn't flip Immune iirc and NB did, Lenlo claimed some sort of immunity early.

Like bop said, Len is likely the anti-thesis of Jacob. In that case, both are 3p, I would guess.

 

Your jumping to alot of conclusions. I am not the smoke guy.

[Pralaya]

 

This discussion does not make me want to watch Lost lol

Dont. Its alright in the first few seasons and then gets meta and bullshitty.

 

I disagree. For me, it is the best series ever created. Never got hooked to anything else after this.

[Lenlo]

I lost interest in the entire series once it got "This island is limbo and a giant cork on the evil of the world. The smoke monster is satan and im island jesus and your all dead but not dead as you meet up in a church between island scenes like 2 different continuities".

 

Cant stand it. I was with it and all for it when it was just a mysterious island in the ocean kinda deal.

[Calder]

I lost interest in the entire series once it got "This island is limbo and a giant cork on the evil of the world. The smoke monster is satan and im island jesus and your all dead but not dead as you meet up in a church between island scenes like 2 different continuities".

 

Cant stand it. I was with it and all for it when it was just a mysterious island in the ocean kinda deal.

This cannot be what the show was about lol.

[Calder]

Why did the Smoke Monster kill people?

 

What was the motivation?

[bopolis]

Why did the Smoke Monster kill people?

 

What was the motivation?

 

he wanted to kill jacob and his candidates so he could leave the island.

 

all the candidates were people he recruited to get to the island.

 

Also all the candidates would be villas in this game (the kwons, sayiid(already flipped), jack,sawyer,charlie,hurley etc etc).

[Calder]

 

Why did the Smoke Monster kill people?

 

What was the motivation?

he wanted to kill jacob and his candidates so he could leave the island.

 

all the candidates were people he recruited to get to the island.

 

Also all the candidates would be villas in this game (the kwons, sayiid(already flipped), jack,sawyer,charlie,hurley etc etc).

Ok. So that makes some sense.

[John Snow]

I lost interest in the entire series once it got "This island is limbo and a giant cork on the evil of the world. The smoke monster is satan and im island jesus and your all dead but not dead as you meet up in a church between island scenes like 2 different continuities".

 

Cant stand it. I was with it and all for it when it was just a mysterious island in the ocean kinda deal.

 

Nope. Single thing that pisses me off most about people who watched Lost. They were not dead the whole time. FFS, pay just a little attention people.

[Calder]

 

I lost interest in the entire series once it got "This island is limbo and a giant cork on the evil of the world. The smoke monster is satan and im island jesus and your all dead but not dead as you meet up in a church between island scenes like 2 different continuities".

 

Cant stand it. I was with it and all for it when it was just a mysterious island in the ocean kinda deal.

Nope. Single thing that pisses me off most about people who watched Lost. They were not dead the whole time. FFS, pay just a little attention people.

My wife watched and although we have not talked about it she told me that the last scene was them waiting to pass on together. Not sure if that is true. But def makes more sense than the always dead stuff.

[Tiinker]

 

 

I lost interest in the entire series once it got "This island is limbo and a giant cork on the evil of the world. The smoke monster is satan and im island jesus and your all dead but not dead as you meet up in a church between island scenes like 2 different continuities".

 

Cant stand it. I was with it and all for it when it was just a mysterious island in the ocean kinda deal.

Nope. Single thing that pisses me off most about people who watched Lost. They were not dead the whole time. FFS, pay just a little attention people.

My wife watched and although we have not talked about it she told me that the last scene was them waiting to pass on together. Not sure if that is true. But def makes more sense than the always dead stuff.

 

 

I stopped watching cause I thought that the pregnant Australian girl got way too annoying past season 2. 

[Tiinker]

 

Why did the Smoke Monster kill people?

 

What was the motivation?

 

he wanted to kill jacob and his candidates so he could leave the island.

 

all the candidates were people he recruited to get to the island.

 

Also all the candidates would be villas in this game (the kwons, sayiid(already flipped), jack,sawyer,charlie,hurley etc etc).

 

 

the candidates are people that the smoke monster recruited to get to the island? or that jacob recruited? 

[Tiinker]

 

I lost interest in the entire series once it got "This island is limbo and a giant cork on the evil of the world. The smoke monster is satan and im island jesus and your all dead but not dead as you meet up in a church between island scenes like 2 different continuities".

 

Cant stand it. I was with it and all for it when it was just a mysterious island in the ocean kinda deal.

This cannot be what the show was about lol.

 

I was upset to find this out as well while I was watching. Tbf the first 2 seasons are class imo.

[Tiinker]

jacob makes sense as third party and it makes sense he's looking for people's names.

 

it could've been a coc protect role where he needs certain people to survive til end game to win. lol if we lynched our own doc.

[Tiinker]

lol doc* protect

[Tiinker]

[unvote][v] notbob [/v]

 

Am I clear yet?

 

lol

[Calder]

 

jacob makes sense as third party and it makes sense he's looking for people's names.

 

 

it could've been a coc protect role where he needs certain people to survive til end game to win. lol if we lynched our own doc.

Different alignment so we are fine.

[bopolis]

 

 

Why did the Smoke Monster kill people?

 

What was the motivation?

 

he wanted to kill jacob and his candidates so he could leave the island.

 

all the candidates were people he recruited to get to the island.

 

Also all the candidates would be villas in this game (the kwons, sayiid(already flipped), jack,sawyer,charlie,hurley etc etc).

 

 

the candidates are people that the smoke monster recruited to get to the island? or that jacob recruited? 

 

 

in the show jacob did things to get them to the island and the smoke monster wanted them dead

[Tiinker]

 

 

jacob makes sense as third party and it makes sense he's looking for people's names.

 

it could've been a coc protect role where he needs certain people to survive til end game to win. lol if we lynched our own doc.

Different alignment so we are fine.

 

 

According to bop the people he would need to survive would be villa so that's a blow if true

[Tiinker]

 

 

Again, because a recruiter reveals the existence of a recruit mechanic on D1 when its clearly in his best interest not to.

 

I dunno what a Protector is, whether thats cult or what. Who do you want checked tonight?

 

here's the thing, even IF you are telling the truth,

 

if you are the guy who kills recruits then i don't see how you could ever be a villa; because you'd have to be the smoke monster and he is in no way ever a town character

 

I guarantee you, I am not the Smoke Monster. Smoke monster would be SK if anything, cause he murders literally everyone.

 

 

It's been 2 days with 2 NKs and we have a vig. There's no way there's an SK in this game.

[bopolis]

 

 

 

jacob makes sense as third party and it makes sense he's looking for people's names.

 

it could've been a coc protect role where he needs certain people to survive til end game to win. lol if we lynched our own doc.

Different alignment so we are fine.

 

 

According to bop the people he would need to survive would be villa so that's a blow if true

 

 

not really since our win-con is to eliminate all threats to town and since shad got a guilty result on him that means he was a threat.

[Tiinker]

 

 

 

 

jacob makes sense as third party and it makes sense he's looking for people's names.

 

it could've been a coc protect role where he needs certain people to survive til end game to win. lol if we lynched our own doc.

Different alignment so we are fine.

 

 

According to bop the people he would need to survive would be villa so that's a blow if true

 

 

not really since our win-con is to eliminate all threats to town and since shad got a guilty result on him that means he was a threat.

 

 

from when I played cop results are usually "town" or "not town" not "threat" or "not threat"