[Basic] Disney Heroes vs. Villains Mafia C9++ Town Wins

[Shad_]

[v]Sili[/v] yolo

[Shad_]

Suppose I should follow that up with an ISO too

[Shad_]

[unvote] meh

[Shad_]

It's irritating because it's not like hunting mafia and any one of you could be the SK really

[Shad_]

When in doubt lynch by effort because it feels less bad to lose to a player trying hard than to a lurker?

[Shad_]

I could still lynch Sili today but I don't have high confidence on much of anything. I have players I want to be villagers more than others but it's not the same.

[Shad_]

just to be sure, if i was a faction i'd have tried a lot harder.

why iyo?

[Songstress]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

Celeste (2): Sili, Cass
Kat (1): Believer

Not voting (4): Katiora, Lenlo, Celeste, Shander

Celeste is at L-2.

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline for Day 3 is Thursday, 8/25/16, at 8AM PDT/11AM EDT:

[Shad_]

@ Believer I think you were obviously not Mafia but that doesn't make you obviously town. You stuck your neck out further than most and for that I have you less likely than the players who kept a low profile, but I'm not 100% ruling you out.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

just to be sure, if i was a faction i'd have tried a lot harder.

why iyo?

 

I tend to care more when it's just me. if it's me and someone else i can rely on someone else.

[Shad_]

meh @ 12 hours to deadline

[Shad_]

At the end of the day I don't have a POE that I really believe in.

[Sili Quirrels]

it seems to me, shad, that you don't like how i've been playing as town. you and everyone else should know that i don't suddenly change styles because i'm third party. your complaint that i've been 'struggling' is absolutely fallacious considering this.

[Sili Quirrels]

When in doubt lynch by effort because it feels less bad to lose to a player trying hard than to a lurker?

this is the sort of thing you say when you want to lose.

[Shad_]

I guess one of Sili or Lenlo for being low involvement in general and reevaluate with a mass claim tomorrow if we don't get lucky.

 

I don't even know if that's an SK tell.

 

I don't know what an SK tell is.  The ones I've caught have generally botched something and I didn't pick up on anything.

[Shad_]

it seems to me, shad, that you don't like how i've been playing as town. you and everyone else should know that i don't suddenly change styles because i'm third party. your complaint that i've been 'struggling' is absolutely fallacious considering this.

 

Most people don't suddenly change styles as 3P.

 

But do you have any better ideas to base a lynch on?

 

I mean aside from not lynching you because you are whatever you are?

[Sili Quirrels]

so you're a headless chicken who wants to murder someone because they're playing inconveniently.

[Shad_]

 

When in doubt lynch by effort because it feels less bad to lose to a player trying hard than to a lurker?

this is the sort of thing you say when you want to lose.

 

 

So do you think it's Cass/Believer?

[Sili Quirrels]

smh

[Shad_]

so you're a headless chicken who wants to murder someone because they're playing inconveniently.

 

I can lynch people who've played different from what I'm used to regardless of having seen them play well as SK before--applies to both you and Lenlo--because at least it's some sort of lead.

 

I can lynch people for flying under the radar in general because it could be SK trying to avoid mafia bullets.

 

I can lynch people for trying hard because SK wants to win.

 

What's the proper method?  Does anything in particular ping you about anybody?  I say bleh to the third option.

[Shad_]

I'm not sure what smh means

[Cass]

@Cass @Shad thoughts on Kat? 

 

I still think Sili is town and I really didn't see Dice as mafia. Sili still hasn't been out of his town range imo and does not seem to be struggling.

I've never played with Kat before but unless she seems straightforward and therefore Town to me. I'll re-ISO later but the recent interaction with Believer reads good to me too.

 

Why? Do you have different thoughts? Why ask just Shad and I?

 

Imo Sili is playing more like his Town games than scum and I kind of hope that translates to not-SK as well. The early vibe/tone here was also different to what I got skimming his last SK game, so I lean that Town. There he was less explanatory, more cheeky/brief/involved imo.

 

There's a difference between his early game here and after the emo, trending down for me from there.

 

What about the rest of us? Scrape together Town leans and PoE/anything you've got.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

When in doubt lynch by effort because it feels less bad to lose to a player trying hard than to a lurker?

this is the sort of thing you say when you want to lose.

 

 

So do you think it's Cass/Believer?

 

well, i don't think someone in a vacuum is likely to play like believer as a pr, but as sk? i think that's more complicated. really depends on what sort of person he is. he has been a little obstinate about his reads. sk's do that sometimes because they don't care as much about their reads. might be just coincidence however.

 

cass - well she took pressure well earlier but that's probably not a tell. =/

 

lenlo - not likely. he's be more circumspect about his phrasing if that were the case.

 

celeste - she strikes me as just a touch indignant at being fos'd. i'm not sure indignant is the right word, but the bigger picture is i can see some of her recent posts as coming from either town or sk. i'm just not really sure how to read her.

[Cass]

Sup, catching up, won't be here long though and will be scarce until late tonight. Inlaws here and Will's birthday ^.^

[Cass]

 

You on the other hand I have to say have been more towny, but I don't trust you. I don't know how you play as scum or town.

While I can tell you that I've been playing nothing like my town game on here, I've never ever been scum so I or anyone else couldn't tell you what that looks like.However, your initial post that I responded to gave off the vibe that there's an equal chance to anyone left being the SK. I object to that statement.Me and Shander are the closest you're gonna get to confirmed town in this game, you should ride or die on that read.

Shander I get but why are you close to confirmed as not SK?