[Basic] Disney Heroes vs. Villains Mafia C9++ Town Wins

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

You gotta have faith.

 

Actually I dont. I have no reason to trust you. You dont seem to have any real reasons. All you have is "you gotta have faith"

 

put in one post plz WHY celeste should be lynched

 

I did post one of the longest posts this entire game solely dedicated to that purpose.

 

The fact that you seem to disregard/ignore that is scummy to me.

 

FoS dicetosser1.

 

 

your kidding right? 

 

Im reading in between calls at work. I cant just scroll thru the thread at leisure. I simply asked you to put ure reasons in one single post. and thats scummy to you?

 

vote Believer

 

We've caught another one, team.

 

 

It's scummy that you disregard one of the longest posts in the game, one of the more detailed posts in the game, with the logic of "I'm busy".

 

It doesn't take more effort to ISO me than it does to write that question. I'm here to catch scum, so that's what I'm doing.

 

If you ask me about the case, I'm gonna refer you to my case that I've laid out.

 

 

If you then decide that it's my unwillingness to play the game for you that's scummy and not make the effort yourself... Well, that's one way to ensure you're being caught.

 

 

If it wasnt for your beginning Id prolly vote you.

 

I wish I had some Meta on you.

 

Stuff like the bold just isnt sitting right with me.

 

But Shad seems to think youre prolly Town.

 

confusedface,gif

[Believer]

 

 

@ shad  ty

 

basically that reads like a whole lot of nothing mostly.

 

He could have answered my question like this 

 

"i think shes been trying to pocket people  there were some post i thought sounded fake." i think there might have been one other decent thing there maybe.

 

 

real easy.

 

 

instead??  he gets up in my grill for daring to ask him to post his thoughts

Yes, making you play the game and not piggyback on me is a legitimate thing to do.

 

If I simply state my thoughts and you respond; "Ok, I get it", what have we learned?

 

 

your thinking. a better idea of where your coming from which was the point

 

you wanna lynch people? then expect to hasve to explain why they should be lynched and dont be surprised if you have to do it more then once.

 

I think it's interesting that you expect a fully fleshed out case so early on D1.

 

I think it's entirely reasonable for someone to read my case and then question it, but when someone doesn't bother with even reading it, then I don't think it's serious.

[Believer]

 

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Belieber[/v]

 

I'm much more interested in pursuing this line of thought as it is.

 

The others will be sorted accordingly as the game unfolds.

Now see, this is disappointing. You were top town just before this post and this comes out of the blue.

 

Were you bored when you posted that?

 

 

Wait....so iyo Townies cant/wont vote you?

 

Sure they can, but his progression is strange.

 

Look at the post he makes about me before this, doesn't look natural to me. Hence why I asked if he was bored.

[Sooh]

Oki, going to start reading up now. I've been in a mafia slump for reasons including work starting up again, lack of sleep and zero motivation. I gave myself some time off and asked my hydra partner to cover for us, but I'm ready to catch up now, at least in part. I hope I'll get through the thread tonight, and I promise I won't do a Zander-type catch up. Most likely I'll summarize my thoughts at the end. I'll keep this window open to "enjoy" Zander-catchup and attempt real time talk, though without having read the game up until now I'm not sure how good my contributions will be.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

You gotta have faith.

 

Actually I dont. I have no reason to trust you. You dont seem to have any real reasons. All you have is "you gotta have faith"

 

put in one post plz WHY celeste should be lynched

 

I did post one of the longest posts this entire game solely dedicated to that purpose.

 

The fact that you seem to disregard/ignore that is scummy to me.

 

FoS dicetosser1.

 

 

your kidding right? 

 

Im reading in between calls at work. I cant just scroll thru the thread at leisure. I simply asked you to put ure reasons in one single post. and thats scummy to you?

 

vote Believer

 

We've caught another one, team.

 

 

It's scummy that you disregard one of the longest posts in the game, one of the more detailed posts in the game, with the logic of "I'm busy".

 

It doesn't take more effort to ISO me than it does to write that question. I'm here to catch scum, so that's what I'm doing.

 

If you ask me about the case, I'm gonna refer you to my case that I've laid out.

 

 

If you then decide that it's my unwillingness to play the game for you that's scummy and not make the effort yourself... Well, that's one way to ensure you're being caught.

 

that shows that he's not as invested as you'd hope he'd be, but it's not scummy  to not be so engaged.

 

It is, though.

 

Breakdown of events:

 

1. Believer makes a case against Celeste.

2. dicetosser1 questions why Believer is pushing for votes on Celeste. specifically asking for one reason to do as he says.

3. Believer refers dicetosser1 to read his case against Celeste.

4. dicetosser1 refuses and votes Believer.

 

There are 3 possible extrapolations one can make from this.

 

1. dicetosser1 is town and lazy and doesn't want to be told to play the game.

2. dicetosser1 is scum and wants to get the easy mislynch.

3. dicetosser1 is town and actually doesn't care.

 

All 3 of these scenarios are bad for town, but I think #2 is most likely.

 

 

 

 

the 'too eager' comment might be even more funny than i first thought.. like, you call me too eager but then your reads are too eager, so i'm like lol because you just implied hypocrisy was a vice, and now you're a hypocrite!

 

it's amazing.

Note to everyone reading this.

 

Passive aggressive when under pressure indicates scum, basic tell.

 

 

[Believer]

 

 

 

You gotta have faith.

 

Actually I dont. I have no reason to trust you. You dont seem to have any real reasons. All you have is "you gotta have faith"

 

put in one post plz WHY celeste should be lynched

 

I did post one of the longest posts this entire game solely dedicated to that purpose.

 

The fact that you seem to disregard/ignore that is scummy to me.

 

FoS dicetosser1.

 

 

How much Mafia experience do you have?

 

50-60 games or so.

[Believer]

@Zander

 

You're realling spinning your wheels in the dirt if you think that is an apt comparison.

[Believer]

 

 

 

 

Okay, joking aside. Time to play.

 

Dark colored hair best hair!

Joking intro post, also objectively wrong. Slight scum read.

 

 

 

Cause I promised Celeste I would lynch her first.

 

Look whos here! [v]Celeste[/v]

R00d! Celeste knows best! Take it little Lenlo, I'm totally harmless!

 

"I'm totally harmless" can be read as a joke, but is unnecessary to write, are you trying to convince me or yourself?

 

 

I'd like to inform everyone that I haven't played a C++ game ever, nor a game with majority lynch.

 

 

For transparancy's sake.

How many games have you played? Same to Tinker.

 

Trying to find info on a new player, null post.

 

Nyn is always spicy

Joke post, null.

 

@believer On DM only?

I'm hurt that you don't remember me instantly, will remember this.

 

 

I've never played a game on this forum before.

Then which forums? Your name looks familiar..

 

Again, you hurt the fee-fees.

 

 

Do explain.

because I didn't get to vote Sili in a mash and now I can vote him. :p

 

If you truly are Alette on MU, I can see you doing this as either alignment. Null post.

 

 

I currently play exclusively on MU (http://www.mafiauniverse.com) but I originally started playing on The Org (http://forums.totalwar.org). I use the same nick on both of those sites as here.

WERE YOU IN STAR FOX THEN?! HI, THIS IS ALETTE!

 

Enthusiasm noticed and appreciated, will remember.

 

Also <3 to Cass!

Null post, everybody loves everybody on this site it appears.

 

I'm turning this into a cass appreciation thread too.

Not sure if intentional derailing of discussion or genuine happiness.

My nihilism tells me it's derailing, we're going with that.

 

 

I should start a fan club.

I'm pretty sure the only games I have played with you are when your mafia. The nonchalant attitude is noticed...

 

Easy town points to make a post like this as scum. Not ruling out town alignment, but the extra 2 dots at the end makes it likelier to be scum.

 

Shad > Rand Town usually

Everyone is >rand town at the start of the game. This post suggests pocketing to me, scum points added.

 

 

 

Shad > Rand Town usually

 

wtf is this???

 

He is one of those good town reads based on intro.

 

From what I've read on Shad and the limited exposure I've had to him on MU (ATPG's Star Fox game) I couldn't disagree more.

 

@Andrej No, i'm not telling you it's a scum tell but it is something to watch more of.

Weak and fence-sitting. Everyone is worth watching more of at the moment. Posting just for the sake of posting.

 

 

Whats your read on me?

I don't know Zander, i usually wait for a flip to read you

 

Pocketing noted.

 

 

You know me and SHad are a Hydra right?

Yes, I acknowledged this before the rand so personally I will look at Shad mostly to read your slot.

 

Pocketing/derp clear attempt noticed, now backing off. Scum points added accordingly.

 

Not sure what a scum reaction would be. Do you give Sili so little credit as to out him/herself with their first post?

Reads fake.

 

Trying to derail the thread again.

 

 

 

Conclusion, Celeste is scum.

 

[unvote]

[v]Celeste[/v]

 

 

 

Maybe Im not remembering this correctly but were you sussing/wanting people to vote Penny PRIOR to this point?

 

I wasn't.

 

That was my first post after waking up on the second day (real time) of the game. I went back and did the work and came up with that.

 

 

So you didnt mention nothing about her at all then prior to the ISO?

 

What made you choose Penny?

 

How much experience do you have with her?

 

If I did, I can't remember it.

 

I thought her posts looked scummy, after closer inspection I solidified on that read. Also another reason that I'll bring up in postgame that will make you laugh.

 

One game.

[Zander?]

its*

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Sili Quirrels[/v]

 

So its a Penny Sili Dice Scum team???

[Believer]

 

its*

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Sili Quirrels[/v]

 

So its a Penny Sili Dice Scum team???

 

It's too early to form a coherent team, but those are scummy yes.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

bruh, you are all over the place. I hate this argument that "this is detriment to town if he's town or if he's scum". Mafia is a freaking game of majority. Leave your reasoning as why you think he's scum otherwise you're just trying egging people on.

I did leave my reasoning, that's what started my exchange with Sili.

 

Is your contention with me that I evolve and change my reads?

 

 

I think it's more that claiming lynching a town that's playing bad or is currently uninvolved in the game helps town is disingenuous and looks like you're just pushing your own agenda.

 

I don't think he's town, I explained as much.

I laid out the possibilities that I see for his conduct and pointed to which one I think is more plausible. If you think that's disingenuous, I don't really know what to say. I don't think it's possible to be more transparent than I am right now.

 

My agenda is to lynch scum, it should be public knowledge by now.

 

PS. Don't think I don't appreciate the shading attempt though, it was nice. DS

 

 

This is like Zander to the 25th power!!!!!

[Zander?]

Im sorry but i dont want anymore of this conversation. Believers terribly biased and or naive and we should let him be these things unless someone thinks its wolfy.

 

I approve this message

[Believer]

Am I making you proud, daddy?

 

 

 

Do you like it when I call you daddy, daddy?

 

[Zander?]

Twice when I checked in on the game he had said something that struck me as odd, ill have to dig up quotes to show it later, and now I find his believer interactions to be fake. Especially those above on this page, looks like setting up town cred for when believer flips.

 

Will be looking for this.

[Zander?]

Tiink is a sneaky, sneaky sneakity.  I have a hard time trusting him.

 

I don't like the Believer train.  

 

Why and who on it sticks out?

[Zander?]

Sili's sounded like his villager self when he gets into it with people but the lack of a broad focus is still sketching me out.  I think it's atypical of him and I've actually gotten a good night's sleep for a few consecutive days now so hopefully I'll be able to reread him tonight without spacing out every ten seconds.

 

Whats your current read on Sili Shad?

[Sooh]

Found where I left off. Looks like I've got 30 pages to catch up on. That's within the realm of what's possible for one hour or so.

[Zander?]

  Posts Zander 146 Nynaeve 90 Believer 85 Shad_ 83 Hallia 75

 

Hey would you look at that, it's the village.

 

 

Im still not sold on Believer but ya i do think nynalia is prolly Town

[Zander?]

Has lenlo said why he's so quiet and i've missed it??? That's really not extremely normal for him

 

ya a lot of this.

[Zander?]

I said while I signed up that I won't be on my usually activity. Where I am briefly is

 

Dice - slight town

Shander - town

Cass - slight town

Sili - null lean town

Nynia- null lean town

Tinker - null

Believer - null

Lenlo- null

Katiora - watching closely

Andrej - watching closely

Darooh - slight scum

 

Whats your reasoning for your Darooh read?

[Zander?]

Oh cool I broke 10k posts.

 

Will you all finally be my friends now?  :sad:

 

I loved you long before you became famous boo!!!!

 

<3 <3 <3

[Zander?]

 

Clarify for me because I'm still not sure I can distinguish between honest opinions and reaction-seeking out of you.  Who are your top wolves and villagers?

From the Celeste case onwards, everything is serious.

 

Top scum:

 

Sili

dicetosser1

 

Top town:

 

Andrej

 

 

Penny is not top Scum anymore???

 

Why???

[Believer]

 

 

Clarify for me because I'm still not sure I can distinguish between honest opinions and reaction-seeking out of you.  Who are your top wolves and villagers?

From the Celeste case onwards, everything is serious.

 

Top scum:

 

Sili

dicetosser1

 

Top town:

 

Andrej

 

 

Penny is not top Scum anymore???

 

Why???

 

At this point, I wonder if anyone is actually reading my posts at all.

 

I had a several page discourse with both of the people I read as scum.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

I dunno, Tiink is the only person here I have zero experience with so I'm hoping others can read him decently.

I've never played with him before. Halli's description in one word or less is "sly". lol

Where do you find these suave gifs? XD

 

 

Youre really asking someone besides ME ABOOT GIFS EH?????

[Hallia]

 

Tiink is a sneaky, sneaky sneakity.  I have a hard time trusting him.

 

I don't like the Believer train.  

 

Why and who on it sticks out?

 

Nyn and I were discussing it, Nyn said:  I will add though, that I don't like the train on him either. I feel like both the Cass push and the push on him are potentially attempts to pull town in a different direction than where we're heading.... which is more towards a Sili/Tiinker direction. So he's not someone I'd consider lynching today.  - I was telling her it feels off, and that I didn't like it.  She says things better than I do.

 

 

 

 

Clarify for me because I'm still not sure I can distinguish between honest opinions and reaction-seeking out of you.  Who are your top wolves and villagers?

From the Celeste case onwards, everything is serious.

 

Top scum:

 

Sili

dicetosser1

 

Top town:

 

Andrej

 

 

Penny is not top Scum anymore???

 

Why???

 

At this point, I wonder if anyone is actually reading my posts at all.

 

I had a several page discourse with both of the people I read as scum.

 

I'm with you, Bee, no worries.

 

 

 

 

 

I dunno, Tiink is the only person here I have zero experience with so I'm hoping others can read him decently.

I've never played with him before. Halli's description in one word or less is "sly". lol

 

Where do you find these suave gifs? XD

 

 

Youre really asking someone besides ME ABOOT GIFS EH?????

 

EH!?  DON'T TAKE THE BOOTS TO ME