[Basic]Spirited Away Mafia - Game over mafia wins

[Sili Quirrels]

no, that's it.

 

u wrong about bfg?

[Clovdyx]

no, that's it.

 

u wrong about bfg?

 

Considering I'm basically set to kill her, and have said as much multiple times, I'm not sure how this is a question at this point.

 

Like, you do understand I'm not arguing she's town, right?

[Katiora]

What if Cory/Sili/Clov are the mafia group... we would all be so screwed... 

[Sili Quirrels]

 

no, that's it.

 

u wrong about bfg?

 

Considering I'm basically set to kill her, and have said as much multiple times, I'm not sure how this is a question at this point.

 

Like, you do understand I'm not arguing she's town, right?

 

tbh i haven't been paying a lot of attention to your posts about bfg since the day before yesterday.

[Clovdyx]

What if Cory/Sili/Clov are the mafia group... we would all be so screwed... 

 

I'm 99% sure this is just empty tinfoil or you thinking out loud, but Cory-Sili is basically never a thing.

 

If you didn't mean in context of how the game has shaken out but a general thing...well, that'd be kind of like with the me-Cory-AJ team mentioned earlier and I'd just apologize for wasting everybody's time.

[Sili Quirrels]

What if Cory/Sili/Clov are the mafia group... we would all be so screwed... 

 ya. if we are though you shouldn't feel bad.

 

our team comp is goat.

[Regy Rusty]

What if the sky turns to fire and your nose falls off?

 

Words of wisdom from Disney's classic film Pocahontas 2: Journey to a New World

[Sili Quirrels]

 

What if Cory/Sili/Clov are the mafia group... we would all be so screwed... 

 ya. if we are though you shouldn't feel bad.

 

our team comp is goat.

 

well, cory and clov are goat, but i'm playing pretty well too.

[Clovdyx]

 

 

no, that's it.

 

u wrong about bfg?

 

Considering I'm basically set to kill her, and have said as much multiple times, I'm not sure how this is a question at this point.

 

Like, you do understand I'm not arguing she's town, right?

 

tbh i haven't been paying a lot of attention to your posts about bfg since the day before yesterday.

 

 

The day before yesterday I had BFG in a five person legitimate suspect pool and listed her in my top three candidates, along with PBF and Kat.  It wasn't until yesterday morning (albeit very, very early yesterday morning) that I said anything positive about her.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

no, that's it.

 

u wrong about bfg?

 

Considering I'm basically set to kill her, and have said as much multiple times, I'm not sure how this is a question at this point.

 

Like, you do understand I'm not arguing she's town, right?

 

tbh i haven't been paying a lot of attention to your posts about bfg since the day before yesterday.

 

 

The day before yesterday I had BFG in a five person legitimate suspect pool and listed her in my top three candidates, along with PBF and Kat.  It wasn't until yesterday morning (albeit very, very early yesterday morning) that I said anything positive about her.

 

well, i'm just saying that the last i heard you were saying something positive about bfg and that's why i had that impression. glad we got that resolved.

[Katiora]

*tries to attempt to stop tinfoiling* 

 

 

The indiscrepancies with BFG that Cory has brought up is a good catch. I didn't even notice it yesterday when I was trying to keep caught up. It is weird that she was "catching up" and at the end of phase but wasn't really trying to solve and find a good target... she was just trying to push off onto ANYONE else. Which is a pretty scummy thing to do.

 

 

I'm just having a hard time wrapping my  head around this game. I keep trying to build a town base that I can listen to and rely on, because that's what I need. That's on reason why it takes so long for me to get going... l need someone I can trust(ish) to be able to bounce my ideas off of. And  I don't know if I can do that with anyone I feel fairly sure of at this point. 

 

Honestly right now I'm thinking BFG and Wifi... and Maybe Seph but I don't know about him. He swung a lot on me yesterday and I'm not sure how I feel about it. 

 

I'm also annoyed at everyone putting me in their bottom four. 2 of you I think should be able to read me better than this and your uncertainty makes me doubt your villagerness. One much more than the other. 

 

I keep seeing where people are "giving me time" but they still have me in the bottom. The thing is, If I'm not a viable target (because I'm not) who is? 

 

Honestly, I'm very much afraid that Hallia isn't town. And it could be more empty tinfoiling but, she's sucking at reading me, she's sucked at reading Zander... That's not very Hallia of her she usually picks us up better than that. And she could have been like me. I had a hard time reading Zander, but I blame that on the Lainey factor... I'm horrible at reading lainey and almost always read her as mafia, especially when she's town. Idk... I'm just really uncomfortable with her and honestly think it could be a BFG, Wifi, Hallia scum team. 

[Katiora]

 

What if Cory/Sili/Clov are the mafia group... we would all be so screwed... 

 

I'm 99% sure this is just empty tinfoil or you thinking out loud, but Cory-Sili is basically never a thing.

 

If you didn't mean in context of how the game has shaken out but a general thing...well, that'd be kind of like with the me-Cory-AJ team mentioned earlier and I'd just apologize for wasting everybody's time.

 

be 100% it was lol... it was just a bad thought sitting here reading up in the thread lol 

[SiRReN]

Kat, you can talk to me or Regy.

[Regy Rusty]

 

 

I'm also annoyed at everyone putting me in their bottom four. 2 of you I think should be able to read me better than this and your uncertainty makes me doubt your villagerness. One much more than the other. 

 

I keep seeing where people are "giving me time" but they still have me in the bottom. The thing is, If I'm not a viable target (because I'm not) who is? 

 

 

Who specifically are you referring to?

 

You're in my bottom group because through POE I have a lot of people I don't think are mafia for various reasons, and you're among those who I don't have any reason so far to write off.

There are others I'm more suspicious of but you're still in the group I'd lynch once those are resolved at least at this point.

[Clovdyx]

*tries to attempt to stop tinfoiling* 

 

 

The indiscrepancies with BFG that Cory has brought up is a good catch. I didn't even notice it yesterday when I was trying to keep caught up. It is weird that she was "catching up" and at the end of phase but wasn't really trying to solve and find a good target... she was just trying to push off onto ANYONE else. Which is a pretty scummy thing to do.

 

 

I'm just having a hard time wrapping my  head around this game. I keep trying to build a town base that I can listen to and rely on, because that's what I need. That's on reason why it takes so long for me to get going... l need someone I can trust(ish) to be able to bounce my ideas off of. And  I don't know if I can do that with anyone I feel fairly sure of at this point. 

 

Honestly right now I'm thinking BFG and Wifi... and Maybe Seph but I don't know about him. He swung a lot on me yesterday and I'm not sure how I feel about it. 

 

I'm also annoyed at everyone putting me in their bottom four. 2 of you I think should be able to read me better than this and your uncertainty makes me doubt your villagerness. One much more than the other. 

 

I keep seeing where people are "giving me time" but they still have me in the bottom. The thing is, If I'm not a viable target (because I'm not) who is? 

 

Honestly, I'm very much afraid that Hallia isn't town. And it could be more empty tinfoiling but, she's sucking at reading me, she's sucked at reading Zander... That's not very Hallia of her she usually picks us up better than that. And she could have been like me. I had a hard time reading Zander, but I blame that on the Lainey factor... I'm horrible at reading lainey and almost always read her as mafia, especially when she's town. Idk... I'm just really uncomfortable with her and honestly think it could be a BFG, Wifi, Hallia scum team. 

 

I'm pretty sure you can trust at least Regy and Sirren.  Call it a hunch.

 

And you can say you're annoyed that people have you in the bottom, but look at this objectively.  Even removing the two confirmed townies from it, should you be above any of these people?

 

-Me

-AJ

-Cory

-Sili

-Darthe

 

Literally the only person with less posts than you is Wildfire.  You can say you expect certain people to read you well (who?), but I don't see how you can expect anybody to read you one way or another when you have less than 50 posts in a 2,400 post thread.  Almost a quarter of your posts have came in the first two hours of the game.

 

Anybody who has you as their #1 scumread would probably be wrong to do so, but anybody who has you as a particularly strong townread is going to look really bad at this point.  

[Clovdyx]

Who specifically are you referring to?

 

You're in my bottom group because through POE I have a lot of people I don't think are mafia for various reasons, and you're among those who I don't have any reason so far to write off.

There are others I'm more suspicious of but you're still in the group I'd lynch once those are resolved at least at this point.

 

 

I am really glad you signed up for this game.

[Hallia]

*tries to attempt to stop tinfoiling*

 

 

The indiscrepancies with BFG that Cory has brought up is a good catch. I didn't even notice it yesterday when I was trying to keep caught up. It is weird that she was "catching up" and at the end of phase but wasn't really trying to solve and find a good target... she was just trying to push off onto ANYONE else. Which is a pretty scummy thing to do.

 

 

I'm just having a hard time wrapping my head around this game. I keep trying to build a town base that I can listen to and rely on, because that's what I need. That's on reason why it takes so long for me to get going... l need someone I can trust(ish) to be able to bounce my ideas off of. And I don't know if I can do that with anyone I feel fairly sure of at this point.

 

Honestly right now I'm thinking BFG and Wifi... and Maybe Seph but I don't know about him. He swung a lot on me yesterday and I'm not sure how I feel about it.

 

I'm also annoyed at everyone putting me in their bottom four. 2 of you I think should be able to read me better than this and your uncertainty makes me doubt your villagerness. One much more than the other.

 

I keep seeing where people are "giving me time" but they still have me in the bottom. The thing is, If I'm not a viable target (because I'm not) who is?

 

Honestly, I'm very much afraid that Hallia isn't town. And it could be more empty tinfoiling but, she's sucking at reading me, she's sucked at reading Zander... That's not very Hallia of her she usually picks us up better than that. And she could have been like me. I had a hard time reading Zander, but I blame that on the Lainey factor... I'm horrible at reading lainey and almost always read her as mafia, especially when she's town. Idk... I'm just really uncomfortable with her and honestly think it could be a BFG, Wifi, Hallia scum team.

.....what?? I can't...I...

[Hallia]

What caused the 180 exactly?

[Hallia]

In what world an I scum with Wifi?

[Katiora]

Kat, you can talk to me or Regy.

It's not that I can't trust you as not mafia... it's that I don't know if I can trust your opinions. The thing with Zander and the reason why I sheep zander most of the time once I feel that he's town is because he's good at finding wolves when he's on his game. I've only seen you as mafia so I don't know about you, and i don't know Regy at all lol. Hallia is also usually pretty good at figuring people out, but she's not doing so great this game. I also don't know how ya'll will take some of my stuff because I can be a hardcore tinfoiler lol... and some people see that as scummish, which is one reason I've been quiet this game. That and the whole thing that every time I've come in the thread and tried to get involved I've felt like I've been attacked for stuff people are viewing as scummy I said at the beginning of the thread that everyone took out of context and I feel that everyone overlooked my later content they said they were looking for. 

[Regy Rusty]

 

Kat, you can talk to me or Regy.

It's not that I can't trust you as not mafia... it's that I don't know if I can trust your opinions. The thing with Zander and the reason why I sheep zander most of the time once I feel that he's town is because he's good at finding wolves when he's on his game. I've only seen you as mafia so I don't know about you, and i don't know Regy at all lol. Hallia is also usually pretty good at figuring people out, but she's not doing so great this game. I also don't know how ya'll will take some of my stuff because I can be a hardcore tinfoiler lol... and some people see that as scummish, which is one reason I've been quiet this game. That and the whole thing that every time I've come in the thread and tried to get involved I've felt like I've been attacked for stuff people are viewing as scummy I said at the beginning of the thread that everyone took out of context and I feel that everyone overlooked my later content they said they were looking for. 

 

 

Well why don't you try me then?

 

I think lynching BFG/Seph/Wildfire/You has a very decent chance of catching all three scum, and I'm almost positive that it will catch at least two of them.

 

Am I wrong? If so, who am I writing off that I shouldn't be?

 

I have some ideas myself of how I'd answer that question but I'm curious what yours would be.

[SiRReN]

 

Kat, you can talk to me or Regy.

It's not that I can't trust you as not mafia... it's that I don't know if I can trust your opinions. The thing with Zander and the reason why I sheep zander most of the time once I feel that he's town is because he's good at finding wolves when he's on his game. I've only seen you as mafia so I don't know about you, and i don't know Regy at all lol. Hallia is also usually pretty good at figuring people out, but she's not doing so great this game. I also don't know how ya'll will take some of my stuff because I can be a hardcore tinfoiler lol... and some people see that as scummish, which is one reason I've been quiet this game. That and the whole thing that every time I've come in the thread and tried to get involved I've felt like I've been attacked for stuff people are viewing as scummy I said at the beginning of the thread that everyone took out of context and I feel that everyone overlooked my later content they said they were looking for. 

 

I see, that`s fair enough. I can honestly say I`m not great at finding scum, but I`m a good person to bounce ideas off of. At the very least you definitely need to be discussing your ideas more in thread because the towniest thing anyone can do is demonstrate a desire to solve the game. I can tell you when you are tinfoiling and you can maybe then step passed the tinfoil and look at other stuff?

[Regy Rusty]

And honestly I don't think it matters too much whether you can trust my skills. While it's possible for confirmed townies to be limp and useless (I've seen it many times) I'm clearly engaged and at least trying. Whether I'm right about things or not it means you can talk to me and be absolutely sure that anything I respond is genuinely what I really think.

 

If that doesn't hold some value to you I dunno what else to say.

[Regy Rusty]

 

Who specifically are you referring to?

 

You're in my bottom group because through POE I have a lot of people I don't think are mafia for various reasons, and you're among those who I don't have any reason so far to write off.

There are others I'm more suspicious of but you're still in the group I'd lynch once those are resolved at least at this point.

 

 

I am really glad you signed up for this game.

 

 

Me too, I'm mostly having fun

[Katiora]

 

*tries to attempt to stop tinfoiling* 

 

 

The indiscrepancies with BFG that Cory has brought up is a good catch. I didn't even notice it yesterday when I was trying to keep caught up. It is weird that she was "catching up" and at the end of phase but wasn't really trying to solve and find a good target... she was just trying to push off onto ANYONE else. Which is a pretty scummy thing to do.

 

 

I'm just having a hard time wrapping my  head around this game. I keep trying to build a town base that I can listen to and rely on, because that's what I need. That's on reason why it takes so long for me to get going... l need someone I can trust(ish) to be able to bounce my ideas off of. And  I don't know if I can do that with anyone I feel fairly sure of at this point. 

 

Honestly right now I'm thinking BFG and Wifi... and Maybe Seph but I don't know about him. He swung a lot on me yesterday and I'm not sure how I feel about it. 

 

I'm also annoyed at everyone putting me in their bottom four. 2 of you I think should be able to read me better than this and your uncertainty makes me doubt your villagerness. One much more than the other. 

 

I keep seeing where people are "giving me time" but they still have me in the bottom. The thing is, If I'm not a viable target (because I'm not) who is? 

 

Honestly, I'm very much afraid that Hallia isn't town. And it could be more empty tinfoiling but, she's sucking at reading me, she's sucked at reading Zander... That's not very Hallia of her she usually picks us up better than that. And she could have been like me. I had a hard time reading Zander, but I blame that on the Lainey factor... I'm horrible at reading lainey and almost always read her as mafia, especially when she's town. Idk... I'm just really uncomfortable with her and honestly think it could be a BFG, Wifi, Hallia scum team. 

 

I'm pretty sure you can trust at least Regy and Sirren.  Call it a hunch.

 

And you can say you're annoyed that people have you in the bottom, but look at this objectively.  Even removing the two confirmed townies from it, should you be above any of these people?

 

-Me

-AJ

-Cory

-Sili

-Darthe

 

Literally the only person with less posts than you is Wildfire.  You can say you expect certain people to read you well (who?), but I don't see how you can expect anybody to read you one way or another when you have less than 50 posts in a 2,400 post thread.  Almost a quarter of your posts have came in the first two hours of the game.

 

Anybody who has you as their #1 scumread would probably be wrong to do so, but anybody who has you as a particularly strong townread is going to look really bad at this point.  

 

 

 

Honestly I think there's a good possibility that there is at least 1 wolf in those 5. If I had to choose one I would say Darthe, but ya'll seem all gung ho on each other. Ya'll keep building up this 5 group like ya'll are all mod cleared or something but the thing is I KNOW I'm town. without a shadow of a doubt I know. And I guess that's what is worrying me the most. Ya'll have cleared all these people and I KNOW I'm not scum but I don't know who to tell you to look at because all the people who have made me uneasy ya'll are clearing... on D1... from drama or the clearing up of said drama. I'm just lost. 

 

and Hallia and AJ should be pretty darn good at reading me by now. Hallia I've played with almost every game I've played and until recently she had a good streak of knowing me. 

 

And clov you know I don't post a lot especially D1. Heck I don't post alot at all... I mean look at my post count for 90s mafia or stick figures and I made it to the end of both games and had super low post counts... I'm just not a big poster and honestly every time I've posted I've felt attacked by one person or another. First it was lainey and then Sili so I haven't had a lot of encouragement to post.