[Advanced] Arthurian Mafia

[Clovdyx]

I've got 5-3-1...

 

To answer your question, not factoring in speculation on roles, you would be my top shot, Darthe.  Eldrick would be my second.  I would also give a lot of thought to shooting Dice if I HAD to shoot, because there's no harm there, and there's a chance he's hiding behind the survivor claim as mafia.

 

 

Bottom two would be MrsClov and Nyn.

[Darthe]

In that case optimal vig play is to holster tonight and the doc protect her. She yolo shoots tomorrow with a higher chance of hitting someone.

[Sili Quirrels]

I forgot about leelou so it seems our situation isnt yet that dire.

 

Btw the optimal vig play is to kill dice since it always results in negating a mpt-town faction.

[Clovdyx]

I was just gonna draw names out of a hat.

[Clovdyx]

....I mean, I was going to suggest drawing names out of a hat.

[Sili Quirrels]

I dont know y u think mrs has a srcond sbot but reminder: we miss and kill a town then it is 4-3-1 and we almost always lose.

[Darthe]

Dice is usually optimal but unless we turn things around it wont matter. Since I know myself to be both town and the optimal lynch target its better to yolo the vig from my perspective.

 

Kinda disappointed in Barms play here. Sure I have been crazy but its just poor gambling on my end. he didnt try to present himself as town.

[Sili Quirrels]

Case A: dice is a survivor. We cant let a survivor live to lylo.

Case B: dice is a wolf. We gain a big advantage if we kill him.

 

 

Conclusion: killing dice is okay or great, it clears the air, and gets village onto the right track.

[Leelou]

I'm lynching Dice or Eldrick tomorrow. 

[Clovdyx]

What changed?

[Darthe]

I'm lynching Dice or Eldrick tomorrow.

Thats odd.

[Sili Quirrels]

I was on my phone earlier, so I didn't notice, but let me lay it out:

 

Mrs clov I really think you're vig shot is going to be a big deal tonight.

 

....I mean, I was going to suggest drawing names out of a hat.

 

Since I know myself to be both town and the optimal lynch target its better to yolo the vig from my perspective.

 

What are you two doing? Tomorrow is lylo, and a blind-shot is incredibly dangerous. More to the point Mrs. Clov has no idea who the scum are. Her shot would be blind.

[MrsClov]

You all do realize that I don't have another shot, right?

[Darthe]

Prob recognizing we need this game cracked open.

[Darthe]

You all do realize that I don't have another shot, right?

Lol no

[Clovdyx]

My comment wasn't about her, but it's probably best if we don't discuss it more than we already have.  Because lolsme.

[Sili Quirrels]

You all do realize that I don't have another shot, right?

It's actually not important right now.

 

Prob recognizing we need this game cracked open.

You crack a game open with hard work and solid reads.

 

 

You all do realize that I don't have another shot, right?

Lol no

 

 

Color me confused. How is it you don't believe Mrs. Clov but you believe Dice?

[Darthe]

I believe her. I didn't know she was out of shots

[Sili Quirrels]

I hope your town game isn't this bad.

[dicetosser1]

@Dice - Why didn't you vote Day 1? This could be vitally important to your survival.

 

sigh  ive already said this twice. Last time im not saying it again and ure lucky the iso isnt working properly or id tell you to find it.  I only voted darthe as an info lynch. I even said that. he had a go at me for it and convinced me i was wrong. so i unvoted. I didnt vote again because i didnt think either darthe or lil were mafia. I did offer to go with Barm tho

 

 

Case A: dice is a survivor. We cant let a survivor live to lylo.

Case B: dice is a wolf. We gain a big advantage if we kill him.

 

 

Conclusion: killing dice is okay or great, it clears the air, and gets village onto the right track.

 

Or C let Dice live cause hes willing to work with town and all win. Cory would be very disappointed with your attitude to survivors.

 

And how does killing the Survivor get the village on the right track? You still have to hunt down and kill all the mafia members, minus an extra player who you know the alignment of and who is willing to help track mafia down. So you are NO better off then you are now.

[Sili Quirrels]

I disagree. We don't know your alignment, and we can't let you get to true lylo (4-3-1) even if you're the survivor. If you're there it is to your win condition to let the wolves win.

 

Am I wrong in this?

[Sili Quirrels]

True Lylo: 3-3-1

[Darthe]

I hope your town game isn't this bad.

If you define it as bad then sure it is. Ive managed to partially clear myself and not die and have found as many scum as anyone else in the game so it seems pretty good so far

[dicetosser1]

re leelou   before I got to her post i was already thinking that her and nyn were possibilitys. Nyn because of her tunnel. I get that she tends not to let go once she wants someone gone but her posts are snipey and feel almost perfuntionary. like shes stuck with it now.

 

 

leelou's problem for me is A) I cant really remember her in this game. I know she's posted but i cant remember what she said. thats not something i associate with town leelou. Then theres the fact that verb died early. I know verb has said in the past that its hard for him to be mafia when leelou is town and he has spotted her pretty quick in some games. Killing him early would take out the biggest threat to her.  And then theres that sudden im lynching dice or eldrick. She hasnt mentioned me at all this game i dont think up til then.

 

and yes i know this isnt exactly backed up with facts but thats my thinking.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

I hope your town game isn't this bad.

If you define it as bad then sure it is. Ive managed to partially clear myself and not die and have found as many scum as anyone else in the game so it seems pretty good so far

 

How have you partially cleared yourself?