[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[TheRagnarok]

Sorry about the triple post. 

[Leelou]

Sorry about the triple post. 

 

5 am gets the best of us. 

[Sili Quirrels]

There was.

 

@Leelou: I would posit that the statement wasn't against my win condition.

[Leelou]

[vote]##Hallia[/v]

[Leelou]

[v]##Hallia[/v]

[dicetosser1]

##vote rags

 

competeing trains ftw

[Leelou]

Dice, thoughts on Des? 

[TheRagnarok]

##vote rags

 

competeing trains ftw

You make me sad.  I wanna lynch Des.

 

I think he is full of it.

[Sili Quirrels]

I have a couple guesses how he could achieve the feat were he scum.

[Leelou]

 

##vote rags

 

competeing trains ftw

You make me sad.  I wanna lynch Des.

 

I think he is full of it.

 

 

He visited me, I'm still alive and there was no NK. Last ditch effort to get rid of the healing role so you can have free rein on kills? 

[hazelkrs1]

Despothera calls out for sexual healing!

[Leelou]

Despothera calls out for sexual healing!

 

Go back to your garrison. 

[hazelkrs1]

Ah HA!

 

Never left in the first place

 

[Pralaya]

Whatever, guess I should stop being emo.

 

I'll vote whoever is the lead wagon at the end of the day.

 

You did that last night, just saying. 

[Leelou]

I could still vote for Sili on voting record alone and also for going with the flow. 

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Whatever, guess I should stop being emo.

 

I'll vote whoever is the lead wagon at the end of the day.

 

You did that last night, just saying. 

 

So I did.

[Pralaya]

Dice, thoughts on Des? 

 

Well, considering that the protect has to come from someone and you actually watched him visit you, I don't see how we can consider him scum now. There is definitely something that is missing. I don't know anymore. 

 

I can't explain how both Des and BFG could be town together.

I can't explain why there was no lynch on D3. 

[Sili Quirrels]

I could still vote for Sili on voting record alone and also for going with the flow. 

I don't have your wim. Sue me.

[hazelkrs1]

 

Dice, thoughts on Des? 

 

Well, considering that the protect has to come from someone and you actually watched him visit you, I don't see how we can consider him scum now. There is definitely something that is missing. I don't know anymore. 

 

I can't explain how both Des and BFG could be town together.

I can't explain why there was no lynch on D3. 

 

 

Bold: We are/were both underpowered protective roles (or roles that have different utility than Doctor at least... JK also has some potential neg utility for town)

 

Underlined: Haven't looked at it in detail, but scum were likely slanking it and not interested in scrambling to get someone lynched since a no lynch would deflate wim anyways and leave town likely trying to lynch the same two the next day (which almost happened). Could have also just been lack of opportunity

[Pralaya]

Okay so some maths first.

 

There are 9 people left total. If there were 4 mafia to start off with, then we're at 5-4 today, and it's mylo. I'm thinking tho that Krak had 4 total antitown out of the original 16, as that perfect ratio of 1:4 is what Krak would normally use imo. Gaming the mod, but meh. Anyways that would make it 6-3 today, and make it so we COULD actually afford to mislynch today technically, but then we would have to have EVERY townie vote for scum from then on out.

 

So imo Hallia and Rags are both confirmed scum. I already kinda showed why I now believe this- well first of all seeing BFKey flip town JK, and then thinking back to Rags saying I had already neatly laid out why Hallia looked town (have I apologized enough for WKing someone who's almost definitely scum here btw? Prob not. Sorry ).

 

Lates and Monstrmanbat are still LOCK CLEAR for me. There's no question in my mind both are town. Need I actually say more here? I can if yall want me to.

 

I'm now thinking Dice and Sili might be town, making them green for me. Dice is slightly associative on account of his attempts to lynch Hallia and her responses to those, but both of them seem to be genuinely interested in trying to solve.

 

Which leaves Alanna and Pray. Last scummer is between those two imo. Or, if there are 4 scum, then there's a good chance they're both remaining scum (after Hallia and Rags). Hallia claiming an inno on Pray didn't seem to be as likely to be "clearing" a teammate if she were scum before, but eh now thinking that's a possibilty. And like I said before, Pray himself has told me before if he's scum he'll just talk about how good my reads are blah blah, and that's exactly what he's done this game. HOWEVER, he DID switch to Hallia yesterday like I said, when he didn't really have to if he was her teammate. So..... eh. Alanna has lurked big time for long stretches of this game, had bad tone for a while before looking a bit townier more recently (altho she was just saying she believed me so was likely pocketing me and making me overlook her earlier scumminess that way). Also there's that thing where Rags said he was joining the "WK Alanna" club a lot earlier in the game, I still think that makes them likely scumbros. So I'm leaning towards Alanna as final scum here.

 

Why is Monstr lock town? Would like to know, yes. 

[Pralaya]

Also, 

 

[v]##Rags[/v]

[hazelkrs1]

Mainly his claim tbh, but also his participation throughout the game, trying to get the game back on track when WIM was plummeting, trying to commit to rereading a wholely unrereadable thread, and going against the grain many many times.

[Pralaya]

Mainly his claim tbh, but also his participation throughout the game, trying to get the game back on track when WIM was plummeting, trying to commit to rereading a wholely unrereadable thread, and going against the grain many many times.

 

So he claimed. However, his entire play D3 and D4 was how he is totally unsure of anything and doesn't know what to do. He ends up not voting Hally against whom he has been going on for a few days. I thought he was town initially but the last 2 days, I don't think so anymore. The reason why D3 lynch did not happen is because I think he missed the deadline. 

 

Anyway, I am not voting monstr till we get further in the game. Rags, Hally and then lets see who is left. 

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

Mainly his claim tbh, but also his participation throughout the game, trying to get the game back on track when WIM was plummeting, trying to commit to rereading a wholely unrereadable thread, and going against the grain many many times.

So he claimed. However, his entire play D3 and D4 was how he is totally unsure of anything and doesn't know what to do. He ends up not voting Hally against whom he has been going on for a few days. I thought he was town initially but the last 2 days, I don't think so anymore. The reason why D3 lynch did not happen is because I think he missed the deadline.

 

Anyway, I am not voting monstr till we get further in the game. Rags, Hally and then lets see who is left.

Fair enough.

[Leelou]

Here is where we are at: 
 

1. Sili Quirrels, vanilla town - lynched D2

2. AJ, Third Party Psychopath - mod killed N2
3. Despo - claimed doc protective role
4. Pralaya - claimed 1x rb
5. Verb, vanilla town - lynched D3
6. Thane, vanilla town - lynched D1
7. Alanna - claimed vt
8. Ragnarok - claimed vt
9. ArsisJr., town watcher - NKed N3
10. YatesLeelou - claimed tracker 
11. Cory & Hallia - claimed JOAT
12. Tommy, vanilla town - Nightkilled N2
13. BFKey, town jailkeeper - Lynched D5
14. Monstrma'am - claimed psychiatrist 
15. Dice - claimed vt
16. Berf Sili Quirrels - claimed vt
 
Failed NK N1, N4 and N5
 
N1 - 
BFKey - jailed Manbat
Des - Lates
 
N4 - 
BFKey - Lates
Des - Lates
 
N5 - 
Des - Lates
 
I'm going to go back and compile all of the NA's soon and EOD vote counts. Well, maybe a bit longer than soon. I'm sick today, so feeling pretty crappy.