[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[Sili Quirrels]

most of what pral giving a null read on aj shows is that he didn't care to make special note of the indy role claim. he came in, probably, gave a lazy sitrep on his reads and left.

 

who's to say how much he read? probably not very much. the fact he put aj down as null is he may have even missed aj's claim.

[hazelkrs1]

And how would you be able to determine what was going through Pray's head when he wrote that list Sili?

 

I will reiterate, I find nothing odd or significant in the slightest at someone putting AJ as "null". Yes not outside either his town or scum range here, and the survivor obviously COULD be a fake claim. Looks like a lot of hooplah over nothing to me.

 

Best part is with a scumflip on basically any of Alanna, BFKey, Sili, or Berf, we pretty much get a LOCK CLEAR on Pray. Good times.

[Andrej]

Meh - I don't really agree with that. I still think Pral's a good chance to be a wolf here based on zero thread presence and his one-off style postings.

 

I also don't think it's outside of the realm of possibility to consider him hard bussing KeyFG like he did in the Firefly game. I'll need to go reread his post where he voted Key but the argument they are using to vote him currently seems very superficial. Kind of like the slap fighting I would expect from a w/w combo.

[Sili Quirrels]

There are really two options. He put it as null because a) he didn't know aj had role claimed, or b) he didn't care to show he knew aj had role claimed indy. One or the other is the case, and neither are very different from the other.

 

Besides, I think the overall proposition is Pral demonstrated no understanding of the thread in his list, and Aj as null on it illustrates that point quite well.

[Sili Quirrels]

Am i the only one who doesn't like that pral's post is being hard defended for little reason?  By attacking Key it seems like angle-shooting.

 

I hope I'm not the only one.

[Yates]

Am i the only one who doesn't like that pral's post is being hard defended for little reason?

I'm not defending Pral at all. It's HIS job to defend himself. My concern is that BFG had listed AJ as purple. Then she voted Pral for listing AJ as gray. Purple isn't green or red and gray isn't green or red. If you are slightly color blind, purple and gray could be the same color. So it seems like a weak reason to vote for Pral. Also somewhat opportunistic because Pral isn't in the game and has been taking heat for it. If I'm scum and Pral is Town? Wow. What a great target to think I could slide in on without taking heat.

 

I work with a guy that drove around in a purple dodge stratus for months before discovering his car wasn't actually gray. True story!

 

[Sili Quirrels]

Pral listed AJ as null, not expressly grey or black. But grey or black is null on most lists. Purple isn't.

 

The point of contention has nothing to do with color code. Pral listed his reads as null/ not null, etc.

[Sili Quirrels]

Why did you chop off my quote anyway? Is angle-shooting not the right word for it?

[Tommyrod]

[Sili Quirrels]

Am i the only one who doesn't like that pral's post is being hard defended for little reason?  By attacking Key it seems like angle-shooting.

 

I hope I'm not the only one.

By the bolded I mean the possibility scum attack Key to present Key's read of Pral as misguided/poorly structured.

[Sili Quirrels]

Am I a fool or an ass to come to these conclusions and have no one believe me. They seem perfectly reasonable XD

[Arsis]

Fire in the mount run boy run.

[TheRagnarok]

Des, I've read all your ISOs so feel happy.

 

That said...I think I am going to do something I have never done before(seriously never)and white knight Alanna today. That lynch feels wrong. So lets hope that doesn't bite me in the ass.

 

I think Key and Verb are the best options today.

[Sili Quirrels]

Hypothesis:

 

I think wolfpacks tend to ignore subjects they don't like until they can't because someone brings it up too much itt.

 

In a way this might be used to chain wolves because other wolves will be a little slow to respond to deep criticism of their wolfpack.

[Arsis]

Busy day. Not a lot of time to post. I'm keeping up in thread. I don't like allana today at all.

[Arsis]

Could someone actually make a case for verb. I'm among the first one to call him scum. I wonder where everyone else joined me.

[Sili Quirrels]

Pral listed AJ as null, not expressly grey or black. But grey or black is null on most lists. Purple isn't.

 

The point of contention has nothing to do with color code. Pral listed his reads as null/ not null, etc.

Yates. I would ask that you respond to this when you can.

[TheRagnarok]

Could someone actually make a case for verb. I'm among the first one to call him scum. I wonder where everyone else joined me.

I've been on Verb for a while due to the fake nature of many of the posts.

[Arsis]

 

Could someone actually make a case for verb. I'm among the first one to call him scum. I wonder where everyone else joined me.

I've been on Verb for a while due to the fake nature of many of the posts.

It was just in general. I'm always worried about scum just picking up and following along.

[Sili Quirrels]

What I am anxious to see is desp take on Verbal.

 

That would be neat, and very revealing, considering this is probably what town desp would want to do - take anyone who was even slightly scummy to task.

[TheRagnarok]

I think Des already ISOed Verb.

[hazelkrs1]

Des, I've read all your ISOs so feel happy.

 

That said...I think I am going to do something I have never done before(seriously never)and white knight Alanna today. That lynch feels wrong. So lets hope that doesn't bite me in the ass.

 

I think Key and Verb are the best options today.

If you agree that Key looks scummy, what do you think about the way they both have handled each other this game? (Key and Alanna)

 

Do you think it looks like town/mafia interaction?

 

Specifically the posts of Alanna's towards Key from D1 I quoted- she stated discomfort with Key's slot, and later said she'd be fine with that lynch, yet when Key got a few votes on her (4 to be precise) Alanna said she had enough votes on her and wouldn't be voting her

 

Don't you think that's... odd? Especially if Key is a wolf?

[hazelkrs1]

I think Des already ISOed Verb.

Don't think I did, I can tonight tho

[hazelkrs1]

What I am anxious to see is desp take on Verbal.

 

That would be neat, and very revealing, considering this is probably what town desp would want to do - take anyone who was even slightly scummy to task.

Well since there's no way I'm town in your eyes, there's not much point to me doing that iso, eh?

 

[TheRagnarok]

 

Des, I've read all your ISOs so feel happy.

That said...I think I am going to do something I have never done before(seriously never)and white knight Alanna today. That lynch feels wrong. So lets hope that doesn't bite me in the ass.

I think Key and Verb are the best options today.

If you agree that Key looks scummy, what do you think about the way they both have handled each other this game? (Key and Alanna)

Do you think it looks like town/mafia interaction?

Specifically the posts of Alanna's towards Key from D1 I quoted- she stated discomfort with Key's slot, and later said she'd be fine with that lynch, yet when Key got a few votes on her (4 to be precise) Alanna said she had enough votes on her and wouldn't be voting her

Don't you think that's... odd? Especially if Key is a wolf?

I think if it was w/w, Alanna would have been more inclined to distance and/or bus. Strikes me more as a townie being cautious.