[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[Arsis]

I've come all the way back around to Verb/Leelou/Cory.

 

Get @ me.

You've come around to two of my scum reads? Coolio.

[Arsis]

 

 

Okay, let's talk about what we learned from the CFD events:

 

-Manbat is reinforced as a continual blueread for his high energy and worry.

 

-Alanna is now very close to blue. She was having fun with the CFD energy and that's probably a villager tell unless she's a sicko like me.

 

-Sili is blue-green for being legitimately irritated at his impending lynch.

 

-BFKey is now green simply for getting annoyed that they were still discussing the merits of lynching Berf before the CFD and for being around at all.

 

-Berf is green for a very villagery series of responses to his impending doom. He read as very sincere and would have to be a very very high level wolf to have made the posts he did at EOD.

 

-Rags could have done that as a wolf, but I'd say he earned like 2 points and is about green-null.

 

-Arsis didn't have a significant impact on the events, and stays about the same. I'd give him maybe 1 point for the comment about being nervous before a lynch.

 

-Verb loses some cred for being reactive instead of proactive during the EOD events.

 

 

And the people that didn't participate:

 

-Lates loses a little cred for not being around during a high-energy village-driven event.

 

-Dice loses a little cred for the same.

 

-Des loses a little cred for being absent.

 

-Cory/Hallia lose more credit for the same as they're both typically active during EODs when they're villagers.

 

-Pral is something of a mystery. He sounds villagery-ish to me when he's around, but I think he's been pushing villagers so far.

 

-AJ claimed survivor, doesn't care.

 

 

So even though we mislynched, we still got a lot out of info out of the threadflow alone and the way people react to high energy tumultuous periods.

Quoting for new page yay!

I disagree with you on mbat/sili and myself.

[Sili Quirrels]

That's because you don't know how to read emotional players.

[Arsis]

That's because you don't know how to read emotional players.

That's a possibility.

[monstrman]

It's actually because he's either stuck in a tunnel or a wolf

[Tommyrod]

I'm kind of relieved I'm gonna die tonight. Means you guys have to sort it out and I can just judge you from the dead thread over the course of weeks.

 

Beware leaving me alive, scum. I'm prone to start CFDs! Next time... it could be you!

[Tommyrod]

I'M WILD AND DANGEROUS! TOMMY DANGER!!

[Sili Quirrels]

tom, would the town you approve of lynching you day 2 or day 3 if you aren't night killed?

[Sili Quirrels]

or at least seriously considering it

[Tommyrod]

tom, would the town you approve of lynching you day 2 or day 3 if you aren't night killed?

No. It's a stupid idea.

[Sili Quirrels]

What if the town you thought you could be lying about the beloved princess claim?

[Alanna]

What if the town you thought you could be lying about the beloved princess claim?

 

lol

[TheRagnarok]

 

tom, would the town you approve of lynching you day 2 or day 3 if you aren't night killed?

No. It's a stupid idea.

 

Watching you have an apoplexy is so much fun though.

[Tommyrod]

I don't really get the doubt. It's not a good fake claim. I don't have the can-be-used-to-scare-off-a-lynch version that only activates when lynched. If I am shot it will still happen. I'm basically making myself an even bigger target.

 

At best you could think I was lying to scum and am actually a bomb or something, but then I wouldn't need to claim anything.

[dicetosser1]

Could dice/despot/cory have wolves in them?

 

take me out of that and ure chance go up by 33.3%

 

Oh, ya, dice... he voted me for no reason. dat guy got steam. Strong wolf.

 

Oh i gave reasons. Quite seriously I have not liked your posts since page 106. All that screaming reads to me as a scum freaking out that he was close to being lynched. Particularly a non experienced scum. plus the early why am i not blue crap. You feel forced. Dont like it? I dont care.

[Alanna]

Okay, let's talk about what we learned from the CFD events:

 

-Manbat is reinforced as a continual blueread for his high energy and worry.

 

-Alanna is now very close to blue. She was having fun with the CFD energy and that's probably a villager tell unless she's a sicko like me.

 

-Sili is blue-green for being legitimately irritated at his impending lynch.

 

-BFKey is now green simply for getting annoyed that they were still discussing the merits of lynching Berf before the CFD and for being around at all.

 

-Berf is green for a very villagery series of responses to his impending doom. He read as very sincere and would have to be a very very high level wolf to have made the posts he did at EOD.

 

-Rags could have done that as a wolf, but I'd say he earned like 2 points and is about green-null.

 

-Arsis didn't have a significant impact on the events, and stays about the same. I'd give him maybe 1 point for the comment about being nervous before a lynch.

 

-Verb loses some cred for being reactive instead of proactive during the EOD events.

 

 

And the people that didn't participate:

 

-Lates loses a little cred for not being around during a high-energy village-driven event.

 

-Dice loses a little cred for the same.

 

-Des loses a little cred for being absent.

 

-Cory/Hallia lose more credit for the same as they're both typically active during EODs when they're villagers.

 

-Pral is something of a mystery. He sounds villagery-ish to me when he's around, but I think he's been pushing villagers so far.

 

-AJ claimed survivor, doesn't care.

 

 

So even though we mislynched, we still got a lot out of info out of the threadflow alone and the way people react to high energy tumultuous periods.

 

I'm gonna have to take a more thorough look at it all later, but just some initial thoughts: I agree about Rags and berf, and I'm feeling a lot more townie about manbat now, too. I'm not as sure about Sili, and I'm still feeling okay about Verb. 

 

As for the ones who weren't here, I'm anxious to hear what they have to say. I'm wondering most about Hallia, because I thought she was going to be around, unless I missed something.

[dicetosser1]

oh and i wasnt here cause its day time for me and im at work. Was in the middle of a difficult issue.

 

 

 

Tommy   plz be completely objective here.  If you were town and I claimed Beloved Princess and you believed my claim what would you do?

[Tommyrod]

oh and i wasnt here cause its day time for me and im at work. Was in the middle of a difficult issue.

 

 

 

Tommy plz be completely objective here. If you were town and I claimed Beloved Princess and you believed my claim what would you do?

If I believed it? Use a watcher or doctor protect on you. Or just wait for you to die. I don't see what else there is to do.

[berf]

@Tommy - You claimed Beloved Princess? Does it activate only when shot or can you be lynched safely? Because despite my townread on you, if it gets close to lylo you become scary.

 

Up to page 50. I'll keep my wall of text to a minimum.

 

@Dice - What's your case on Sili? Just the emotion she displayed close to her own lynch? Because that in itself isn't a scumtell. I'll be rereading the wagon closely, mind.

[dicetosser1]

in that situation why wouldn't you do what I proposed?

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Could dice/despot/cory have wolves in them?

 

take me out of that and ure chance go up by 33.3%

 

Oh, ya, dice... he voted me for no reason. dat guy got steam. Strong wolf.

 

Oh i gave reasons. Quite seriously I have not liked your posts since page 106. All that screaming reads to me as a scum freaking out that he was close to being lynched. Particularly a non experienced scum. plus the early why am i not blue crap. You feel forced. Dont like it? I dont care.

 

I stand corrected. Not no reason, just a bad meta read and poor reasoning. it's also not very specific. page 106 was only when aj said the behavior was scummy, not when I actually demonstrated that behavior. So basically what you're telling me is you think it's scummy because aj said so. Nice case.

[TheRagnarok]

So I feel pretty good about this group as being townie

Berf

Monstr

Tommy - Before someone asks, I think his EOD was very townie for him. 

Alanna

 

Most everyone else is kind of in a mass of gray below this.  There's a few more I want to ISO cause I have them leaning town, like dice and arsis, but wanna be more sure.

 

 

Verb and Key are at the bottom for me.  Didn't like their EOD and they're my top scum leans. 

[Sili Quirrels]

I don't really get the doubt. It's not a good fake claim. I don't have the can-be-used-to-scare-off-a-lynch version that only activates when lynched. If I am shot it will still happen. I'm basically making myself an even bigger target.

 

At best you could think I was lying to scum and am actually a bomb or something, but then I wouldn't need to claim anything.

Technically you're only a target because we've made you into one.  It's very possible, like last game, you have some sort of grandfather role.

 

I don't know, I wouldn't put it past Tom Ripley no offense. I think you're capable of going big. But I cleared you for other reasons.

[Tommyrod]

in that situation why wouldn't you do what I proposed?

Which is what? Lynch you?

 

Because then you mislynch AND scum gets an extra kill out of it?

 

I mean how obvious is that?

[Sili Quirrels]

For Reference:

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/91500-advanced-revenge-of-the-marlfox/page-106